Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that donating tinned tomatoes to the food bank shows a real lack of understanding of food poverty?

659 replies

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 01/11/2021 08:53

The food bank donation box at my local supermarket this morning had a fairly good mix of items, apart from about a third of the tins were tinned tomatoes.

Surely it would be better all round to donate products which need little to no additional ingredients?

Tinned tomatoes are a base - they will never be a meal in their own right. They need at the bare minimum, some seasoning and or some veg or protein to make them useable.

And then even if you could rustle up some other ingredients to make them palateable/nutritious, you need to heat them - if they contain meat or lentils they need a good length of time on the heat.

Those using food banks likely cannot give over 20mins on the hob for tinned tomatoes. The cost of heating up the food (if there is even funds on the meter) is too high for the return.

I do think that people who donate tinned tomatoes, come at it from a reasonably comfortable point of view - just chuck it in with some mince and a bit if garlic and slow cook it for a couple of hours.

All of which is likely to be outside of the financial scope of the recipient.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
Incredibad · 04/11/2021 13:29

Used our local food bank after job loss from 2018 to 2020 tinned tomatoes were a godsend and very ‘suitable’ thanks.

ElementalIllusions · 04/11/2021 12:24

I volunteer at a food bank,
tinned tomato’s are one of the top requested items specifically BECAUSE they are the base for so many dishes.

I get your point about people needing things that are quick, easy and ‘whole meals’ like a tin of beans, chilli or Mac and cheese, etc,
but that only serves one maybe two on a stretch for one meal, a tin of tomatoes, with a few store cupboard staples could feed a family or a single person for several meals.

things like tinned veg and lentils are requested far more regularly than tinned meals, in fact it’s common for people to ask to exchange a tinned meal for something like tinned tomatoes or tinned veg as they can make it go further.

Cupcakeschocolate · 04/11/2021 12:12

We use loads of tinned tomatoes at home. Granted we are lucky not need to use the food bank. But they can be used in so many ways. We have a Mediterranean diet and I add them to stews. Stuffed veg with meat and rice. Spag bol. Casseroles, and many many other meals!!

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 04/11/2021 12:08

But in the same token I used to work at the front end of benefit fraud, and saw what some (emphasis on some) people were doing and claiming. It is ridiculous.

To be fair, the system itself begs to be defrauded, it does the same to many claimants. It isn't fit for purpose. Ridiculous isn't a strong enough word for it!

It really shouldn't be that hard to claim a top up credit that means families, kids, can have a good basic standard of living.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 04/11/2021 12:05

The system is cumbersome. Initially the computer systems didn't work (the compant building them didn't finish, made a complete balls up of it). It doesn't cope with fluctuating incomes - the gig economy makes it almost impossible to manage. It started with massive overpayments, based on how it was calculated. Millions of people were left with debts TO the system BECAUSE of the system.

That difficulty remains with UC too, again because of the time period in which it is calcutaed and dealing with fluctuating incomes.

And that's just the technicalities of it, not even considering the wider ethics of it - removing the cost: benefit basis of working for both employer and employee. No matter how good your employer they had to either
a) play the system for your benefit
b) play the system for their own benefit
c) screw it up for everyone through not understanding the system

And there are no checks and balances on that - the gig economy saw to that!

It could have been exactly what they wanted - a move to a single benefit / support system for working age adults. but it failed, UC will fail the same way.

You only have to read the "workshy bastards with their hand out - just get a job" posts here to see why!

I hate the UKs prototypical, liberal welfare state. Nothing is ever learned, something newer and shinier is always reached for and god forbid any government look elsewhere to see what works well, even less expect a shift in public perceptions!

spudjulia · 04/11/2021 11:55

Looks like this thread has moved on a bit from the OP, but anyway..

I grew up with very little money. Tinned tomatoes was still a staple in our house. We used to have this thing called tomato soldiers (bacon tomato soldiers if we had enough for a rasher of bacon). It was basically a tin of plum tomatoes shared into bowls, with bread cut into soldiers (like egg soldiers). We used to dip the soldiers in the juice till it was all soaked up then eat the tomatoes. Was delicious!

