Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset by comment my Dad made

244 replies

wateringthenightgarden · 31/10/2021 20:29

Recently went to my parents house, the conversation ended up with us talking about families that can not afford to have heating on in their home, my Dad who is in his 60's said he didn't have heating in his house until he was 23 and he didn't moan about it and that people will just have to wear coats and jackets to keep warm.

I was upset at my Dad's comments as we're not living in the 60's and 70's anymore when my Dad was a child when it might have been acceptable not to have heating in your home.

OP posts:
ThePoisonousMushroom · 03/11/2021 20:33

@MrsCardone

For those saying they ‘can’t afford’ to heat their homes, may I ask do you have enough food? I only ask this because I would go without food to heat my home as I cannot bear being cold. I would rather go hungry.
I’m not in this situation but I’d rather be cold than hungry. You can wear extra layers if you’re cold. Not ideal, but better (for me) than being constantly hungry.
MrsCardone · 03/11/2021 20:13

For those saying they ‘can’t afford’ to heat their homes, may I ask do you have enough food? I only ask this because I would go without food to heat my home as I cannot bear being cold. I would rather go hungry.

Porcupineintherough · 03/11/2021 19:46

@Bobsyer ??? Quite a few of us cant afford to heat our houses to a nice even 23 degrees, that's why we don't. I dont know a single person who doesnt selectively heat rooms in cold weather or who doesnt layer up. Just saying that those things are normal and not an example of extreme deprivation. Having no means to keep warm is deprivation.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 03/11/2021 19:14

@EnidFrighten

It's mainly about insulation really, this country's housing stock is terrible.

I'd be annoyed at your dad too. Older people often say kids in their day had it harder, the thing is that older people in their day also had it much harder than today's older people. No foreign holidays, hip replacements, dining out etc. You don't hear so much about that!

Well, no. Because for somebody to remember not being able to go to a restaurant, fly abroad or have a hip replacement, they'd be around 120 years old by now, as the former two have been steadily increasing in popularity since the 50s and all have been regularly available since the 1970s.
Bobsyer · 02/11/2021 19:12

I do find it amusing that we’re all talking about “back in the 70s” and “when I was a kid” - we bought our first house in 2007 and it didn’t have CH!

Just remember people - you win no medals for roughing out the cold and denying yourself and your family the basic comfort of being warm. And it’s crass in the extreme to suggest that because you’re happy to do it families that can’t afford to heat their homes should also be happy to live like that. Cop onto your privilege that you can afford it and don’t need it.

SpaceshiptoMars · 02/11/2021 17:58

@Andwander

I understand you are upset.its that sort of unempathetic attitude towards poverty in general that is so unpleasant to listen to.However, I also think, it is totally inapropriate how (mostly young) people cant be bothered to wear a fleece or a thick jumper indoors in winter.There is a point in both those arguments.
I've been clearing a house recently. There were a number of old, worn woollen jumpers with holes in. Warm, but no charity shop would take them. So - I left them outside the door with a help yourself sign. They vanished within half an hour.

So - people are layering up now, whether because of climate reasons or lack of cash.

hardboiledeggs · 02/11/2021 16:43

It's a fact, that's what he was brought up with so he's always going to have a different view than you on this. I don't understand why that would upset you tbh.

Andwander · 02/11/2021 08:46

I understand you are upset.its that sort of unempathetic attitude towards poverty in general that is so unpleasant to listen to.However, I also think, it is totally inapropriate how (mostly young) people cant be bothered to wear a fleece or a thick jumper indoors in winter.There is a point in both those arguments.

EnidFrighten · 02/11/2021 08:38

It's mainly about insulation really, this country's housing stock is terrible.

I'd be annoyed at your dad too. Older people often say kids in their day had it harder, the thing is that older people in their day also had it much harder than today's older people. No foreign holidays, hip replacements, dining out etc. You don't hear so much about that!

Lasair · 02/11/2021 08:33

Why on earth has this upset you enough to write a post about it? Seems utterly bizarre!

Takemetothe90s · 02/11/2021 07:23

@nildesparandum

Takemetothe90s

I am fully aware I get a winter fuel allowance.I am also aware that it s likely to be means tested under this government so am enjoying it while it lasts.

Well if it’s means tested and you won’t get it you don’t need it! God the entitlement!
nildesparandum · 02/11/2021 00:37

Takemetothe90s

I am fully aware I get a winter fuel allowance.I am also aware that it s likely to be means tested under this government so am enjoying it while it lasts.

PaulRuddsWife · 01/11/2021 21:27

Maybe the OP's dad is a baby boomer, who now owns a house and has a good final salary pension

Maybe he lived through those times as a young person but benefited from improving welfare and workplace support

Maybe he's like many of those of his age, who have no idea of how lucky they were, and that these privileges aren't on offer to current / future generations

Or maybe he's like my mum who had to live sleep and eat in one room with her mum and 3 siblings thanks only to the generosity of her aunt after her dad died. Or my dad who slept 3 in a bed with his brothers, with both parents being written off before they got to senior school because they failed their 11 plus. Who had to raise two kids on one small salary before childcare and top up benefits were freely available and one of whom died before he reached pension age and certainly not a good final salary pension and who never had a holiday, let alone a holiday abroad because they couldn't afford it.

Ah, the gold old days 🙄 How lucky my boomer parents were.

Honestly, the agism on MN sucks.

