Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband won’t take time off for sick child

221 replies

Exhausted111 · 31/10/2021 14:42

AIBU?? Our son has tested positive for covid so needs to isolate for 10 days. Both me and my husband work, him full-time and me part-time (Monday/Tuesday). I’m a teacher so don’t have access to holiday days. My mum who normally does childcare for us is also positive for covid.

My son’s isolation will hit both my work days for this week and next. I think we should both take two days off - one of us this week, one of us next. My husband seems to think I should do it all. My headteacher is very reasonable but understandably likes to see that we’re taking turns in time off for sick children.

My husband is shouting, screaming, calling me all the names under the sun as if this is my doing, and I can’t help but feel he’s being utterly childish and selfish. I believe I’ve brought this on myself because I’ve fallen into the ‘part-time’ trap of working outside the home yet still taking on all the responsibilities as if I were a stay at home mum so now this situation has arisen, he can’t believe he’s being asked to take time off work. I 100% cannot see this from his point if view at all, can anybody help me she’d light on why he this I this is reasonable?!

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 31/10/2021 21:09

Please don’t misconstrue the messages being sent to you as all being cruel because there is a wealth of support and knowledge here and a lot of posters will have first hand experience of abuse in all forms.

I agree.

OP it is very easy to feel like everyone is attacking you on here (I’ve been there before) but it’s out of frustration that you are burying your head in the sand instead of facing the truth. Our anger is directed at him.

You are obviously a clever women and there’s no shame in saying yes he was a bit of a dick I will speak to him when the kids are in bed and tell him it’s not going to happen again.

You know he doesn’t respect you as much as you deserve.
The reason he flew off the handle was because you dared to ask him to take a day off for his own child - meaning you/your job is just as important as his, which he obviously disagrees with.
‘How dare you ask him to take 2/5 days off from his very important work when you should be the one to do it.’
Why is his job so much more important than yours?

I can almost guarantee that you will be taking the time off and he’ll be going on to work as normal.
And you won’t even complain because you know it’ll start an argument again.

Hankunamatata · 31/10/2021 21:09

No excuse op. My Dh has PTSD for same reasons. He has had lost of therapy etc. He crossed the line swearing like you have described once and I packed his bags as no child deserves to hear their mother treated like that nor do I deserve that.

He took it on board and we had counselling together, we have rules to arguments and he knows his PTSD is no accuse to abuse me or the children.

Comingup · 31/10/2021 20:59

OP you are a teacher. If a student said that this was happening would you normalise it in the same way? This is disturbing.
I used to get screamed at. My abuser " couldn't help it" either.He too was fabulous...when he wasn't being abusive. He had a MH condition too. He also "couldn't help"then getting physical . I left him.
Come back and read these replies later.
Will you tell the children he can't help it when ( not if) he does the same to them?

Iloveallofthem · 31/10/2021 20:39

@Extraonions

TBH OP, giving half a story in your first post had sent everyone off down a rabbit hole.

Is he being unreasonable … yes, but you know that. You accept his behaviour as part of your relationship.

I’m not sure why you have asked the question, when you are fully aware of the answer.

This 👆

RestingStitchFace · 31/10/2021 20:29

Jesus OP, that sounds awful. Does he behave like that regularly?

For context, I work 3 days a week, DH works full-time. When DS is sick we usually divide childcare 2-thirds to me, 1-third to him. But he would never dream of not doing his share. Working full-time does not allow you to abdicate parenting responsibility.

Sofiegiraffe · 31/10/2021 20:27

My partner gave 12 years of his life to the Army too and left with PTSD. He doesn't shout and swear and call me names, and if he did, he'd be gone.

BoredZelda · 31/10/2021 20:24

He shouted, he swore and he called me some names in an argument. At no point did I say I sat cowering in a corner too scared to stick up for myself. Perspective, people.

So you were shouting and screaming at him back? That doesn’t sound much better.

Or my husband a bad father. It’s just not fair and just not accurate.

Choosing to scream at your partner when you are asked to do some childcare sounds like a low bar for “good father” material.

Anyway I’m currently hid in the bathroom crying my eyes out about all your cruel comments, whilst my husband is reading the kids the next chapter of Harry Potter.

Your husband who is supposed to love you and care for you, screams at you for asking him to look after his children and you’re absolutely fine with that, but some complete strangers on the internet suggest that’s really not acceptable and your children would be impacted by it, and you’re in tears? Seems an extreme response.

toomuchlaundry · 31/10/2021 20:24

Who is looking after your child?

