Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 01/11/2021 16:22

Is it poor ickle-bickle syndrome?

What do you mean?

I don’t think it’s different. I’ve seen so much negativity re U.K. it’s picked up a lot in last year.

IsleofRum · 01/11/2021 16:20

@MarshaBradyo

Tbh U.K. / English gets a fair amount of attack on here too.

It’s pretty constant

Maybe we should say what we like about other cultures instead

It's the reaction that is offensive. Say something offensive about America or Ireland and it's not taken up by moderators or the post removed. Say something about certain other countries or continents and the reaction is totally different.

Is it poor ickle-bickle syndrome?

dreamingbohemian · 01/11/2021 16:17

@znaika

It's UK based in London. Maybe UK more accurate. Majority nationality of UK is English. I am not English. Just an observer.
So is everything in the UK 'English' because most people in the UK are English?

How ironic that you're criticising Americans for not understanding other countries.

JaneJeffer · 01/11/2021 16:15

@znaika

Nope. But it means that when you accuse me of being a troll you won't be able to back it up
For someone with so many deleted posts I'm surprised you're still around TBH.
justmaybenot · 01/11/2021 16:13

@znaika

Nope. They hate the English and it rings through the text. Why they come in to an English forum to rile themselves up god in heaven only knows. Its been noted. I eveb recognize the names and can predict their presence.
No. I've been critical of some posters but I don't hate 'the English'. I dislike the attitude certain posters express in relation to other nationalities. I'd characterise it as xenophobic as it is expressed as finding things that are specific to another culture as weird or ridiculous.

Even if this is mainly a UK site, there are at least 430,000 Irish-born people resident in England, Scotland and Wales and far more that may identify as Irish due to their parents.

Anonymous48 · 01/11/2021 16:11

@secretllama

I'm Scottish and whenever I've been in America we always get Americans telling us they're Scottish. I feel bad because they aren't doing any harm and genuinley think that scottish people take this seriously but I aways want to tell them that it's a bit of a joke amongst us.

Also find it annoying when Americans refer to themselves as Italian. Not Italian-American... just Italian. When they've clearly never been and neither have their parents. I suppose it's just identity/tribalism as other posters have mentioned.

Would it help you to realize that when an American, who is clearly American, refers to themselves as being Scottish, it's shorthand for being of Scottish descent? They are not trying to claim they were born and raised in Scotland. Similarly, an American who refers to themselves as Italian means that they are Italian American. They aren't pretending to have come from Italy. They are telling you that they are of Italian heritage. And usually that it's a pretty important part of their identity, affecting the way they celebrate holidays like Christmas, their religion, and the foods they eat.

I think the confusion mainly comes from the fact that when British people say or hear "I'm X-nationality" they take it to mean I was born and brought up in that place, whereas Americans often mean that it's where their ancestors came from before settling in the US.

gwenneh · 01/11/2021 16:11

@znaika

Nope. But it means that when you accuse me of being a troll you won't be able to back it up
Ah. So you think long-standing forum membership exempts you from being a troll. Got it.
znaika · 01/11/2021 16:10

Nope. But it means that when you accuse me of being a troll you won't be able to back it up

znaika · 01/11/2021 16:09

It's UK based in London. Maybe UK more accurate. Majority nationality of UK is English. I am not English. Just an observer.

gwenneh · 01/11/2021 16:08

@znaika

Nope. Ive been here more than a decade)))
Is that supposed to make you exempt from bullshit posts?
znaika · 01/11/2021 16:07

Nope. Ive been here more than a decade)))

dreamingbohemian · 01/11/2021 16:07

@znaika

Nope. They hate the English and it rings through the text. Why they come in to an English forum to rile themselves up god in heaven only knows. Its been noted. I eveb recognize the names and can predict their presence.
MN is not an 'English forum' ffs
JaneJeffer · 01/11/2021 16:05

@znaika

Nope. They hate the English and it rings through the text. Why they come in to an English forum to rile themselves up god in heaven only knows. Its been noted. I eveb recognize the names and can predict their presence.
Bullshit post
znaika · 01/11/2021 16:03

Nope. They hate the English and it rings through the text. Why they come in to an English forum to rile themselves up god in heaven only knows. Its been noted. I eveb recognize the names and can predict their presence.

