Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have declared this?

113 replies

stressingsusan · 31/10/2021 21:22

Dp and I currently going through a mortgage application for our dream home. Provided wage slips, lots of other information and it's all been approved.

I have a loan between myself and a family member that I pay back monthly. It's about £400 a month. I didn't declare this on the application because firstly it's a private loan between family and there's no record of it. And also because when we move and our current house sells I will be able to pay them back in a lump sum so in theory it won't affect our mortgage repayments anyway.

Our advisor recently mentioned I need to provide a bank statement and I'm now worried that this payment will show up and be questioned. Should I have declared this earlier on? Will it affect the application if it comes out? I'm really worried now.

OP posts:
AnyBloodyUsername · 01/11/2021 09:00

@tedsletterofthelaw

Buying a house can be very overwhelming and consuming the first time so I think you're getting an unfair flaming on here OP.

If you're mortgage has been approved then they will have done a hard credit check so your loan will have come up on there. I'm pretty sure they do a hard credit check on an agreement in principle too so I'm pretty sure they will already be aware of it.

I wouldn't say it's an unfair flaming at all, buying a house is a huge financial commitment and doing a bit of research about what to expect and the timeline and step by step of buying is a Google search away. (Coming from a person who has googled every element of house buying at this point!)

Also AIPs very rarely use hard credit checks and the loans OP is referring to wouldn't of shown up on any credit checks as it's paying off a family friend so unlikely to show any defaults or affect credit rating.

tedsletterofthelaw · 01/11/2021 08:48

Your*

tedsletterofthelaw · 01/11/2021 08:47

Buying a house can be very overwhelming and consuming the first time so I think you're getting an unfair flaming on here OP.

If you're mortgage has been approved then they will have done a hard credit check so your loan will have come up on there. I'm pretty sure they do a hard credit check on an agreement in principle too so I'm pretty sure they will already be aware of it.

Cheerbear23 · 01/11/2021 08:38

The broker should have picked this up already if it’s on your bank statements. Mine went into the in’s and out’s of all my payments, hairdressers and frequency, personal grooming, how much I pay for parking and travel per month. So a £400 payment more than likely will be picked up and questioned.
Re the Solicitor- isn’t it you that instructed them?

PurBal · 01/11/2021 08:34

No, I think it’s fine. My 3 months payslips looked liked I overspent every month: was just before Christmas and I move money between accounts a lot. It didn’t make a jot of difference.

Jasmine11 · 01/11/2021 08:31

[quote stressingsusan]@AnyBloodyUsername I am clueless I admit it. I haven't been through this process before.

Appreciate the advice. Will speak to our advisor ASAP as the whole process is stressful enough without worrying that the rug is going to be pulled at any point.

[/quote]
I hadn't done the process before this year either OP as my husband had got the mortgage on our previous house before we'd met. But it's not hard to do a little bit of research so you understand what you are getting into. Making a purchase worth hundreds of thousands of pounds isn't something you should blunder into without having a clue- I'm really shocked you are not sure whether you have the mortgage offer or not, how can you not know whether or not you have signed up for the most expensive purchase you will probably ever make? Start with reading posts on the MSE website like this one www.moneysavingexpert.com/mortgages/buying-a-home-timeline/

stressingsusan · 01/11/2021 08:30

@Whinge it's mortgage free. I'm not going into the details of it as it's personal and outing.

Appreciate all the replies even the ones telling me how useless I am. Will speak to our advisor as a matter or urgency to remove any more confusion. Thank you.

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 01/11/2021 08:27

@stressingsusan

Yes it's the same amount monthly and the reference is quite obvious that it's a loan repayment.

The mortgage has already been approved so I'm hoping that if they were doing those sort of checks it would have been picked up on by now. But it might raise questions if I have to provide a full bank statement.