Now I'm better off and I've moved to chopped tomatoes and they are now mainly used for the base of other meals, but for people with less money, tinned toms are a great way to get the goodness of tomatoes far cheaper and with a lknger life than fresh tomatoes.

TheRiat · 04/11/2021 11:55

Like Ive said before, I certainly dont begrudge anyone who genuinely needs the support.

But in the same token I used to work at the front end of benefit fraud, and saw what some (emphasis on some) people were doing and claiming. It is ridiculous.

I have actually been there. We were living in rented housing, a new born, literally hardly any food in the house and not 2 pennies to rub together, oh and neither of us had a job. Its hard.

And actually for the person that said about been at the other end, where we do have to claim. My partner was diagnosed with a long term condition recently and are now going through the process.

Unfortunately the few spoil it for the many.

4fingerKitKat · 04/11/2021 11:39

Thanks - I will have to do some more reading around WTC. I thought they were intended to alleviate working poverty and were broadly welcomed by anti-poverty groups. What went wrong?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 04/11/2021 11:21

Yes. WTC.

Intended to boost the economy, but it just became another way for employers to pay less and force people into a system that is never going to be fit for purpose

TreborBore · 04/11/2021 08:14

@TheRiat - PIP is not an out of work benefit, it’s to help towards the extra costs of living with a disability, so some people claiming PIP are in work. For some the PIP payment enables them to work by covering the extra costs of getting there - that’s what it’s for. But not everyone is fortunate enough to have circumstances that allow them to work.

FuzzyPuffling · 04/11/2021 07:13

@TheRiat

I really do feel for those that have budgeted properly and still do not have enough at the end of the week/ month.

I claimed benefit once in my life. And do you know what it made me do!!!! It made me promise myself to never claim another benefit again. (Job seekers for 6 months)

There are plenty of jobs out there. The service industry are crying out for people, the transport industry (if you believe the media) are crying out for people.

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

As stated above I really do feel for those that are genuine and really do struggle. But I used to work for the fraud dept in one of the government agencies and it really has made me cynical of people.

And for those that are talking about delays to their PIP. A friend of mine is in a wheelchair, has a full time job and banks their PIP. Just because you claim PIP dosent mean you cant work.

Utterly infuriated by this attitude. We got poor when DH was diagnosed with blood cancer. Long term, very damaging treatment and he needed full time care from me.

But of course, in your world, we're just a pair of smoking, drinking, Netflix watching skivers. ( None of those apply)

Let's hope the dice of life always falls your way, eh?

FluffyBooBoo · 04/11/2021 06:56

“Gordon Brown's decision to alleviate the wages bill for companies”?

I would hazard that they are referring to the introduction of working tax credits.

Which, because of the name, people don't think of as 'benefits' but of course they very much were.

SummerOrAutumn · 04/11/2021 06:43

IIRC Jack Monroe donated copies of Tin Can Cook to foodbanks so that people could see how versatile cooking with tinned vegetables can be. There's a lovely recipe for Tinestrone (a version of Minestrone) that hardly takes any time to cook and makes a huge pan. I made it and it's delicious.

4fingerKitKat · 03/11/2021 22:30

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

Thanks for your insightful posts on this thread!

What was “Gordon Brown's decision to alleviate the wages bill for companies”?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 03/11/2021 22:11

That's true. We run stats on the client base and the number of 2-wage households now seeking our help has risen dramatically over the last couple of years, it was already rising pre Brexit, covid etc. They just seem to have sped it up.

The gig economy, the long term effects of Gordon Brown's decision to alleviate the wages bill for companies, and the inequity and unwieldiness of the benefits system have been financially devastating for a lot of people. Many of our clients are struggling because they have no idea how to navigate the benfits system, never having made m/any claims before.

That's why we also have support workers to help people work out what they can and cannot claim!

