Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that donating tinned tomatoes to the food bank shows a real lack of understanding of food poverty?

659 replies

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/11/2021 08:53

The food bank donation box at my local supermarket this morning had a fairly good mix of items, apart from about a third of the tins were tinned tomatoes.

Surely it would be better all round to donate products which need little to no additional ingredients?

Tinned tomatoes are a base - they will never be a meal in their own right. They need at the bare minimum, some seasoning and or some veg or protein to make them useable.

And then even if you could rustle up some other ingredients to make them palateable/nutritious, you need to heat them - if they contain meat or lentils they need a good length of time on the heat.

Those using food banks likely cannot give over 20mins on the hob for tinned tomatoes. The cost of heating up the food (if there is even funds on the meter) is too high for the return.

I do think that people who donate tinned tomatoes, come at it from a reasonably comfortable point of view - just chuck it in with some mince and a bit if garlic and slow cook it for a couple of hours.

All of which is likely to be outside of the financial scope of the recipient.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
santabetterwashhishands · 03/11/2021 09:47

Tinned tomatoes on toast with a bit of pepper is gorgeous 🤷‍♀️

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 03/11/2021 09:44

but as others on the thread have said, it’s a dreadful indictment of our politics that they are needed at all. (I don’t think that posters in this thread are unaware of this either.)

Absolutely! It can't be said often enough Talk to yur MP!! Do anything lese you can think of. There isn't a food bank anywhere that wants to open its doors!

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 03/11/2021 09:43

@TheRiat

I really do feel for those that have budgeted properly and still do not have enough at the end of the week/ month.

I claimed benefit once in my life. And do you know what it made me do!!!! It made me promise myself to never claim another benefit again. (Job seekers for 6 months)

There are plenty of jobs out there. The service industry are crying out for people, the transport industry (if you believe the media) are crying out for people.

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

As stated above I really do feel for those that are genuine and really do struggle. But I used to work for the fraud dept in one of the government agencies and it really has made me cynical of people.

And for those that are talking about delays to their PIP. A friend of mine is in a wheelchair, has a full time job and banks their PIP. Just because you claim PIP dosent mean you cant work.

Good for you. Have a fucking medal for being a better person than everyone else. Then go and educate yourself on the many many reasons the jobs that are available aren't always suitable for the job seekers. Or why people who are too sick for work are being turned down for PIP.
foxgoosefinch · 03/11/2021 09:26

@HoardingSamphireSaurus that’s good to hear. I don’t know why the lady had not been able to access appropriate food - this was during the first lockdown and she didn’t have good English, so it could be that there was a miscommunication about what she needed. She wasn’t able to go out because of shielding so a food bank volunteer had dropped a box round which she couldn’t eat. The local community hub was able to give her a lot though so she was okay in the end.

It’s good to hear that foodbanks are able to cater for these situations but as others on the thread have said, it’s a dreadful indictment of our politics that they are needed at all. (I don’t think that posters in this thread are unaware of this either.)

ThePoisonousMushroom · 03/11/2021 09:25

Just because you claim PIP dosent mean you cant work

No, but the reason you claim PIP could mean you can’t work. Your friend is lucky that her disability is one that allows her to work.

BiLuminous · 03/11/2021 09:24

@TheRiat

I really do feel for those that have budgeted properly and still do not have enough at the end of the week/ month.

I claimed benefit once in my life. And do you know what it made me do!!!! It made me promise myself to never claim another benefit again. (Job seekers for 6 months)

There are plenty of jobs out there. The service industry are crying out for people, the transport industry (if you believe the media) are crying out for people.

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

As stated above I really do feel for those that are genuine and really do struggle. But I used to work for the fraud dept in one of the government agencies and it really has made me cynical of people.

And for those that are talking about delays to their PIP. A friend of mine is in a wheelchair, has a full time job and banks their PIP. Just because you claim PIP dosent mean you cant work.

Biscuit
TheRiat · 03/11/2021 09:15

I really do feel for those that have budgeted properly and still do not have enough at the end of the week/ month.

I claimed benefit once in my life. And do you know what it made me do!!!! It made me promise myself to never claim another benefit again. (Job seekers for 6 months)

There are plenty of jobs out there. The service industry are crying out for people, the transport industry (if you believe the media) are crying out for people.

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

As stated above I really do feel for those that are genuine and really do struggle. But I used to work for the fraud dept in one of the government agencies and it really has made me cynical of people.

