Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU engagement proposal

133 replies

Ale24 · 01/11/2021 00:22

AIBU
Please help
I should feel happy but I feel so terrible
My parent of over 5 years proposed to me today, it was awkward and it really felt like he didn’t mean it
He proposed to me with the ring he gave me as my 40th birthday present saying that it is a engagement ring and there is no need to buy new one. I thought it was joke, but it isn’t.
Btw he does have enough money to buy ring.
I feel so worthless and embarrassed 😞
He also didn’t told his friend or family that we engaged.
It’s all feels and looks sad and fake and now I am crying all night
Please tell me if I am wrong 😑

OP posts:
OnyxOryx · 01/11/2021 10:58

@Ale24

My 40th birthday was over 4 years ago and I wore that ring everyday
Nah that's not good enough. It's the thought that counts and he's put zero thought or effort into this, other than thinking how he can avoid spending money on this and ensure you know he doesn't think you're worth an engagement ring so won't ask for one. So his proposal was "suppose we can get married since it's what you want, you're not getting a ring though". Sorry but it all shows his true character, which is selfish. No way would I marry him. The way he's gone about this proposal, it's an insult. I couldn't marry someone who's effectively just told me I'm not worth a ring, when it'd cause him no financial hardship. Just no.

I'm seeing red flags too about the saving his life thing. What was he doing or what state was he in that was so bad he needed someone to "save" him? What measures was he taking, help he sought out for himself, to fix his own problems? He sounds like he's hard work as a person. Possibly this relationship doesn't have a healthy dynamic.

Have you been unhappy in the relationship so far? Were you thinking at all about the possibility of splitting up? They sense this. I'm wondering if this proposal is to counteract you leaving. I'm also wondering if he has any intention of getting married or if this is just to shut you up and 5 years more everything will still be exactly the same with no wedding on the horizon.

Flowersintheattic2021 · 01/11/2021 10:55

My proposal was. When are we gonna get engaged etc. He said we'll we have a kid so it's like where engaged. I said OK when we getting married. He said whenever. This was the Jan (2011) I arranged the wedding for August.

DaydreamerBetty · 01/11/2021 10:36

Just be honest and tell him you’re disappointed he used your 40th birthday ring to propose with. Do you think he may buy you one for Christmas?

Dixiechickonhols · 01/11/2021 10:35

Your reaction shows you shouldn’t be marrying him. You shouldn’t feel how you feel getting engaged. You can’t speak to him - you cried all night rather than discussing.
You obviously wanted the proposal and ring. If he doesn’t know that about you after 5 years then there’s no hope.
I didn’t have an engagement ring or proposal. Just a discussion. But neither of us were type for that and 20 years later no regrets. If he’d spent £1000 on a ring and done a public proposal I’d have hated it and it would have shown me he did know me.

TwinsandTrifle · 01/11/2021 10:34

Ah, sorry OP, I just saw your updates.

I'd be really pissed off. He goes on and on about how much he wanted to get married with his ex wife and the tens of thousands he spent on her ring.

Then tells you, he doesn't want to get married, but sort of will now out of acknowledgement to how you've stuck by him. So just use a ring you've already got.

That's not ok. He's saying, look how I treat someone I do want to marry, now see how I treat you.

He's doing it because he thinks you'll be off if he doesn't. Not because he wants too. So you should be accepting of the zero effort, bargain basement treatment, because you should be happy that he's graced you with a marriage at all.

Out of interest, is your 40th ring, a "tens of thousands" ring, as in, he thinks you've got "the ring" already, from a time when marriage wasn't on the cards for him. Now it is on the cards, he thinks of it as the important ring?

If it's more of a token/costume ring, then he's being a dick trying to take it back to reuse as an engagement ring. Because clearly he can buy a proper one for someone he wants too.