But yes, "Ooh! They're just workshy" is so very yesterday!

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 03/11/2021 21:15

@sunglassesonthetable

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

I think it's widely accepted now that many of those at the receiving end of food banks ARE in jobs @TheRiat

You sound massively out of touch.

Exactly. Including professionals such as nurses

So smug yet ignorant @TheRiat

sunglassesonthetable · 03/11/2021 21:08

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

I think it's widely accepted now that many of those at the receiving end of food banks ARE in jobs @TheRiat

You sound massively out of touch.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 03/11/2021 20:59

@TheRiat

I really do feel for those that have budgeted properly and still do not have enough at the end of the week/ month.

I claimed benefit once in my life. And do you know what it made me do!!!! It made me promise myself to never claim another benefit again. (Job seekers for 6 months)

There are plenty of jobs out there. The service industry are crying out for people, the transport industry (if you believe the media) are crying out for people.

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

As stated above I really do feel for those that are genuine and really do struggle. But I used to work for the fraud dept in one of the government agencies and it really has made me cynical of people.

And for those that are talking about delays to their PIP. A friend of mine is in a wheelchair, has a full time job and banks their PIP. Just because you claim PIP dosent mean you cant work.

If you have kids and no childcare, you can't work those jobs. The service industry and transport industry requires evening and weekend work. Personally I could not do that as a single parent, I have no one to look after my child and there is no childcare at weekends. So what then?
Fangdango · 03/11/2021 20:54

[quote HoardingSamphireSaurus]@Fangdango! Yes! That!

It's a next step from the War Book of recipes and has stood us in good stead over the years.

Flour, fat and a tin of anything - plate pie. Add a tin of potatoes/vegetables and you're REALLY well set! DH says he fell in proper love when he ate my first plate pie. He wasn't to know just how cheap and easy it was, or how long the women in my family had been cooking them, keeping the recipe secret Smile

If you want a really posh version that doesn't cost much more: pastry, minced meat of some sort, vegetables cut small , a packet of stuffing that matches the meat and a pie plate:
Line the pie plate with pastry
Mix the meat/veg and stuffing put in top of the pastry
Add a pastry lid
Oven on about 180/200 for about 30 minutes

Egg, tin of tomatoes - shakshuka, or tomato mess if you live with me. Add a tin of potatoes and you're into frittata territory

Tin of any kind of sausages, tin of tomatoes, tin of beans (not baked beans) - sausage hot pot

Tin of meatballs, tin of beans (not baked beans), maybe tomatoes, some spicing - chilli meatballs

So many one pot dishes can be made from tins of stuff.

We have a chart like that. people who want ideas can take a sheet of paper and put a tin in each column to make a meal. We have an A N Other column for spices etc.

It's great for sweet and savoury dishes from very little.[/quote]
Starving now Wink

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 03/11/2021 19:41

@ILoveShula

That's easy *@NeverDropYourMoonCup*, 0/28 = go to foodbank
Exactly! If somebody has nothing, you can't tell them to spread it out over the next month and then tell them that if they get any money the following month, they'll have to make it last two in case their UC is fucked up or their ZHC amounts to seven hours for a fortnight - they need food now, not a lecture on not spending it all at once.
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 03/11/2021 19:40

Sorry not the tories fault. Get a job. Dont rely on the benefits system.

OMG you really have no idea of the reality some people face do you?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 03/11/2021 19:37

Foodbank isn't a 28 day thing

And if they were how do you get there and back with all the bags?

But yes, it is easy - you just leap into your time machine, go back however many years you need to and make better decisions. Simples!

ILoveShula · 03/11/2021 19:35

That's easy @NeverDropYourMoonCup,
0/28 = go to foodbank

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 03/11/2021 19:16

@CatsArePeople

Teach people to budget.

Biscuit

Yes. Could that poster perhaps remind us again what zero pounds divided by twenty-eight days is?
MarshaBradyo · 03/11/2021 18:49

What would you suggest is best op?