Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that donating tinned tomatoes to the food bank shows a real lack of understanding of food poverty?

659 replies

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/11/2021 08:53

The food bank donation box at my local supermarket this morning had a fairly good mix of items, apart from about a third of the tins were tinned tomatoes.

Surely it would be better all round to donate products which need little to no additional ingredients?

Tinned tomatoes are a base - they will never be a meal in their own right. They need at the bare minimum, some seasoning and or some veg or protein to make them useable.

And then even if you could rustle up some other ingredients to make them palateable/nutritious, you need to heat them - if they contain meat or lentils they need a good length of time on the heat.

Those using food banks likely cannot give over 20mins on the hob for tinned tomatoes. The cost of heating up the food (if there is even funds on the meter) is too high for the return.

I do think that people who donate tinned tomatoes, come at it from a reasonably comfortable point of view - just chuck it in with some mince and a bit if garlic and slow cook it for a couple of hours.

All of which is likely to be outside of the financial scope of the recipient.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
nancywhitehead · 01/11/2021 10:56

Tinned tomatoes and mince do not need to be slow cooked for a couple of hours Hmm

Many people who use food banks still want to prioritise healthy and nutritious meals, and will find ways of cooking. Those who want more convenience foods will take the things that suit them.

HarrietsChariot · 01/11/2021 10:55

People donate tinned tomatoes because they're cheap. Chuck a couple of 35p cans in the donation bin and you can feel good that you're part of the solution and are a GOOD PERSON who has done all they need to do.

Also, there's the guilt factor and pester factor when leaving the shop. Kids pester their parents into donating something they've bought, people feel guilty about not doing it. What can be more inessential out of all your shopping than tinned tomatoes, which were destined to sit at the back of the cupboard for a year or so until they get thrown out for being out of date?

Finally there's the "follow the leader" aspect, people see the donation bin filled with tinned tomatoes and thing "shit, that must be what we should be donating." People are unoriginal like that.

Food banks don't want tinned tomatoes, and the people who use them certainly don't. The most important things to donate are
-Baked Beans (Heinz, Branstons, HP or Waitrose own brand)
-Tinned meals like "Hunger Breaks All Day Breakfast"
-Tinned pasta shapes in tomato sauce
-Corned beef
-Sardines/mackerel/salmon (not tuna)
-Pasta (fusilli or macaroni)
-Bleach
-Sugar
-Coffee
-Long life milk
-Tinned fruit and veg
-Potatoes
-Bread

sHREDDIES19 · 01/11/2021 10:54

I love tinned tomatoes on toast! Nowt wrong with that as a hearty brekkie and very cheap.

bubblesbubbles11 · 01/11/2021 10:53

do you have to be referred by a GP/social services etc to ask to receive items from a foodbank? I just wondered how it worked, am on a very very tight budget.

onelittlefrog · 01/11/2021 10:52

I think you may lack some understanding of food bank users. You're making a bit of an assumption about who is using food banks.

Yes, there will be people who aren't able to cook from scratch and tinned tomatoes won't be suitable for them.

There will also be people for whom other items aren't suitable for a plethora of reasons. That's why they ask for a variety.

Just because someone is using a food bank does not mean they don't want/ aren't able to cook once they have the food.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 01/11/2021 10:51

When I was young and starting out in life. I took a tin of tomato to work everyday for my lunch.

Microwaved for a few minutes and eaten in a bowl. It was delicious and cheap. 17p as I recall.

Maireas · 01/11/2021 10:46

Like pp, I donate what the food bank requests.
There's a list next to the boxes at the supermarket. Often tins of tomatoes are requested, I'm guessing for the reasons suggested above, such as versatility and nutrition.

Tillysfad · 01/11/2021 10:45

Surely you want your food bank to allow folk to create healthy meals from scratch? The alternative is convenience foods!

Do you actually know how to cook? Any student knows that tinned tomatoes are an essential component of most cheap, nutritious meals because they can be cooked with mince.

PABJ · 01/11/2021 10:45

YABU. They're one of the most versatile foods. You can make them easily into a tomato soup, as a base for sauce for so many things, etc. My simplest use is to cook them on the stove with a big knob of butter or margarine for a while until they go all thick and silky, and mix them with spaghetti. Add meatballs if you want to. Tomatoes with toast dipped in are lovely.

If food banks only wanted foods that don't require any prep then they'd say that. You're being absolutely ridiculous.

doginabox · 01/11/2021 10:44

and as I have said before, my food bank actively asks for it. I am not going to be an up myself donator and put in merchant gourmet wild rice and puy lentils and smoked Maldon salt, like someone I saw last week. People do buy and eat tinned meat meals - that's why the supermarkets sell them - they aren't just being bought for food banks, lots of people actively like them.

julieca · 01/11/2021 10:43

I had tinned bolognaise regularly as a student. I wouldn't now, but it was okay.

Maireas · 01/11/2021 10:43

@sashh

Tinned tomatoes can be eaten cold.

They can be a side dish like any veg.

They can be put in a pan with a tin of some other vegetable to make a simple, if not very tasty meal.

They can be put in a pan and have pasta added to make another simple meal.

They can be broken up with a potato masher to make a soup either on their own or adding other ingredients.

They can be put on toast like beans.

They are suitable for vegetarians, vegans, people of various faiths.