This will be picked up as a regular monthly payment. Speak to your mortgage advisor urgently.
Whinge · 01/11/2021 08:26

[quote stressingsusan]@AnyBloodyUsername I am clueless I admit it. I haven't been through this process before.

Appreciate the advice. Will speak to our advisor ASAP as the whole process is stressful enough without worrying that the rug is going to be pulled at any point.

[/quote]
You say you haven't been through this process before but also mention selling your current home. Is it mortage free or are you not on the mortage for your current home?

Bluntness100 · 01/11/2021 08:25

This is quite unusual. Is it the broker asking for the statement? I suspect the issue is going through a middle person

We had to provide three months bank statements, I don’t think any lenders look at just one. The bank won’t just go and look at your husbands, they will ask first.

I think you both need to speak to your broker, and find out where in the process you are. The reason he said the only reason it wouldn’t go through was house value is because he was assuming you’d disclosed all loans etc, and the fact he actually refered to it going through, tells it’s not gone through yet. Otherwise he’d not have made the comment. Logically.

As said you both need to speak to your broker or the lender as having this level of confusion isn’t good.

stressingsusan · 01/11/2021 08:23

@AnyBloodyUsername I am clueless I admit it. I haven't been through this process before.

Appreciate the advice. Will speak to our advisor ASAP as the whole process is stressful enough without worrying that the rug is going to be pulled at any point.

OP posts:
AnyBloodyUsername · 01/11/2021 08:03

Sorry OP this post is actually the one that's tipped me over the edge of joining Mumsnet instead of just lurking. You sound bloody clueless!

  • You should of absolutely declared the loan, it's a large amount of money coming out. I even declared a £200 month payment that I pay to my husband (he paid off my final payment on a car) even though it's due to be done in January
  • Secondly I'm sorry to tell you but it doesn't sound like you actually have your mortgage offer sounds like an agreement in principle. We had to provide all our documents /bank statements etc and the offer didn't come through until the bank had done a valuation on the house. Offers can take days or weeks (ours took 3) and you'll know when it comes through.

-Thirdly my advice is don't use the banks solicitor/conveyancer. They're normally bloody crap, you're best off find your own local one that comes recommended. Then that means you can use them for sale and purchase.

-Fourthly what's preventing you putting your current house on the market if your looking for a move in February!? House sales are generally slower over the Christmas /winter period and the average transaction time from offer is 12 weeks ... I would advise get moving.

  • Finally I would suggest doing some research on the housebuying timeline , often solicitors are instructed prior to mortgage offers etc because they take so long! There's some really excellent articles on the moving timelines and steps!

Hope this helps and hasn't came across as too arsey, I just couldn't help myself since I'm currently stuck in the house buying process hell.

CrimeJunkie01 · 01/11/2021 07:51

My broker rang me to ask why I have money passing backwards and forwards between 2 of my own accounts, apparently it looked dodgy. I did it because I didn't have the payee details on the other account so would be lazy and transfer money to the one which did.

I think you might come unstuck here, you mentioned paying the loan from a different account and only showing them statements from another one, you can't do this. They will want to see all bank accounts statements, and will know from your credit check that you have more than one account.

You may think you can (and probably can) afford the £400 on top of the mortgage, but the bank have strict criteria. My broker told me of a person who was paying £1700 a month mortgage, and had never missed a payment. The remortgage made this c£1400 so was much less but the bank decided he couldn't afford it!!!

Jasmine11 · 01/11/2021 07:47

But don’t banks usually want proof of affordability? It would be a nice world if they just took people’s word for it :) Wage slips aren’t usually enough as you could earn a six figure sum but if you were heavily in debt and living off your overdraft how would you afford repayments?

