Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that donating tinned tomatoes to the food bank shows a real lack of understanding of food poverty?

659 replies

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/11/2021 08:53

The food bank donation box at my local supermarket this morning had a fairly good mix of items, apart from about a third of the tins were tinned tomatoes.

Surely it would be better all round to donate products which need little to no additional ingredients?

Tinned tomatoes are a base - they will never be a meal in their own right. They need at the bare minimum, some seasoning and or some veg or protein to make them useable.

And then even if you could rustle up some other ingredients to make them palateable/nutritious, you need to heat them - if they contain meat or lentils they need a good length of time on the heat.

Those using food banks likely cannot give over 20mins on the hob for tinned tomatoes. The cost of heating up the food (if there is even funds on the meter) is too high for the return.

I do think that people who donate tinned tomatoes, come at it from a reasonably comfortable point of view - just chuck it in with some mince and a bit if garlic and slow cook it for a couple of hours.

All of which is likely to be outside of the financial scope of the recipient.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BlusteringBoobies · 02/11/2021 10:56

@B0G0F

Not currently needing a foodbank, but there are other tinned food that would be useful. A tin of chickpeas or kidney beans would add protein, for example.

I made a huge batch of hummus just now with a 10p lemon from the greengrocer, the dregs of a jar of tahini that I bought in the yellow sticker section a while ago for 59p, some garlic, and 3 for 99p chickpeas.

The lemon was the juciest one I've ever seen - I warmed it before squeezing.
I've popped the hummus I won't use up in the next few days in the freezer.

Biscuit
Punkyfish3000 · 02/11/2021 10:52

@HelpMeTree

I think you’re virtue signaling. Of all the people to criticise, those who donate to food banks probably shouldn’t be at the top of your list.
Well the OP would hate me then as I regularly donate food to my local food bank. My most frequently donated items include toiletries (inc. sanpro/incontinence aids) and baby items as well as food. Often they're items the subject of coupons, or reduced to clear but still have shelf life left.
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 02/11/2021 10:51

@B0G0F

Not currently needing a foodbank, but there are other tinned food that would be useful. A tin of chickpeas or kidney beans would add protein, for example.

I made a huge batch of hummus just now with a 10p lemon from the greengrocer, the dregs of a jar of tahini that I bought in the yellow sticker section a while ago for 59p, some garlic, and 3 for 99p chickpeas.

The lemon was the juciest one I've ever seen - I warmed it before squeezing.
I've popped the hummus I won't use up in the next few days in the freezer.

???
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 02/11/2021 10:50

@Bluesheep8

And I suppose tinned stuff isn't organic.

Does tinned organic food not exist?

Can we remember this is a stop gap service. Not a forever and ever service.

We deal with people who are quite desperate and we rely on donations.

We shouldn't exist. But we do.

Stop quibbling over what is or is not available in a bloody tin.

Go shout at your elected MP!

B0G0F · 02/11/2021 10:49

Not currently needing a foodbank, but there are other tinned food that would be useful. A tin of chickpeas or kidney beans would add protein, for example.

I made a huge batch of hummus just now with a 10p lemon from the greengrocer, the dregs of a jar of tahini that I bought in the yellow sticker section a while ago for 59p, some garlic, and 3 for 99p chickpeas.

The lemon was the juciest one I've ever seen - I warmed it before squeezing.
I've popped the hummus I won't use up in the next few days in the freezer.

TrevorFountain · 02/11/2021 10:42

Lots of organic tins, jars and packets are on display in Asda, including the newish Gino range (which is pretty pricey) of olives and tomatoes, and some less pricey ones including tinned tomatoes.

user64323 · 02/11/2021 10:42

Yes and no. When I was in poverty I used a great deal of tinned tomatoes! But I do agree with your point on the whole. At school some of the try hards donate all manner of different lentils, chia seeds, polenta etc. I tend to go for biscuits, pot noodles, meals in a tin, tuna, tinned chicken etc knowing it isn't just about needing the cooking facilities but those in need of food banks are more likely to be struggling with their mental health too and will appreciate some easy things that don't need recipes and can just be heated.

FluffyBooBoo · 02/11/2021 10:39

@Bluesheep8

And I suppose tinned stuff isn't organic.

Does tinned organic food not exist?

It absolutely does exist.
Bluesheep8 · 02/11/2021 10:16

And I suppose tinned stuff isn't organic.

Does tinned organic food not exist?

camperjam · 02/11/2021 09:45

I have used a food bank before and have been glad to receive tinned tomatoes. They are useful for bulking up a meal and for making soup with.
There are lots of different people who need to use a food bank.

thecatsthecats · 02/11/2021 09:37

@me4real

Although not as good as fresh

@thecatsthecats Tinned and frozen fruit and veg are pretty much as good as fresh, if not better, depending how fresh the fresh is.

Tinning or freezing preserves all the nutrients.

Apologies, I meant not quite as good - by a fractional degree. And I suppose tinned stuff isn't organic.

