Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really worried about the NHS this winter

240 replies

AtlasPine · 31/10/2021 15:58

Just that really. Lots of issues around GP access, backlogs of people waiting for treatments and overstretched A&E departments. Flu season coming, Covid cases rising, staffing problems linked to Brexit and the rise of private practices offering better terms and conditions to doctors.

What can we do to support the NHS?

Vaccinations (flu and Covid) and look after ourselves as much as possible I suppose. I can’t afford private health care like most here I suspect.

OP posts:
anon12345678901 · 03/11/2021 15:59

@Franklin12

We are slowly going down other routes because we are not accepting that we need to change. We need to be clear and accepting of change and yes I do think that involves people putting their hands in their pockets for their own health.

Problem is many dont want to pay anything, point to others etc. NHS is a massive waste of money now.

I agree. I don't believe the NHS is fit for purpose anymore. And no, I'm not very rich. I'm a single parent on an average wage.
julieca · 03/11/2021 15:54

@Franklin12

We are slowly going down other routes because we are not accepting that we need to change. We need to be clear and accepting of change and yes I do think that involves people putting their hands in their pockets for their own health.

Problem is many dont want to pay anything, point to others etc. NHS is a massive waste of money now.

Yes you think if people cant pay for healthcare then tough luck. Or if people to be able to pay for healthcare have to pull their kids out of all afterschool activities and turn down the heating, well tough luck. I suspect you are very rich.
julieca · 03/11/2021 15:53

@Franklin12 I have posted a number of times, including in answer directly to you, about what I would do.
I would get rid of the internal market that only creates another layer of bureaucracy. I would prosecute hard all the government corruption that has handed NHS money to their rich friends - PPE that could never be used, ventilators that were never built. Politicians need to know they will be prosecuted individually in court and that will stop this happening in future.
Anyone who think the current government, who are incredibly corrupt, would be able to manage any public service saving money is naive beyond belief. Our current government has handed nearly the whole of an annual NHS budget to rich friends, many of whom did not provide what they were supposed to.
We had firms contacting the government offering to provide emergency ventilators at cost. Their calls were not returned.
So please don't talk to me about waste.

Franklin12 · 03/11/2021 15:49

We are slowly going down other routes because we are not accepting that we need to change. We need to be clear and accepting of change and yes I do think that involves people putting their hands in their pockets for their own health.

Problem is many dont want to pay anything, point to others etc. NHS is a massive waste of money now.

Franklin12 · 03/11/2021 15:47

Thing is Rose. The people in the NHS dont want change and efficiencies. So they carry on with the old ways and are as slow as snails and often very resistant to change.

(Big supplier to NHS for many many years - - dont do it anymore). I swore I would never work for a local or health authority. The time wasting was criminal.

Giving them more and more money will just involve more wastage. We need a cross party/even a refendum to discuss fixing the NHS and I honestly think some sort of co paying is the way forward. Allow people to manage their own health.

Gingernaut · 03/11/2021 15:44

@Franklin12

The US system is not the only option. Stop going on about it as though it’s the only choice.
The trouble is, it's mainly American firms being courted and taking contracts.

We are slowly going down the route, even if there are other paths available

RoseAndRose · 03/11/2021 15:39

They're crap at buying power. Friend was head of buying at NHS hospital she was directed as who to use. Left went to work with a hospice charity again buying where she was free to negotiate haggle for everything from cotton wool to drugs

Agree - first thing I would do would be to get together a team of the most hard-nosed shark-like negotiators (maybe the big supermarkets could loan a few?) and really find the ways to do this.

It doesn't work terribly well with the 'postcode lottery' structure, which leaves regions doing their own thing, but I'm sure a way can be found round that.

Franklin12 · 03/11/2021 15:35

Julieca - so I am asking too. What would you do? The NHS is wasting millions, they are inefficient and often run little cottage industries and cannot see the wood for the trees. Like a lot of government depts no one wants to make a quick decision so have endless meetings about very little to ensure that their jobs are safe.

No country in the world as far as I am aware has a system like ours. I wonder why that is??

Its not the envy of the world. Its free and people use and abuse it because they know that they wont be fined, and that time wasters and even health tourists are rarely chased.

Throwing more money at a broken white elephant will not make it any better.

Shizen · 03/11/2021 14:28

@julieca

Oh and international comparisons of health systems don't agree with you either.
Again I ask, what comparisons are you relying on for these statements? Can you provide a link to a valid source?
Shizen · 03/11/2021 14:24

[quote julieca]@Theluggage15 funny how the reforms are always either introducing a new layer of bureaucracy or private shareholders to make profit and rationing healthcare to poor people far more.
Its like the idea of reforming schools by introducing academies which always mean new uniforms, managers on high salaries and expulsion of SEN kids[/quote]
We disagree about the data @julieca, but nonetheless, what do you suggest then if you’re so opposed to reforming the system to a copay or means tested model?

Poor people aren’t being especially well served by the NHS as it stands… being unable to access GP appointments, a 6 month lead time being considered “quick” for most referrals and a 2 year+ wait for mental health services, are they?

And this was all pre covid!

ReallyQuirkyName · 03/11/2021 14:16

What can we do to support the NHS

Stop using a&e for minor ailments would be top of my list.

I took my son to A&E a few months ago. There was a wait of over 6 hours. Within about an hour of being there he was struggling to breath and going limp and he was rushed through onto the ward and ended up on oxygen for days. I was really surprised at how fantastic they were when the situation got serious.