TillyTopper · 01/11/2021 07:39

More than worrying about the loan I think you need to really determine if you have a mortgage offer or not. The offer is quite definite - if you are not sure then call the bank/building society or whoever you have used to get your mortgage.

ferneytorro · 01/11/2021 07:36

Not to sound harsh but, however the loan thing pans out, you really need to make sure you understand the house buying process. To not know if you’ve had a mortgage offer isn’t really a good place to be. Is this a joint mortgage where you’ll be joint and severally liable if you default? As others have said, the lender can withdraw a mortgage offer literally minutes before you are due to complete if they find something out that makes them nervous to lend.

colourmebladd · 01/11/2021 07:31

Just say it was for 4 months and it’s now been paid off. Then cancel the SO so if they ask for next month’s statement it won’t appear. Give cash instead for a month or 2.

stressingsusan · 01/11/2021 07:29

Yes I am a bit confused. Is it that obvious lol.

The bank have instructed solicitors as they offer this service.

Obviously the loan will be paid off once the current property sells but I'm concerned that they might make completion of this property a condition of getting the mortgage which is a worry because who knows how long it might take to sell?

OP posts:
xksismybestletter · 01/11/2021 07:26

Who is instructing the solicitor here?

It is normally the purchaser - IE you, and happens pretty early on in the process. Like the day after you have an offer accepted.
Then you start jumping through hoops, such as getting a valuation, mortgage and loads of information sharing and legal info.

Are you confused with the process?

Dee1975 · 01/11/2021 07:20

@stressingsusan hi op. Sounds like you have an agreement in principle (which is the first part). Which is great. It means based on all the info you have provided along with credit check all approved subject to valuation and all proofs.

You will need to declare it (as they will see on bs). But say no more payments due once completion goes through. But - Don’t worry. It will be fine. As long as they know no more payments due once you take out the new mortgage, then they don’t need to factor it in (because it’s not a cost you will have at that point).

Jasmine11 · 01/11/2021 07:17

This all seems very strange OP, are you in the UK? Usually the house valuation is the first step in the process before the mortgage is offered. You can get an agreement in principle without having to show detailed financial statements, but once the valuation is done then you’ll have to provide further proof of everything you’ve stated. I can’t understand how your broker is guaranteeing you you’ll get the mortgage when it sounds like things are quite early on in the process?

askingforafriend86 · 01/11/2021 07:00

Don’t over think it. It comes down to affordability. If you can afford the payment even with that outgoing it doesn’t matter. Plus it will be paid soon.

Our broker didn’t look through our bank statements or ask any questions about it. They probably should have but they didn’t

Morechocmorechoc · 01/11/2021 06:48

For people saying tell the truth, it sounds all great, but it totally depends on the banks rules. Our monthly non obligatory child things were even deducted and that was 2 months ago. Most lenders will deduct it or want proof of next month's statement with no outgoing if not to include it.

If your family member will let you stop payments until the house is sold, then you could honestly tell the bank no more monthly payments are going out. Don't mention you owe more for a lump sum as its not relevant. Problem solved.

DixonD · 31/10/2021 23:59

@stressingsusan

Having spoken to dh they have access to all of his statements and activity already as he banks with them. However he is the main earner (earns 3 x more than me). As yet I haven't been formally asked to produce bank statements.

I'm wondering why solicitors have been instructed if so much is still pending?

Because you can instruct them without an offer.
DixonD · 31/10/2021 23:53

@stressingsusan

The last thing our advisor said to me was that the only thing that would stop the mortgage going through now would be if the house valuations came back wrong - so if the bank deem the property to be worth significantly less than what we are wanting to pay for it.

We have done our sums. We know that we can afford the repayments even with the extra loan money on top. And we had a third of the asking price to put down as a deposit. So in theory we are in a fairly strong position but im just worried that the bank will withdraw or change the offer if this loan comes to light.

The fact you haven’t declared this extra borrowing would concern them more I imagine, than your ability to pay. You would have had to declare any loans on your application. You’ve lied by omission.

Also, a lender can withdraw an offer at absolutely any time. When I was in conveyancing, we had offers withdrawn even AFTER exchange of contracts.

Swipe left for the next trending thread