Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
Eealoty · 01/11/2021 19:40

@Mingmoo

This thread is honestly making me feel unwell, as someone who has been living in the UK for almost twenty years. There is no respect for Irish people or Irish history here, and if you have an Irish background almost certainly you were brought up to forget about that and hide it rather than celebrating it. Maybe it's worth thinking about why that was rather than sneering at people who do celebrate their culture and history and roots.

I always find it interesting that people in Britain focus on Noraid and the IRA bombing campaigns in England when they think about the Troubles. I grew up in the Republic of Ireland and the news headlines every morning on the car radio on my way to school were full of deaths that happened fifty or sixty miles away: civilians shot by British soldiers at checkpoints, or loyalist paramilitaries killing taxi drivers who were overwhelmingly from Catholic background, or rioting, or IRA punishment shootings and beatings, or IRA massacres of innocent Protestants for no reason other than their religion or their job as a prison officer or a police officer. The 'mainland' bombing campaign was a tiny, tiny part of the Northern Ireland troubles. It says so much that you all focus on that when you think about Irish Americans.

I couldn't agree more, it is an awful thread. Seeps of everything people with dual/multi heritages (who haven't internalised the xenophobia that is) have to deal with every day in the UK. This kind of irritation that someone could have they own meaning and pride towards a nationality, a culture that they feel within them, in some way. What exactly is the problem with that....? Hmm
PurBal · 01/11/2021 19:33

I had an American friend like this who would constantly tell me he was from India. I was like “dude, you were born in the US, your parents were born in Malaysia, how many generations do you have to go back to be from India?” Bizarre.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2021 19:31

I see your point. I think being “Italian British” (which obviously no one says but ykwim) does mean something to me.

My family does some things noticeably differently to most British - food being a big one.

Mollymoostoo · 01/11/2021 19:26

The difference is that the Irish American is several generations removed and is trying to capitalise on the struggles os the immigrant communities. African Americans are still struggling not just because of their ancestry but because they still personally feel the struggle.

My in laws are Irish, came to UK 50 years ago and sound fresh off the boat. I am mixed race, African and English but look Spanish. Noone asks my husband about his family but everyone asks me where I am from. People always see colour.
On a side note that horrible fake Irish accent some Americans use is gross, especially when they have never even been to Ireland on holiday.

Mochudubh · 01/11/2021 19:22

I used to work in a fairly posh hotel in the heart of Rob Roy Country. We once had an American couple stay and the man's name was something like Charles Rob Roy MacGregor and there had been a Rob Roy in his family for oatcake generations. He proudly told me he was descended from THE Rob Roy. I tried to look impressed while thinking "You, me and half the county, mate".

He followed up by asking me "What kind of steer is that in the field over there". He'd never seen a Heilan' Coo before!

KentdonMum · 01/11/2021 19:21

I found it fascinating, years ago when I went to the states that some US colleagues seemed intent to pin down what ‘generation’ something I was. I’m actually compete mix of heritage and I had never given this kind of analysis a second thought.

Tigger1895 · 01/11/2021 19:20

@millenialblush

I agree. I have spent a lot of time in the USA and I always found it a bit cringe how much they play on being 'Irish'. Irish pubs everywhere, the obsession with St Patrick's day, dying the river green in Chicago. Yet ask them to point it out on a map and they'd be stuck...
Even more cringeworthy is the fact they call it patty’s day
Abhannmor · 01/11/2021 19:20

A lot of lazy stereotypes of Irish Americans here. I was on an Irish language course in Donegal 2 years ago. The teacher on the most advanced class was from the USA. One of the other teachers was from Canada. Naturally you will meet others more distantly connected. From my experience in England it is ppl with Irish mothers or grandmothers who have stronger links. Women are the bearers of culture.

eggandonion · 01/11/2021 19:19

In Ireland we have the double whammy of a Trump owned golf resort just down the road from the village Mike Pences family came from.

justmaybenot · 01/11/2021 19:19

@Carpedimum

I lived in the States for a while, I was surprised by the St Patrick’s Day celebrations, decorations, marching, events, food etc. but shocked by the anti-English sentiment that also went with some of it, lots of sectarian rhetoric and fundraising for the IRA. The worst thing about that was the total ignorance of the issues, not a single person had any actual understanding of the history of Ireland, utterly dismaying.
When was that? I lived in the USA and experienced St Patrick's Day in a number of cities and never once heard of money being raised for the IRA.
Margerine78 · 01/11/2021 19:17

Reading the posts here from Irish folk and understanding why it bugs you, I had the thought that its a little like cultural appropriation (for those Americans who do it but yet have never been to Ireland or lived through some of the horrors some Irish people have had to - in my lifetime but prior also).