Hont1986 · 31/10/2021 20:23

I don't think he's a hero and I certainly don't think he fought for our safety.

saraclara · 31/10/2021 20:19

I'm sorry that you've been upset, and yes, some of the posts do read as blaming you. But your more recent posts have read very differently from what you said in your OP.

screaming, calling me all the names under the sun

Screaming (which would definitely have been heard in the garden) has turned into shouting, now, for instance. And no, calling you all the names under the sun for asking him to look after his children for two days is not 'having a disagreement.

I know what it's like to live with someone with mental health issues, but normalising the behaviour that comes with it isn't the way to go.

Has he apologised for the names he called you?

CityMumma78 · 31/10/2021 20:18

Hey OP, I’m sorry these comments have upset you so much. Please don’t misconstrue the messages being sent to you as all being cruel because there is a wealth of support and knowledge here and a lot of posters will have first hand experience of abuse in all forms.
I hope you find a solution to the childcare that is equal and I wish your son and mum a speedy recovery Flowers

AcrossthePond55 · 31/10/2021 20:18

One of my BFF's DH did two tours in Viet Nam in the late '60s. He did and saw things there that no person should ever have to see or do. When he came home there was 'no such thing' as PTSD, he was expected to 'suck it up and deal with it'. He also came home to a nation (I'm ashamed to say) that called him a baby killer and reviled him.

He used to wake screaming in the night. He would shake and cry for no discernible reason. He became angry over trivial things. But what he never did was 'scream and call every name under the sun'. And he certainly never shirked his parenting duties. This went on for years, until the US VA decided that PTSD was a 'real thing' in the '80s. And it still took a good 20 years to get his claim approved.

Your DH's behaviour is unacceptable, whether it happens once a year or once a day. By accepting that it's just the way he is, you're enabling him to continue it and are actually putting up roadblocks in the way of him really changing his behavior.

BoxOfDreams · 31/10/2021 20:17

So he can't help himself? It's his PTSD. He's not responsible for his actions. So your DC should expect and accept the same treatment? He can't help it after all. Your DC are going to be so fucked up. You have a choice to put up with a volatile man, they don't - they're trapped.

Screaming, shouting and name calling is NOT part of a normal relationship. I've been married 35 years and yes we have disagreements and sometimes raise our voices, but we've never screamed, shouted or name called.

MajorCarolDanvers · 31/10/2021 20:07

Sorry you've had a hard time on the thread.

Why does he think it's solely your responsibility to care for your child?

StopGo · 31/10/2021 20:04

Got to love the Army and other services. Conditioning the partner/spouse (wife) to excuse and enable abusive behaviour as a result go the aggressors heroic service.
Don't for one minute think your children are unaware or unaffected.

WonderfulYou · 31/10/2021 20:03

You seem to have normalised your DH's behaviour. On the one hand, you are excusing it on the grounds of his military service and ptsd, and on the other hand you seem to be suggesting that a bit of screaming and swearing over disagreements is normal in most relationships. I'm not sure which of these you think is true or whether you're just clutching at any old straw to make sense of his behaviour.

I agree.

I know many, many ex military men and only one would fly off the handle like this as they needed help for their PTSD. They chose not to live with their partner as they didn’t think it was fair on them. They got therapy and now they are a happy family once again.

It’s worrying that you keep trying to make excuses for him even though you posted knowing it was wrong.

I’d take a few days and think about his behaviour. You burying your head in the sand acting like it’s normal is not going to help your relationship. It may be that you both need couples therapy or he needs to see someone about his PTSD.

hellololabells2019 · 31/10/2021 20:02

@Exhausted111 please don't be upset by what others say on here. Just forget this thread and move on Smile

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 31/10/2021 19:59

OP your husband is a hero for what he’s done overseas.

Every couple will row and shout on occasion. However calling names is a line in the sand which he should not cross, and you need to tell him this. PTSD is not an excuse- he needs to work through that and understand as much as he is working through stuff, there is behaviour that is not acceptable. You need to be firm on this, and the childcare, he can’t play the victim card if he wants to be in a healthy adult relationship.

I have many sympathies for you, suffering with PTSD myself, and knowing veterans not long back from conflict, and those who’ve been back for decades. His behaviour here is not acceptable and not excusable. You need to have a serious talk about him taking responsibility for his actions.

