Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
UniBallEye · 01/11/2021 10:52

I think PPs have it right, certainly from the Irish American many generations back perspective. It would have been unusual for many of the million of Irish people who emigrated to USA in the 19th / early 20th centuries to have done so entirely willingly.

It was a last resort life-line and undertaken with huge grief that they would likely never see home or family again. That is a profound grief carried by such huge numbers of people, coupled with the fact that their language, culture and religion was outlawed in their own country for so long it is unsurprising that keeping it alive in the new world was a priority. They lived in close knit communities and married other Irish immigrants etc. These stories and histories and values were passed down through the generations and were at the heart of their family life.

I am Irish, living in Ireland now again and I really feel no animosity for any American who identifies as Irish American. I can't honesty see why I should. It could have been me...my branch of the family were lucky to survive all that befell them and I am here as a result of that.

I have also spent time in Australia which to me is a totally different and more challenging heritage situation, especially for Irish people historically (not recent immigrants). Under British law in Ireland many thousands of Irish people were banished to Australia and Tasmania (Van Diemen's Land) to work in the colonies as prisoners. Many were political prisoners who were seeking an independent Ireland and many many were desperate starving poor who stole food to feed families.

Under the Earl Grey Scheme 4,000 Irish girls aged 14 - 18 from post-famine workhouses across Ireland were sent to Australia to provide wives for the colonies and it is estimated 20% of the current population of Australia can be traced to this event. the girls were known as 'breeders' and on average had 8 children. They were sent by the colonial government to prevent the men finding Aboriginal wives which would have been a nightmare for the colony formed only 16 years at that stage. They were sent with a bowl and a spoon and a petticoat.

Known as the Founding Grandmothers these girls were never expected to return to Ireland, most never did, through their decendents have done and still do come to trace roots.

Australia, due to the origins of it colonisation has an uneasy relationship with heritage as lots came from prisoner stock, or prison guards or 'free settlers' who were very unlawful and found this remote new colony far away from other places to settle. For many years there was a reluctance to delve too deeply into your family heritage but that's all changing now and that's also a good thing.

I think unless you come from a place where these are issues that face you or your people it's very hard to understand and easy to pass judgement.

There has been an unpleasant feel to this thread at times which is not nice to read.

Middersweekly · 01/11/2021 10:31

I don’t think there is anything wrong with trying to fit in, assimilate or belong to a community. It’s part of human nature to want acceptance. I think the issue is when it’s done for political or financial gain or when it’s culturally or racially offensive. Most people in today’s world move around much more than our ancestors ever did. We are also far more likely to be of mixed ethnicity. It’s an interesting topic of conversation for many people and it’s used to assimilate and build connections. Personally as someone with a GGM who was of Irish decent I feel very far removed to be claiming I’m Irish unlike Joe Biden. GGM emigrated to London (part of the London Irish descendants) and both my GM and DM would say they were English. I am half Scottish (DF is Scottish, both GP’s Scottish) and I do feel it’s appropriate to claim that heritage but technically I was born in England which means I’m English. DH is Scottish and tells the DC they’re more Scottish than English. They were also born in England though so I feel this makes them English even though 75% of their descendants are Scottish.

JaneJeffer · 01/11/2021 10:22

@jewel1968

Reminds me of the Irish poet who gave a talk about Christmas at an event in Leeds (I think). He talked affectionately about being a Wren Boy at Christmas time. After his talk a woman came up to him full of sadness and compassion. She thought he had said he had been a Rent Boy in his youth.
Brilliant Grin
wallowmall · 01/11/2021 10:13

@AryaStarkWolf I don't think you read my post properly

AryaStarkWolf · 01/11/2021 09:55

@wallowmall

I’m not disputing the American influence on Halloween, but Halloween was definitely a thing twenty years ago*

it did exist but not like now. We didn't really do trick or treating as kids & often went to Ireland for the holiday as it's much bigger over there. I live pretty much where I grew up & my dc get a bucket load of sweets.

I definitely went trick or treating as a child in Ireland, that was over 30 years ago
FlemCandango · 01/11/2021 09:37

I know what you mean op, it is an attitude towards heritage that is jarring to British cultural sensibilities. Having said all that, I am currently slightly obsessed with identifying my own Irish ancestry, for more practical purposes. I and my siblings would love to be able to claim dual nationality and Irish passports! This may mean a bit of digging as my father died many years ago and said he had an Irish mum but we can't find a jot of evidence. Too many Mary's in Liverpool in the 1930s😂

TomPinch · 01/11/2021 08:58

No, I think that (banter, sporting rivalry and Gallipoli aside) Australians like people from the UK, leastways that's my impression. Historically, they'd have preferred Larwood to Jardine IYSWIM, but that latter sort doesn't exist now.

TomPinch · 01/11/2021 08:48

For those who like maps: Largest ancestry by US county

Nb: this is claimed ancestry, rather than actual. Big swathes of Germans.

OhWhyNot · 01/11/2021 08:48

I assume in Australia the assumption is that you are English unless you identify as being from XYZ (maybe not the case)

Sydney had a St Patrick’s day parade when I was living there

But yes many don’t seem to like the poms (those with a pom accent)

OhWhyNot · 01/11/2021 08:35

Yes I realise that recent history will stop some people wanting to claim their German ancestry. But even recently with younger generations especially wanting to claim their ancestry and having a different attitude I have not heard this.

But some countries have much stronger self identities (Italian, Irish, Jamaican, Scottish - if anyone has a great grandparent from these countries you are very soon likely to know Spain, England, Greece not so much) I’m sure there are many other examples

TomPinch · 01/11/2021 08:33

OhWhyNot,

I'm in NZ. There isn't the same sort of Irish identification here at all, even though plenty of Irish people came here, and only a generation ago the Catholic churches were full of Macs and O's.