I always found it annoying (as a Brit) but I can see now how its actually really offensive too.

Mochudubh · 01/11/2021 19:09

@Tulipomania

To be fair to Trump (much as I loathe the man), his Mother was from Lewis so he is genuinely half Scots and has been to Scotland many, many times.

znaika · 01/11/2021 19:04

But the carrying the nationali
ty of the surname happens in other countries without the offensive side order of patronising and stereotypes.. Many russian emigres in France who proudly carry the names of their forebears, many in the UK who i have bonded with. What they never did was pretend to be something they're not.

Coffeetree · 01/11/2021 19:02

Yes, @Carpedimum, I saw that in the Irish- American community in the US, especially in the 70s and 80s. From people who'd never been to Ireland. Dismaying is the right word.

Carpedimum · 01/11/2021 18:55

I lived in the States for a while, I was surprised by the St Patrick’s Day celebrations, decorations, marching, events, food etc. but shocked by the anti-English sentiment that also went with some of it, lots of sectarian rhetoric and fundraising for the IRA. The worst thing about that was the total ignorance of the issues, not a single person had any actual understanding of the history of Ireland, utterly dismaying.

JassyRadlett · 01/11/2021 18:50

But their perceptions are of themselves are based on harmful stereotypes rather than anything meaningful or real.

I don’t think you get to decide what’s meaningful or real for other people and their heritage, though I think it is totally fair for them to be challenged on harmful stereotypes associated with current people in those countries. I don’t think the two are as totally inextricable as you do. Yes, there will be a subset who identify as X heritage who buy into and peddle the harmful modern stereotypes.

So when they say I got this tattoo od a knife because im Russian or I dress really slutty because im a russian. This harms Russians. They can walk away from it and assume the straight forward "American" nationality whereas we can't. We condemned to be the killer or Natasha. I think it's quite hard to understand if you haven't been Russian in the US how fucking awful the negative stereotypes are and how relentless the prejudice is. Seeing Americans coopt this for laughs or street cred isnt very funny

No, I don’t doubt that, and I’m not questioning your experience. That’s awful and it should absolutely be challenged. That’s what I meant when I talked about what they say about modern people in their country of heritage absolutely being open to challenge and condemnation.

I am however saying that’s in quite a different category for me than identifying as being of that heritage and making inauthentic versions of the cuisine or wanting to learn more about their heritage and history. The one is certainly a (nasty) subset of the wider group, and as other PPs have pointed out is also tied to wider stereotypes and intolerances. But I don’t think the wider group should be excoriated or condemned because of a shitty subset whose behaviour should definitely be called out.

znaika · 01/11/2021 18:49

I just think that the practise of referring to yourself as being from a country you have never visited and only have a hackneyed or stereotyped view of is harmful sometimes.
As a real EEuropean I can say the prejudice I experienced in the US was relentlessly horrendous I have had nothing like it in the UK
I have been spat at in 3 countries-Poland (possibly expected) Ireland (shocking) and USA (too many times to count).

dreamingbohemian · 01/11/2021 18:45

Anyone who says 'I dress slutty because I'm Russian' isn't saying that because they're Russian-American, they're saying it because they're stupid.

You could erase all the Russian-Americans, there would still be loads of negative stereotypes about Russia and prejudiced people, from people all over the world.

You can't judge a whole community because a few people are stupid, just like you can't judge all Russians because some of them are xenophobic themselves.

JassyRadlett · 01/11/2021 18:42

I’m always a little surprised by European people who don’t recognise that they share their history and heritage with people who live elsewhere, but whose ancestors emigrated from that country, and that immigration and heritage shaped communities and the way those countries developed.

