Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - boarding school?

196 replies

marateach · 31/10/2021 21:32

My partner and I are thinking about having children soon however we have quite different ideas about their upbringing. He went to a boarding school from age 11 and loved it. He has said that if we have children he would like to give them the option to go away to boarding school from KS2 onwards.
I can’t imagine only seeing my children during school holidays!

AIBU?
If you / your children went to boarding school, were they / you happy? Do you have any regrets?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Charlotte2022 · 08/01/2022 22:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Charlene1971 · 03/11/2021 20:09

Who does your partner expect to raise his kids whilst they're in boarding school?

I think it's vile to send a child away and let them essentially raise themselves. People who do this don't deserve children.

LuckyHindleyBells · 03/11/2021 20:06

Boarding school at 7 is cruel unless other options are worse. When you bring your 7 year old to the school, the head distracts them and asks you to dissappear. That 7 year old may be crying themselves to sleep and many will wet their bed. They may be bullied and will not share it with you as your bond is broken. They may develop a thick skin made of jokes and arrogance to defend themselves. Upside, posh accent, good education. How do I know all this, I've seen it happen, don't recommend it in the slightest.

RoseGoldEagle · 03/11/2021 15:16

Steppered thank you for sharing this, I have a friend who echos almost exactly what you say- she said she liked boarding school well enough at the time, but says a lot of repressed emotions came out when she had her own daughter.

I think there’s also a pressure on some children to do the family proud and show that they’re enjoying it, especially in those cases where families have made sacrifices to afford to send a child to a certain school.

In terms of a great education- couldn’t you get a lot of those benefits from a private day school?

Steppered · 03/11/2021 14:35

I boarded in the 90s from age 11. I didn't dislike it; I didn't love it either. There were pros and cons. But I just got on with it. You could have asked me "do you like BS?" and I probably would have said yes.

My feelings changed significantly when I had a child of my own. A lot of feelings that I had suppressed all came bubbling over. I know I could never send my child away, I'd move heaven and earth to put them first.

I always find it hard reading and writing on these threads (because I'm so fucking repressed emotionally). I tried therapy but I can't articulate myself.

But take a look at boarding school syndrome. I have so many hallmarks of that. I'm not saying BS has given me a bad life; it hasn't. But I struggle with relationships, I can't deal with my feelings, I drink to block any uncomfortable feeling out. I have made bad choices because I feel insecure. I am independent but too much so. I struggle with family things sometimes, it is like my emotional development stopped when I was 11 sometimes.

I wouldn't want my child at boarding school dealing with a medical issue alone; or crying without me to comfort them. I know how hard it is to parent teens when they're under your roof let alone when you are distanced from them - probably more so now with social media. I love my parents but I keep them at arms length. I genuinely think my life would be very different if I hadn't gone to BS.

Not trying to make this post all about me. (I will definitely come back and delete it!) I would have been one of those people who would have seemed happy and to enjoy it - but those suppressed feelings came back to bite me.

I know that boarding is far less common now and very different to how it was when I went. Just wanted to be a voice of caution because I'm sure my parents went round saying I loved it and I was thriving. I was fine, I adapted, but here 20 plus years later there wounds.

Otherpeoplesteens · 03/11/2021 11:48

Pallisers has started from the same position that many do, which is totally understandable from a parent's perspective but which I think is a false assumption.

I can tell you from my own experience, that of my sister and my wife (all of us boarded) that the dichotomy where home 'competes' with boarding school is a false one, and it is not a zero sum game.

From the age of nine I knew full well which was my home and which was my school. The existence of one did not detract from the existence of the other at all; rather, it added a whole lot more to my life and strengthened the ties I had to home, as well as reinforce my appreciation of home in a way that most teenagers simply don't get. I am rather bemused my all the tales on MN of 15 year olds who refuse to go on family holidays or sulk through them - this sort of thing was absolutely unthinkable to me and those of my boarding school friends who had normal family lives int he first place. Enjoying strong parental relationships as an older child was nothing like as toxic for my boarding school friends as it was for the ones who stayed at home.

Before she died, one of the things my mother made clear about boarding school is that foregoing my presence, affection and attention when I was at school meant that she didn't have to compete for it when I wasn't.

Well, of course. You wouldn't deliberately leave your child shivering in an icy cold bedroom with a growling empty stomach, when you have plenty of money to pay for heating and nourishing food - just because you reckon 'they'll cope' (or at least might appear to).

To read the threads on here about central heating you'd think this was pretty normal!

TillyDevon · 03/11/2021 11:11

Pallisers it’s not the majority of the week in our case, it’s two nights which can be skipped anytime. Then he’s twice asked to do a Saturdays night for a special event and I fetch him when want which has been after breakfast.
I totally hear you and I boarded myself from 8 and generally wary of it. I have struggled to be open minded and not project what I feel but i think there are degrees of it where it can be a happy thing too. I also totally understand avoiding it altogether !

