Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
justmaybenot · 02/11/2021 08:32

@RavingAnnie

I've always thought it strange that people adopt their distant roots as their identity, having not been brought up in a country or often ever been there, and neither have their parents or grandparents.

I am British but have recently found out that I am 20% Jewish. I do my family tree as a hobby and am interested in understanding where my Jewish dna comes from and about who my ancestors were and their story, but I'm not suddenly gong to bowl about saying I'm Jewish like it's part of my identity because it isn't (even though it's part of my dna), I was born and raised in England to a non-Jewish parent.

I also have some Scottish ancestry but again not going to start saying I am Scottish either.

I just don't understand people who do that. Very odd behaviour.

It's only 'odd' because it's different from you. Why can't you respect other people and cultures approach their ancestry differently than you do?
JassyRadlett · 02/11/2021 08:07

@RavingAnnie because pride in one’s heritage in countries like the US, Australia, Canada or other countries with populations where the overwhelming majority are the result of immigration in the last few centuries is very closely tied to pride in their communities and their countries.

Being part of the Italian or Greek or Maltese community in different parts of Australia, for example, confers a strong sense of belonging and pride for a lot of people.

There is an odd refusal on this thread to recognise that there is a sense of community and identity resulting from immigrant heritage in these countries that just doesn’t exist in, say, the UK or other countries whose history isn’t so hugely tied up with immigration, where not just one of your great-grandparents came from somewhere else but all of them did.

It also ignores, in a really tin-eared and ignorant way, the impact that immigrant communities had on the development of those countries. Some English people seem to think that immigration in those countries was about people arriving and then assimilating - completely ignoring how those immigrant communities shaped the development of their towns, cities, regions and even their country, which also confers a sense of pride in what their ancestors achieved (as well as pride in those people for what they did and overcame.)

NotAnotherPylon · 02/11/2021 07:31

@RavingAnnie you did some delving into your ancestry and made a few interesting discoveries. That's vastly different from a person who has grown up with a sense of identity which has been handed down for generations. People generally don't declare themselves Irish American after a quick internet search. Also, it's not everything about who they are, but rather a part, albeit an important part. I think your comments are rather dismissive and it's a shame you 'just don't understand people who do that'. Maybe read the thread and discover that your position is not the default.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 02/11/2021 06:52

Celebrating diversity is all a cunning convenient plot by government in my opinion. Remember the saying "divide and conquer"

Imagine if every person in America declared themselves American first and that comes before anything else. You would have a United population. A very dangerous situation for any ruling party.

Same with the constant push in the uk to support every preference as being diverse. It's divide and conquer again. Put the commoners against each other and they are too busy fighting each other over which pro noun to use to notice the governments doing what they want without any protest.

I'm apparently of Irish decent too. Relatives made the trip from Dublin to the fens in the 1850s during a potato famine. I guess with thousands of others too. I was excited about it for about 10 seconds but I'd never consider to tell anyone I have Irish ancestry. If I could go back tens of thousands of years I'd probably find I have African ancestry.

BritinDelco · 02/11/2021 01:49

Half English half Welsh Brit married to an Irish/Italian American here. I'm apparently known as a WASP - White Anglo-Saxon Protestant
My FIL (Irish American) did tell me to be wary of the Italian temperament, referring to both DH and MIL. I think it's less national identity than personality traits

RavingAnnie · 02/11/2021 01:45

@iamtheoneandonlyyy

I think pride in heritage is lovely
Why?
RavingAnnie · 02/11/2021 01:44

I've always thought it strange that people adopt their distant roots as their identity, having not been brought up in a country or often ever been there, and neither have their parents or grandparents.

I am British but have recently found out that I am 20% Jewish. I do my family tree as a hobby and am interested in understanding where my Jewish dna comes from and about who my ancestors were and their story, but I'm not suddenly gong to bowl about saying I'm Jewish like it's part of my identity because it isn't (even though it's part of my dna), I was born and raised in England to a non-Jewish parent.

I also have some Scottish ancestry but again not going to start saying I am Scottish either.

I just don't understand people who do that. Very odd behaviour.

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2021 01:41

My biggest surprise is the obsession that the USA has with the UK royal family.

Obsession? My guess is that the vast majority of Americans have very little interest in the British RF. I have a strong interest, based on my interest in British history, and quite a bit of knowledge, but I am far from obsessed.

verymiddleaged · 02/11/2021 01:01

My biggest surprise is the obsession that the USA has with the UK royal family.
I could understand if I was living in Oz or Canada.
But the US actually fought a war to remove the royals so why does my mainstream news channel have a blinking Diana series currently.
Why do I have to know everything about the queen's health? Royal kids going to school etc, etc?