And for those that are talking about delays to their PIP. A friend of mine is in a wheelchair, has a full time job and banks their PIP. Just because you claim PIP dosent mean you cant work.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 03/11/2021 08:54

@foxgoosefinch

I’m late to this thread, but during lockdown our local community had a free food hub going to supplement food bank usage - one important issue was that people with special diets can’t always eat processed food donated to food banks so are left without things to cook. We had a lady who was shielding for severe health problems including T1 diabetes who was also Muslim and vegetarian - she had run out of food, couldn’t leave the house and could eat hardly anything from the food bank as it all had too much sugar or was meat based. She desperately needed basics like ruined tomatoes, onions, and lentils to make things she could eat.

Lots of people don’t eat premade pasta sauce for various reasons. Especially those who are from cultures where they are vegetarian or cook from scratch. Tinned tomatoes are an essential!

Sorry, I feel like I am coming back to tell you off Smile

If someone has a special dietary need they only have to tell the foodbank staff and they will get what they need. We have lists for just about any restricted diet you can think of. We generally use cash donations to fulfil these, to save donated foods goind beyond their useful dates.

I don't know of any foodbank that doesn't do this - expect maybe the newest ones set up during covid. We have all had decades to work this out, it's not new to us - sadly!

Had we been put in touch with that lady we would have gone out and done a shop just for her. We would also have asked around our wider network for someone to offer 1-2-1 support.

If anyone knows someone who fears their dietary restrictions would prevent them from getting aid from a food bank please, reassure them, we can and will provide them with food they can safely eat.

KirstenBlest · 03/11/2021 08:42

Yes. Not everyone using a food bank will be without things like a freezer or a telly or broadband but there are people who cannot afford them or the fuel to cook a meal. There are people who don't have smart phones or computers, or maybe they had them but they broke and they can't afford to replace them.

Helenluvsrob · 03/11/2021 08:37

Tinned tomatoes on toast. Good comfort food

TreborBore · 03/11/2021 08:35

@TheRiat

"Ah yes I'm sure the representatives will rebuild the welfare system and address the deep rooted social inequality following some letters. The best way, as always, is for people to stop voting tory, but many won't."

No, the best way to stop the need for food banks, is education.

Teach people to budget.

Probably slightly derailing away from original topic. But Labour seem to want people who are "struggling" to be eternally tied to the benefits system.

I used to donate my self, but 1 day I was driving past our local bank, and saw several people smoking, and some of them with cups of costa. oh and the odd one with booze.

How much is a packet of fags? How much is the cheapest Costa? How much for a bottle of booze?

Did you know that in my area, the average wait for a newly disabled person to get a PIP claim assessed is 3 months? Until it comes through, people have to use food banks to survive. There are all sorts of problems with benefits now that didn’t exist before universal credit was introduced.
JustDanceAddict · 03/11/2021 08:27

I had them on toast at uni. I still
Like one out of the tin!

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 03/11/2021 08:20

Hard to budget when your income is less than your outgoings.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 03/11/2021 08:18

@TheRiat
You've forgotten the huge TVs. You definitely need to mention the huge TV to win MN bingo.

"Teach people to budget" - how does that help when their Universal Credit payment is delayed, or when they are sick and their employer only pays SSSP, or when their weekly budget (which they have carefully costed out to the last penny) is thrown by their car needing a new part, and they need the car to get to work.....

TheRiat · 03/11/2021 08:01

"Ah yes I'm sure the representatives will rebuild the welfare system and address the deep rooted social inequality following some letters. The best way, as always, is for people to stop voting tory, but many won't."

No, the best way to stop the need for food banks, is education.

Teach people to budget.

Probably slightly derailing away from original topic. But Labour seem to want people who are "struggling" to be eternally tied to the benefits system.

I used to donate my self, but 1 day I was driving past our local bank, and saw several people smoking, and some of them with cups of costa. oh and the odd one with booze.

How much is a packet of fags? How much is the cheapest Costa? How much for a bottle of booze?

MissTrip82 · 03/11/2021 07:55

[quote pineapplevape]@FluffyBooBoo Not trying to make people feel bad. Not at all. By all means, donate. But I'd be willing to bet that 95% of the people commenting are not proactive in any way at all about the root causes of food poverty and why it's being allowed to happen in the UK that so many are relying on charity food.

I get the 'idea' that people are becoming desensitised to it and that it's somehow normal now - because literally not one other poster - in 574 posts - has even commented on the root causes and wait a minute maybe we should be trying to do something to help that as well as donating.[/quote]
Yes, I imagine you see things much more clearly than everybody else.

You will almost certainly be the most intelligent, best-informed and most compassionate person contributing. It’s perfectly normal and insightful to view others so negatively.