ANameChangeAgain · 01/11/2021 10:34

I think for one have a long serious think about what it is you are upset about. Is it that you missed the Instagram moment of a big gesture, or is it that you don't want to marry him, or do you feel a bit second to his first wife.
I'm never been particularly sold on the idea that the woman waits around to be proposed to and be presented with the ring. Its a bit too Jane Austin. An engagement, or intention to marry, is very much a joint decision that should be discussed and agreed on. As for the ring, you have to look at it on your hand for (hopefully) the rest of your life, so its important that you have something you love that you can look at with happy memories.
I think, after a bit of thinking, you need to take charge and have the talk. Tell him this isn't an engagement ring, you are going shopping for something suitable, buy him a good watch as a token too, which equates to the same portion of your income as the ring to his, and start the rest of your relationship on a more even footing.

Nanny0gg · 01/11/2021 10:25

If you're this unhappy now, when most are on cloud nine at this stage, it doesn't bode too well for your future together, does it?

TwinsandTrifle · 01/11/2021 10:25

I agree with "are you sure he's got the money for it?" It's not a normal thing to do.

The stories of people proposing with joke rings/haribo rings are missing the point here, because that was clearly a token ring, most likely replaced with a proper one. This is a ring OP was given 4 years ago for a significant birthday, that she's been wearing every day, for years, so it's not the same.

I don't like the "you don't get what a marriage is about if a ring is important to you"... it's very holier than thou. Just because a ring/proposal didn't matter to you, doesn't mean it doesn't matter to everyone. I'm married (twice) and both times it's been a mutual discussion, and whilst I love DH, it does make me sad that I've never had, and never will now, have a lovely romantic proposal. It's through no one's fault, it's just the way things happened. I'm a very romantic person and it would have meant the world to me. It doesn't change the meaning or validity of my marriage, but this doesn't mean therefore it's irrelevant or unimportant.

GatoradeMeBitch · 01/11/2021 10:21

I don't think it's worth comparing to past partners. Things change and people change. Maybe his marriage ending showed him that spending tens of thousands on a piece of metal doesn't guarantee happiness.

I think it's worth setting aside your disappointments over proposal style and jewelry and announcements, and thinking about whether you want to spend your life with this man and want that commitment with him. That's what matters. Excitement over a designer engagement ring and fancy party only takes you so far if the relationship is not working. Other things are more fundamental.

VanCleefArpels · 01/11/2021 10:10

2 key things

The day before this happened if someone had asked you “do you want to spend the rest of your life with this person?” Would you have answered YES? If so, then his unarguably crass proposal was regrettable but surely not terminal.

Second, you are far better legally protected if you are married.

PleasantBirthday · 01/11/2021 10:07

I think some posters are being very unkind. I don't think it's about the ring necessarily and it's great if you got engaged with a ring made of twine and are very happy, that's wonderful.

Ultimately, I think the problem is the attitude. Who would want to marry someone who proposes with no joy, no excitement, just a heavy sigh and the attitude of "ok, I'll just do it if you want". Who wouldn't find that deflating and upsetting?

Irishfarmer · 01/11/2021 10:01

I would be upset. Yes I know people saying that it's not the ring that matters, and it isn't. But it'd be nice to feel like he went to some effort, not just giving you a ring he gave you as a birthday present 4 years ago!! Tell him how you feel and that you would like a ring that is just for your engagement. Well, that is if you actually want to still be engaged to him

Autumnleaves4 · 01/11/2021 09:57

He says you saved his life and yet he proposed to you with a 4 year old previous present despite having money?
Are you sure he has money and not hidden debts?
He spent thousands on his ex’s ring?
He is not showing to you that he values you, he is taking you for granted.
You put him first even when you had cancer??? Why???

This does not sound good or healthy for you. LEAVE.

CounsellorTroi · 01/11/2021 09:50

@BigFatLiar

No he didn’t wanted to get married at first at all and always said he will never marry again. He previously was married and I had to listen how much he wanted that marriage and how many 10s and 10s and 10s and 10s of thousands he spend on her ring

Are you surprised at his reluctant proposal? He has a failed marriage which seems to have hit him hard. It had an expensive ring which didn't lead to a long lasting marriage. If you were focussed on marriage and rings from the start rather than the relationship then this was the wrong relationship, he told you early on. Sounds like he wants to keep the relationship and thinks this is the only way. Lots of people have long term partners and are unmarried, many seem to last longer than marriages.

