Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
Mifacagare · 31/10/2021 09:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 31/10/2021 09:47

@ ManifestingWisdom - For decades now though any anti-Irishness displays only a very lower middle class hyacinth bouquet mindset. I never worried about anti-Irishness in the UK, as the only people who ever said anything to me were not in positions of power above me with any control over my life. This is how it is now. Ireland is a modern European country with adequate/good health care and a well educated population. It's so dated to look down on the Irish. Anybody who reveals how out of date they are, I just pitied them, and that was over 15 years ago as although I spent 13 years in London, I've been back 15 years now.

You just have to look at the comments on the recent past by various British politicians about Ireland and the Irish to see that is not the case at all. I don't know have you seen the comments by the British diplomat who resigned over being asked to lie to Americans about the impacts of brexit? One UK minister, when told about negative impacts on Irish businesses, said it was only a bunch of farmers with turnips in the back of the truck. Priti Patel's suggestion that you starve the Irish into submission was another beauty.

I think as well that it depends on what you call anti-Irish displays. In the 80's it was very overt and, while the aggressive behaviour was mainly from more "lower-case" people, there was plenty from all "classes". There is still plenty of anti-Irish attitudes prevalent amongst all classes in the UK. It's just disguised as banter or slagging in the more affluent and educated.

Naunet · 31/10/2021 09:46

@LedTasso

I am not sure why Brits get so upset over this. If an American has Irish great-grandparents and says they are American Irish, that's fine. I think you don't hear so much abour people identifying as "English-Americans" as much because it tends to be the default, and because often it goes much further back. That said I do know Americans who are very interested in their English heritage.

I am Irish, was born there but didn't grow up there (nor did I grow up in the UK). Some people on this thread seem to think you can only be the nationality of the country you were born in. This is not the case at all, it's not always that simple. My kids were born in the UK and they are British and Irish.

Also, most people are quite interested in their ancestors, hence the popularity of "Who do you think you are?". Americans will have ancestors who emigrated, I think I would find that interesting if I were them and want to know where they came from. More interesting than centuries of farm labourers which I assume to be the case for my ancestry!

I don’t think it’s that we get upset, more just find it a weird quirk, as I’m sure a lot of other Europeans do too.
ManifestingWisdom · 31/10/2021 09:43

@newrubylane

It's worth noting that a DNA test can't identify a genetic 'ethnicity'. It can only tell you which modern populations your genetic make up is most similar to. It doesn't necessarily mean you're literally from there. They call it an 'ethnicity estimate'. Taking into account the way that your DNA can come in different proportions from each grandparent (i.e. not necessarily 25% from each) as well, you could very easily have a set of Irish great-grandparents and not obviously appear genetically 'Irish'.
Yes, my brother did one and it came back that he was 13% Irish. The rest was Scottish, Welsh and Irish with him being 26% Scottish although we did know that my Dad's mum was Scottish.

I just realised that I forgot that when I described myself as plain old Irish!

So he paid 99 euro to learn that he was 96% from the uk. and 4% swedish with I think everybody gets. 99 euro well spent! The excitement of these results!

SickAndTiredAgain · 31/10/2021 09:43

@ManifestingWisdom

For decades now though any anti-Irishness displays only a very lower middle class hyacinth bouquet mindset. I never worried about anti-Irishness in the UK, as the only people who ever said anything to me were not in positions of power above me with any control over my life. This is how it is now. Ireland is a modern European country with adequate/good health care and a well educated population. It's so dated to look down on the Irish. Anybody who reveals how out of date they are, I just pitied them, and that was over 15 years ago as although I spent 13 years in London, I've been back 15 years now.
Yes but when you’re talking about identifying as Irish due to a reasonably distant relative, once that stops, for example due to anti-Irish prejudice, it’s less likely to reappear in later generations I think. It’s the kind of thing that is passed down.
Cherrysoup · 31/10/2021 09:43

Woah, American Indian?! I think that’s an offensive term these days (any day, actually) and perpetuates the myth that Columbus had a clue about his whereabouts. God knows why he’s so celebrated in America.

I did chuckle on meeting some people in Kentucky who told me they were 9th generation Irish ie not at all. Given the relative newness of the country and it being such a melting pot, I think people like to be able to hang their hat on something and it’s important to them, so let them crack on. I’m not including African American in that, that’s a whole different issue.

LedTasso · 31/10/2021 09:42

I am not sure why Brits get so upset over this. If an American has Irish great-grandparents and says they are American Irish, that's fine. I think you don't hear so much abour people identifying as "English-Americans" as much because it tends to be the default, and because often it goes much further back. That said I do know Americans who are very interested in their English heritage.