I had to have some very hard talks with my DH as he was in the depths of MH issues. He was shouting a lot and I made it clear it was unacceptable and he had to shape up or I couldn’t go on. To his credit he has worked very hard, and is still working very hard.

You do not have to put up with tantrums, name calling, and shouting. Hero or not.

WonderfulYou · 31/10/2021 19:56

I know you are on the defensive right now but hopefully over the next few days you’ll think about how healthy your relationship is and how you improve your respect for yourself.

You were discussing who would stay home and look after your child.
That should not have resulted in screaming and name calling. You were not the bad one here, it’s not your fault your child is off, you didn’t have an affair or offend him, so there was no way you should have got any blame.

You posted on her for a reason as you knew it was not ok.
You say yourself you have low standards so maybe it’s time you raised them up a bit. That doesn’t mean ending your relationship you could expect a little more respect.

Vulpius · 31/10/2021 19:52

OP, nobody is "looking down their nose" at you. I think it's more concern (possibly mixed with a degree of frustration, when it seems so obvious) that you have come to believe that this behaviour in a relationship can ever be normal.

Garriet · 31/10/2021 19:51

I’m sorry you’re upset OP, but what you described here is not “just” frustrated loss of temper or healthy arguing. You yourself said “shouting, screaming, calling me every name under the sun.” No matter what reasons your husband might have for his uncontrollable temper, it’s absolutely not excusable in any way. Imagine someone shouting at your children in the same way, you’d not think it was OK then. It’s also not OK for them to be exposed to this - and you’d be surprised how much they overhear or pick up on. If your children reported this to someone at school, a safeguarding referral would most certainly be made.

I’ve only had one relationship where a man treated me similarly to how you describe, and he was gone shortly afterwards. It really isn’t normal or healthy.

NothingSafe · 31/10/2021 19:49

Most people here aren't trying to upset you, OP. They can just see more clearly than you that this isn't a healthy dynamic, and that given what you've said, you aren't able to see quite how abnormal it is.

I don't think you're a bad mum. I think your husband is being a bad husband, potentially regularly. And that reading your interpretation of events is quite sad.

I hope you're okay, and I really hope we're all wrong. But from your version of events, this isn't alright, and people here have got all sorts experience, lived or having seen it first hand or having seen the countless threads on here where someone defends behaviour they thought was normal, of seeing someone be unable to recognise the situation they're in.

It might be harsh (and no disagreement from me that MN can be an absolute cesspit at times!) but in this case I think it's broadly meant as tough love.

alexdgr8 · 31/10/2021 19:49

OP, i haven't read the whole thread, but my impression is that most people are concerned for you and your situation, not that they are looking down on you.
sorry you are upset.

KnightError · 31/10/2021 19:49

@AlexaShutUp

Of course DH and I lose our tempers occasionally, but not about day to day stuff like caring for a sick child and not to the extent that we scream and swear at each other or call each other names. Yes, we disagree and get annoyed with each other at times, but verbal abuse is not a normal response to this.

You seem to have normalised your DH's behaviour. On the one hand, you are excusing it on the grounds of his military service and ptsd, and on the other hand you seem to be suggesting that a bit of screaming and swearing over disagreements is normal in most relationships. I'm not sure which of these you think is true or whether you're just clutching at any old straw to make sense of his behaviour.

It's hard to acknowledge that someone close to you is abusive. I get that. It's easier to pretend that it's normal, or that he can't help it because of what he has been through. Because the alternative is that you will have to do something about it, and that's quite scary. You don't have to live like this unless you choose to do so. Maybe you think you're happy to put up with it, but please do think about the longer term impact on your children of living with someone who is so unable/unwilling to control his emotional reactions. Do you really want them growing up thinking that this behaviour is normal?

This is a sensible and well balanced post. I waited too long to leave my husband - partly because I couldn't get my mind round the idea that his 'fly off the handle' behaviour was anything other than at the 'bad' end of normal - and the children were already damaged by then. I deeply regret it now.
NeedAHoliday2021 · 31/10/2021 19:48

He shouted, he swore and he called me some names in an argument.

In 20 years of being with dh we’ve had the occasional argument but never had he called me names.

I would be clear that I’d cover 2 days and dh needs to cover 2 - he can choose which. I wouldn’t budge on that. Why would my job be less important than his? But then dh and I have always shared childcare for sickness. Some posters are being unkind but it’s hard to hear a woman minimising a man calling her names. If you have a future together it’s up to you whether you’ll stay on these terms or if you’ll tackle this and reset the boundaries of your relationship.