The big groups who have their own labels are groups from the various Pacific islands (arriving since the 70s) Chinese and Indians (since the 2000s) and of course Maori (got here first).

I got the impression Australia wasn't that different - perhaps I'm wrong? But nothing like the US.

NZ and Australia are very Anglophile - more so than the US - perhaps that has something to do with it.

KittenKong · 01/11/2021 08:19

Italians didn’t seem to try to hide the issue though. Trump didn’t mention his dads side of the family’s origins (he did mention his mum - she was an immigrant though - but we said we didn’t want him).

Bathtoy · 01/11/2021 08:10

@OhWhyNot

I have never heard anyone claim to be German American (which I believe is the largest immigrant group) and I spend a lot of time in the states

I think some national identities as stronger (Irish, Scottish and Italian)

And also seems a new world thing we are an old established country it’s similar in Australia

I find Americans to be far more obsessed with your background than people here they also quickly put you in a box my family is South Asian but the box is Hispanic (we are mainly light skinned) but no one would think here my dad or brother is Hispanic they look Asian

Again, there are reasons why being explicit about your German-American heritage has been problematic at times during the 20thc — German-Americans experienced prejudice during and after WW2, for instance.
phoenixrosehere · 01/11/2021 08:06

I do wonder at the phrase 'African American'. Africa is a hugely diverse place and African Americans have little in common with people from any part of it. Still, if the Africans don't object then I don't see what anyone else should.

Because many native Black American ancestors were taken from several parts of Africa for slavery (cheaper than indentured servants) by several European countries, stripped of their cultures so don’t know where they came from in Africa without a dna test. Those who are lucky to know their ancestry are likely ones who immigrated after the 1960s and had children in the US. They wouldn’t call themselves African Americans though because they know where they’re from and some would find it offensive to simply lump them in. It’s one of the reasons many Black cultures hate being lumped together. Some Black Americans refuse to use African Americans and others chose to use it and since they can’t refer to themselves as simply American without issues, that’s what they do despite many of them having ancestors there longer than many of the immigrants who say (insert country) American.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 01/11/2021 07:54

@znaika - But it's not their parents that's the point. It's their several times great grandparent. Conveniently ignoring all the others that weren't the ethnicity they want.

Or perhaps the heritage they identify with was emphasised as it was passed down. So a person with a Greek background married someone from an Irish background. They lived close to the Irish family in an area with many others with an Irish background. The Irish heritage was dominant and the Greek neglected by the time their grandchildren came along and so on.

OhWhyNot · 01/11/2021 07:47

I have never heard anyone claim to be German American (which I believe is the largest immigrant group) and I spend a lot of time in the states

I think some national identities as stronger (Irish, Scottish and Italian)

And also seems a new world thing we are an old established country it’s similar in Australia

I find Americans to be far more obsessed with your background than people here they also quickly put you in a box my family is South Asian but the box is Hispanic (we are mainly light skinned) but no one would think here my dad or brother is Hispanic they look Asian

znaika · 01/11/2021 07:40

If the bigoted crass stereotypes are about Eastern Europeans it's fine. Other groups who experience this shit it's definitely seen as harmful

Sonex · 01/11/2021 07:35

it doesn't bother me at all and I don't think I really see the harm in the Irish/Italian/Scottish American thing - ok stereotypes but is it atuallybharming anyone. I just find it odd/noteworthy that you can have 2 people on this planet, who identify so differently based on, I guess, cultural context..I'm much more "Irish" than my colleague is and yet it's a big deal to him and meaningless to me. Then on the other hand you have my thourougly English son who spends so much time watching America YouTubers that he told me the other day that his bag was "in the trunk"! Weird. Humans are weird, and inconsistent 😁

ManifestingWisdom · 01/11/2021 07:32

Its just culturally a different approach which has been observed. It's not "bothering" me.

NotAnotherPylon · 01/11/2021 07:30

I agree with pp's who say they don't understand why anyone would have a problem with someone identifying themselves as Irish American etc. It doesn't dilute my Irishness just because someone in America called Patrick Murphy refers to his Irish roots when stating his identity.

Very often this sense of partially belonging to another country is handed down through generations whose forebears emigrated out of dire need rather than some romantic notion of making their fortune. They were displaced people and would have gravitated towards, and lived in communities with, other Irish immigrants, thereby keeping cultural practices and ties alive. They may be more scattered now, but people absorb their sense of identity through culture, religion, storytelling and a whole host of other things. There are probably also millions of Americans with Irish or Italian or Scottish roots, whose heritage is no more than a fleeting diversion to them. And that's fair enough too.

ManifestingWisdom · 01/11/2021 07:29

Stereotypes are more than a bit annoying. On brooklyn 99, modern family and several other american shows i have seen it presented as fact that alcohol is like a drink of water to irish people. These shows are bought by other countries all over the world.

znaika · 01/11/2021 07:23

Because it reinforces harmful stereotypes that that the fully assimilated white 100% Americans don't have to deal with and the new immigrants do

jewel1968 · 01/11/2021 07:21

But cultural links can (and obviously do) pass down the generations. Why does it matter?

znaika · 01/11/2021 07:16

But it's not their parents that's the point. It's their several times great grandparent. Conveniently ignoring all the others that weren't the ethnicity they want.
Elizabeth Warren and her claims of native American ancestry. It's bullshit essentially.

shouldistop · 01/11/2021 07:14

The English people I know with Irish parents might not loudly declare they are Irish but often times they will let me know that they have an affinity to Ireland through their parents

That's one generation though. I think op is talking about 100-200 year old ancestry.