Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
ManifestingWisdom · 31/10/2021 14:03

How is it provincial to not share the same perspective as scotch or Irish Americans? ? I thought everybody on the thread got it; America is a melting pot. Thought it was an interesting thread.

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 13:58

Sick Well he actually clung on to that citizenship long after he was faced with a tax demand and only surrendered it as part of a negotiated settlement. But then that was in his liberal Mayor days. I am sure it changed from a minus to a plus when it came to his plans to be world King…..

PrincessNutella · 31/10/2021 13:54

I think this thread is incredibly condescending and shows the narrowmindedness and lack of imagination of some British people at how people in other parts of the world might see the world differently. I love Mumsnet, but sometimes it does reveal a very ugly provincialism. And that is the nicest word I can come up with to describe what I am saying. You should be truly ashamed of yourselves.

JassyRadlett · 31/10/2021 13:52

@CoalTit

Does this happen in Australia too? No. So it can't be explained by the US being a country of immigrants. I knew an otherwise lovely man who started getting very north American about his Dutch ancestry, to the point of fretting on Facebook about who to barrack for when the Netherlands played (association) football against Australia. People just asked him if he was really into football, told him to enjoy the game and not worry about it, politely making it clear that that sort of nonsense wouldn't fly with them.
I don’t agree. I don’t think it exists to the same degree as in the US and not in a way that people would call themselves ‘Greek Australian’ but there is still, in my experience, a strong association with the immigrant experience and where your forebears came from, and that being quite tied up in your identity.
RocketPanda · 31/10/2021 13:49

I haven't read the entire thread but just wanted to offer a little perspective. I live very close to some famine cottages that pre covid saw their fair share of tourists and Irish Americans. Beside the cottages are wayside graves that hold some of the children of two particular houses. They were victims of a famine in which vast amounts of food were exported out of Ireland and are dead because of it. Their relatives were burned out when they couldn't pay rent and either died, moved or emigrated. If someone wants to call themselves Irish American and come here and see for themselves the likely reason why they are Irish American I don't have any problem with that. We must never forget the atrocities that the human race is capable of in pursuit of being dominant. Whole families are buried in fields and hedgerows all over the west of Ireland, most marked with just a few rocks placed lovingly.

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 13:48

You OK? Little Dandelion You seem very angry.

You know what? I would love to go and live in the land of my great grandmother to get away from all the angry little Englanders who have landed us in the current shitshow. As well as being a lovely country with an amazing rich culture of music, dance, poetry and writing, they have petrol in their stations, and full shelves in their supermarkets and they are not facing a Christmas with skyhigh infection rates of a mutating virus, possible power cuts and a shortage of Turkeys. Only problem is that that right to move there or any other EU country has been taken away from us hasn’t it?

CoalTit · 31/10/2021 13:44

Does this happen in Australia too?
No.
So it can't be explained by the US being a country of immigrants.
I knew an otherwise lovely man who started getting very north American about his Dutch ancestry, to the point of fretting on Facebook about who to barrack for when the Netherlands played (association) football against Australia. People just asked him if he was really into football, told him to enjoy the game and not worry about it, politely making it clear that that sort of nonsense wouldn't fly with them.

JassyRadlett · 31/10/2021 13:42

@MooseBreath

I am Canadian. My ancestors were Irish and Russian. The reason this is so relevant in North America is because there are so many cultures and ways that households operate and it often goes back to roots.

My friend's family is "German" and their traditions are totally different than mine which are "Irish". Both Canadian, but totally different ways of life at home.

I’m Australian and I recognise this too.

I think it’s probably quite hard for those who live in a country where most/many people’s heritage is at least partly or mostly within that country to understand how much the immigrant experience is part of the national story in countries where nearly everyone comes from somewhere else. And for so many that immigration experience in their ancestry was quite intrepid and spoke of sacrifice or hardship or adventurousness. And so those stories become part of your identity.

And there is a degree, too, of immigrant communities hanging onto their traditions more strongly as communities in the home country becoming more modern. The sense of identity and tradition become incredibly important to a lot of immigrants, and that gets passed down.

SickAndTiredAgain · 31/10/2021 13:42

@Emilyontmoor

It proper boils my piss. That Biden dude who America have voted for president, comes out with the 'I'm IRISH!' bull. Errr NO you are AMERICAN

And what temperature does you piss rise to when faced with a man who proudly claims to be American (and a bit Turkish ) when playing being a liberal member of the metropolitan elite as mayor of a proudly diverse city, then goes a bit quiet on it when faced with a tax bill and cynically uses the populist nationalist ticket to become PM?

I know I’m not the poster you were replying to, and I do loathe Johnson. But he wasn’t claiming to be American, he was literally an American citizen. And I’d give up citizenship to a country where I happened to be born and hadn’t lived since I was a child if it was increasing my tax bill. But to use the PP’s charming phrase, yes it does boil my piss that he managed to get himself elected.
LittleDandelionClock · 31/10/2021 13:36

@wallowmall

Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK?

🙄

Nice bit of cherry picking my post, so you can post a lovely rollie eyes smiley.

Have THIS one > Hmm

AosSi · 31/10/2021 13:36

I've no issue with Americans claiming to be Irish-American. By all means, be proud of your ancestors and the struggles they had.

