Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 02/11/2021 16:54

What I don't understand is how you can have pride in something that you haven't done or experienced or influenced? Why pride? I also don't understand "national pride". I'm not proud of just happening to be born somewhere. Likewise how can you be proud of something your past ancestors did or experienced? It's interesting, I give you that but otherwise it has little to do with you. I find it very odd.

Ok, if all ideas of externalised sources of pride or national or subnational identity are odd to you, then you’ll never understand those who do experience a sense of pride in a different way. You’ll feel the same about someone who describes themselves as a ‘proud Yorkshireman’.

For me, it’s not a sense of personal achievement, it’s a sense of being linked by my heritage and birth to people who did some things that were objectively incredibly difficult and overcome huge hurdles and hardship, and thinking ‘fuck me, that’s what I came from, what an example I’ve been set, that’s something to live up to and aspire to’.

It goes beyond the ‘interesting in a dispassionate and objective sort of way’ into a feeling of connection and kinship with those roots. So there is pride in a community and the heritage of that community, and the journey that community has been on and what it’s overcome.

I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the strongest senses of immigrant community and identity are from those who were in the minority, who had to leave their homelands because of particular hardship or persecution and weren’t part of the ruling class in their new land.

RavingAnnie · 02/11/2021 16:41

[quote JassyRadlett]@RavingAnnie because pride in one’s heritage in countries like the US, Australia, Canada or other countries with populations where the overwhelming majority are the result of immigration in the last few centuries is very closely tied to pride in their communities and their countries.

Being part of the Italian or Greek or Maltese community in different parts of Australia, for example, confers a strong sense of belonging and pride for a lot of people.

There is an odd refusal on this thread to recognise that there is a sense of community and identity resulting from immigrant heritage in these countries that just doesn’t exist in, say, the UK or other countries whose history isn’t so hugely tied up with immigration, where not just one of your great-grandparents came from somewhere else but all of them did.

It also ignores, in a really tin-eared and ignorant way, the impact that immigrant communities had on the development of those countries. Some English people seem to think that immigration in those countries was about people arriving and then assimilating - completely ignoring how those immigrant communities shaped the development of their towns, cities, regions and even their country, which also confers a sense of pride in what their ancestors achieved (as well as pride in those people for what they did and overcame.)[/quote]
What I don't understand is how you can have pride in something that you haven't done or experienced or influenced? Why pride? I also don't understand "national pride". I'm not proud of just happening to be born somewhere. Likewise how can you be proud of something your past ancestors did or experienced? It's interesting, I give you that but otherwise it has little to do with you. I find it very odd.

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2021 16:27

It was definitely the definition of "obsessed" that prompted my comment about Americans generally not being obsessed.

"Obsessed" is what a certain coterie of posters on MN are about Meghan, Duchess of Sussex. And not in a good way.

TheNinny · 02/11/2021 16:25

This is true I think. Im from Scotland but lived in the states for 7 yrs. When inevitability asked where I was I from I’d say ‘I’m Scottish’, to be met with an oh me too! type response. They clearly meant heritage where as I meant actual country of origin. I got around it by saying I’m from Scotland, and that seemed to work better.

Annoyingly though, on several occasions I was informed by people who had never been, that I don’t sound very Scottish etc.( I’m from the central belt) I also don’t have a traditional Scottish name which seems to lessen my proper Scottish standing in their eyes 😂

dreamingbohemian · 02/11/2021 16:17

Americans are definitely not obsessed with the RF

They had a lot of affection for Princess Di, as did many people around the world, so it makes sense for a movie about her to be promoted there.

They were interested in William and Harry as Diana's sons, and of course when Harry married an American that was a big deal.

Otherwise the vast majority of Americans really do not care very much, except when there's a scandal, which is basically treated like celebrity gossip. The US is very anti-monarchical, they don't take royals seriously. It's tabloid fluff.

MissConductUS · 02/11/2021 15:55

Good, so we have established that Americans are not obsessed with the RF.

OVienna · 02/11/2021 15:52

to engage any further on that point, that is.

OVienna · 02/11/2021 15:51

Goodness, I can't be bothered.

MissConductUS · 02/11/2021 15:49

@OVienna

lol.
Can you cite a different definition of obsessed?
OVienna · 02/11/2021 15:37

@verymiddleaged

yes, it is different than it was for Australia and Canada, because they remained under your yoke for so much longer, and have not developed distinct identities of their own for as long or as powerfully.

This odd idea that Canada doesn't have such a powerful individual identity as the USA is one I have come across before.
It is American exceptionalism at its finest.
The look on the Canadians' faces as it was explained to them by American the was quite something. I imagine that an Australian might also have the same look.

Also this, x1000. This may have changed since I was growing up but neither Oz or Canada got much media coverage. I think awareness of/knowledge of the detail of either country is minimal.
verymiddleaged · 02/11/2021 15:31

yes, it is different than it was for Australia and Canada, because they remained under your yoke for so much longer, and have not developed distinct identities of their own for as long or as powerfully.

This odd idea that Canada doesn't have such a powerful individual identity as the USA is one I have come across before.
It is American exceptionalism at its finest.
The look on the Canadians' faces as it was explained to them by American the was quite something. I imagine that an Australian might also have the same look.