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/11/2021 10:22

Exactly. And PP who said 'On the surface he appears to be coping well', it shouldn't be about coping at that age, there shouldn't be that struggle.

Well, of course. You wouldn't deliberately leave your child shivering in an icy cold bedroom with a growling empty stomach, when you have plenty of money to pay for heating and nourishing food - just because you reckon 'they'll cope' (or at least might appear to).

It reminds me of the old joke about the wealthy duchess looking to appoint a new chauffeur. She asks each applicant about their driving skills and how close they could confidently drive to the edge of the local cliff without going over. The first says 3ft, the second says 2ft, the third says just 6 inches; but she gives the job to the fourth one who replies "I wouldn't drive anywhere near the edge - why on earth would you?!"

I agree with you, too, Pallisers - very beautifully put.

alexdgr8 · 03/11/2021 03:44

Pallisers, that;s a lovely way of putting it; home is just where you are, with those who love you, whom you love.
sounds so simple, so unambitious; and is worth more than gold.

Pallisers · 03/11/2021 02:01

Tilly I'm not judging and I do applaud you for putting what you think are your son's interests abover your own but I would have been so incredibly sad if my 10 year old wanted to spend the majority of the week somewhere other than home. Visiting friends houses/sleepovers/etc yes but wanting to spend weekends as well as week nights away from his home and not being homesick once would really really bother me. It turns home into a place that needs to compete with friends/boarding etc. rather than the place we just live with those who love us - no endless entertainment just living together with people who love you.

Dayofpeace · 02/11/2021 22:18

I went to boarding school in the 80’s when I was 11 and absolutely loved it. Loved it so much I cried when I had to leave.

I would think it’s very dependent on the child’s outlook though.

Toddlerteaplease · 02/11/2021 21:40

@Restzol yes. I had the same thoughts about that documentary. They were very dismissive of the children's and parents feelings. I felt really sorry for the girl who's mum wasn't there, who was hanging on to her friends mum. She practically blacked her and barely acknowledged her.

TillyDevon · 02/11/2021 21:26

I don’t think you can always judge as there’s so much variability . We live walking distance from DS’s school and he’s started to ask to board a night -then immediately to board more and to add weekends in -despite being so happy at home. I guess it’s quieter at home while they do so much stuff and he plays games with friends at school (we do often at home too but it’s probably not as fun as having peers and his sibling busy with gcse work) .
He’s got so much closer to friends as a result which was something that didn’t come naturally to him when he was younger and aged 10 says not been homesick once. I keep hoping he’ll board less but it feels so positive for him to be so animated and they have endless opportunities he’s into . Plus home is here anytime as it’s flexi boarding and he chooses

notanothertakeaway · 02/11/2021 21:19

There is a school of thought that pupils at boarding school have many of the same issues as children who grow up in care, due to trauma of being separated from family and being raised by paid carers

Indoctro · 02/11/2021 21:10

My sister went to one, said it was awful

Hekk · 02/11/2021 21:00

@Tailendofsummer

Why on Earth does an 8 year old need to be "self-reliant"?
Exactly. And PP who said 'On the surface he appears to be coping well', it shouldn't be about coping at that age, there shouldn't be that struggle.
Tailendofsummer · 02/11/2021 19:57

Why on Earth does an 8 year old need to be "self-reliant"?

iwanttobeonleave · 02/11/2021 16:29

My son is 8 (Yr4) and flexi boards - through choice. He absolutely loves it.

There are YR3 kids that do too, and about half of YR4s do.

It's nothing like it used to be, in my experience.

It's great for independence and self reliance.

I'd never make a child board if they didn't want to, and I'm not sure school would want them to either.

MarioPants · 02/11/2021 16:24

@Platax

People who loved boarding school, what was it you loved about it? Did you really not miss home and your families? Didn't you think it was a bit of a weird set-up where you were being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over you?
For me it was a clear choice. I could have stayed in the UK with my abusive narcissistic fuck up of a birth mother and carry on as a day girl at the prestigious but actually awful school I was at or I could move to Australia with my dad and (step)mum who love, cherish and care for me and where I would attend the local-ish tiny primary school then have to board for secondary. Even at 8 years old I knew that was a no-brainer. I did miss my parents and felt homesick at first but everybody else is in the same boat, I had lots of opportunities and made great, friends. It wasn't a weird set-up because it was normal for all of us and we all knew that was what would happen. Some of my classmates were ecstatic because they lived on such remote farms their primary schooling had been over the airwaves and they'd met their 'class'mates a handful of times a year. For them being among their peers and seeing friends every day was a fucken miracle
User2638483 · 02/11/2021 15:47

I wouldn’t sweat it
Of course if he had a positive experience he wants to offer that to his kids but doesn’t mean it will happen. Costs an absolute fortune for one thing.

JudgeJ · 02/11/2021 15:43

@Cocomarine

You know that KS2 is age 7, right? No way in hell would I not have been in my 7 year old’s daily life - whether they wanted or not.

