Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really worried about the NHS this winter

240 replies

AtlasPine · 31/10/2021 15:58

Just that really. Lots of issues around GP access, backlogs of people waiting for treatments and overstretched A&E departments. Flu season coming, Covid cases rising, staffing problems linked to Brexit and the rise of private practices offering better terms and conditions to doctors.

What can we do to support the NHS?

Vaccinations (flu and Covid) and look after ourselves as much as possible I suppose. I can’t afford private health care like most here I suspect.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
vivainsomnia · 05/11/2021 13:44

some people go to A and E with very minor issues with their kids. Yes they will wait a long time
Im surprised how parents will go to A&E with their children if they have a fever over 39 degrees, are coughing non stop for 3 days, are a bit whizy, or not eaten as normal for 4 days.

I would never have occured to me to take my children with these ailments. However, I appreciate that it is under recommendation of the NHS. In the end, in 100 kids going to A&E, the very large majority will be fine, but there is always the one and we prefer to treat 99 who are fine to be sure not to miss the 1 who really needs urgent treatment.

The problem is this results in huge pressure on the system and long waits.

justasking111 · 05/11/2021 13:29

@Courtier

I mean personally I never aim to become ill. But if I am I'll use the health service I pay into.
Think you need to know where exactly your NI contribution is going, IT'S not just hospital GP
justasking111 · 05/11/2021 13:27

[quote julieca]@Intercity225 where you live that is the protocol? I wonder what struggling to breathe means? Obviously, a baby really struggling to breathe needs the hospital, but people say this when it's a cold.[/quote]
Suggest you read the advice given plentifully on here about rise and fall of stomach, when judging whether a child needs extra care. When a GP refuses to see a child hospital is your only option

Courtier · 05/11/2021 11:36

I mean personally I never aim to become ill. But if I am I'll use the health service I pay into.

Intercity225 · 05/11/2021 08:45

where you live that is the protocol?

Yes, it is. He had had a cold, but he was over it by then. He had an ear infection, which was really painful, and according to the GP in Poland, a chest infection.

Anyway, they had been told in a Zoom appointment with the GP to take DGD to A & E for a throat infection a few months before, as antibiotics weren't working. The one where she lost a 1/4 of her body weight, because she didn't want to eat.

DS does not take DGC to A & E for what he considers minor snuffles - he only does it on the advice of a doctor.

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:22

@Intercity225 where you live that is the protocol? I wonder what struggling to breathe means? Obviously, a baby really struggling to breathe needs the hospital, but people say this when it's a cold.

Intercity225 · 05/11/2021 08:18

some people go to A and E with very minor issues with their kids. Yes they will wait a long time.

Apparently it is the protocol here for GPs to send a baby struggling to breathe to A & E.

julieca · 04/11/2021 23:00

@MercyBooth some people go to A and E with very minor issues with their kids. Yes they will wait a long time.

MercyBooth · 04/11/2021 22:53

@Intercity225 And yet when ppl film these issues they are accused of privacy invasion or faking it. If they dont film it they get accused of lying or exaggerating.

julieca · 04/11/2021 19:50

@Intercity225 Okay sorry. The baby had an ear infection and was snuffly. Yes you would wait a long time.
I got an appointment with the GP on the same day with my GP for my teenager face to face. But then it was an issue that needed dealt with and I have never said my kids need to be seen urgently unless it is needed.

Intercity225 · 04/11/2021 19:43

A baby really struggling to breathe would not be left for 6 hours.

I didn't say really struggling to breathe. I was not there, I can only go on what DS said, who said DGS was "struggling to breathe" and he was in real pain with an ear infection. DS rang the GP at 8 am for an appointment, but the GP refused to see DGS, as he didn't have a negative PCR. The GP told them to take DGS to A & E, which is a good half an hour's drive away, as they have closed the three nearer A & Es, in the time we have lived here. DDIL can't drive.

DS did say NO patients in children's A & E were seen for 5 hours - the staff just kept coming out saying

"A doctor will be here soon!"

They were there for 6 hours, and then DS had to leave to pick up DGD from nursery, and DDIL had to go to work. They went back to A & E sometime in the evening, and were eventually seen at 2.30 am. They said a little girl, who had been coughing and vomiting when they were there in the morning, still hadn't been seen, when they left. DS told the doctor, they saw eventually that DGS is ill all the time, as he catches everything off DGD, who started nursery recently. The doctor who examined DGS didn't know why he was struggling to breathe. He told them to buy a nebuliser for next time - I am not sure why, as surely something has to be prescribed to put in it?

Anyway, DS and DDIL went to Poland last week to see her family. They were able to arrange a face to face appointment with a GP there straightaway for £30, who said DGS had a chest infection. (So GPs are not afraid of Covid there)

julieca · 04/11/2021 11:19

A baby really struggling to breathe would not be left for 6 hours.

