Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU engagement proposal

133 replies

Ale24 · 01/11/2021 00:22

AIBU
Please help
I should feel happy but I feel so terrible
My parent of over 5 years proposed to me today, it was awkward and it really felt like he didn’t mean it
He proposed to me with the ring he gave me as my 40th birthday present saying that it is a engagement ring and there is no need to buy new one. I thought it was joke, but it isn’t.
Btw he does have enough money to buy ring.
I feel so worthless and embarrassed 😞
He also didn’t told his friend or family that we engaged.
It’s all feels and looks sad and fake and now I am crying all night
Please tell me if I am wrong 😑

OP posts:
BiLuminous · 01/11/2021 09:04

Been there. Had the doubts. Im divorced. Pull out now!

ChristmasFluff · 01/11/2021 08:58

People have missed the real significance of He previously was married and I had to listen how much he wanted that marriage and how many 10s and 10s and 10s and 10s of thousands he spend on her ring

This isn't a man who has issues with marriage due to his past, this is a man who is using triangulation. He's saying, 'look OP, I REALLY wanted to marry my ex-wife, and I bought her The Best Ring Ever. But you aren't worth that, so I don't want to marry you, and here, have one of your own rings.'

He's trying (and succeeding, by the looks) to squash your self-esteem and to keep you in a relationship that takes little effort on his part. This is not about you getting marriage as a reward for sticking with him and putting him first when you should have been putting yourself first - but that is what you are thinking it is, and that is why you won't let go.

A PP has mentioned the sunk costs fallacy, and they are right. Please don't continue to make this mistake, just because you've spent a long time making it.

He does not love, care or respect you. This is the best it will ever be. He hasn't told anyone, because he isn't overjoyed, and I highly doubt there will ever be a wedding. If there is, expect it to be as underwhelming as his proposal.

Another PP is right. You really do need to raise your bar. This doesn't mean lecturing and prescribing to him, or 'talking' to him, because I'd bet my life you've talked to him about this sort of thing over and over.

You get what you accept. Non-acceptance of this is walking away to make space for someone who actually loves you.

Porcupineintherough · 01/11/2021 08:56

It's really not about the ring OP - unless you are using it as a measure if his commitment to you. And if you are, then why? You say you've given your all to him over the last few years has that been reciprocated?

If he'd proposed w a shiny diamond ring would you feel happy now?

BigFatLiar · 01/11/2021 08:52

I’m sorry but this sounds like the tip of the iceberg and I would question his sincerety on your relationship future

I wouldn't be questioning his commitment to the relationship but to the idea of getting married which he's already said he didn't want. After several years I suspect he's happy with the relationship but has given in on the marriage idea to keep the peace. Sounds more like something he's being pushed into.

icelollycraving · 01/11/2021 08:51

I would have felt deflated too. I think I would not refer to the engagement again, and decide if I actually saw a future together. If he brought up the engagement, I’d say I thought it was a joke because surely no one would propose with a ring you wear daily and have done for years. Him not telling anyone, taking any romance out of what is essentially a romantic gesture is telling you exactly how he sees you.

HeartsAndClubs · 01/11/2021 08:50

This isn’t about the lack of a ring IMO. It’s about the message sent out that “you have enough rings, so if you want one just use that one.” Coupled with “do you know how many 1000’s I spent on my ex’s ring?”

That’s what makes the gesture cheap. If he’d suggested that he wanted to marry her but wasn’t sure whether they could afford/whether a ring was the best idea that would be one thing, but he didn’t even suggest that.

When my eXH proposed he actually did so with a ring I already owned, but it was just for the proposal, and then we went out and shopped for rings, as he knew how particular I am and didn’t feel confident buying me one on his own. But that’s an entirely different prospect from taking a ring from 4 years ago and saying that “well, you know that was your birthday present? Now it’s your engagement ring.” Added to which, if they split should she feel obliged to give it back since it’s now her engagement ring?

Skysblue · 01/11/2021 08:46

It sounds like he has major issues around marriage/rings etc. Given this I wonder why he propsed at all - perhaps he thought it was something you want/deserve? But he’s being half-hearted about it which is very unfair to you.

I can see why he hasn’t announced the engagement to everyone yet as clearly you are very uoset and if he knows you at all he’ll have picked up on that.

Pause. Tell him that you’re confused about whether or not he wants to get married and that reusing your ring felt like some kind of statement but you don’t understand what it meant.

Tell him that getting married should be a romantic time when you feel very close and this feel like a bad start.

But before all of that, work out in your heart if you want to marry him. It’s ok to marry an unromantic thoughtless guy (I certainly did!) if you love him anyway.

NameChange2PostThis · 01/11/2021 08:45

@Ale24

My 40th birthday was over 4 years ago and I wore that ring everyday
This ^ is shocking. Your op may have confused pps but this clarifies.

So basically your marriage-reluctant’D’P took an old piece of your jewellery and re-gifted it to you. And told you this was your engagement ring - and didn’t share the news with anyone else.
Red flags everywhere here.
I’m sorry but this sounds like the tip of the iceberg and I would question his sincerety on your relationship future.
If you do decide to stay, you need to insist he proposes again, properly. Stand firm. Not because you need a new ring but because a new ring will represent his desire to make an effort for you, to commit to your needs and wishes. And then he needs to be sharing the news with family and friends as a representation of his public commitment. Good luck Flowers

NowEvenBetter · 01/11/2021 08:44

Do you want to get married to him or not? If you actually do, you’re going to look back on your behaviour and be so embarrassed. If not, dump him.

TasteTheMeatNotTheHeat · 01/11/2021 08:41

If it feels wrong then it is wrong.

