Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
SW1amp · 31/10/2021 09:03

DH is Irish, born and grew up there, and has had virtual strangers in NY bars try to out-Irish him to prove their credentials as an Irish-American

Most of them are more fervent about their Irish roots than all the Irish people we know

KingsleyShacklebolt · 31/10/2021 09:03

I can’t help but think these companies doing the dna tests are just onto a money spinner!

This is actually something I know quite a bit about.

DNA kits from companies like Ancestry are quite expensive - around £80. Lots of people do them to find out their ethnic make-up.

But that doesn't make them a con. It's entirely possible that someone who has American parents and and even American grandparents or great grandparents has a high percentage of Scottish DNA if people further back were from Scotland (or northern England, northern Ireland, there's an overlap) and then those immigrants in the late 19th century married people from within their own community.

Ancestral tourism and finding your roots is a HUGE industry in the US and there are lots of us who make a living or a sideline helping Americans look for ancestors in the UK. 24% of American visitors to Scotland feel they have an ancestral link to our country, which is great for our economy.

It is a bit weird though that Biden positions himself as "Irish" when his link was several generations back. Trump never branded himself as Scottish, even though his mother was born and grew up here. Obama didn't say he was Kenyan-American.

Anyway. It's all fairly harmless, if Americans want to come to Scotland or Ireland, spend their money, buy lots of tartan, pay people to guide them round places where their ancestors came from and spend their $$$ that's fine by me.

KittenKong · 31/10/2021 09:02

@Lottapianos

'Americans visiting Skibbereen to research their family connections are always given the warmest of welcomes.'

Oh sure, but are they accepted as truly 'Irish' or just indulged for the sake of politeness?

A colleague told me that when they were students and the Americans would come over ‘looking for roots’ they would make up the most outrageous nonsense (and get free drinks all night). The Americans would go home with tales of daring dos by their ‘ancestors’ and ‘first hand eyewitness accounts’ of leprechauns.
Naunet · 31/10/2021 09:01

@BurnedToast

Do they ever say I'm "American-English'? I've never heard that, but presumably alot of them will have English heritage?
Yeah, I’ve heard it loads, along with many other European countries (especially France, Italy and Spain).
Twentypast · 31/10/2021 09:01

I have a friend in Boston who has one set of Irish and one set of Italian great grandparents. She makes a huge deal that she's Irish/italian American. My grandparents were Russian but I consider myself 100% British. I find it very weird.

RandomLondoner · 31/10/2021 09:01

Do they ever say I'm "American-English'? I've never heard that, but presumably alot of them will have English heritage?

I read somewhere that there are actually more Americans with German heritage than British heritage. If you classify surnames by likely country of origin, more are German than British.

Santastuckincustoms · 31/10/2021 09:01

I say let them have it, it's sad when they talk about their history, like their 'old' buildings. If it makes them feel bette then let them craic on.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 31/10/2021 09:00

@SunShinesBrightly @Leavisite - one of the reasons people of Irish descent living in the UK don’t often flag themselves as ‘Irish’ the way Americans of Irish descent do is that there remains significant levels of anti-Irish prejudice towards Irish people.

My Grandparents and my friend’s parents remember very clearly ‘No dog, no children, no ‘blacks’, no Irish’ posters in shops and pubs.

100% agree with this. My parents endured the "no blacks, no dogs, no Irish' signs and the anti-Irish discrimination in the 60's.

I lived in England for a while in the 80's and there were many times I was afraid to open my mouth in case people heard my accent. That said, most people were fine. It was just a subset of anti-Irish bigots, although there was also a larger number who engaged in casual xenophobia under the guise of "sagging".

KittenKong · 31/10/2021 09:00

@Lonelymum21

I do laugh at Joe Biden when he manages to shoe horn "I'm Irish" into almost every public introduction.
Yes I heard him telling the pope. How far back/ what % of his ancestors are Irish I don’t know.
IcedPurple · 31/10/2021 08:59

It's just a different culture, that's all. Being Irish American is different than being Italian American for many people. It will affect their family, their traditions and their culture.

Will it though?

Very few Americans these days are 'pure' Italian or Irish or whatever. Mostly their ancestors will have emigrated to America in the 19th century or the early years of the last century. By now, they'll usually be mixed in with other ethnicities. Somebody like Joe Biden, for example, also has French and English ancestry, but chooses to identify as 'Irish', probably for personal and political reasons.

