Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
SenecaFallsRedux · 01/11/2021 18:14

@Howshouldibehave

Yes, I happily have picked and chosen this element to claim. So what?

It means that people who have cherry picked ‘being Irish’, will probably be very upset when their children go to Irish universities and aren’t welcomed with open arms into the Irish community as ‘being Irish’ as mentioned upthread. That sort of thing.

I can't speak for others, but when I, as a Scottish-American, went to a Scottish university, I was warmly welcomed as someone from the diaspora "coming home." Perhaps the surname helped.
phoenixrosehere · 01/11/2021 18:06

So Americans can perpetuate as many harmful and bigoted stereotypes about a country as they like as long as 1 of 16 or 32 or 64 grandparents came from that place !!!!

If that is what you got out of what they posted, it says more about you than them. Many Americans don’t even use the term (insert whatever ancestry)- American. Most say they’re American. You’re no better if you’re lumping all together because of the few out of 330 million+ you’ve met who’ve annoyed you. Plus, the U.K. is no better when it comes to harmful and bigoted stereotypes within its own borders.

Bathtoy · 01/11/2021 18:05

@Howshouldibehave

Yes, I happily have picked and chosen this element to claim. So what?

It means that people who have cherry picked ‘being Irish’, will probably be very upset when their children go to Irish universities and aren’t welcomed with open arms into the Irish community as ‘being Irish’ as mentioned upthread. That sort of thing.

I was the person who said that up the thread, and while it was an annual headache to deal with upset visiting students, I think it was actually probably a useful and potentially enriching, if initially uncomfortable, experience for them, usually. As with anyone who heads abroad for the first time and has certain preconceptions challenged. (I had them myself when I first left Ireland.) And it was certainly not just Irish-Americans I had a Korean-American student who had previously lived very much within a devoutly Christian Korean-American community in his hometown, and who ended up going home halfway through his stay because of extreme culture shock he'd never before come directly into contact with atheists or people having no-strings-attached sex that wasn't at least between engaged people.
FedUpAtHomeTroels · 01/11/2021 17:56

@KindergartenKop

Everyone in America is a something-american. The government, over the years, have done a fantastic job of uniting all these people from completely different backgrounds into all being 'American'. I'd say it's not designed to be divisive, quite the opposite (if we ignore all the racism etc etc, which I actually can't).

In America patriotism is a major thing. They sing the anthem at baseball games and pledge allegiance to the flag every day at school. That's the glue they use to stick everyone together which we just don't have on the UK!

Yes this. I spent 30 years living there, at first it was very odd when people say Irish American, as most have many nationalities in their background Dh's best friend recently found out he's not just of Irish heritage but also Welsh and French, he's now very proud of all 3, and tells anyone who will listen. I love all the reciting the pledge and singing the national anthem, it does encourage pride in there country. They also develop massive pride in their school, college and University. Something you don't see to this degree in the UK.
JaneJeffer · 01/11/2021 17:52

The intolerance on here, and sense of entitlement to pronounce on the norms of other cultures is unreal!
Couldn't agree more!

znaika · 01/11/2021 17:52

@justmaybenot

*'American' is a political nationality, it is not an ethnicity.

For some people that's fine, for others who feel close to their ancestral ethnic heritage, they want to acknowledge that.

We are all American, but we are not all the same. The lived experiences of a Mexican-American, an Irish-American and a Japanese-American are really quite different in many ways. Why should we erase that? It's part of who we are.

If you don't get it that's fine, but don't tell us we're all wrong or dumb. We're just different.*

Exactly. The only 'wrong' and 'dumb' people are those who laugh at other peoples' culture - and as the convention for so many people in the USA is to hyphenate their identity, that is a part of American culture. Just because it isn't the same as the UK doesn't mean it's wrong, just different. The intolerance on here, and sense of entitlement to pronounce on the norms of other cultures is unreal!

So Americans can perpetuate as many harmful and bigoted stereotypes about a country as they like as long as 1 of 16 or 32 or 64 grandparents came from that place !!!!
Howshouldibehave · 01/11/2021 17:50

Yes, I happily have picked and chosen this element to claim. So what?

It means that people who have cherry picked ‘being Irish’, will probably be very upset when their children go to Irish universities and aren’t welcomed with open arms into the Irish community as ‘being Irish’ as mentioned upthread. That sort of thing.