It's when they say they are Irish that it annoys me. There's a big difference between the actually Irish and the historically Irish ime. I find that they don't tend to understand Ireland as a modern day nation and expect to see donkeys, thatch cottages and girls dancing at the crossroads. I remember having a great row with a boatload of Irish-Americans over to campaign against the 2015 marriage referendum here...the fecking cheek of them, interfering in another country's democratic process "because that's what my great granny would have wanted".

LadyJaye · 31/10/2021 13:35

I'm Scottish and I personally don't mind when American people tell me that 'I'm Scottish too!' (although they could barely point to Scotland on a map).

It doesn't really affect my life or identity in any meaningful way, and it used to get me great tips when I worked as a tour guide as a student. Grin

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 13:35

It proper boils my piss. That Biden dude who America have voted for president, comes out with the 'I'm IRISH!' bull. Errr NO you are AMERICAN

And what temperature does you piss rise to when faced with a man who proudly claims to be American (and a bit Turkish ) when playing being a liberal member of the metropolitan elite as mayor of a proudly diverse city, then goes a bit quiet on it when faced with a tax bill and cynically uses the populist nationalist ticket to become PM?

LittleDandelionClock · 31/10/2021 13:35

@Tillysfad

Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK? confused

No words.

I am on about the people BORN here. Not the people who CAME here. Do you have comprehension problems?
LittleDandelionClock · 31/10/2021 13:34

@Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet

Um, some people had no choice but to leave their country of heritage, for many reasons. Most people who left Ireland didn't want to leave, but if they wanted to be able to, ya know, get a job, then they had to look elsewhere for that.

I am talking about the people BORN here, if you could be bothered to read my post properly.

When someone is born here, and berates the UK, and says how much better the country of heritage is, it's fucking infuriating.

Tillysfad · 31/10/2021 13:33

Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK? confused

No words.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 31/10/2021 13:32

@LittleDandelionClock

Some people are born in the UK, and have grandparents/great grandparents etc, (who moved here from a different country in the last 60-70 years,) and they have all the rights and privileges of living here. Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK? Confused
Um, some people had no choice but to leave their country of heritage, for many reasons. Most people who left Ireland didn't want to leave, but if they wanted to be able to, ya know, get a job, then they had to look elsewhere for that.
elp30 · 31/10/2021 13:31

@Naunet

The thing that’s always confused me most about Americans, is why they suddenly decided that Spainish people aren’t white.

My dad is Spanish, so over there I’m suddenly mixed race 🙄

That's not entirely true.

I mentioned earlier that I am Mexican-American.
Mexicans and other peoples from the Americas, especially, are people who were indigenous and mixed with Europeans i.e., Spanish, Portuguese, etc...

To me, and many people like me, the Spanish and Portuguese are white Europeans.

People who think that people like Antonio Banderas and yourself are now Latino are incorrect. Most likely, it's people who aren't Hispanic/Latino make that mistake. They don't know the distinction but we do.

wallowmall · 31/10/2021 13:31

Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK?

🙄

gabsdot45 · 31/10/2021 13:30

I am Irish. The only non Irish ancestors I have are a great great granny from Liverpool.
My parents are keen genealogists and have had their DNA tested. My mum found an American cousin who had 99%irish DNA. His nearest ancestors who were actually born in Ireland were great grandparents. He's genetically more Irish than I am.

SickAndTiredAgain · 31/10/2021 13:27

It's jingoistic to the British ear, but it makes complete sense in a nation of immigrants

I’d agree with that more if all identities were viewed a bit more equally. Looking at politicians, Biden clearly feels he gets some political capital from the Irish identity, due to having a couple of Irish great grandparents. It’s seen as desirable to keep that link and celebrate that heritage, which is fair enough.
Yet in that “nation of immigrants” I doubt congresswomen Rashida Tlaib (born in the US to Palestinian parents) or Ilhan Omar (born in Somalia) get the same political capital from their identities. How desirable is it for them to be seen to be keeping that link and celebrating their heritage? How many politicians with a couple of Palestinian great grandparents would mention it frequently, or would refer to themselves as Palestinian, as Biden calls himself Irish.
So it’s clearly not just that as a nation of immigrants, they love to celebrate everyone’s different identities and heritage.

Nikki360 · 31/10/2021 13:27

@LittleDandelionClock

Some people are born in the UK, and have grandparents/great grandparents etc, (who moved here from a different country in the last 60-70 years,) and they have all the rights and privileges of living here. Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK? Confused
Maybe they have family here jobs friends etc ? They can still have a love for their ancestral home and culture !
NalPolishRemover · 31/10/2021 13:27

This thread is really revealing & it's mostly not pretty [Confused

LittleDandelionClock · 31/10/2021 13:25

Some people are born in the UK, and have grandparents/great grandparents etc, (who moved here from a different country in the last 60-70 years,) and they have all the rights and privileges of living here. Yet some of them blather on and on and ON about how amazing their country of heritage is. It REALLY pisses me off. If it's THAT good then why are you still here in the UK? Confused

LittleDandelionClock · 31/10/2021 13:20

It proper boils my piss. That Biden dude who America have voted for president, comes out with the 'I'm IRISH!' bull. Errr NO you are AMERICAN.