Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that donating tinned tomatoes to the food bank shows a real lack of understanding of food poverty?

659 replies

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/11/2021 08:53

The food bank donation box at my local supermarket this morning had a fairly good mix of items, apart from about a third of the tins were tinned tomatoes.

Surely it would be better all round to donate products which need little to no additional ingredients?

Tinned tomatoes are a base - they will never be a meal in their own right. They need at the bare minimum, some seasoning and or some veg or protein to make them useable.

And then even if you could rustle up some other ingredients to make them palateable/nutritious, you need to heat them - if they contain meat or lentils they need a good length of time on the heat.

Those using food banks likely cannot give over 20mins on the hob for tinned tomatoes. The cost of heating up the food (if there is even funds on the meter) is too high for the return.

I do think that people who donate tinned tomatoes, come at it from a reasonably comfortable point of view - just chuck it in with some mince and a bit if garlic and slow cook it for a couple of hours.

All of which is likely to be outside of the financial scope of the recipient.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
logsonlogsoff · 03/11/2021 00:14

Christ,
If you looked in my cupboard about a third of the tins are tomatoes! We use them as a base for so much. My kids love them on pasta on their own with a bit of cheese chucked on.
Perhaps people
Are
Giving what they have spare of.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/11/2021 00:08

What's the point I wonder...tinned tomatoes cost 35p. Surely people can buy their own? I would have thought that expensive things are more use.

Belleager · 03/11/2021 00:02

To be honest - and I know this could sound callous - I'm disturbed by the whole free school meals thing too. Why do we assume so many parents in the UK can't feed their children enough? Presumably because incomes are so low? Absolutely would be willing to subsidize this as a taxpayer, but the assumption that many kids would go hungry without free school food is really disturbing.

Fangdango · 02/11/2021 23:57

In my experience, people who donate food etc are also likely to volunteer are also likely to campaign are also likely to set up direct debits. So I wouldn't assume anyone's just donating food.

That said, I was really uncomfortable with the Trussell Trust and Cameron's Big Society and the normalisation of food banks when it all came on the scene - 2010? I always gave my little Tesco coin and my various donations elsewhere. I think I became desensitised by a combination of lockdown and closer exposure to people in need locally. So I don't disagree with you really, @pineapplevape But I want people local to me to have immediate help, and foodbank donations seem one way to do that.

I don't see much hope of change under current government so better to light a candle etc.

pineapplevape · 02/11/2021 23:08

@FluffyBooBoo I'm not setting out to get anyone's 'backs up'. That's a ridiculous statement. I'm simply trying to relay (albeit in an exasperated way) to those on the thread - why is this becoming so normalised - that on a thread like this, no-one else comments about the underlying causes of why huge numbers of people are needing food charity in the UK.

And why not - as well as donating - start to try to influence change in other ways - like making it clear to your representatives that a welfare system which relies on charity to stop people starving is perhaps not fit for purpose??!!

Silenceisgolden20 · 02/11/2021 22:24

@PlausibleSuit

I think you're making a lot of very broad and likely incorrect assumptions about people who use food banks.
Yes
FluffyBooBoo · 02/11/2021 22:21

because literally not one other poster - in 574 posts - has even commented on the root causes and wait a minute maybe we should be trying to do something to help that

At risk of repeating myself, they haven't because that's not what this thread is about.

If you wanted to take it in that direction, you could. Instead you are going on about how you believe that 95% of people aren't doing what you think they should do. So instead of getting people onside, you are getting their backs up.

I really don't see how that is helping anyone.

TreborBore · 02/11/2021 22:17

[quote pineapplevape]@FluffyBooBoo Not trying to make people feel bad. Not at all. By all means, donate. But I'd be willing to bet that 95% of the people commenting are not proactive in any way at all about the root causes of food poverty and why it's being allowed to happen in the UK that so many are relying on charity food.

I get the 'idea' that people are becoming desensitised to it and that it's somehow normal now - because literally not one other poster - in 574 posts - has even commented on the root causes and wait a minute maybe we should be trying to do something to help that as well as donating.[/quote]
I'm with @pineapplevape - we should all be lobbying to tackle the root causes of poverty. Food banks didn't exist in most areas before the 2008 financial crash and it is disgraceful that the social safety net has been so eroded.

I don't give food to food banks. I give money so their volunteers can buy whatever it is their customers need at wholesale prices. If you all did that then food banks could buy tinned tomatoes if their customers use them, or not if they don't.

edenhills · 02/11/2021 22:12

@HelpMeTree

I think you’re virtue signaling. Of all the people to criticise, those who donate to food banks probably shouldn’t be at the top of your list.
This!
pineapplevape · 02/11/2021 22:09

@FluffyBooBoo Not trying to make people feel bad. Not at all. By all means, donate. But I'd be willing to bet that 95% of the people commenting are not proactive in any way at all about the root causes of food poverty and why it's being allowed to happen in the UK that so many are relying on charity food.