Intercity225 · 04/11/2021 10:57

If you can leave A&E because the wait is too long you don't need to bloody be there in the first place.

Some people have commitments to care for other more vulnerable people, and they can't just abandon them, because they are in A & E.

DS took baby DGS to A & E a few weeks ago, as he was struggling to breathe - on the advice of the GP. Six hours later, not having been seen, he had to leave, to pick up the three year old from nursery. What would you suggest - he left the three year old to walk home and let herself in with a key, under the plant pot?

julieca · 03/11/2021 22:21

@purpleflowerlegs exactly those deemed unable to pay will be those on a very low income. Maybe families are entitled to free school meals?
On paper, I would have to pay co-pays. In practice, I would have to pick and choose what treatment I had for my chronic health condition and for my teenager. In reality, I would forgo treatment so the teenager could get treatment. Which I know will in the long run put me back in hospital as an emergency case, or I will die.
In reality I will move to Scotland.

frumpety · 03/11/2021 22:04

If 40 brand new additional hospitals were built ( not sure that is what the Government had in mind when it made that promise ? )that would mean about 5,500 extra hospital beds for those 10 million people who have joined the population in the last 30 years.

frumpety · 03/11/2021 20:47

On the bright side we can look forward to 40 'new' hospitals.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/50579557

frumpety · 03/11/2021 20:28

This is why we cannot get past the left wing who dont look at the elephant in the room which is that regardless of how much is given to the NHS it will never be enough

I am left of centre and have worked in the NHS for a couple of decades, nobody who works in the NHS thinks it is perfect. Policy mistakes have been made along the way by parties of all persuasions, for instance bed numbers were reduced far too much, every successive Government has known that the population is ageing ( it has gradually increased so not a sudden suprise ) and was well aware of the impact that would have on the need for healthcare provision especially in the Winter months.
Private healthcare in this country isn't really set up for the type of patient that the NHS has to deal with, how many private hospital beds are available to people who need admitting due to carer strain ? Or people who develop delerium due to an infection, or people who need ICU care following post operative complications or just need ICU care following surgery? The local private hospital will call an ambulance to transfer to the NHS hospital if this happens, the local private mental health facility regularly sent patients via ambulance to the NHS hospital after over sedating their detox patients, they no longer offer this service but do utilise the NHS district nursing team to apply a dressing should any patient injure themselves. The NHS has to see everyone, always, which means there will sometimes be a wait due to the bed numbers being halved in 30 years and the population increasing in those 30 years by 10 million.

purpleflowerlegs · 03/11/2021 20:27

@justasking111

Family in Ireland pay. Son was poorly visit to GP who diagnosed chickenpox the bill €60 . There's health care for those unable to pay
@justasking111 just curious about how it works - who decides if you can't pay? Do you have to be on benefits or is there some other threshold?

I'm fairly middle income on paper and would never qualify for benefits but I could never pay outright for our healthcare. I have a child with SEN in and out of the NHS and I have a long term condition where I have regular health care appointments.

Just wondering how many people would just have the money to pay? The very poor would be subsidised but many people wouldn't be able to pay who on paper would be expected to presumably?

justasking111 · 03/11/2021 20:20

Family in Ireland pay. Son was poorly visit to GP who diagnosed chickenpox the bill €60 . There's health care for those unable to pay

MercyBooth · 03/11/2021 19:02

Means tested means - those who are low income for whatever reason get state sponsored or subsidised care

Which definately means they wont get criticised or reminded every minute that their healthcare is subsidised and they should be grateful.....just like social housing tenants are told they should be grateful for their "subsidised" housing.

So basically the attitudes to poorer NHS patients will remain the same!

Shizen · 03/11/2021 18:58

Should have said we already means test access to basically every other benefit

Shizen · 03/11/2021 18:57

A means tested system does not equal = “if you can’t pay for your healthcare then tough luck”. We means test access to basically every other benefit in this country already, why should healthcare different?

Means tested means - those who are low income for whatever reason get state sponsored or subsidised care. Those who can afford it pay for private health insurance, which then alleviate pressure on public resources.

Plenty of countries run this model very successsfully,

frumpety · 03/11/2021 18:32

So can anyone give us an idea of how much it will cost for the average person if we get rid of the NHS ? I can't see the Government lowering taxes so it will be an additional charge on top of what you already pay out in tax and NI.

Franklin12 · 03/11/2021 16:22

Of course I am not very rich!! I am trying to have a sensible discussion about how to fix the NHS having worked with them for too many years than I care to remember.

This is why we cannot get past the left wing who dont look at the elephant in the room which is that regardless of how much is given to the NHS it will never be enough.

MercyBooth · 03/11/2021 16:20

Well im sure this will help Hmm

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/care-homes-face-closure-sajid-25363798