YABU

Excellent post
doginabox · 01/11/2021 10:41

Some tinned bolognaise is fine. It is no worse than tinned soup. I'd be happy to eat either tbh!

FluffyBooBoo · 01/11/2021 10:39

@girlmom21

Tinned bolognaise etc is vile. Just because someone's going through a rough patch doesn't mean they shouldn't be allowed decent food.
It wouldn't be on sale if it wasn't sold in reasonably high qualities.

Just because you don't like it, doesn't mean others won't appreciate it.

girlmom21 · 01/11/2021 10:37

Tinned bolognaise etc is vile. Just because someone's going through a rough patch doesn't mean they shouldn't be allowed decent food.

REP22 · 01/11/2021 10:36

They're cheap, nutritious and can be mixed with a wide variety of other things. I would be very grateful for some tinned tomatoes. I think they'll always be popular.

MrTumblesSpottyHag · 01/11/2021 10:34

Whenever we donate to our food bank I check their wanted list and bulk buy whatever they're asking for. So if you visit the food bank box after I've been there it'll look like the only thing they've been given is 100 part baked rolls or 62 packets of smash or whatever.
Ours is always asking for tinned custard which looks crap as a donation but I think the people running it are the ones who know what's needed so I try to stick to their list.

MrsEricBana · 01/11/2021 10:32

Blimey. Well I think the OP may have had a fair question as to would it not be more useful to donate things nearer to the end point than a base ingredient. The answer is no, turns out tinned toms are very useful, versatile and much wanted item. I don't think OP was being presumptive at all and right to try and give the most helpful thing. Our supermarket has labels by partic products that would be very welcomed at the food donation point e.g. packet milk, pasta etc so I go by that.

Whinginadeville · 01/11/2021 10:32

The tone deaf donators are giving mini prosecco, chocolate and pink himalayas salt as 'everyone deserves a treat' not the much requested and always used tinned toms.

doginabox · 01/11/2021 10:31

@DeepaBeesKit

Things like ready made tinned bolognese also tend to be horribly salty and made with utter crap. Why do we assume these service users should be willing to eat shite we wouldnt buy ourselves?

Not to mention, by having a mixed product you limit who you can give it to.

Tinned toms can be given to anyone.

A can of ready made bolognese will likely contain beef (which lots of people of South Asian heritage will not eat), or pork (which Muslims & Jewish people will not eat). Not to mention it can't be given to vegetarians.

goodness. I used to eat it when I was struggling and it was fine. It's not utter shite actually and besides, our food bank actively asks for tinned meals and tinned meat. If you don't have a hob then you can heat it in the microwave and it doesn't involve ltos of chopping and cooking. I assume they wouldn't give it to vegetarians!
DrCoconut · 01/11/2021 10:30

I have been so poor that I had no fuel at all as the gas and electricity were switched off. The company fitted token meters but in the downstairs flat where we had no access to it and there was usually no money to put in it anyway. So for people in those circumstances things that can be eaten cold are a godsend. Ring pull tins as you can't even assume people have a tin opener. But then there will be people who are maybe awaiting payment, been made redundant etc and are not in as dire straits and will be able to cook from scratch. So I'd say a good variety of donations is ideal so they can be matched to people's circumstances.

DeepaBeesKit · 01/11/2021 10:29

Things like ready made tinned bolognese also tend to be horribly salty and made with utter crap. Why do we assume these service users should be willing to eat shite we wouldnt buy ourselves?

Not to mention, by having a mixed product you limit who you can give it to.

Tinned toms can be given to anyone.

A can of ready made bolognese will likely contain beef (which lots of people of South Asian heritage will not eat), or pork (which Muslims & Jewish people will not eat). Not to mention it can't be given to vegetarians.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 01/11/2021 10:27

They are requested, I hope they are of use. At my last employer(very big) we supported the food bank. List of items divided between teams. Competition to raise money and then to get the best value for the money in sourcing a specific thing. Tinned tomatoes were defo on that list.
I do hear you though that some would find a tomato pasta source more use!

doginabox · 01/11/2021 10:25

gosh - surely this is massive overthinking? I donate what the food bank asks for and they often ask for tinned veg or tinned meals. I don't normally put tinned tomatoes in because I always donate tinned bolognaise/tinned meals/tinned potatoes/tinned peas (and tea!) but I cannot believe they would mind tinned tomatoes. If they don't think they are suitable they will specify this on the donation box.

AuntieStella · 01/11/2021 10:23

My local food bank has an online list, regularly updated, of what is most wanted (varies, but UHT milk and non-dairy milks, tinned meat, tinned vegetables and tinned fruit always seem to be in it) plus a list of 'thanks to previous generosity we currently have plenty of' list ie we don't want it at the moment.

I will always include things from the most wanted list, but will also add in treat food (as well as the basic supplies, clients are allowed to take 1 or 2 items from the treat/random stuff table), surplus BOGOFs and other items (unwanted gift toiletries).

And yes I'm the person who did worse than the oysters - I donated tinned snails - it was a joke present and never going to pass the lips of anyone here, so gave it away on the off chance that someone might like it! I did include long-life part-baked baguettes that time, so someone could pretend they were having French cuisine (though I doubt they stayed together!)

Swipe left for the next trending thread