Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have declared this?

113 replies

stressingsusan · 31/10/2021 21:22

Dp and I currently going through a mortgage application for our dream home. Provided wage slips, lots of other information and it's all been approved.

I have a loan between myself and a family member that I pay back monthly. It's about £400 a month. I didn't declare this on the application because firstly it's a private loan between family and there's no record of it. And also because when we move and our current house sells I will be able to pay them back in a lump sum so in theory it won't affect our mortgage repayments anyway.

Our advisor recently mentioned I need to provide a bank statement and I'm now worried that this payment will show up and be questioned. Should I have declared this earlier on? Will it affect the application if it comes out? I'm really worried now.

OP posts:
DixonD · 31/10/2021 23:48

I’ve been through this several times (showing bank statements to a mortgage lender) and in my experience, they will ask about this. Some lenders will go through your statements and will query everything. It’s suggested before applying for a loan that you cut out any unnecessary spending from your account so that it looks more desirable.

However, you have a means of redeeming this loan, so hopefully they will look past it. If not, it can affect the amount they are willing to lend to you if you have extra debts. And £400 is a sizeable repayment.

FinallyFluid · 31/10/2021 23:29

We paid off our main mortgage in about 2017, in 2018 we took out a smallish £40k to do the kitchen and bathroom (finally) they even queried my coffee habit, so quite frankly it is up to you.

ballsdeep · 31/10/2021 23:15

@stressingsusan

Having spoken to dh they have access to all of his statements and activity already as he banks with them. However he is the main earner (earns 3 x more than me). As yet I haven't been formally asked to produce bank statements.

I'm wondering why solicitors have been instructed if so much is still pending?

To get the ball rolling. Everyone wants to get the moving business started. If you waited for mortgage offers for the whole chain, it would take forever. That's why you have AIPs
crayray · 31/10/2021 23:00

I can't comment on whether the loan will be an issue but I can tell you that having any sort of mortgage offer doesn't mean they can't ask for more info at any point up until completion. We had a move fall through on completion day, just as our removals company had finished packing the van, because our buyers' lender decided do some further checks 'which may take up to nine working days' before releasing funds. Fortunately it all went through and we were able to move two weeks later but I was shocked to learn that lenders are able to do this right up to the last minute.

However, hopefully you will have a much less fraught experience. Good luck!

MintMatchmaker · 31/10/2021 22:57

@ballsdeep

We had our mortgage recently with HSBC. If you look at the intermediary info it says that debt that is going to be paid off within 6 months of completion doesn't need to be declared. So if your broker clicked it will be paid then it won't be used.
This happened to us too, except ours was on completion.
Africa2go · 31/10/2021 22:57

OP you're getting some really poor advice on here. Do not lie. Have a conversation with your broker tomorrow and be honest.

ballsdeep · 31/10/2021 22:52

We had our mortgage recently with HSBC. If you look at the intermediary info it says that debt that is going to be paid off within 6 months of completion doesn't need to be declared. So if your broker clicked it will be paid then it won't be used.

SarahAndQuack · 31/10/2021 22:48

@stressingsusan

Having spoken to dh they have access to all of his statements and activity already as he banks with them. However he is the main earner (earns 3 x more than me). As yet I haven't been formally asked to produce bank statements.

I'm wondering why solicitors have been instructed if so much is still pending?

You say this as if someone other than you instructed solicitors? What happened exactly?

I went through this recently, and when I contacted solicitors, they all wanted to know exactly what the situation was with the mortgage - whether we had a mortgage in principle, or a formal offer, or what.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 31/10/2021 22:45

@BernieBaby

Yes, do tell another lie.

Say October was the final payment, tell the family member you'll need to stop payments for a month or two in order for the mortgage to go through and enable the lump sum pay off.

Literally lie through your teeth to your broker and everyone else and swear up and down that it's fully paid off now.

There's no way they can prove it and it's much less likely to impact you than saying there's still an active loan which may affect your affordability.

Never lie to a lender if you ever want finance again. Full and frank disclosure every single time.
ihavespoken · 31/10/2021 22:45

I think it will be fine - if they query you can explain it is an informal loan. The bank will only be bothered about other lenders who have the right to get your money, I think, and the family loan is probably unenforceable so would be ok.
As long as you’re sure you can demonstrate affordability if it comes up then I wouldn’t worry.

Disclaimer: I am not a bank or a financial adviser, that’s just what seems logical to me. By nature I am a massive worrier and over thinker and I personally would not worry about this.

stressingsusan · 31/10/2021 22:44

@Igfdyjxzyjkv the loan will be repaid when the current house sells. I can't say for sure when that will be. It isn't listed yet as we don't anticipate moving into the new house until at least Feb next year.