Mingmoo · 01/11/2021 17:49

This thread is honestly making me feel unwell, as someone who has been living in the UK for almost twenty years. There is no respect for Irish people or Irish history here, and if you have an Irish background almost certainly you were brought up to forget about that and hide it rather than celebrating it. Maybe it's worth thinking about why that was rather than sneering at people who do celebrate their culture and history and roots.

I always find it interesting that people in Britain focus on Noraid and the IRA bombing campaigns in England when they think about the Troubles. I grew up in the Republic of Ireland and the news headlines every morning on the car radio on my way to school were full of deaths that happened fifty or sixty miles away: civilians shot by British soldiers at checkpoints, or loyalist paramilitaries killing taxi drivers who were overwhelmingly from Catholic background, or rioting, or IRA punishment shootings and beatings, or IRA massacres of innocent Protestants for no reason other than their religion or their job as a prison officer or a police officer. The 'mainland' bombing campaign was a tiny, tiny part of the Northern Ireland troubles. It says so much that you all focus on that when you think about Irish Americans.

SenecaFallsRedux · 01/11/2021 17:48

if it's Joe Biden's g-g-grandfather that is Irish that still means his ancestry is only 1/32 Irish

All eight of President Biden's great-great-grandparents on his mother's side were born in Ireland. Two great-grandparents on Biden's father's side were born in Ireland. Not sure what the math is on that, but I'm pretty sure it's more than 1/32. But even more to the point, the Irish identity was especially strong in his mother's family, the Finnegans, and he was heavily influenced by that.

justmaybenot · 01/11/2021 17:47

*'American' is a political nationality, it is not an ethnicity.

For some people that's fine, for others who feel close to their ancestral ethnic heritage, they want to acknowledge that.

We are all American, but we are not all the same. The lived experiences of a Mexican-American, an Irish-American and a Japanese-American are really quite different in many ways. Why should we erase that? It's part of who we are.

If you don't get it that's fine, but don't tell us we're all wrong or dumb. We're just different.*

Exactly. The only 'wrong' and 'dumb' people are those who laugh at other peoples' culture - and as the convention for so many people in the USA is to hyphenate their identity, that is a part of American culture. Just because it isn't the same as the UK doesn't mean it's wrong, just different. The intolerance on here, and sense of entitlement to pronounce on the norms of other cultures is unreal!

Margerine78 · 01/11/2021 17:30

I've had a few close American friends over the years and they seem as a culture to be more centred on themselves as the individual, so they tend to have an interest in anything that makes them different, if that makes sense. Same with therapy, everyone seems to be in therapy to know themselves better, whereas the majority of Brits might go if we have trauma.

Also, I wonder if it's a lack of history (in comparisons to ours) so they have more of a focus on the more recent generations?

SenecaFallsRedux · 01/11/2021 17:23

It's not 'acknowledging your family history,' it's 'picking and choosing one element of your family history you don't really understand.'

So what? And who is to say that the chosen element is not understood? My many times great-grandfather left an island in the Hebrides to sail to North Carolina. I have his surname, which is still very much associated with that part of Scotland. Yes, I happily have picked and chosen this element to claim. So what?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/11/2021 17:23

But as other posters have pointed out, when we Americans say "I'm Scottish" or "I'm Italian", it's shorthand for Scottish-American or Italian-American. We certainly understand that we are not citizens of a country in Europe when we say that. Also I think it's cultural insensitivity for people outside the US to make fun of this when it is an important part of American culture and identity to know, acknowledge, and even to honor, their family history.

And it's certainly not cultural appropriation as some have suggested; it's a different cultural expression. We are all hyphenated or double barreled Americans.

I know it's fiction, but the episodes of The Sopranos when they are in Italy are hilarious - the Americans think the Italian food is crap and the Italians think the Americans are rude and obnoxious

OhWhyNot · 01/11/2021 17:20

Interestingly I know a number of people who have immigrated to the statutes and now citizens and consider themselves Americans

onceandneveragain · 01/11/2021 17:10

@logsonlogsoff

Almost ALL Americans were immigrants original and it’s a huge part of their identity. Many still are. DW for example has one set of immigrant grandparents on one side and immigrants great gps on the other - so her family really haven’t been American that long. I bet if pretty much everyone in England was from immigrant Roots in the last couple hundred years you’d be much more interested.
But most people in England/Wales etc do have other roots to the same degree that Americans do. E.g. if it's Joe Biden's g-g-grandfather that is Irish that still means his ancestry is only 1/32 Irish! How can that be enough to identify himself as Irish? Why does that one great great grandfather take precedence over all his other non-Irish ancestors? It's not 'acknowledging your family history,' it's 'picking and choosing one element of your family history you don't really understand.'