Weonlyhavealoanofit · 02/11/2021 00:40

I think a few themes are being cross referenced here re ‘identity’. Australia and Canada are full of people who identity as Monarchists, and want their head of state to be a British monarch. I find that mindset far harder to comprehend than someone living in the USA, who knows that in 1850 the great grandparents left Italy, Ireland, Russia etc and sought a new life in America. Most humans want to know ‘who am I?’ which is another way of saying ‘this is where my people are from’. Why shouldn’t the great grandchildren or grandchildren of immigrants take great pride in their heritage. After all, almost every other popular telly programme is about people desperate to better understand their own family history or some OTT biography of the Royal Family focusing upon their slavish devotion to Queen Victoria’s contrariness circa 1820-1901…. Claiming Irish heritage seems to get under the skin of some people. We have a RF who have for over a century adopted a completely contrived Sir Walter Scott fantasy, without the slightest bit of irony. Their ancestors destroyed the Gaelic speaking peoples living in the Highlands. Often the people who express annoyance at Irish Americans discussing Irish affairs (they should keep their noses out) are themselves woefully and deliberately ignorant about Irish history. Didn't Dominic Raab have to be reminded that the UKs closest land border with the EU was ….er The Republic of Ireland…and who can forget that the Secretary of State for NI, Karen Brady didn’t know the voting patters of the unionist or nationalist population! It came as an awful surprise to know that the 12th July is rather different to St Patrick’s Day.
23 Presidents of the USA have Irish heritage. Many American institutions claim Irish connections from ‘The Fighting 69th’, Notre Dame College and the Democratic Party. Being Irish in America (save for the old WASP bigotry) is not the handicap that is it in British society. And frankly when seeking an Irish or Italian or German passport to offset the worst effects of Brexit, shouldn’t it be incumbent upon the applicant to acquaint themselves with their background and heritage? I don’t find it strange that people called Murphy or Kelly living in Pittsburg or St Louis, have a fondness for Ireland, and feel a kinship for the country. I do find it odd that people called Kelly living in say Yorkshire and applying for an Irish passport via the parent/grandparent rule in 2021, have zero interest in their heritage.

NalPolishRemover · 02/11/2021 00:27

Oh @bathtoy that's incredibly sad about your uncle. I'm sorry to read that.

I was also thinking of John McGahern That They May Face The Rising Sun too. An immensely moving book & he is such a wonderful writer. I met him once.

Dancing at Lughnasa also touched on it when Rose & the other sister went to London & were never heard from again

My friend saw an old man thumbing a life outside Limerick one late after noon a few years back & something compelled him to stop. Turns out the man had spent his life working as a labourer in America & had left Enistymon when he was in his v early 20s & had never made it back till then. Some charity bought him a ticket but he was trying to find his way home. My friend gave him a lift right to the village & they chatted all the way. He was concerned for him as he was old & not certain of his own memories. They found his old family home which was now a shop & he stood on the street & wept in sadness. He had no where to go & no one left who knew him & he'd no plan. My friend brought him to the church & they found the priest who then took over & said he'd help him connect with some elderly townspeople who may have known his family.

I often wonder what ever happened to him Sad And so many more like him.

Bathtoy · 02/11/2021 00:13

John McGahern has often written about the same group of men, and Edna O’Brien has a good story about them, ‘Shovel Kings.’ And the Christmas dinner scene in Colm Toibin’s Brooklyn was populated by their New York equivalents (cheered up slightly in the film version by one of them being played by Iarla ‘Voice of God’ O’Lionáird. Grin)

My own uncle went to Manchester in the 50s as a popular, sporty youth who’d served his time as a carpenter but couldn’t get work at home, gradually stopped writing and coming home in the summer and couldn’t be found at any address he’d given when his brother went looking for him. When he was ‘found’ decades later, by a priest who tried to repatriate people with any living family, he was a wreck of a man, prematurely aged, with serious MH issues. He was never able to talk about what had happened to him, but we think he may have been enslaved, and then discarded when he could no longer work — we don’t know. His life was incredibly sad.

NalPolishRemover · 01/11/2021 23:38

The book is actually by Timothy O'Grady

NalPolishRemover · 01/11/2021 23:35

This thread makes very uncomfortable reading.

It wasn't just families in the West of Ireland who received money from America being sent home, it was all over I'd say.

The lost Irish in England is another incredibly sad group of mainly older men who left Ireland due to huge economic hardship & worked as manual labourers on building sites, railways, roads & in fields till their bodies gave up. They sent money back to Ireland but rarely returned themselves. So many of them ended up alone & destitute. I saw a documetary about it some years ago & it has stuck in my heart ever since. Sad, broken hearted lonely broken old men dying alone. There was a charity that brought them home to Ireland to visit but in most cases all their family had long since died & homesteads & towns were unrecognizable.