Takemetothe90s · 01/11/2021 21:06

@nildesparandum

I was a child in the 1950s . We had one coal fire n the living room with a broken back boiler so used a gas heater for hot water it was called an Ascot.The bedrooms were unheated so we only used them for sleeping in, then we used hot water bottles, and coats on top of the blankets to keep warm.The windows froze over in the winter, Jack Frost drew patterns on them.We would get dressed in the cold mornings in the kitchen with the oven lit and the door open until the fire got going. When I got married and first house with two young children in the 70s things were not much better, but what you never have you never miss. Then in the 80s we got central heating it was like heaven and still is. I would not like to go back to the early days, but now I am a pensioner I may have to.
You get a winter fuel allowance as a pensioner. £200? That would cover my winter gas bill, why won’t it cover yours?
Takemetothe90s · 01/11/2021 21:03

Due to various setbacks I went without central heating in my house from Christmas till the end of February last winter and wearing warm clothes, hot water bottles, electric blankets is nowhere near the same as having central heating.
I had one of them plug in convention heaters too, ok but bloody expensive.
I’m sorry it’s nearly 2022 and there’s no way I’m going cold to save a few quid, I’m old enough to remember coal fired and the rest of the house being Baltic.
Nope we’ve moved on and my house is as warm as we need.

BlackCountryWench2 · 01/11/2021 19:31

My mum and dad didn’t have central heating until I was in my mid-teens in the late 80s. Until then, yes, all the things everyone has said - hot water bottles, electric blanket on for half an hour if you were very lucky, a hundredweight of Witney blankets, a paraffin lamp in the bathroom to stop the pipes freezing, visits from Jack Frost on the windows… yet when it snowed, you couldn’t wait to run and play outside! You don’t miss what you’ve never had. I look back with some fondness but at the time it was horrible compared with now, and it was so much colder then. Your dad is talking from experience, let it go - there’ll be a time when you reminisce to your grandkids about not having house robots or some such when you were growing up!

itsgettingwierd · 01/11/2021 18:45

I think it comes more from a place where they try and show its survivable!

Not comfortable and not the 21st centrist lifestyle we have all learnt to take for granted - but also not something that is out of the norm or been seen before.

And for many it's a reality and people who have knowledge of what it's like and how to survive it and get through it are actually useful to know!

LakieLady · 01/11/2021 18:38

I grew up in a home without central heating.

We had an open fire in the living room that had a back boiler that heated a radiator in my parents bedroom and the hot water, and an immersion heater for when the fire wasn't lit. The other 2 bedrooms had no heating at all, but my DB and I both had electric blankets on our beds.

It was bloody grim. It was so cold we had ice inside the bedroom windows - not frost, actual ice a few mills thick. I used to get into bed and take my clothes off and put my pj's on under the covers.

The mornings were even worse. There was no heating in the bathroom at all, and it was impossible to have a hot bath because the water cooled so quickly. I used to get up first so I could get dressed in the living room while no-one else was around, and put my school uniform on the fireguard to get warm while I was in the bath.

I didn't live in a house with CH until I was in my late 20s and I bloody love it.

cobblers123 · 01/11/2021 18:30

1972 we got ch at home, before that we had gas fire in lounge and a spare electric 2-bar fire for anywhere else. We had Crittal windows which were metal surrounds so in really cold weather in the bedrooms we often had thin ice on the insides of the windows and condensation water on the window sills.

It was horrible but we managed. It was sheer luxury when dad got the ch put in though. Grin

Ariela · 01/11/2021 18:24

I grew up in the 60s. Whilst we had a rudimentary heating system, with a few radiators, we still put a jumper on in winter, and when we woke on a cold morning Jack Frost had been and left a lovely pattern of ice on the inside of the (single glazed) window.

That was pretty normal.
I know nowadays people expect to swan about in short sleeved tshirts when at home (someone on the news the other day thought it disgusting that she'd have to wear a jumper if she couldn't afford to heat her home), but can assure you that was the normal in the 1960s. Then we had the fuel strikes of the 70s, so you'd come home from school - no heat no electricity. Homework by candle, and bread and cheese for tea. Great.

PinkiOcelot · 01/11/2021 18:24

Don’t understand why you were upset by that comment. At all.

Lynne1Cat · 01/11/2021 18:21

It's a generational thing. I'm 62, didn't have heating at home until I left and got my own place at 20.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 01/11/2021 18:18

Many people don’t have central heating, or choose not to use it. I do think people should know how to dress for winter in a cold house, how to save heat by closing doors etc. Thermal base layers, wool jumper, fleece socks etc. Lots of layers for kids, extra duvets and blankets in winter.

We had minimal heating when I was a kid and in my student flat I didn’t turn it on as couldn’t afford the bill. I’ve also lived in a house with oil heating that was so expensive to heat we rarely had it on, just dressed warmly and lit the fire or woodburner.

Heating a house so you can wear one layer all winter or live in T-shirt and shorts is a fairly new concept. Like double glazing, proper insulation etc weren’t around for many people and still aren’t accessible or affordable to everyone.

SoItWas · 01/11/2021 18:08

*I can vaguely remember having a coal fire at home, and know I burnt myself very badly when younger on it. I think we got central heating around 1998.

SoItWas · 01/11/2021 18:03

I can remember both sets of grandparents having central heating installed, and having coal fires, and I was born in the 90's. I must have been about 8? We stayed regularly with both sets, and I can remember how cold it be upstairs when you went to bed, although one gran had an electric blanket for my bed, which was amazing.