If there were an overlap we could afford it but once the house sells the loan will be gone.

OP posts:
Igfdyjxzyjkv · 31/10/2021 22:44

@MintMatchmaker

Our lender only wanted details of any finance that wouldn't be settled on or by completion.

Therefore it is not a give that the OP has made a false declaration.

That would be contrary to any major lenders practice in the UK. Otherwise everyone would just decide that they can pay X off by Y. I have never known any lender not to ask for full details off all current financial liabilities.
BernieBaby · 31/10/2021 22:42

Yes, do tell another lie.

Say October was the final payment, tell the family member you'll need to stop payments for a month or two in order for the mortgage to go through and enable the lump sum pay off.

Literally lie through your teeth to your broker and everyone else and swear up and down that it's fully paid off now.

There's no way they can prove it and it's much less likely to impact you than saying there's still an active loan which may affect your affordability.

stressingsusan · 31/10/2021 22:42

Having spoken to dh they have access to all of his statements and activity already as he banks with them. However he is the main earner (earns 3 x more than me). As yet I haven't been formally asked to produce bank statements.

I'm wondering why solicitors have been instructed if so much is still pending?

OP posts:
Igfdyjxzyjkv · 31/10/2021 22:40

@stressingsusan

The last thing our advisor said to me was that the only thing that would stop the mortgage going through now would be if the house valuations came back wrong - so if the bank deem the property to be worth significantly less than what we are wanting to pay for it.

We have done our sums. We know that we can afford the repayments even with the extra loan money on top. And we had a third of the asking price to put down as a deposit. So in theory we are in a fairly strong position but im just worried that the bank will withdraw or change the offer if this loan comes to light.

You said that the loan will be paid off when you sell your current house but from this is sounds like the loan repayment will overlap with your new mortgage payments. Which is it?
Basically, you have decide to assess your own affordability and not provide the full information to the lender (who is giving you funds) to enable them to do so. The bank will entirely disregard the fact that you think you can repay it on sale of your current house (if that is true) because they will have no way to enforce it. They will simply focus on the fact that you did not disclose a substantial financial commitment, and therefore signed a false declaration
MargaretThursday · 31/10/2021 22:40

Oops wrong thread Grin Reported

Fabvegetablegrower · 31/10/2021 22:40

I think the mortgage lender will pick up this payment on your bank statement if they are doing there job properly. It's better to be upfront and let them know the situation. As it's going to be paid off it won't affect their decision but you're not being entirely truthful.

Horseradish01 · 31/10/2021 22:39

Don’t overthink it, it’ll be fine. If they question it (which is unlikely at this stage), let them know it isn’t a formal arrangement and it’s paid off before the new mortgage starts hence not declaring it.

MargaretThursday · 31/10/2021 22:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread.

MargaretThursday · 31/10/2021 22:37

Since it'll be gone before you start making the new mortgage payments its irrelevant.

But they've only got the Op's word for it that it will be gone by then.

Op Hopefully they'll not worry about it, but if they ask then be honest.

TotallySuper · 31/10/2021 22:36

@stressingsusan

At no point so far have they even asked for bank statements. It was mentioned in the last meeting but literally as a passing comment not a formal, urgent request! Dh hasn't had to provide his at all. It did seem quite odd to me.

But they have had 3 months worth of pay slips and asked a lot about things such as our car finance arrangements etc. Credit checks have been passed so would that flag up any loans?

You really just need to speak to your broker. PP is right - you don't get a mortgage offer until the valuations are done. Just speak to your broker as you're getting lots of mis information on here.
MintMatchmaker · 31/10/2021 22:36

Our lender only wanted details of any finance that wouldn't be settled on or by completion.

Therefore it is not a give that the OP has made a false declaration.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 31/10/2021 22:34

@Morechocmorechoc

This will go against you, so personally I would say that was the last payment which is why you didn't mention it as it is paid off now. Any monthly outgoing has to be deducted from they can lend (usually annual amount x 4 or 5). Its a non issue for you to pay it off so don't give the bank a reason to deduct it
Don’t tell another lie
MintMatchmaker · 31/10/2021 22:34

I would cancel the direct debit and ask the family member if you can stop paying for now and then settle in full as you intended to do.

Then, if it is raised (some brokers ask for a bank statement as a matter of course, not because the lender has requested them) you can legitimately say that you are no longer making monthly payments.

You do not have mortgage offer yet. Your formal mortgage offer will only be issued when all checks and an acceptable valuation on a property have taken place. An illustration is exactly that, it shows you what your mortgage would look like if it were granted.

Igfdyjxzyjkv · 31/10/2021 22:33

You have made a false declaration. It is entirely irrelevant that the loan will be paid off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread