Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
dreamingbohemian · 31/10/2021 19:19

Reminds me of being asked - in Boston of all places - what the Brits thought about 9/11. I said truthfully that it was an appalling tragedy, but since the subject was terrorism I also mentioned how regrettable it was that some in the US had funded our own IRA for years

How fucking rude

And they weren't your IRA, that was sort of the whole point

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 19:19

Anyway I am now off to join the huge crowds celebrating Halloween in our high street, a Celtic festival that was not at all a feature of English culture twenty years ago when I first encountered the American phenomenon. It grew in importance in America, in no small part due to the immigration from Ireland, where it has always been celebrated, during the famine. American culture flew with it and now so has England…

IcedPurple · 31/10/2021 19:17

The only people who seek to present our history in those terms of influencing the world out of proportion to our size are driven by political factors not trying to understand the reality.

Are you suggesting England or Britain's influence on the world has been in proportion to its size?

Because it's clear to me that it has not. That's not to say English influence has always been benign, anymore than that of any other country, but it has certainly been extremely important over the past 4 centuries.

I don't think pointing that out is politically motivated, although I do think your attempts to downplay the influence of English culture, and see it only in a negative light, certainly are.

RVN123 · 31/10/2021 19:15

@thepinknecklace

How likely is someone to turn up at an office in Glasgow or get on a bus in Edinburgh wearing full tartan and kilt?

As a Glaswegian I can honestly say if someone turned up to work in an office in a kilt there would be some raised eyebrows and folk would definitely talk.

I agree. And not many men have their 'own' kilt. They are usually hired for events. The outfit consists of so many parts and it can be HORRENDOUSLY expensive to buy your own proper kilt for an outfit that only gets worn a couple of times a year at best.

On any given day in Edinburgh, the only folk wearing kilts in Princes Street are usually the guys playing the bagpipes for tourist money - buskers!

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 19:06

What I did say is that English culture has been extremely influential. That's simply a fact. Well that is the academic debate because “influence” is not a one way process, it is not a fact, it is an exchange mediated by a lot of factors and that included guns, imperialism and racism as well as creativity and enterprise.

The only people who seek to present our history in those terms of influencing the world out of proportion to our size are driven by political factors not trying to understand the reality.

MarshaBradyo · 31/10/2021 19:04

I also find it pretty easy to find positives in many cultures, having travelled a fair bit

MarshaBradyo · 31/10/2021 19:00

I agree with Iced I don’t recognise this exceptionalism you claim to counter

Your posts seem overly negative to me as someone who grew up o/s and sees a lot of positives in the culture here.

Mn seems to thrive on it though for some reason.

StoneofDestiny · 31/10/2021 19:00

I'm not sure how tartan and kilts, which are rarely worn at all in contemporary Scotland and were never universally worn, constitute a 'distinctive culture'. If you want to take twee historical relics like that as evidence, then Morris dancing, bowling on the green, and afternoon tea mean the same thing for "English culture"

You are missing my point - it's the Americans and Canadians coming to Scotland to 'claim their tartan', not the Scots! The kilt turns up more on a Scots body when Scotland plays Rugby and at weddings.

queenofarles · 31/10/2021 18:59

None of my lot have a kilt. Dad said they don’t have the legs for it
Grin
I’m sure they only do that in weddings and stuff like that.

I find it very cruel when Italians say : that’s not Italian , all these Americans are only going to tourist traps , it’s not the real Italy. I’ve been to so many "real"Italy places , so many of the beaten track sort of places , small towns in Sardinia , ,Sicily. What I found is very little to zero Authenticity , it’s no different to any small town in Spain , Portugal or Greece . It’s all apartment blocks , A Small corner shop, liquor shop , bar , pizza place etc.
No one from the new generation is actually interested in preserving their own culture.
Maybe it’s the Italian American who will!

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 18:58

Marsha It is odd

Amongst my academic and business peers it is not at all odd to try and take an objective view of English culture in relation to other cultures. Business obviously depends on it in international markets, however much sidelined that perspective has been in the U.K. recently, and academically orientalism is an accepted historical phenomenon in British history. The academic debate is more about the subtle nuances of influence and exchange and the role of occidentalism in that process (because exceptionalism is not actually the sole preserve of the English).

OchonAgusOchonOh · 31/10/2021 18:50

@Puzzledandpissedoff - I also mentioned how regrettable it was that some in the US had funded our own IRA for years

The IRA are not British as you seem to be implying by referring to them as "our own". The lack of recognition of the nationalist community's Irishness and the outright discrimination against them in housing, employment and education is what led to the Troubles in the first place. Doesn't excuse terrorism but you only have to see how the British responded to peaceful civil rights marches to understand why a minority of nationalists felt they had no other choice but to resort to violence.

thepinknecklace · 31/10/2021 18:43

How likely is someone to turn up at an office in Glasgow or get on a bus in Edinburgh wearing full tartan and kilt?

As a Glaswegian I can honestly say if someone turned up to work in an office in a kilt there would be some raised eyebrows and folk would definitely talk.

IcedPurple · 31/10/2021 18:40

@Emilyontmoor

Marsha Icy I am not putting English culture down, in fact if you read my posts you will see me cheerleading it’s distinctive character. It is just there is a difference between being distinctive and being exceptional. We are not exceptional and it is a reaction to that illusion of exceptionalism and a colonial past that is behind some of the comments on here that are putting English culture down.
I never said anything about English culture being 'exceptional', so you're strawmanning again.

