Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset by comment my Dad made

244 replies

wateringthenightgarden · 31/10/2021 20:29

Recently went to my parents house, the conversation ended up with us talking about families that can not afford to have heating on in their home, my Dad who is in his 60's said he didn't have heating in his house until he was 23 and he didn't moan about it and that people will just have to wear coats and jackets to keep warm.

I was upset at my Dad's comments as we're not living in the 60's and 70's anymore when my Dad was a child when it might have been acceptable not to have heating in your home.

OP posts:
bakingdemon · 31/10/2021 22:08

There was a chat on here recently where someone said they wanted it to be 23 degrees inside their house all year round so they could just wear t shirts. Which is madness. So much energy wasted when we should be accepting that to stay warm in the winter the first step is to put more layers on. So your dad has a point.

AnnaBegins · 31/10/2021 22:08

I grew up in the 90s. We had no central heating. We stayed in the living room with the fire until bedtime, then had hot water bottles in our beds. Ice would form on the insides of the windows.
I will do everything in my power to ensure that my children never have to experience that. It's not a mark of character to live through something like that. Times change and acceptable standards of the past are not comparable.
We are in the fortunate position that I can ensure my children have all the heating they want, but the energy price rises make me so worried for others. It's unprecedented and it saddens me that some have no empathy. Sadly the rose tinted spectacles are strong for some like your dad.

darklindor · 31/10/2021 22:07

I always promised myself that when I grew up I would have a sofa that went down to the floor, no wind whistling round the backs of your legs and Granny's Tartan burns up the fronts.

I spent much of my childhood freezing, couldn't even read in bed because your hands were too numb to turn the pages, hated it.

I'm warm now and intend staying that way.

Wineandroses3 · 31/10/2021 22:07

What’s the problem? Your dad is spot on.

Muchmorethan · 31/10/2021 22:06

Not sure what there is to be upset about. Your Dad was just saying what he experienced and was expressing an opinion

EinsteinaGogo · 31/10/2021 22:05

@NeverDropYourMooncup

It's shit living in a house with no heating.

I grew up not knowing what chilblains were, not because I was warm, but because I wasn't told there was a name for the itching and burning of my feet and fingers in case I told somebody at school. The sink and bath were frozen up regularly, so you couldn't have washed even if you were a) allowed and b) wanted to get that cold when there wasn't any way of getting warm again. I looked forward to the windows icing up, because it made my bedroom warm enough to breathe without watching it come out of your mouth all night.

Many people would say it wasn't that bad, but when you know you didn't change into clean clothes because it was too cold to get undressed, you didn't wash, you didn't have a warm hat, socks or coat and you were constantly told that you were making a fuss about nothing and not to tell anybody that you were cold all the bloody time and relied upon a cat sleeping on you every night to keep you warm (she was very good for that, but how many people would be happy with a cat sleeping on the chest of a six year old because she was too cold to sleep without her?), it was utterly shite.

I'm really sorry you had to live like that.

Cocomarine · 31/10/2021 22:02

@CoolOven

Why are you upset? Not everyone has central heating even now

Indeed not. We don't. It's quite a big house and would cost a fortune to install.
It's really only cold for 3 or 4 months of the year. We have an electric heater in the hallway, and whichever room we're in. Woodburning stove for when it's very cold. And lots of fleecy Jim jams.

Which is very different to having no heat source (that you can afford).

There is such a difference going to bed warm but into a cold room, and spending all your evening cold right through your bones and then going to bed cold too. Day after day.

Gastonia · 31/10/2021 22:01

On an entirely other subject, where I remember it actually was better in the 1970s...
I remember the doctor coming to see me when I was ill with tonsillitis
So do I. Those were the days! Now, you can't even get through to the doctor on the phone...

LilQueenie · 31/10/2021 21:58

Difference is now we have houses made with better insulation and it makes lack of heat an issue. It can lead to mold issues. One of the reasons we need heating is to heat the house and stop it from going damp.

CoolOven · 31/10/2021 21:57

Why are you upset? Not everyone has central heating even now

Indeed not. We don't. It's quite a big house and would cost a fortune to install.
It's really only cold for 3 or 4 months of the year. We have an electric heater in the hallway, and whichever room we're in. Woodburning stove for when it's very cold. And lots of fleecy Jim jams.

SierraJulietGolf · 31/10/2021 21:57

NeverDropYourMooncup. Similac experience minus the cat. My main memory of childhood is feeling sick with cold for months on end, chilblains , doing anything to put off getting out of bed in the morning, getting dressed in bed, coming home from school and helping to get dinner ready still wearing our coats because it was just too cold to take them off. I remember the doctor coming to see me when I was ill with tonsillitis and him telling my DF it was no good giving me a hot water bottle when the bedroom was freezing cold. That there are still people having to live like this 60 years on is such a horrible thought.

StaplesCorner · 31/10/2021 21:57

@SpaceshiptoMars

Why does this upset you? If the governments of the world don't get their act together, we will have worse to face than not switching on the heating. The next 10 years are going to make the 60s and 70s look like the garden of eden. Buckle up, it's going to be a rocky ride.
I think things today are ALREADY making the 60s and 70s seem like that Sad
raspberrymuffin · 31/10/2021 21:54

There's a difference between no central heating and no source of heat at all. Before central heating, homes in the UK had fireplaces and stoves in which they could burn fuel to stay warm. OP's dad is unfortunately full of shit or being extremely disingenuous. Other than extremely rural homes or those who've had a wood burner put in for fun, most homes now don't have ANY OTHER SOURCE of warmth so when people can't afford to put their central heating on they aren't huddling around the fireplace for warmth, they've got literally nothing.