I'd give the ring back. Don't settle, OP.

BigFatLiar · 01/11/2021 08:39

No he didn’t wanted to get married at first at all and always said he will never marry again.
He previously was married and I had to listen how much he wanted that marriage and how many 10s and 10s and 10s and 10s of thousands he spend on her ring

Are you surprised at his reluctant proposal? He has a failed marriage which seems to have hit him hard. It had an expensive ring which didn't lead to a long lasting marriage. If you were focussed on marriage and rings from the start rather than the relationship then this was the wrong relationship, he told you early on. Sounds like he wants to keep the relationship and thinks this is the only way. Lots of people have long term partners and are unmarried, many seem to last longer than marriages.

AudTheDeepMinded · 01/11/2021 08:35

Tight git! I know it's not all about an expensive ring but that is just taking the piss. Mine was a vintage (secondhand!) ring hat was a couple of hundred quid, but he chose it and put thought into what style I liked tec. And how embarrassing when everyone asks to see it! I'd probably recruit friends and family to tease the hell out of him (but the original action can't be undone can't it?). You are right to feel hurt.

CoffeeAndKittens · 01/11/2021 08:32

If his proposal had been better (ring, flowers, down on one knee, basically whatever your dream proposal would have been), would you have said yes enthusiastically thinking how perfect he was and how happy you were to marry him? If so, I wouldn't worry about the fact he is rubbish at proposals. For example, mine was rubbish, but my husband did it on the spur of the moment out of the blue because of a thought that popped into his head at the time and I love him so much and he is pretty much perfect in every other way that there was no doubt in my mind, despite the rather uninspired proposal!

If your partner is usually thoughtful and generally considerate and lovely, I'd sit him down and tell him how disappointed you feel. His reaction and consequent answer would tell me all I needed as to where he stood on the relationship.

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/11/2021 08:29

Posted too soon - All women, I mean. Not just you. Women as objects. In saying he bought a ring for the last ‘woman object’ and look how that turned out. ‘Women objects’ aren’t grateful for what they get. And you ‘woman object’ have had your quota of rings.

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/11/2021 08:27

I agree with people saying it’s controlling to repurpose your property and especially unkind when he harps on about how much he spent on his ex’s ring.

Both of these actions suggest perhaps that he doesn’t see you as a fully fledged person. If this is the case, that would make you his property, his support animal and woman to fuck.

jackstini · 01/11/2021 08:24

YANBU
That was a thoughtless thing for him to do, a bit mean really Sad
Do you still want to be with him?

Maskless · 01/11/2021 08:24

Talk to him about it.

thepeopleversuswork · 01/11/2021 08:22

@BigFatLiar

Quite: the scenario you've just described seems very plausible. All the more reason for the OP to decline a very half-arsed and grudging marriage proposal. Its hard to imagine life improving being married to someone with this outlook on marriage.

BigFatLiar · 01/11/2021 08:19

It's not really about the ring though is it?

I hate engagement rings and think the money people spend on them is absolutely nuts. But I'd want to think that anyone who asked me to marry them would actually want me to marry them rather than just do it with bad grace to shut me up. And I sure as hell wouldn't marry someone who proposed like this.

Perhaps he doesn't want to get married and is happy with the status quo (they've been together 5 years) not everyone sees the need. Maybe he proposed because he felt he had to. We have no idea about the background. Maybe she's been on at him about getting married and he sees it a a way to keep the peace. He may not be enthusiastic about it but at the same time he may not be actually opposed.

onelittlefrog · 01/11/2021 08:14

@Midlifemusings It's also the presumption that he gets to repurpose her property. It's not OK for him to take her ring and decide himself that it's now and engagement ring. It's not his.

It actually stinks of a controlling nature to be honest.

VeganCheesePlease · 01/11/2021 08:13

Are you really happy with him, OP?
When DH proposed to me, he used a small promise ring and as it was nearly Christmas, I got my proper engagement ring on Christmas eve but I wouldn't have minded just having the promise ring. It's a very small ring too, I didn't want a super expensive ring.
DH's best friend proposed to his wife with a Haribo ring! He did get her an actual engagement ring after but its a funny story they always have now.
Maybe this is about more than a ring? Do you feel that he's just neglected to do a proper proposal for you, or somewhere deep down are you having second thoughts?

Milliepossum · 01/11/2021 08:12

It almost sounds like he is getting revenge on his ex by taunting you with how much hers cost and expecting you to reuse an existing ring. As if he wished he hadn’t bothered with a ring for her. This makes me feel unsettled. He isn’t making you feel special which is an awful thing to do to you, like you don’t deserve to be happy or even acknowledged.

RobertsRadio · 01/11/2021 08:12

Well, do you Want to be married to the bloke? Surely that is the most important question, if so then tell him you want a proper engagement ring. It sounds like you are questioning your relationship, not the absence of a ring.

Suddenlyfamily5 · 01/11/2021 08:11

I wonder if he deliberately kept it low key to be as different as possible from the time before; clearly the £1000s spent on his ex’s ring didn’t bring happiness.

Nevertheless, you need to speak to him and let him know how you feel. Flowers

thepeopleversuswork · 01/11/2021 08:11

@BigFatLiar

Do you want to marry him. Tell him how you feel. Perhaps he doesn't see the point of engagement rings. (Mine was a cheapy out of Argos we got when out shopping, I have costume jewellery that cost more - plus I paid for it)
It's not really about the ring though is it?

I hate engagement rings and think the money people spend on them is absolutely nuts. But I'd want to think that anyone who asked me to marry them would actually want me to marry them rather than just do it with bad grace to shut me up. And I sure as hell wouldn't marry someone who proposed like this.