Fetarabbit · 03/11/2021 07:38

[quote pineapplevape]@FluffyBooBoo I'm not setting out to get anyone's 'backs up'. That's a ridiculous statement. I'm simply trying to relay (albeit in an exasperated way) to those on the thread - why is this becoming so normalised - that on a thread like this, no-one else comments about the underlying causes of why huge numbers of people are needing food charity in the UK.

And why not - as well as donating - start to try to influence change in other ways - like making it clear to your representatives that a welfare system which relies on charity to stop people starving is perhaps not fit for purpose??!![/quote]
Ah yes I'm sure the representatives will rebuild the welfare system and address the deep rooted social inequality following some letters. The best way, as always, is for people to stop voting tory, but many won't.

phishy · 03/11/2021 06:53

@pineapplevape the way you keep telling us patronisingly to THINK is so annoying.

Yes, I know what needs to be done, (and you haven’t said what YOU’VE done so I doubt you’ve done anything tbh).

However, I have so many problems right now coupled with depression, if I want to donate to a food bank and not lobby the government right now, that’s what I’ll do, and you won’t make me feel guilty about it.

FluffyBooBoo · 03/11/2021 05:59

I'm not setting out to get anyone's 'backs up'. That's a ridiculous statement

It's not a ridiculous statement. You have repeatedly slated 95% of people on this thread for not doing enough, with nothing to back it up.

no-one else comments about the underlying causes of why huge numbers of people are needing food charity in the UK

I don't see you doing that either. You just keep asking the question. If you want to discuss the causes, raise them. All you have done, so far, is ask why nobody is speaking about them and suggesting that they write to their MPs about it.

What is it about the current welfare system that isn't for for purpose? What potential solutions could their be? Is it just about money, or are there other possible things that could be done?

If you want people that aren't already doing something to write to their MPs, maybe give them more information?

And why not - as well as donating - start to try to influence change in other ways - like making it clear to your representatives that a welfare system which relies on charity to stop people starving is perhaps not fit for purpose??!!

And there you are again, assuming people aren't doing that, but at least this time you have added a hint of the very causes you are complaining that other people aren't speaking about.

PrincessNutella · 03/11/2021 04:00

tinned tomatoes are a great food. Versatile, nutritious, and tasty..

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/11/2021 03:51

There really was less food poverty in the Blair / Brown years, or does it just feel that way?

Benefits were far more generous. So there should not have been the same degree of food poverty.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/11/2021 03:49

I don't give food to food banks. I give money so their volunteers can buy whatever it is their customers need at wholesale prices. If you all did that then food banks could buy tinned tomatoes if their customers use them, or not if they don't.

This. Giving a 35p Tim of tomatoes to a food bank has to be the ultimate in virtue signalling. Especially if you then also vote Tory

eeek88 · 03/11/2021 00:35

@DerbyshireMama

I saw someone on Facebook asking for details of a local food bank. Had a nosey on her profile and she was regularly posting photos of her latest acrylic nails. Aren't they at least £20 a pop? Isn't it a bit off to regularly spend that much on a complete non-essential while also claiming you can't afford to feed yourself and taking food away from people who genuinely don't have a pot to piss in?
There’s always one (I mean you, not nail-woman).

Thank you for your thoughtful and relevant contribution.

People are allowed to have changing financial needs, to post photos on social media that aren’t up-to-date, to have sudden financial crises, to fuck up. But yeah let’s all jump on the ‘poor people are just scroungers bandwagon’ shall we?

I’m guessing that one would not publicly announce one’s destitution if it did not exist. Food banks aren’t fun.

Belleager · 03/11/2021 00:27

@logsonlogsoff

‘ Why do we assume so many parents in the UK can't feed their children enough?’

We’re not assuming anything. There are endless studies and reports to support the fact that children in the U.K. are going hungry, do rely on school meals, aren’t getting either enough food or the right nutrients or both.
Nutrition is expensive, calories are cheap.
I know it might seem hard to believe and it is DISGRACEFUL that this is the case in a country as wealthy as ours but it is fact, not assumption.

You're right - should have written, why is this situation accepted as the norm and built in to planning. But obviously the school dinners are needed. Food banks by same token.

There really was less food poverty in the Blair / Brown years, or does it just feel that way?

logsonlogsoff · 03/11/2021 00:18

‘ Why do we assume so many parents in the UK can't feed their children enough?’

We’re not assuming anything. There are endless studies and reports to support the fact that children in the U.K. are going hungry, do rely on school meals, aren’t getting either enough food or the right nutrients or both.
Nutrition is expensive, calories are cheap.
I know it might seem hard to believe and it is DISGRACEFUL that this is the case in a country as wealthy as ours but it is fact, not assumption.