Yes, he may have thought “well I did a romantic proposal and spent a shitload on a ring last time and look how that turned out”.
Fireflygal · 01/11/2021 09:44

I saved his life ( his words and not mine) we been through so much last 5 years. I lost hair due to stress, had cancer but always put him first and supported him, hence he said he would be dead by now without me

Have you given more to him and not had your needs met so the ring is symbolic of his lack of meeting your needs?

Why would you put another person first over your essential needs, such as illness?

I suspect you were waiting for him to show you really mean something to him and the proposal felt an enormous let down.

CaptainMyCaptain · 01/11/2021 09:40

@TasteTheMeatNotTheHeat

If it feels wrong then it is wrong.

I'd give the ring back. Don't settle, OP.

It's her own ring that she's been wearing for 4 years. Why should she give it back?
ByeByeMissAmericanPie · 01/11/2021 09:38

If your gut is telling you that it’s wrong… then it is.
Listen to your gut.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 01/11/2021 09:37

All that matters is, do you want to be married to him?
My husband casually asked “Do you think we should get married this year?” While we were watching TV one night. No ring. No bended knee.
We’re very happily married.

Scoobydoobywho · 01/11/2021 09:34

Find something you gave to him for his birthday and re gift it to him for Christmas.

peachesarenom · 01/11/2021 09:32

I think you know if it in some way felt disingenuous. It should have been heartfelt and not awkward. He may be telling you how married life with him will be like. Not at all generous or loving. You need to have a serious chat.

NewbieAlert · 01/11/2021 09:31

@Ale24

My 40th birthday was over 4 years ago and I wore that ring everyday
YANBU.

It’s not too late to change your mind.

Allgreyeverything · 01/11/2021 09:25

So… my husband proposed without a ring, on a spur of a moment and he went to Pandora the next day to buy me a £60 promise ring ‘until he saved up for a proper ring’ which I thought was really sweet. I got ‘the proper ring’ a few months later in a very romantic setting.
But to be honest my both proposals were amazing and I think it’s because it felt right and genuine and it wasn’t an afterthought like it seems in op’s situation.
I think what your boyfriend did is awful on so many levels. Yes- it’s not about the ring. It’s about his ‘I don’t give a shit’ attitude, his bragging about how much he’s spent on his ex’s ring yet couldn’t even be bothered to buy you a cheap but new one, how he talked about not wanting to marry but gave in and gave you a half arsed non proposal. I would be too embarrassed to pull a shitty move like this, but he clearly doesn’t care enough.
I don’t believe it’s about him not wanting to spend much money on a ring because he’d been burnt before. He just doesn’t want to marry you very much and therefore showing zero effort. Dump

AnneLovesGilbert · 01/11/2021 09:23

If he definitely didn’t want to get married what’s changed? Is it a reluctant proposal because he still doesn’t want to do it? Does he think you’ll dump if you’re not engaged?

NataliaSerene · 01/11/2021 09:16

I don’t think marrying him is going to bring you happiness. Have you been married before? Are you financially safe without him?

ancientgran · 01/11/2021 09:10

This isn't a man who has issues with marriage due to his past, this is a man who is using triangulation. He's saying, 'look OP, I REALLY wanted to marry my ex-wife, and I bought her The Best Ring Ever. But you aren't worth that, so I don't want to marry you, and here, have one of your own rings.' Or he's saying the spending thousands on rings and weddings doesn't make a good marriage.

We don't know, maybe the OP does but her views are different to his. I don't have an engagement ring, we had 10 guests at our wedding and all went out to lunch and then got on with our day. Thirty six years later it doesn't seem to have done any harm.