I get the 'idea' that people are becoming desensitised to it and that it's somehow normal now - because literally not one other poster - in 574 posts - has even commented on the root causes and wait a minute maybe we should be trying to do something to help that as well as donating.

FluffyBooBoo · 02/11/2021 22:07

@3luckystars

They are very different than an actual real tomato though.
What are they then, if they aren't real tomatoes 😉
3luckystars · 02/11/2021 22:03

They are very different than an actual real tomato though.

foxgoosefinch · 02/11/2021 22:02

@3luckystars

Are they ruined though?
I love a tinned tomato, I can’t ever say they’re ruined 😂
FluffyBooBoo · 02/11/2021 22:02

[quote pineapplevape]@FluffyBooBoo Don't any of you actually want to write to your MPs etc about WHY so many people are needing charity food in the UK though??

Look, I'm not trying to attack any of you, I get you are trying to help - I'm just exasperated tbh. Why is it so normalised for you, that so so many people need charity food in the UK?? I'm pretty sure I'm the only person on this whole thread who has said wait a minute, why aren't we trying to do something, campaign, demand, that food charity stops being the norm in the UK for so many??[/quote]
You might be the only person that has said it on this thread (which, as I said, is about the merits of tinned tomatoes for people that need to use food banks).

You are also the only person making the (fairly massive) assumption that nobody is being proactive in other ways. I don't think it's normal. I don't think it's ok. I'm really not sure where you get that idea from. But just because it's not ok, doesn't mean it's not needed right now.

So you can talk about how demoralising it is, but please don't try to make people feel bad admit trying to help people in need. That's unnecessary. You can make your point in other ways.

3luckystars · 02/11/2021 22:01

Are they ruined though?

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 02/11/2021 22:01

I work in social care and where I live quite a few people who may use food banks are vegan or have health issues like high blood pressure so plain unprocessed food is welcome.

foxgoosefinch · 02/11/2021 21:59

Tinned tomatoes! Not ruined tomatoes Grin

pineapplevape · 02/11/2021 21:58

@WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia If enough people wrote to them and mentioned that things like benefit cuts, the 5 week wait for benefits, how the disabled are treated, and zero hours contracts - are issues which will be influencing their voting choices, then maybe they'd care??

Or you could just watch the ever escalating slide into it being normalised that such huge numbers of people need charity food in the UK every month / year ??

foxgoosefinch · 02/11/2021 21:58

I’m late to this thread, but during lockdown our local community had a free food hub going to supplement food bank usage - one important issue was that people with special diets can’t always eat processed food donated to food banks so are left without things to cook. We had a lady who was shielding for severe health problems including T1 diabetes who was also Muslim and vegetarian - she had run out of food, couldn’t leave the house and could eat hardly anything from the food bank as it all had too much sugar or was meat based. She desperately needed basics like ruined tomatoes, onions, and lentils to make things she could eat.

Lots of people don’t eat premade pasta sauce for various reasons. Especially those who are from cultures where they are vegetarian or cook from scratch. Tinned tomatoes are an essential!

pineapplevape · 02/11/2021 21:54

@CiaoForDiNiaoSaur I'd wager a bet that 95% of those commenting on this thread have never even written to their MPs about the subject, no. Even less have been involved in any campaigning.

WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 02/11/2021 21:52

[quote pineapplevape]@FluffyBooBoo Don't any of you actually want to write to your MPs etc about WHY so many people are needing charity food in the UK though??

Look, I'm not trying to attack any of you, I get you are trying to help - I'm just exasperated tbh. Why is it so normalised for you, that so so many people need charity food in the UK?? I'm pretty sure I'm the only person on this whole thread who has said wait a minute, why aren't we trying to do something, campaign, demand, that food charity stops being the norm in the UK for so many??[/quote]
MPs don’t give a shit. Have you got any other suggestions?

TolkiensFallow · 02/11/2021 21:51

This is a bonkers thread.

I would quite happily give fresh meat, fish, veg to a food bank or high quality nutritious pre prepared meals but they ask for long life tinned foods. They specifically ask for tinned tomato’s, beans and pasta. This is the reason that “most people who donate to food banks give these things” ffs.

RevolutionRadio · 02/11/2021 21:50

The list on the foodbank basket at our local supermarket this week was:
Rice, Rice Pudding, tinned fish, uht milk, tinned potatoes, fruit juice and coffee.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 02/11/2021 21:50

@pineapplevape how do you know we aren't involved in campaigning and petitioning for things to change so no one needs for banks? So you honestly think you're the only person who's thought of that?
It's possible to campaign for change and discuss what food banks need. Any change that happens, if it happens at all, won't be over night. So for banks will still be needed for the foreseeable.

Sunshinealligator · 02/11/2021 21:44

Tinned tomatoes on toast. Yum