Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you attended private/grammar school, what is your job role and salary?

539 replies

Z3lda · 31/10/2021 08:24

Extremely nosey I know and obviously no one is obliged to share. But I'm just intrigued as it seems many are quite desperate to get their children into the best private or grammar school, but I just wondered what kind of jobs and salaries students from these schools go on to actually have? I know that education provides children with far more than just a path to a specific job and salary, but I do think many send their children to these schools for this reason.

OP posts:
Xenia · 03/11/2021 17:28

I also wanted my children to have a broad range of skills and parents can provide that at home and hope they get it in school so eg mine would know how to forage for food or keep going on long distance hikes or know how to find water in forests and how to live a balanced lice and have loads of hobbies. Those are not just things you learn at private or state schools but at home too but they are all part of the broader term of education. I want them to be able to perform classical music with me at home (I sing and play every day) and a large range of other things from driving a car at 17 to knowing about life skills and tax and how to cope no matter what life throws at you.

Winecrispschocolatecats · 03/11/2021 17:15

Me - early 50s, grammar & good university, salary £34k. I've never been that career oriented and havehappilyturned down promotion opportunities to maintain a decent work/life balance.
DH - late 40s, comprehensive school, redbrick university, earns around £120k. Not massively ambitious, but found a niche he really enjoys and which is in demand.

A good education is always going to be an advantage, but drive and determination are far more important I think. And a decent sprinkling of luck!

DallasDerby · 03/11/2021 16:52

@68degreesnorth You might find this useful

www.preplounge.com/en/management-consultant-salary-uk

DallasDerby · 03/11/2021 16:16

@Xenia

I understand now. Some of my sons' friends have got graduate jobs in firms of management consultants. These are very very hard to get at that entry level and you need a stellar CV etc even to get a look in. Those jobs are on a par with City lawyers (£80k on qualifying), top accountancy firms and all the banking graduate jobs at financial services companies and hedge funds. It is on that last of the highest paid and hardest to get into work. Most people who apply fail to get in.
What do management consultants get qualified in?

It is hard to get in because the combination of skills is extremely hard to find. Everyone focuses on the academic but for consultancy the soft skills are just as important and it's bloody amazing how few people have them, but then most of these kids have over focused on their academics, soft skills don't get the same priority and often an overly competitive nature will work against you as you struggle to demonstrate you can be a team player.

Firesidefox · 03/11/2021 15:47

@ThanksItHasPockets

A much more interesting question IMHO is whether those who were privately educated can afford and / or choose to send their own children private. My anecdotal experience is that friends who were privately educated on one professional salary in the 80s and 90s cannot afford the same for their own children unless they are in very very high-earning careers, or the grandparents are paying.
This is true
Xenia · 03/11/2021 15:37

I understand now. Some of my sons' friends have got graduate jobs in firms of management consultants. These are very very hard to get at that entry level and you need a stellar CV etc even to get a look in. Those jobs are on a par with City lawyers (£80k on qualifying), top accountancy firms and all the banking graduate jobs at financial services companies and hedge funds. It is on that last of the highest paid and hardest to get into work. Most people who apply fail to get in.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 03/11/2021 13:41

[quote DidoAeneas]@68degreesnorth
It can sometimes help if you have a masters in your specialist field or an MBA. None of us know exactly what 'business as unusual' is going to look like but I'd be surprised if travel / overnight assignments at least in domestic markets are not back on the table next year. It adds to the cost of childcare if you/you're both away on business at the same time unless you have a live in nanny etc. Even then, my mother was a regular feature as she would deal with more of the housekeeping side of things (like new furniture or builders arriving) while the nanny was ferrying between music/dance lessons. I suppose it took two women to replace me! Grin[/quote]
That's because they both have their own lives also. Different if nanny is a full time live in nanny/housekeeper.

DallasDerby · 03/11/2021 13:40

[quote 68degreesnorth]@DallasDerby not suggesting you're a charity. I'm genuinely curious as to how people become consultants. My 'success' is creating two regular salaries from a business that gives myself and my partner time, freedom and a good work/life balance. It was once suggested to me that I should become a consultant - hence I was curious. [/quote]
A consultant in what, sorry I am confused - do you think someone will pay you to replicate your business model? Who do you see as your client? Industry or individuals?

68degreesnorth · 03/11/2021 13:26

@DallasDerby not suggesting you're a charity. I'm genuinely curious as to how people become consultants. My 'success' is creating two regular salaries from a business that gives myself and my partner time, freedom and a good work/life balance. It was once suggested to me that I should become a consultant - hence I was curious.

Titsywoo · 03/11/2021 13:18

I'm on £25k a year - private school. DH is on £130k a year - state school. That is more due to me taking a back seat for childcare though so the difference between male and female privately and state educated is probably a factor.

DidoAeneas · 03/11/2021 13:15

@68degreesnorth
It can sometimes help if you have a masters in your specialist field or an MBA. None of us know exactly what 'business as unusual' is going to look like but I'd be surprised if travel / overnight assignments at least in domestic markets are not back on the table next year. It adds to the cost of childcare if you/you're both away on business at the same time unless you have a live in nanny etc. Even then, my mother was a regular feature as she would deal with more of the housekeeping side of things (like new furniture or builders arriving) while the nanny was ferrying between music/dance lessons. I suppose it took two women to replace me! Grin

DallasDerby · 03/11/2021 13:00

[quote 68degreesnorth]@Xenia in this case it was in order to get a job as a consultant[/quote]
Your business is not financially successful and that is the point of business - we are not a charity - how are you measuring success?