OVienna · 02/11/2021 15:30

lol.

MissConductUS · 02/11/2021 15:29

I think it does prove the point about the US being RF obsessed.

dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/obsessed

unable to stop thinking about something; too interested in or worried about something:

I think that most Americans are mildly interested in the goings-on of the RF or amused by them. I don't know any who are "obsessed".

OVienna · 02/11/2021 15:27

The story AFTER M&H was something about one of the investigations into Donald Trump. It absolutely the main news.

OVienna · 02/11/2021 15:21

@MissConductUS

When I was in in the US in Oct 2019, the US news channel I was watching led on a Harry and Meghan tour story. This is like two weeks before we could have crashed out of the EU. If the goal was 'world news' it was gobsmacking they chose that item.

Media outlets have different audiences. CNBC would have covered the EU story and not H&M. It's also about attracting viewers. H&M are entertainment, not news, and most Americans aren't that fussed about Brexit.

@MissConductUS This was one of the major networks, their nightly news. I can't remember if it was NBC, ABC, or CBS. It was not something like Entertainment Tonight.

Americans aren't that fussed about Brexit. Why the hell would they care about H&M's South Africa tour??? If it's the first story and your theory that it would attract viewers, I think it does prove the point about the US being RF obsessed.

PrincessNutella · 02/11/2021 15:19

What I am seeing here is that a lot of British posters are imposing their view of how people should understand culture onto another country. They come from a country that is fundamentally a monoculture with one race and people that has dominated not only their own land but many lands for hundreds of years. So of course you think that your way is the only way and although you allow other groups in, you still maintain that colonialist mindset. The U.S. is a nation that WAS a colony. We were the back office of your imperialist project and were constantly receiving multiple streams of immigration. So we have always had to live with and understand cultural differences within our borders. That duality is a fundamental part of American identity in a different way than it was for the UK. And yes, it is different than it was for Australia and Canada, because they remained under your yoke for so much longer, and have not developed distinct identities of their own for as long or as powerfully.

queenofarles · 02/11/2021 15:09

4,000 Irish girls aged 14 - 18 from post-famine workhouses across Ireland were sent to Australia to provide wives for the colonies and it is estimated 20% of the current population of Australia can be traced to this event.
I didn’t know that Shock,

PrincessNutella · 02/11/2021 15:07

Znaida, you plainly missed the point of what I was saying. I don't think ANYONE needs to be educated about how to think if they don't want to be. Some Americans may have a peculiar relationship with modern Scotland, in your opinion. You may have a lack of understanding of their perspective. And some Brits may have a lack of understanding of what the real America is all about. Three perspectives that are all lacking in complexity. It's a pity, but what can you do?

SilverBirchWithout · 02/11/2021 15:06

My British (UK passport, living in England) DH has 2 great grandparents who came over from Ireland, he’s very proud of his Irish roots.

MissConductUS · 02/11/2021 15:06

When I was in in the US in Oct 2019, the US news channel I was watching led on a Harry and Meghan tour story. This is like two weeks before we could have crashed out of the EU. If the goal was 'world news' it was gobsmacking they chose that item.

Media outlets have different audiences. CNBC would have covered the EU story and not H&M. It's also about attracting viewers. H&M are entertainment, not news, and most Americans aren't that fussed about Brexit.

verymiddleaged · 02/11/2021 15:03

Sorry @OVienna I obviously need to drink some more coffee.

OVienna · 02/11/2021 14:56

@verymiddleaged

Ok, obviously not all citizens of the USA are obsessed or even vaguely interested in the UK Royals but Yes, there is media coverage in the way celebrities might be. This isn't the case either.

There is no reason for a long dead princess from another country with no links to the USA to have a min series on a serious news channel.

Why is Prince Philip considered a celebrity in the USA? ( just the most recent example)

I have lived in other countries in addition to the USA and UK so can observe that the USA is much more interested in the royals than most other countries with no current UK connections are.
There are more magazines with bizarre royal rumors at my local supermarket checkout in the Midwest than there were in the UK.

Yes, there is media coverage in the way celebrities might be. I was talking about the UK there, not the US.
OVienna · 02/11/2021 14:56

@OVienna

Another British SuperFan said to my mother: "Have you ever spoken to a TRUE YORKSHIREMAN?" "Yes," she said. "My son-in-law."
sorry - this was before she was about to impart some deep cultural insight, she felt my mother needed to hear.
verymiddleaged · 02/11/2021 14:55

Ok, obviously not all citizens of the USA are obsessed or even vaguely interested in the UK Royals but
Yes, there is media coverage in the way celebrities might be.
This isn't the case either.

There is no reason for a long dead princess from another country with no links to the USA to have a min series on a serious news channel.

Why is Prince Philip considered a celebrity in the USA? ( just the most recent example)

I have lived in other countries in addition to the USA and UK so can observe that the USA is much more interested in the royals than most other countries with no current UK connections are.
There are more magazines with bizarre royal rumors at my local supermarket checkout in the Midwest than there were in the UK.

eggandonion · 02/11/2021 14:45

There are a few closet royal fans near me in Ireland, my late neighbour and i used to have lovely chats about them.