At 11, I’d have considered it if:

  • they really wanted to go
  • there was a good reason (e.g. a musical talent)
And even then I’d want flexi boarding or weekly boarding. It’s not even about would they be happy - I wouldn’t be happy.

If my partner actively wanted to go for boarding at KS2, I wouldn’t be with them. Our values would be too different. At KS3, I’d need to feel certain that they would put the needs of the child first.

It wouldn’t bother me that they were open to the possibility if they liked it themselves, as long as I was sure they wouldn’t try to over rule either my child or my wishes. I would need to know that they would respect my veto, for any reason.

Surely the end of KS2 is Year 6, 11 years old.
Otherpeoplesteens · 02/11/2021 14:46

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Plus, without wanting to be harsh about it, if she did die whilst he was still at school, I can't see his 'school family' being willing to suddenly take over all of his fees and living costs until he's an adult.

Funnily enough, one of my close former school friends recently approached me about this situation. He has no living relatives, his wife none outside the former USSR and none who speak a word of English between them. They haven't sent their two children to boarding school because it's not her preference and it's beyond them financially. What they have done, though, is make provision that if they both die then the fees at our old school are covered through life insurance etc, and I would take care of them otherwise.

Not quite the same thing, but you'd be surprised at what boarding school families do for each other. At my school one boy effectively walked away from his own highly dysfunctional family into another's. It happens.

Otherpeoplesteens · 02/11/2021 14:36

@Platax

People who loved boarding school, what was it you loved about it? Did you really not miss home and your families? Didn't you think it was a bit of a weird set-up where you were being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over you?
I boarded from age nine, mid Eighties through to mid Nineties, and was from an overseas family. No Facetime or Skype, no email, just aerogrammes once a week and a ten minute phonecall during exeat or half term.

At first I loved the sheer breadth of the opportunities available. It was a rural school close to two national parks so as well as the academic curriculum and the normal team sports there was a huge focus on outdoor pursuits: rock climbing, caving, mountaineering, kayaking were all normal things, available to us several times a week at no additional cost. That's before more normal things which would often still be lacking in many day schools: squash, Fives, debating society, choir, orchestra, Tiddlywinks Club, drama. It meant that we were able to move freely between several 'tribes' based on interests without real cliques forming.

And because everything is under one roof and fee-paying, they tried to make everything work for us: during the summer I used to get first choice for practice time on the organ because I also played the rather time-consuming cricket and couldn't be in both places at once. In the winter, I was happy to take what I was given because I didn't play rugby.

It built up a sense of how to live in a community. Because I couldn't leave it all behind when the bell rang at 3pm I learned to live with people I couldn't stand, as well as with those I liked. By the time I left, it wasn't the classroom or the sports or the outdoor pursuits I loved most, it was being in House, with 55 other kids ranging from 13 to 18 years old.

The older kids were able to take on tremendous amounts of responsibility if they were so inclined and capable; running swimming sessions, instructing in campcraft or survival, or more formal leaderships roles around the school or in the CCF or both. There were times when at 17 or 18 I would be walking around the campus in the dark, often with a teacher and sometimes not, on a Saturday night checking that no-one was smoking behind the bike sheds or in the Music School bogs at the same time as making sure that if anyone overdid it in the 6th Form bar then they got back to their house safely, whilst intervening in a fight between two 15 year olds over something or nothing, before going back to House to comfort a 13 year old who had just received word that his family dog had died. I loved it.

I'm still in touch with many of the kids from my House, including those both much older and much younger and view them as family. The teacher who lived in my House at the Resident Tutor when he was a young man in his twenties I'm also still in touch with. He came to my wedding 20 years after I left the school, and when he got made redundant from his last teaching post and set up his own business I helped him with it.

I wouldn't characterise it as a weird set up being sent off to live with a load of strangers who had considerable power over me. It was a whole, massive, second family that I built in the way I wanted. They did not replace my own family, rather the experience amplified the strong relationship I had with my own family. Of course I missed my family, but I appreciated them a lot more than my friends who didn't board.

Several of my schoolfriends were, indeed, 'sent away' and they knew it. For some the experience again amplified that already dysfunctional relationship with their families; for others boarding provided them with stability and affection for the first time in their lives.

The school instilled in me a sense of values that I hold dear today, and I know that I would probably trust someone who went to my school with my life, even if I hadn't met them.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 12:13

Bold fail

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 11:48

the widow lady who said it might be good for her young son to establish close friendships in case he should lose her too; no.
can you not see if that were to happen he would be even more bereft, to think the time he could have had with you was wasted being somewhere else.

Exactly - definitely a parent/child version of 'better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all'. Plus, without wanting to be harsh about it, if she did die whilst he was still at school, I can't see his 'school family' being willing to suddenly take over all of his fees and living costs until he's an adult.

Moreover, plenty of adults will shun and avoid bereaved people, because they don't know what to say or how to relate to them; I can imagine this being amplified with other children, who might now also be extra frightened of losing their own parents and project their fears on to the 'orphan boy'.