MarshaBradyo · 01/11/2021 16:02

It’s more likely some posters based here join in with the anti English /U.K. stuff

A recent thread that asked for positive stuff got completely railroaded

OchonAgusOchonOh · 01/11/2021 16:02

@MarshaBradyo

Tbh U.K. / English gets a fair amount of attack on here too.

It’s pretty constant

Maybe we should say what we like about other cultures instead

The flack to the UK is usually in response to xenophobia.

Maybe we should say what we like about other cultures instead

I haven't noticed a restraint in some posters in this regard.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 01/11/2021 16:01

@znaika

Im Russian so no skin in this game but there are some posters who always spout the most disgustingly bigoted anti English crap on here. Many posters think that anything less than positive fawning is anti American. It's not true. There was a ffs Australia thread on here about climate change earler today. The Australians responded with maturity,information and understanding that it wasnt them it was their government. If it was Ireland or US and not Australia it would be filled up with chippy anti-English whataboutery
Maybe the Irish and Americans are a bit more fed up about the casual xenophobia that permeates so many threads on here so respond more aggressively.
znaika · 01/11/2021 15:58

Im Russian so no skin in this game but there are some posters who always spout the most disgustingly bigoted anti English crap on here.
Many posters think that anything less than positive fawning is anti American. It's not true. There was a ffs Australia thread on here about climate change earler today. The Australians responded with maturity,information and understanding that it wasnt them it was their government. If it was Ireland or US and not Australia it would be filled up with chippy anti-English whataboutery

justmaybenot · 01/11/2021 15:49

@IsleofRum

Why don't we admit that anti American xenophobia or racism is a sport in the UK that is never tackled by moderators or the media.
Yep - anti-Irishness too. Probably acceptable xenophobia to MN HQ! This snooty characterisation of Americans as stupid and weird and Irish-Americans are particularly stupid is sheer ignorance. It's like a bad dream from the 1970s, all these little britons whinging about anything that doesn't precisely conform to their own myopic world view.
UniBallEye · 01/11/2021 15:48

@OchonAgusOchonOh this thread has been pretty eye-opening!

MarshaBradyo · 01/11/2021 15:45

Tbh U.K. / English gets a fair amount of attack on here too.

It’s pretty constant

Maybe we should say what we like about other cultures instead

OchonAgusOchonOh · 01/11/2021 15:44

@IsleofRum

Why don't we admit that anti American xenophobia or racism is a sport in the UK that is never tackled by moderators or the media.
They don't tackle the anti-Irish xenophobia either. Stuff on here and in the media has only gotten worse since brexit. The fact we wouldn't roll over appeared to be astonishing.

I think the fact the US is also not backing up the UK stance is a bit of a shock. After all, special relationship etc etc.

elp30 · 01/11/2021 15:34

@IsleofRum

Why don't we admit that anti American xenophobia or racism is a sport in the UK that is never tackled by moderators or the media.

No shit!

I'm married to an Englishman and lived nine years of my life in England so I hold those in England and the UK, as a whole, in high regard.

To see such nastiness on on media and other places is disappointing to me, to say the least.

IsleofRum · 01/11/2021 15:28

Why don't we admit that anti American xenophobia or racism is a sport in the UK that is never tackled by moderators or the media.

dreamingbohemian · 01/11/2021 15:28

@OchonAgusOchonOh

So why is it Americans of Irish descent that get the scrutiny? Or is this just another one of those threads so MNers can enjoy scoffing at Americans while simultaneously demonstrating that they don't understand them in the first place?

There is an enormous amount of anti-Irish feeling on MN and MNHQ don't treat it terribly seriously so it is generally allowed to stand. This topic gives them a double whammy - scoff at americans (a popular pastime) and demonstrate their anti-Irish sentiments. What more could they ask for?

Yeah I think this explains it really

I just find this whole thread astounding, that English people think their opinion on this question actually matters. It's between the Irish and the Americans, it's nothing to do with you.