Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if we can stop dicking about with the clocks?

385 replies

ThirdElephant · 01/11/2021 04:48

Just that, really. I'm up at 4:30 for the second day in a row because of this clock nonsense. Changing bedtime is not adjusting wake-up time, just resulting in a tired infant. Can we all just leave the clocks where they are from now on?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 01/11/2021 13:02

We were in the South East so God knows what it must have been like for people further north or in Scotland.

According to my mum, it was awful. And the statistics agree with her as more people were killed or injured in Scotland over that period of time.

LemonSwan · 01/11/2021 12:32

As a gardener YABU,

But I am happy for us to stay on winter time permanently if the change is what irritates you.

endofagain · 01/11/2021 12:27

Decades ago we did try not changing them, but the number of children getting run over on their their route to school went up a lot. I think there were other reasons to do with consumption of electricity perhaps, but it was changed back.

Toddlerteaplease · 01/11/2021 12:20

@sleepinglionsroar we don't get paid for it.

Snoozer11 · 01/11/2021 12:18

I never understand why people have such a fuss over this. It's literally one hour!

Apparently we didn't change the clocks one year and there were kids walking to school at 8am in darkness.

PuffinShop · 01/11/2021 12:10

@HalloHello

Iceland manage their very few daylight hours just fine. Why can't we manage a dark morning? We would all get used to it after a few days and then wouldn't really notice it in the following years I don't think!
How do you know? People cope because they have to, of course, but a lot of people find the winter very hard.

We have similar debates in Iceland and public health campaigns because we're on GMT which is wrong for the position of the sun. We don't have to deal with clocks changing, but we do have 'unnaturally' dark mornings for longer than we would need to because the sun reaches its high point at 1 pm rather than noon. Sleep experts say that this is not good for us. It is healthier to get up in the light when possible.

notimagain · 01/11/2021 12:09

I remember it..and the RTA (adult pedestrian hit by car, VSI but fortunately non fatal) that happened one morning right in front of us whilst we were waiting for the schools bus.

Being v rural we had about a one hour bus ride to/from school, so we ended up either going to school in the dark, which happened during the trial, or coming home in the dark, when the trial stopped……?

that aside the trial didn’t leave much of an impression on me either..

80sMum · 01/11/2021 11:55

@risefromyourgrave

I’m sure they had a trial where they didn’t change them one year. My mum has said about it, she said it was horrible.
It was 3 years. I remember it. All of us schoolchildren were encouraged to wear reflective hi-viz armbands and to stick reflective stickers on our schoolbags, so we could be seen while walking to school in the morning.

Here's an article from BBC News in 2010 on the subject.

Peregrina · 01/11/2021 11:41

I am old enough to remember the experiment of keeping on BST all the year round, and quite honestly, it has made no impression on me whatever.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 01/11/2021 11:37

The clocks going back is my favourite time of the year! I actually feel rested for about a week until I get used to it.

AlfonsoTheUnrepetant · 01/11/2021 11:34

@blink1eight2 - What is so ridiculous about my post? You're still not answering the question.

Lockdownbear · 01/11/2021 11:31

@jontyl

Wouldn't it be better to move Scotland school hours to 9.30 start in the winter.
Then kids won't be coming home until half hour later and in dark at night.

Messing with school start times is stupid because then parents say I can't start until later, so everything else becomes later.

And places opening at different times and stuff.

OverTheRubicon · 01/11/2021 11:29

We're a nation with an obesity problem, a lack of exercise problem, and a female safety problem. All of these would be better addressed by lighter afternoons and evenings.

Going to school or work in the dark is not great but is a safer time of day and will be largely on lit roads. Playing or socialising simply isn't possible in dark parks and playgrounds, and walking home at 5pm in the dark is less safe than walking to work or school at 8.30am in the same darkness.

Lockdownbear · 01/11/2021 11:28

@Peregrina

I read the EU will be dropping it next year but we wont

So what do we do with N Ireland? Play silly buggers and have a different time zone than the Republic? Or insist that the Republic falls into line with the UK?