I am Irish, was born there but didn't grow up there (nor did I grow up in the UK). Some people on this thread seem to think you can only be the nationality of the country you were born in. This is not the case at all, it's not always that simple. My kids were born in the UK and they are British and Irish.

Also, most people are quite interested in their ancestors, hence the popularity of "Who do you think you are?". Americans will have ancestors who emigrated, I think I would find that interesting if I were them and want to know where they came from. More interesting than centuries of farm labourers which I assume to be the case for my ancestry!

wallowmall · 31/10/2021 09:42

A decade earlier I was watching the news with a mix of Americans and Canadians and they were fully amazed that as an English person I was appalled by the Orangemen and their marching through Catholic areas. They thought every English person would be behind them. No nuanced understanding at all.

That happens here though, I've been told I obviously supported the IRA as an adult because I have an Irish name 🤔 And plenty have no idea about loyalist involvement.

Leavisite · 31/10/2021 09:41

@CantBeAssed

I always thought the claim of having Irish ancestors was just a ploy of some wanna be politician to get votesConfused
Well, it’s certainly that, too. Biden reiterating the US position on Brexit and the NI protocol — that nothing can be allowed to happen re. borders that threatens the Good Friday Agreement — is in part a matter of not alienating the sizeable Irish-American vote.
Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 09:41

Kingsley Read the UCL link for the actual science.

Ancestry hang on to your DNA unless you expressly ask them to destroy it. Why do you think that might be? They have no reason to hang on to it unless they regard it as having value beyond the immediate results of their analysis?

These are businesses and are valued by the market for the DNA records they hold.

Coffeetree · 31/10/2021 09:40

Psychological equivalent of losing virginity! Lol

My ancestry is Irish and I'm American. I have some distant relatives in Ireland but never went to actual Ireland until I was in my 30s.

In my parents' generation, in a Northeast US city, people said "Irish" or "French" or "Italian" to refer to communities/neighbourhoods/people. So my parents were second-generation immigrants but still lived in an "Irish" neighbourhood and met at the "Irish" church. Growing up people would hear my surname and be like "Oh you're Irish".

As I recall, sometime in the 80s people started saying "Irish-American" etc. Because obviously not actually Irish. I would never dream of calling myself Irish now.

I think some people do try to cling to it because it's a way to avoid getting sucked into the homgenising machine.

But on the other hand it can be a sort of cringey and sinister way of appropriating a culture and trying to get a free pass from recognising one's own white privilege. Like no Biden, you're a white American Chad, own it.

FictionalCharacter · 31/10/2021 09:40

@NutellaEllaElla

It's bordering on appropriation. How they can call themselves Irish/Scottish when they've never even been, couldn't point it out on a map is beyond me. It's embarrassing.
Yep - it’s their (partial) ancestry, not their nationality. Joe Biden said “I’m Irish”. No you’re not mate, you’re American through and through. It’s this kind of nonsense that led to Americans supporting and funding the IRA when they were blowing people up in Britain.

It’s very selective too. Loads of Americans call themselves Irish because they have an Irish great-grandma or something, but imagine how it would have gone down if Obama had proudly called himself Kenyan!

newrubylane · 31/10/2021 09:40

It's worth noting that a DNA test can't identify a genetic 'ethnicity'. It can only tell you which modern populations your genetic make up is most similar to. It doesn't necessarily mean you're literally from there. They call it an 'ethnicity estimate'. Taking into account the way that your DNA can come in different proportions from each grandparent (i.e. not necessarily 25% from each) as well, you could very easily have a set of Irish great-grandparents and not obviously appear genetically 'Irish'.

MyOtherProfile · 31/10/2021 09:40

@queenofarles it really is, and I love listening to it. However the most recent "french" Americans I met were from Chicago 😆

ManifestingWisdom · 31/10/2021 09:39

Obviously I don't know what my experience would have been in the USA.
Although I'm Irish my surname is English. And when I was in the USA the people I spoke to didn't seem to register that I was Irish not English.

There's no reason why they should be experts on accents a continent away but it did used to surprise me.

DyingForACuppa · 31/10/2021 09:38

One of my parents siblings moved to USA and thus my cousin's are American. Absolutely no links to forced immigration/early American struggles etc.

They are 1/8th Irish, as am I, through the same family member.

They describe themselves as Irish American. I am aware of my Irish heritage, but don't prioritise it my over cultural backgrounds in the way my cousin does.