I then read an incredible book - I could read the sky by Dermot Bulger based on these old men. I cried my way through it & even now just thinking about it can bring a lump to my throat.

eggandonion · 01/11/2021 22:00

I sometimes look at the houses in the West of Ireland and wonder how many families living in them received 'money from America' which emigrants sent home. And it is sad how many emigrated to England in the fifties and had very tough lives.
I think in Ireland the 'Yanks' who come here with 'big talk' are met with a sort of kindly amusement.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 01/11/2021 21:45

@jewel1968

It's worth remembering too the impact Irish Americans had on the Good Friday Agreement. Project Children was set up by a retired NYPD Irish American and was designed to give Catholic and Protestant children some respite from the bombing. The children stayed with Irish American families.

It has been suggested that some of those families were prominent political families that saw up close the situation in Ireland. They put pressure on Clinton to get involved. His involvement is thought to have been important. So, perhaps that connection with the ancestral homeland benefited people in the long run.

Well said. The Irish American influence on the GFA was huge.

The Irish American influence also has a big impact on the access Ireland has to the US political ear generally.

EmeraldShamrock · 01/11/2021 21:45

Reading the posts here from Irish folk and understanding why it bugs you, I had the thought that its a little like cultural appropriation (for those Americans who do it but yet have never been to Ireland or lived through some of the horrors some Irish people have had to
No it's not.
I don't think I've noticed posts Irish pp's writing it bugs them.
It makes me proud our little country and cultures are well thought of in other countries.

jewel1968 · 01/11/2021 21:40

It's worth remembering too the impact Irish Americans had on the Good Friday Agreement. Project Children was set up by a retired NYPD Irish American and was designed to give Catholic and Protestant children some respite from the bombing. The children stayed with Irish American families.

It has been suggested that some of those families were prominent political families that saw up close the situation in Ireland. They put pressure on Clinton to get involved. His involvement is thought to have been important. So, perhaps that connection with the ancestral homeland benefited people in the long run.

TeaAndBiscuitsAndWine · 01/11/2021 21:34

@ClaireFraser2018

IsleofRum:

`Or "African American".

The term 'African American' acknowledges the cultural heritage and slave trade. Jesse L Jackson, the civil rights leader, has popularised this term.

Exactly. The reason so many people use ‘African American’ rather than, say, ‘Nigerian American’ is because their ancestors were enslaved, and had their children forcibly removed and sold, meaning that their cultural heritage and knowledge of where their family originally came from was lost. Including ‘African’ in their identity is a way of acknowledging this.
dreamingbohemian · 01/11/2021 21:28

@Margerine78

Reading the posts here from Irish folk and understanding why it bugs you, I had the thought that its a little like cultural appropriation (for those Americans who do it but yet have never been to Ireland or lived through some of the horrors some Irish people have had to - in my lifetime but prior also).

I always found it annoying (as a Brit) but I can see now how its actually really offensive too.

Almost all the Irish people who have posted here have said it does not particularly bother them
SenecaFallsRedux · 01/11/2021 21:10

@Harmonypuss

I'm 25% Finnish, 75% English, should I be saying that I'm Finnish-English/British when filling in my nationality on forms etc or just carry on saying I'm English/British as I have my whole life?
I'm not exactly sure what you are saying here, but Americans distinguish between nationality (American) and ethnicity (Irish American, etc.). For ethnicity, sometimes the term "national origin" is used.
Bllueblazerblack · 01/11/2021 21:07

One thing that I find particularly amusing is how many Americans claim to be direct descendants of Robert the Bruce or Mary Queen of Scots. I'm on a few Scottish Gaelic Facebook groups (because I've been learning Scots Gaelic) and there are so many on there. It's particularly funny because they're so anti-immigrant apart from when they're talking about themselves.
My biological father was from Scotland yet I'd never claim to be Scottish because I don't have that connection. It's just embarrassing when Yanks do it.

Harmonypuss · 01/11/2021 20:28

I'm 25% Finnish, 75% English, should I be saying that I'm Finnish-English/British when filling in my nationality on forms etc or just carry on saying I'm English/British as I have my whole life?

ClaireFraser2018 · 01/11/2021 20:17

IsleofRum:

`Or "African American".

The term 'African American' acknowledges the cultural heritage and slave trade. Jesse L Jackson, the civil rights leader, has popularised this term.

MissConductUS · 01/11/2021 19:42

@IsleofRum

Why don't we admit that anti American xenophobia or racism is a sport in the UK that is never tackled by moderators or the media.
Well said.