I am Welsh, my parents are Welsh, as were my grandparents, so I consider myself to be Welsh. But if I looked back any further my great, and great-great grandparents were English, Scottish, Welsh, French, and German, but I don't go round saying I'm German because a great grandmother was born there in the 1850s!

dreamingbohemian · 01/11/2021 17:10

@BigFatLiar

I guess for many it's not enough to be American. Most who claim to be xxxx-American have little idea of what xxxx is actually like these days.
'American' is a political nationality, it is not an ethnicity.

For some people that's fine, for others who feel close to their ancestral ethnic heritage, they want to acknowledge that.

We are all American, but we are not all the same. The lived experiences of a Mexican-American, an Irish-American and a Japanese-American are really quite different in many ways. Why should we erase that? It's part of who we are.

If you don't get it that's fine, but don't tell us we're all wrong or dumb. We're just different.

phoenixrosehere · 01/11/2021 17:01

But as other posters have pointed out, when we Americans say "I'm Scottish" or "I'm Italian", it's shorthand for Scottish-American or Italian-American. We certainly understand that we are not citizens of a country in Europe when we say that. Also I think it's cultural insensitivity for people outside the US to make fun of this when it is an important part of American culture and identity to know, acknowledge, and even to honor, their family history.

This. The history of the U.S, is vastly different from that of the U.K. and the U.S is a very young country compared to those in the U.K and Europe. If it wasn’t for them and their explorers that stepped foot on North America, on top of the mass immigrations from some of those countries, the culture wouldn’t be what it is It’s two sides reading the same sentence and coming away with something different and wanting to be right.

BigFatLiar · 01/11/2021 16:55

I guess for many it's not enough to be American. Most who claim to be xxxx-American have little idea of what xxxx is actually like these days.

znaika · 01/11/2021 16:49

My hypothesis is that it's different as modern Irish are wealthy and comfortable for the most part. Laughing at challenges antecedents faced and attributing stereotypes as to how they overcame those challenges might be fine if you're sufficiently removed from it all. If the home country still experiences poverty it's not so amusing.

znaika · 01/11/2021 16:40

I have never been deleted btw. I asked mn to delete all my posts following a massive data breach and they did.

SenecaFallsRedux · 01/11/2021 16:38

@secretllama

I'm Scottish and whenever I've been in America we always get Americans telling us they're Scottish. I feel bad because they aren't doing any harm and genuinley think that scottish people take this seriously but I aways want to tell them that it's a bit of a joke amongst us.

Also find it annoying when Americans refer to themselves as Italian. Not Italian-American... just Italian. When they've clearly never been and neither have their parents. I suppose it's just identity/tribalism as other posters have mentioned.

But as other posters have pointed out, when we Americans say "I'm Scottish" or "I'm Italian", it's shorthand for Scottish-American or Italian-American. We certainly understand that we are not citizens of a country in Europe when we say that. Also I think it's cultural insensitivity for people outside the US to make fun of this when it is an important part of American culture and identity to know, acknowledge, and even to honor, their family history.

And it's certainly not cultural appropriation as some have suggested; it's a different cultural expression. We are all hyphenated or double barreled Americans.

znaika · 01/11/2021 16:36

Read the op again. Its about different cultures that Americans claim as their heritage even though the link to the homeland maybe only 1 ancestor out of 16 or 32. I hate it when Americans do it about my culture as it normally involves lots of offensive stereotypes. I am entitled to my voice.

JaneJeffer · 01/11/2021 16:32

@znaika

It doesn't matter. I have said as have others that this can be an offensive appropriation. It is as I see it as it happens to my culture. This is not anti- American. It's actually Americans being offensive to my culture.
This thread is about Irish Americans so I fail to see how it affects you in any way. You have come on here with the sole purpose of agitation.
znaika · 01/11/2021 16:27

@MarshaBradyo

Is it poor ickle-bickle syndrome?

What do you mean?

I don’t think it’s different. I’ve seen so much negativity re U.K. it’s picked up a lot in last year.

Marsha is correct. It's noticeable.
znaika · 01/11/2021 16:25

It doesn't matter. I have said as have others that this can be an offensive appropriation. It is as I see it as it happens to my culture. This is not anti- American. It's actually Americans being offensive to my culture.