I mentioned how the Norwegian border is two hours or one hour in summer behind Russia - but the border is very short, and not all that may people live there, and I doubt whether all that many cross the border regularly (except to buy petrol in Russia because it's cheaper) but NI/RoI is a very different kettle of fish.

Ireland and Portugal are with Western European Time same as UK if Central Time doesn't change their clocks then the time difference will be 2hrs instead on 1hr.
jontyl · 01/11/2021 11:28

Wouldn't it be better to move Scotland school hours to 9.30 start in the winter.

Lockdownbear · 01/11/2021 11:26

@Walkingthedog46

I don’t know how to change the car clock either - still, it is correct for six months of the year!
Set it to BST and it will be right for 7 months April, May, Jun, Jul, Aug, Sep, Oct. GMT is only 5 mths Wink
Edinvillian · 01/11/2021 11:20

I'm in the North of Scotland and even with the time change it can still be quite dark when my son goes to school at 8.30 in Winter. If they didn't change it would be pitch black.

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 01/11/2021 11:12

Throws us all off at work, as there are two tasks that have to be done at very specific times which we don't/change change when the clocks change (so will do at, eg 9am instead of 10 now).
Hate it.

Peregrina · 01/11/2021 10:56

I read the EU will be dropping it next year but we wont

So what do we do with N Ireland? Play silly buggers and have a different time zone than the Republic? Or insist that the Republic falls into line with the UK?

I mentioned how the Norwegian border is two hours or one hour in summer behind Russia - but the border is very short, and not all that may people live there, and I doubt whether all that many cross the border regularly (except to buy petrol in Russia because it's cheaper) but NI/RoI is a very different kettle of fish.

avocadotofu · 01/11/2021 10:52

I'm totally with you. My son woke up at 4:30am Sunday and 5am today and I'm exhausted!!

Alwaystired99 · 01/11/2021 10:49

Same here. We'd just got over weeks of disruption due to teething and now she's awake at 5 like clockwork. My son was always a rubbish sleeper and no good with routine but she's got an internal clock that is bang on every day so this is hard. Plus by the time she gets to nursery she's asleep as she's been up playing for hours!

notimagain · 01/11/2021 10:40

@Peregrina

Ireland and Portugal have the same timezone as the UK. Spain has arguments about their timezone.

I am well aware of this, and aware that the Spanish have considered going back to what should be their normal time zone. I believed that it was a hangover from Franco's regime, but I may be wrong there.

But in practice with countries that have more than one time zone, those people who live in the areas bordering the place where the zone changes get used to knowing that the clock is an hour different on the other side. Or two hours if you are on the Russian/Norwegian border.

Unless you are in India of course, where they are five and a half hours ahead of the UK in wintertime, don't bother with Summer Time, and could well make a case for three time zones. As for China, which is officially 8 hours ahead of UTC, and only have one time zone - do people in districts far away from Beijing have some sort of local time?

As you say plenty of places have odd half hour time zones- India certainly, I think South Australia is half an hour out from some neighboring states, and even the Falklands at one point, maybe still does, had a time difference between Port Stanley and the rest of the islands…..

Ultimately it’s just time on a display/dial so I expect in reality people learn to work with what they have rather than worrying what the clock says.

I wonder in the case of the Chinese set up you mentioned if those in the west just accept working with their day/night skewed across the day differently to those in the East, or do they just start and finish work later on the clock?

RandomLondoner · 01/11/2021 10:23

I've been thinking what time structure I'd choose if I were dictator, assuming the clock was always set to GMT. At the moment, I think I'd want the school/working day recommended start at 9am in December and January and 7.45am in June and July, with other months being shifted 15 minutes from the one before. So February and November 8.45am, March and October 8.30am, April and September 8.15am, May and August 8am.

(I think this means in June and July school/work would be starting 15 minutes earlier than our current BST, but not sure about that.)

(I would be a gentle dictator, so the times would only be recommendations. People and schools and businesses could settle on something else mutually agreeable, if they preferred.)

whynotwhatknot · 01/11/2021 10:19

I read the EU will be dropping it next year but we wont

tiredoftiers · 01/11/2021 10:12

The kids would be going to school in the pitch dark in Scotland if we didn’t change to GMT. I’m not hugely sure that BST really benefits us.