So the Great Famine is just as much a part of the heritage and history of an American with significant Irish ancestry from the nineteenth and twentieth century immigration waves as someone living in modern Ireland but with, say, one non-Irish grandparent.

Just as the Clearances are a large part of my family’s history, as they are for many modern Scottish people, and played a particularly significant role in how my region developed, in local religion and schools that exist to this day, in the economy, and much else.

It’s a shared history. It’s theirs, just as much as it is yours. I find it personally weird that people can’t get their heads around it, but I d come from a place where those different histories are part of our shared story, and we understand that our history prior to our ancestors’ emigration wasn’t magically erased when they stepped on a ship.

phoenixrosehere · 01/11/2021 18:40

I care about my culture and my people who do not have the privileges of Americans who are harmed by Americans bandying around stereotypes about the old country
Clearly it can be harmless for Irish. But it's not harmless for my people. I think irs absolutely indicative of how acceptable it is to be anti E European in Ireland and US that when an E European comes and says that this can be quite offensive that their concerns are just dismissed and belittled. Extremely telling

Yet, you’re ignoring the mass amounts of anti-EE in England too. It’s not just Ireland and the States. I’ve heard some pretty offensive things about Eastern Europeans living in England yet never heard that growing up in the States. I had friends who had close family still living there and worked for a couple for two years and never heard of any stereotypes of them (not saying that some don’t exist, just my experience) compared to what I’ve heard in England.

Others are just explaining why SOME Americans hyphen, adding their ancestry on. It’s not on ALL Americans because some of those that have some type of ties to your country think a certain way. Why not put that on their family and not all Americans?

znaika · 01/11/2021 18:39

Also I am a Russian in the UK from the 90s actually when there weren't many of us. I know exactly what a immigrant community looks like

znaika · 01/11/2021 18:35

But their perceptions are of themselves are based on harmful stereotypes rather than anything meaningful or real. So when they say I got this tattoo od a knife because im Russian or I dress really slutty because im a russian. This harms Russians. They can walk away from it and assume the straight forward "American" nationality whereas we can't. We condemned to be the killer or Natasha. I think it's quite hard to understand if you haven't been Russian in the US how fucking awful the negative stereotypes are and how relentless the prejudice is. Seeing Americans coopt this for laughs or street cred isnt very funny

JassyRadlett · 01/11/2021 18:28

But @znaika I think you are conflating two different things here. One is about spreading inaccurate stereotypes of what modern Russians (or current day people in any of the countries we are discussing) are like which can be hurtful and harmful.

The other is people feeling a sense of affinity with their heritage and the community that has grown up around that heritage in their own country, whether they spell the food names correctly and use authentic ingredients or not. (And holy god trying to get hold of authentic Austrian ingredients in 70s and 80s regional Australia… well, there’s a reason my cousin set up his own deli and import business.)

That’s about Americans, or Canadians or Australians or New Zealanders or whomever having a sense of local community and affinity with their ancestry, which as I’ve said can be quite hard for people who haven’t come from these kinds of countries to understand why it matters to a lot of people.m

It’s probably a Venn diagram where some people are in both groups, but membership of one does not automatically lead to the other.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 01/11/2021 18:19

@Howshouldibehave - It means that those who have cherry picked ‘being Irish’, will probably be very upset when their children go to Irish universities and aren’t welcomed with open arms into the Irish community as ‘being Irish’ as mentioned upthread. That sort of thing.

I teach in an Irish University. We have lots of Irish Americans here. I don't think I've ever come across one who expects to be treated as if they were Irish. Yes, they are proud of their roots, yes they like to have those roots acknowledged but they pretty much all know they are not actually Irish.

Sometimes Ireland is very different to what they expected but they get over that very quickly.

znaika · 01/11/2021 18:17

I don't care about Americans saying they are American. I care about my culture and my people who do not have the privileges of Americans who are harmed by Americans bandying around stereotypes about the old country
Clearly it can be harmless for Irish. But it's not harmless for my people. I think irs absolutely indicative of how acceptable it is to be anti E European in Ireland and US that when an E European comes and says that this can be quite offensive that their concerns are just dismissed and belittled. Extremely telling