WeAreTheHeroes · 31/10/2021 08:58

Did anyone see the Jeremy Irons episode of Who Do You Think You Are? He was desperate to be Irish and convinced that was his background. Turned out he wasn't at all. I'm from the NW. So many people have Irish connections, but don't call themselves Irish.

Lottapianos · 31/10/2021 08:56

'Americans visiting Skibbereen to research their family connections are always given the warmest of welcomes.'

Oh sure, but are they accepted as truly 'Irish' or just indulged for the sake of politeness?

Naunet · 31/10/2021 08:56

@MacMahon

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

It’s just an American thing, they all seem to do it. They’re all French or English or Italian or Irish etc, it’s so strange when they’re such a patriotic country, but maybe it comes from having less history?
HTH1 · 31/10/2021 08:55

I agree but Americans identifying as Irish etc do no harm to the actual Irish so it’s probably more of a compliment/fun if celebrating St Patrick’s Day etc.

lnsufficientFuns · 31/10/2021 08:54

So many millions of Irish left Ireland in the potato famine that there was then a huge Irish influx in America in the 1840-50s.

We forget about the scale of it now. But the population decreased from 8-6milliom over just a few years - mainly the potato famine boy also a cholera outbreak which followed.

Many Irish refugees agitated for independence for Ireland for decades after they arrived and there was a whole political movement for that.

This led to fundraiser events which prob led, in turn, to the leprechaunisation of the whole country because being Irish in America is big business

Re the other point about patriotism- America is a “melting pot” of nationalities and you need to have some social forms of bonding hence the pledge, adherence to constitution and promotion of all things American.

America = the home of marketing

thelegohooverer · 31/10/2021 08:53

I’ve noticed that among my many friends and acquaintances who emigrated the only ones who seem ashamed of their accents, and scathing of Ireland are the ones who emigrated to the UK.

I suspect OP that the reason your ancestry plays no part in your identity is probably in large part to the discrimination your great grandparents faced and the need to integrate in order to survive.

SunShinesBrightly · 31/10/2021 08:53

Different generations I must add.
Agree prejudice still exists.

Cofifeefee · 31/10/2021 08:52

It doesn't bother me if people want to identify as Irish even if their ancestor left Ireland in the 19th century. Irish-Americans contribute hugely to the Irish tourism industry.

FatBettyintheCoop · 31/10/2021 08:52

@Lottapianos

'I do laugh at Joe Biden when he manages to shoe horn "I'm Irish" into almost every public introduction'

Just like a lot of American people with even the vaguest family connection to Ireland. The response of actual Irish people who were born and brought up in Ireland is pretty much Hmm to this

Really? That’s definitely not my experience.

Here, we’re very happy to meet our Irish American cousins, especially down in the South West where the famine hit hardest and many families did whatever they could to send their children abroad.

Americans visiting Skibbereen to research their family connections are always given the warmest of welcomes.

céad míle fáilte!

SunShinesBrightly · 31/10/2021 08:51

@Leavisite

Look, to point out something blindingly obvious which no one has brought up — one of the reasons people of Irish descent living in the UK don’t often flag themselves as ‘Irish’ the way Americans of Irish descent do is that there remains significant levels of anti-Irish prejudice towards Irish people.
This is very true. My Grandparents and my friend’s parents remember very clearly ‘No dog, no children, no ‘blacks’, no Irish’ posters in shops and pubs. I myself remember very clearly the IRA attacks.
TowerOfJoyless · 31/10/2021 08:49

But unlike Biden with his 'Irish roots', Trump could genuinely claim to be half Scottish as his mother was born and raised on the Scottish Islands. Not that us Scots took to him in any way due to that!

Leavisite · 31/10/2021 08:46

Look, to point out something blindingly obvious which no one has brought up — one of the reasons people of Irish descent living in the UK don’t often flag themselves as ‘Irish’ the way Americans of Irish descent do is that there remains significant levels of anti-Irish prejudice towards Irish people.

Muttly · 31/10/2021 08:45

I have heard many Americans speak of British heritage. On a hike in Seattle one time a British descended American even told me that she couldn’t talk to me because she was on the other side in the Northern Ireland dispute. She was only half joking Grin

x2boys · 31/10/2021 08:45

My Dad is Irish,he was born in cork and lived there untill he was eleven ,when they emigration to England,it doesn't make me Irish though ,although it is part of my heritage

ArcheryAnnie · 31/10/2021 08:44

@chocolatecerealcampingbrekkie

They are not doing any harm so I don't see the problem.
The fundraising by "Irish"-Americans for the IRA did quite a lot of harm, in its time. It was weirdly respectable to do so, via organisations like Noraid.