DallasDerby · 03/11/2021 12:47

[quote 68degreesnorth]@DallasDerby thank you! I'm wondering how you show/prove your talents in a particular area... In my current career for example, I own a business, so would the proof be in your annual turnover, expected growth and number of employees? If anyone looked at my business from those perspectives it's not very successful, but in other ways it is a successful business nevertheless. See what I mean? [/quote]
Sorry I have no idea what you mean with your business success example. We test our candidates via written assessments, analytical assessments and technical interviews - they need to be able to discuss in depth, current and future issues in our specialism and offer views and solutions to the problems we suggest to them, just as they would need to be able to do with a client.

68degreesnorth · 03/11/2021 10:51

@Xenia in this case it was in order to get a job as a consultant

Whataday198 · 03/11/2021 10:23

Grammar. I work in the third sector as senior management and make around 45k. DH went to public school on an academic scholarship and works in logistics and ops management on £55k.

Neither of our parents paid for our education so it was probably worth it.

Xenia · 03/11/2021 10:21

68 depends why you are trying to prove them. Eg I kept my law firm at one person as I could not care less if other people think I am ha huge firm with a big glossy office. I know other City lawyers however for whom that is the thing - to get up the office in the big glass fronted place, have a secretary serving their tea and show off they have 6 people working for them (and they prefer that even if it means they have less money than I do as they have the over heads).

However for the purposes of an investor who might buy a business assessing success or rather value of the company is a very different issue and a very skilled task involving a lot of due diligence, contracts etc etc.

There is another thread on the back of this one about how you spend all this money once you are on £100k (it is certainly not hard once HMRC have loads of it back and you are paying for full time childcare for 3 children under 4 as we were at one point.....)

68degreesnorth · 03/11/2021 09:48

@DallasDerby thank you! I'm wondering how you show/prove your talents in a particular area... In my current career for example, I own a business, so would the proof be in your annual turnover, expected growth and number of employees? If anyone looked at my business from those perspectives it's not very successful, but in other ways it is a successful business nevertheless. See what I mean?

buntybanana · 03/11/2021 09:45

Local comprehensive school. Now 27 and earn £35,000 as a gov analyst. Husband went to a local comp too - he's now 30 and earns £84,000 as business lead.

A few people from my school did well but most didn't, especially in comparison to friends I have that went to private and grammar. I absolutely hated comp, had a horrible time and couldn't wait to get out.

Draggondragon · 03/11/2021 09:25

Boarding school, engineer around 70k no tax with housing school fees etc provided

EarlyPlanner · 03/11/2021 09:14

I think there's a big difference between Grammar and Private.

I went to grammar but from a working class background, working class town, just I'm academically bright so passed the 11+ and went to the grammar school in my town.

Real mix of jobs from the people in my class that I'm still friends with. Even the ones who went on to oxbridge none of them are huge high flyers really.

My best friends husband earns the most of anyone I know really. She went the to grammar I did but now is a occupational therapist in the NHS so doesn't earn huge.

He dropped out of the local comp before a levels. Never did well in school but liked computers and earns loads now.

So I don't think grammar education has a huge difference to non grammar state school.

Can't comment on private but I am considering for my daughter as I worry about her (SEN) being easily led astray in a comprehensive. She's very bright so would like her surrounded with kids and teachers who will respect her and expect her to reach her potential.

Boltonbabe · 03/11/2021 07:18

Sorry I'm not 28 am 38!! Typo

GreenWednesday · 03/11/2021 06:53

Mid-30s, private school educated, parents split part way through and dad left us all with debt and not a lot else. I was one of the poorest there (in the time of Assisted places). My mother did all she could to keep me there. I earn just under 100k heading up a professional services department for a software company. Took 5 years out to be a SAHM which did/has impacted my career.

DH, same age, grammar school educated. Didn't do well in A-levels, didn't go to uni. Company director - 300k+ annual take home.

We are privately educating our kids, but not so they end up with high salaries - we want them to have choices, and we want them to be happy, whatever the salary. Thinking back to my class mates, everyone has a real mix of careers and salaries.

DallasDerby · 03/11/2021 06:47

[quote 68degreesnorth]@DallasDerby I'd love to know what the requirements are to become a consultant! [/quote]
You need to be flexible, comfortable with change and uncertainty, be open minded, have excellent people skills, value relationships, work collaboratively, low ego - be humble, rely on your team, work hard, be fiercely organised and prepared to go the extra mile to deliver a fantastic result, excellent communicator - you make the complex sound simple. After all that be talented in the area you want to consult in. That’s us - that’s the kind of person we are looking for - schooling means nothing.

Babdoc · 03/11/2021 00:32

I don’t think that “people who went to grammar school” are a homogenous lump. My own class at the local grammar over 40 years ago ended up in a very wide range of jobs and salaries - ranging from millionaire company director, hospital doctor and airport manager, to social worker, fork lift truck repairer, airport ground staff, bank clerk, shop assistant and a prostitute!
I think home circumstances, personality, luck and opportunity had more bearing than the school.

dratsnotyouagain · 03/11/2021 00:28

31, earn base salary of £156k (not including bonus), work in finance, have a Masters in engineering.