But also, even if people did literally freeze in the winter 50 years ago, why would it be a good thing for that to still be the case, in one of the richest countries in the world where we can easily afford for everyone to be warm and eat food?

Gastonia · 31/10/2021 21:52

It's very different not being able to afford heating when you're living, say, in the north of Scotland, compared with, say, the south of England.

It's easy enough to just wrap up warmer in the southeast, where we are. We've not had to put our heating on at all yet.

Dodie66 · 31/10/2021 21:52

We didn’t have central heating. Just put lots of blankets on the beds and coats too sometimes. We had frost on the inside of our bedroom windows. The only heating we had was a fire in the living room and a coke boiler in the kitchen which heated the water. Lots of jumpers snd warm clothing. Seems like we will have to do that again this winter. We are only heating one room at the moment. Wearing a cardi in bed over my thermal nighty to keep warm

BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 31/10/2021 21:49

We didn’t have heating installed in this house until the late 90s when I was pregnant - until then we just had the coal fire and an immersion heater.

My neighbour doesn’t have central heating but does have a gas fire in one room and an immersion heater for hot water.

I do still put on a jumper if I’m chilly.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 31/10/2021 21:48

It's shit living in a house with no heating.

I grew up not knowing what chilblains were, not because I was warm, but because I wasn't told there was a name for the itching and burning of my feet and fingers in case I told somebody at school. The sink and bath were frozen up regularly, so you couldn't have washed even if you were a) allowed and b) wanted to get that cold when there wasn't any way of getting warm again. I looked forward to the windows icing up, because it made my bedroom warm enough to breathe without watching it come out of your mouth all night.

Many people would say it wasn't that bad, but when you know you didn't change into clean clothes because it was too cold to get undressed, you didn't wash, you didn't have a warm hat, socks or coat and you were constantly told that you were making a fuss about nothing and not to tell anybody that you were cold all the bloody time and relied upon a cat sleeping on you every night to keep you warm (she was very good for that, but how many people would be happy with a cat sleeping on the chest of a six year old because she was too cold to sleep without her?), it was utterly shite.

catsandhens · 31/10/2021 21:45

There is a difference between people not having the heating on because central heating didnt exisit, and people not having the heating on because they are too poor to afford to put it on.

In a country with this much wealth people shouldnt have to be cold because of poverty.

There are of course arguments to be made about carbon footprints, global warming, the consequences of having the heating on too much, but telling your child to put a jumper on before turning the heating on is very very different to not being able to put it on because you cant afford it.

The conversation was about poverty but got turned into 'well I used to have to do that so whats the problem)

It also ignored the fact that a lot more people had open fires in the 60s and 70s. New houses and flats tend to be built with less or no fireplaces so its a very different senario.

felulageller · 31/10/2021 21:43

There's a big difference between no heating and no central heating.

People may not have had radiators but coal fires were warm!

Notimeforaname · 31/10/2021 21:41

I'm only 34. We didn't get heating in our house til I was 14..so 2001/02 ish.. before that we had one gas fire in the sitting room.
As pp said lots of blankets,warm jammies and hot water bottles.

Couple of years ago my best friend was diagnosed with cancer ,she simply couldn't afford to put the heating on for all of winter. She wore big dressing gowns and blankets at home. Its what you do when you need to/have no other option.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 31/10/2021 21:41

I understand why this upsets you OP. I bet your dad is one of them who romanticises his childhood where nobody had much. It was probably normal for his whole street not to have heating when he was a child.

However, as he aged, things got better, life expectancy grew, healthcare outcomes improved, poverty levels reduced. He may have got free tuition through uni, probably bought a nice house on a single salary and retired with a final salary pension, goes on a nice annual cruise.

He then probably repeatedly votes for governments that kick the ladder from those coming up behind him. Saying he didn’t have heating when he was a lad is irrelevant as general living standards today should mean that is a thing if the past.

My DM used to go to a communal washing place where you washed your clothes and had a good bath once a week in the 1960’s because she and her neighbours were poor. She says a few things I don’t agree with but she would never be so dense as to watch a news story in England 2021 where some poor mother was crying about having to share communal bathes with her whole street and that her working DH has removable collars on his shirts to pretend they were clean as they can only be washed once a week and say ‘well we did that in the 60s and survived’. She’d be wondering what the hell went wrong as she would be hoping/expecting things to have progressed.

Some people will not be content until we are literally living like just post WW2 with busted up buildings and rations. There are strong cultural traits in this country that are so weird to the point of being nihilistic and quite scary. You notice it if you go away for a bit and return.

Nanny0gg · 31/10/2021 21:41

What's to be upset about?

Cameleongirl · 31/10/2021 21:40

@lap90

Ah yes, the suffering Olympics. Brits love it.
@lap90. It’s not “the suffering Olympics,” though, it’s factual!
theremustonlybeone · 31/10/2021 21:40

your wound up by your dads comments. Instead of being wound up you should be shocked that people lived like that. I used to visit my grampa and it was a coal fire and we had multiple layers of bedding to keep warm.

Instead of being wound up you should be grateful you havent experienced that. Power cuts, and outside toilets

KatherineJaneway · 31/10/2021 21:39

YABU

He is telling you how it used to be and he was right. I remember no central heating and the windows rattling in our home, it is just how it was. If I said I was cold, I was told to put a jumper on and / or stoke the fire.