Apologies, I don't have a link to hand, but my source was my mum, who has an MA that focused on medical historical research, so I assume she got it from a reliable source!

sunglassesonthetable · 02/11/2021 08:28

Yep . Fair play to OP. Still wincing at the title of this OP though

"donating tinned tomatoes ....shows a real lack of understanding "

But in fairness, I was reminded to donate at the supermarket yesterday, so all good. Cheers OP.

110APiccadilly · 02/11/2021 08:12

Fair play to OP for admitting they were wrong. They've done a valuable service though in reminding people to donate to foodbanks and look at what the foodbanks themselves are requesting.

Another option if you have the cashflow is to set up a regular money donation to the foodbank. Regular donation means they'll know how much they have coming in each month which can make it easier for planning. And it means you won't forget! They can then use it to buy whatever they're short of, or even cover costs (their own energy use, fuel if they're delivering at all, etc).

dementedma · 02/11/2021 08:09

Tinned tomatoes on bread in a bowl was a meal in our house when money was scarce

sashh · 02/11/2021 07:56

@RoseAndRose not a scientific study so may not be as true as some reports but this is an easy to read piece.

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/oct/05/tinned-tomatoes-health-benefits-anti-cancer-strong-bones

00100001 · 02/11/2021 07:49

I'm having tinned tomatoes on toast for breakfast in the back of this thread! Thanks :D

Tiredout123 · 02/11/2021 07:03

You can make tinned tomatoes on toast and an egg. Or sausages, mash and tinned tomatoes. Or egg, chips and tinned tomatoes. I think it's an easy way of getting some nutrients, if you're on a budget.

RoseAndRose · 02/11/2021 04:58

@thecatsthecats

YABU.

Colon and other digestive cancers declined massively with the advent of tinned food. Although not as good as fresh, it made nutritious food accessible for the urban working classes. People who use food banks shouldn't be expected to live on pure crap. As PP have said, there's plenty of ways to use them cheaply.

Do you have a link for that?

Genuinely interested, as tinned food was first produced commercially in 1813 (meat) and 1825 (fruit and veg), and I didn't think cancer stats went that far back

EmmaGrundyForPM · 02/11/2021 03:54

I donate tinned onions as well as tinned tomatoes. You can mix them together and heat them through in a couple of minutes, and have the basis of a sauce for pasta or rice.

melj1213 · 02/11/2021 00:55

Food banks don't want tinned tomatoes, and the people who use them certainly don't. The most important things to donate are ...-Tinned fruit and veg

So which is it @HarrietsChariot? No tinned tomatoes or tinned fruit and veg accepted?

My local food banks are always asking for tinned tomatoes because there is such high demand for them so clearly your experience is not the same as mine.

Equally not everyone using food banks are lacking in cooking facilities (either in terms of the gas/electric needed or kitchen facilities like oven/microwave/toaster/kettle) or coming from long term poverty. Some just need a short term boost so having "ingredient" options to supplement existing supplies rather than just processed options meant to cover all nutritional needs is not a bad thing to have.

I had to use a foodbank once because, as a single parent on low income I get UC top ups, but because I get paid 4weekly I had one month where I got paid twice and so it messed up my claim and we were left short at the end of the month. I had some pantry staples and basics in, essential bills (rent, council tax, water, gas, electric etc) were all paid, I was just short on money for groceries and day to day expenses. When I went to the food bank I just needed enough to tide us over until payday, and it was only a short term need, so I didn't need pot noodles and microwave pasta because I only had a kettle and microwave, I had a full kitchen available so tinned tomatoes and a bag of pasta was a much better option to add to the onion, cheese and half tube of garlic puree I already had at home as it made a cheap, filling pasta dish that could do multiple portions (and I could mix it up with various other odds and ends to bulk out the meal)

me4real · 02/11/2021 00:20

Although not as good as fresh

@thecatsthecats Tinned and frozen fruit and veg are pretty much as good as fresh, if not better, depending how fresh the fresh is.

Tinning or freezing preserves all the nutrients.

me4real · 02/11/2021 00:17

I considered them mainly from a perspective of seeing people who cannot heat their home on a single person benefit, cannot spend money on fresh ingredients, cannot afford to run/buy/repair cooking facilities or hold a small stock of pantry ingredients.

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz Most people will have a microwave and/or oven. If they can't spend money on fresh ingredients, that's exactly why some tinned tomatoes etc could be good. The food parcels are basic and people could get by on them, but some herbs/spices/seasonings would enhance them.

thecatsthecats · 02/11/2021 00:07

YABU.

Colon and other digestive cancers declined massively with the advent of tinned food. Although not as good as fresh, it made nutritious food accessible for the urban working classes. People who use food banks shouldn't be expected to live on pure crap. As PP have said, there's plenty of ways to use them cheaply.

OutIsay · 02/11/2021 00:06

YABU. Tinned tomatoes are really versatile and one of your 5 a day. One of our local foodbanks is asking for them

AIBU to think that donating tinned tomatoes to the food bank shows a real lack of understanding of food poverty?
RedMarauder · 02/11/2021 00:05

@DroopyClematis my local food bank asks for packets of noodles so due to the demographics of the area I end up buying a mixture.