However, the amount of people I heard asking the nurses how much longer it would be because they'd have to leave soon and things like that was ridiculous. If you can leave A&E because the wait is too long you don't need to bloody be there in the first place.

justasking111 · 03/11/2021 13:24

[quote frumpety]The other thing that niggles me about doing away with the NHS, is losing the NHS's buying power when it comes to medication.

lowdownnhs.info/drugs/billions-are-spent-by-the-nhs-on-drugs-every-year-but-how-does-it-work/[/quote]
They're crap at buying power. Friend was head of buying at NHS hospital she was directed as who to use. Left went to work with a hospice charity again buying where she was free to negotiate haggle for everything from cotton wool to drugs

julieca · 03/11/2021 13:09

Oh and international comparisons of health systems don't agree with you either.

julieca · 03/11/2021 13:08

@Theluggage15 funny how the reforms are always either introducing a new layer of bureaucracy or private shareholders to make profit and rationing healthcare to poor people far more.
Its like the idea of reforming schools by introducing academies which always mean new uniforms, managers on high salaries and expulsion of SEN kids

Theluggage15 · 03/11/2021 13:04

Virtually every European health system is better than the NHS. It’s way past time to reform it. I have friends from various parts of Europe and they are always appalled by how terrible the NHS is compared with their home countries’ systems. Doesn’t matter how much money is chucked at it, without reform it will be wasted.

julieca · 03/11/2021 13:01

@Shizen it depends what healthcare spending you include. A lot of analysis leaves out co pays.

Lavender24 · 03/11/2021 12:14

Don't become ill. If you do, don't expect any help.

This really. My DH had a serious head injury and we waited 6 1/2 hours in the street for an ambulance. It's made me realise that we cannot rely on the NHS anymore.

Shizen · 03/11/2021 11:39

@julieca did you look at the link I posted? When compared to % of GDP, the difference in spend isn’t very big at all between the U.K. and other counties. It’s the same % as Norway & The Netherlands, who far out perform us on outcomes.

To be really worried about the NHS this winter
julieca · 03/11/2021 10:12

[quote Shizen]**@julieca* We pay way less per person for healthcare. From a quarter to half as less*

What data are you using to support those claims? And we pay less per person for healthcare, as compared to who?[/quote]
We pay a quarter compared to Canada and about half compared to a lot of EU countries. Yet people compare the NHS to countries that pay way more for their healthcare. Someone has already posted links to these costs.

frumpety · 03/11/2021 09:33

Whatever figures are quoted they need to take into account Covid, health expenditure went up for most countries during this time in response to the pandemic, so will skew the figures for 'normal' health expenditure.

Namechangedox · 03/11/2021 09:30

I thought the NHS was amazing until I went to Singapore, my DD was around 2 at the time and became sick with severe D&V and was very dehydrated. MIL who is a Singaporean citizen took her to a children's hospital, a pediatrician was waiting for DD and she was seen instantly no queues, was given tests and meds. It cost us 30 Singapore dollars which is £15. It would take hours and hours here !

People are living a lot longer with long term conditions, The NHS wasn't designed for this we need to have a conversation about its future. I haven't been able to get a GP appointment after I had surgery for blood tests or refill of medication I have had to pay privately.

Shizen · 03/11/2021 09:26

@julieca We pay way less per person for healthcare. From a quarter to half as less

What data are you using to support those claims? And we pay less per person for healthcare, as compared to who?

julieca · 03/11/2021 09:19

[quote frumpety]The other thing that niggles me about doing away with the NHS, is losing the NHS's buying power when it comes to medication.

lowdownnhs.info/drugs/billions-are-spent-by-the-nhs-on-drugs-every-year-but-how-does-it-work/[/quote]
Yes everything will cost more. Singapore who have been quoted here set wage levels for staff and bulk buy medicines and supplies, just like the NHS.

julieca · 03/11/2021 09:17

[quote Shizen]What is this obsession with putting forward the US system as the only alternative to the (completely unfit for purpose) NHS?

There are other models with proven better outcomes to look at it the world….look at the co-pay system in France, or the means tested system in Australia.

And 😂😂😂😂 to everyone bleating on about what a great system the NHS is…. Have you ever experienced health care in other countries? The U.K. has not ranked best in the world for healthcare, on any measure, for years (and that was pre covid). Norway, The Netherlands and Australia all provide far greater outcomes than the U.K, while spending a similar % of their GDP on healthcare.

www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2021/aug/mirror-mirror-2021-reflecting-poorly#rank[/quote]
We pay way less per person for healthcare. From a quarter to half as less. That our outcomes are so good on so less money is testament to the efficiency. Instead people want another layer of bureaucracy to sell and manage insurance policies and co pays which makes healthcare more expensive. And it will still be rationed, it will just be your insurance company refusing to accept your claim now or setting enormous co pays because of your age pr pre existing conditions.

frumpety · 03/11/2021 09:07

On the night he was admitted he was told he was scheduled for surgery next day. Next day he was told that they were going to "watch and wait" instead. Now, a sensible approach would have been to discharge him, and if his condition worsened to tell him to come back in.

A similar thing happened with DH, who also fortunately didn't need surgery, the surgery would have almost certainly required a stoma formation so he was mightly relieved. Part of that watching and waiting included regular observations and IV antibiotics. So he was getting treatment during that time, just no surgery.

Swipe left for the next trending thread