It is curious.

HikingforScenery · 31/10/2021 09:37

I think it’s a beautiful thing for people to identify with their roots and link to their ancestors.

Unless an American is Native American, really they should be something American, including British, Australian, etc. They’re people who see themselves as ‘American’ because they’re white and instead ask those who look Asian, Black, Latino, etc “where are you really from”.

I think your post also shows privilege. Because someone who look Asian or black hasn’t got the luxury of identifying as from Yorkshire because even if their parents came here as part of Windrush or following the 2nd world war, for e.g. , they’ll be asked where they’re really from or worse be told to go back home at some point.

ManifestingWisdom · 31/10/2021 09:37

For decades now though any anti-Irishness displays only a very lower middle class hyacinth bouquet mindset. I never worried about anti-Irishness in the UK, as the only people who ever said anything to me were not in positions of power above me with any control over my life. This is how it is now. Ireland is a modern European country with adequate/good health care and a well educated population. It's so dated to look down on the Irish. Anybody who reveals how out of date they are, I just pitied them, and that was over 15 years ago as although I spent 13 years in London, I've been back 15 years now.

wallowmall · 31/10/2021 09:35

And I think belonging to a sub tribe within the wider population is a nice feeling!

I am just plain old Irish and I would like to have somewhere i could go where I'd be accepted as not one of the wider population, but one of us

This makes sense

EdgeOfTheSky · 31/10/2021 09:35

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I got harangued by an Irish American online once for being English due to the Irish Famine.

I have, as it happens, only English Ancestry.

At the time of the famine my ancestors were illiterate and didn’t have the vote.

It is very hard for me to understand how it’s any part of my fault - it’s just an accident of birth.

The IRA were massively funded by Noraid, contributions by Irish Americans. It only stopped after Bush banned contributions to terrorist organisations in the wake of 9/11.

A decade earlier I was watching the news with a mix of Americans and Canadians and they were fully amazed that as an English person I was appalled by the Orangemen and their marching through Catholic areas. They thought every English person would be behind them. No nuanced understanding at all.

Years before that I worked in Central London, used to drink in the Sussex Arms (bombed: 1 dead several injured), listening to the controlled explosions going off all the way up Tottenham Court Rd. hosted a party of American colleagues who moaned about how scuzzy it was not to have rubbish bins on tube platforms. “And why do you think that might be?” was met with a flummoxed ‘no idea’.

ManifestingWisdom · 31/10/2021 09:34

@CantBeAssed

I always thought the claim of having Irish ancestors was just a ploy of some wanna be politician to get votesConfused
I agree. They definitely look at the electorate and get a breakdown of its ethnicity and if the politician is Tipp-ex white then they're not going to aim for the hispanic vote. When will the melting pot lose track of their 1 / 16th Irish/Scottish ancestory!? When it's 1 /32nd?
SickAndTiredAgain · 31/10/2021 09:33

one of the reasons people of Irish descent living in the UK don’t often flag themselves as ‘Irish’ the way Americans of Irish descent do is that there remains significant levels of anti-Irish prejudice towards Irish people.

Of course. But it’s not just Irish-American. I worked with an American woman once who described herself as “Dutch-American” due to one Dutch great grandparent. It doesn’t bother me, people can view that as an important part of their identity if they want, but you wouldn’t often find a Brit describing themselves as “Dutch-British” due to one great-grandparent.

However, is this uniquely an American trait? Maybe we’re the unusual ones and we just don’t know it because America is the place mainly portrayed on tv, no language barrier etc. The French may well also describe themselves as “Irish-French” due to a great great grandparent, I have no idea.

queenofarles · 31/10/2021 09:32

I've met Americans who have said they are french or Dutch or whatever. When I've asked if they speak the language they say oh no. So then I ask is it that your mum or dad are from France or Netherlands? Nope. Turns out to be some great great grandparent. So they may be like a 16th whatever, max. With no language and no cultural connection.
Google Louisiana French, it’s fascinating!

Naunet · 31/10/2021 09:32

[quote OchonAgusOchonOh]@Naunet - oh, I see what you mean. I thought you meant officially in terms of ethnicity.[/quote]
To be fair, it’s not just Americans, I’ve seen Mexicans do it too, and in a way that shocks me even more because they’re likely to have Spanish heritage considering Spain and Portugal colonised Mexico.

CantBeAssed · 31/10/2021 09:31

I always thought the claim of having Irish ancestors was just a ploy of some wanna be politician to get votesConfused

Swipe left for the next trending thread