What I did say is that English culture has been extremely influential. That's simply a fact.

KittenKong · 31/10/2021 18:37

@derxa

I've spent a fair bit of time in Scotland and never saw anyone in a kilt except at weddings or occassional cultural events. How likely is someone to turn up at an office in Glasgow or get on a bus in Edinburgh wearing full tartan and kilt? 🤣🤣🤣 With an attitude like that it's no surprise that you didn't get invited to many weddings or events. Anybody working in a Glasgow office wears a suit no matter what their heritage. Most of my male contemporaries have their own kilt.
None of my lot have a kilt. Dad said they don’t have the legs for it (he point blanc refused to wear one at my wedding!)
Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 18:34

Marsha Icy I am not putting English culture down, in fact if you read my posts you will see me cheerleading it’s distinctive character. It is just there is a difference between being distinctive and being exceptional. We are not exceptional and it is a reaction to that illusion of exceptionalism and a colonial past that is behind some of the comments on here that are putting English culture down.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 31/10/2021 18:31

I remember having a great row with a boatload of Irish-Americans over to campaign against the 2015 marriage referendum here...the fecking cheek of them, interfering in another country's democratic process "because that's what my great granny would have wanted"

I suppose the irony here is how interfering in their democratic processes would be viewed

Reminds me of being asked - in Boston of all places - what the Brits thought about 9/11. I said truthfully that it was an appalling tragedy, but since the subject was terrorism I also mentioned how regrettable it was that some in the US had funded our own IRA for years

Didn't go down well ...

IcedPurple · 31/10/2021 18:30

With an attitude like that it's no surprise that you didn't get invited to many weddings or events

A very strange conclusion to draw, but that's up to you.

Most of my male contemporaries have their own kilt.

How many days a year do you think they wear it, on average?

DdraigGoch · 31/10/2021 18:27

@Parker231

DH is French Canadian and refers to himself as that. Signifies his background.
A bit different when there are very clear things which set you apart from the other four-fifths of the Canadian population. A different first language for a start.
derxa · 31/10/2021 18:26

I've spent a fair bit of time in Scotland and never saw anyone in a kilt except at weddings or occassional cultural events. How likely is someone to turn up at an office in Glasgow or get on a bus in Edinburgh wearing full tartan and kilt? 🤣🤣🤣 With an attitude like that it's no surprise that you didn't get invited to many weddings or events. Anybody working in a Glasgow office wears a suit no matter what their heritage. Most of my male contemporaries have their own kilt.

DdraigGoch · 31/10/2021 18:13

@IsleofRum

Or "African American".

It's fine for the initial immigrant and first generation a little. But in you are born and live in the country you should accept that country as home. Otherwise keep a little connection if you like, but not seriously.

For African Americans the memories of segregation are very recent, you look different and are often still treated differently by American society.

Someone whose great-great-great grandfather migrated from Ireland? No one will have the foggiest idea until you tell them. They won't treat you any differently to any other American. You probably don't have a clue who St Patrick was, you may not even be able to point to Ireland on a map, let alone have you visited. The other 31 of your great-great-great grandparents may well have been of English descent so even if you think blood is important, there's precious little Irish blood in your veins. And yet you claim to be Irish even though you have no more in common with an Irishman than I do.

I saw posted on here a couple of years back that someone landed at a US airport on St Patrick's Day and there was recorded bagpipe music playing over the tannoy because (as one member of staff said) "everyone's Irish on St Patrick's Day!"

The tune being played was Scotland the Brave Hmm

IcedPurple · 31/10/2021 18:09

@Emilyontmoor

Iced Yes we have benefitted from great artistic creativity but what are the roots that it emerged from? The Blues in America as much as British folk and indeed eastern music (see the Beatles) You do know that the most popular pop group in the world at the moment is Korean?

As to universities I doubt you will find any Oxbridge Don who does not ascribe some of their academic success to absorbing ideas from elsewhere, particularly the Middle East and Asia. It is just there has been a 200 year project to erase that influence and agency.

Some strawman arguments here.

I never said that British or English culture developed in a vacumn. Of course it didn't. No culture did. You're constructing arguments against something I never said.

And yes, Korean pop is having a moment, but English and British pop music has enjoyed great success going back decades.

To deny that England and its culture has been massively influential, and not just because of 'guns', is ridiculou. But then, this is MN.

MarshaBradyo · 31/10/2021 18:08

@Emilyontmoor

Iced Yes we have benefitted from great artistic creativity but what are the roots that it emerged from? The Blues in America as much as British folk and indeed eastern music (see the Beatles) You do know that the most popular pop group in the world at the moment is Korean?

As to universities I doubt you will find any Oxbridge Don who does not ascribe some of their academic success to absorbing ideas from elsewhere, particularly the Middle East and Asia. It is just there has been a 200 year project to erase that influence and agency.

Why so down on achievements here?

It is odd.

Of course many are attracted to what London or England have to offer and that is based on a positive perception

Emilyontmoor · 31/10/2021 18:05

Iced Yes we have benefitted from great artistic creativity but what are the roots that it emerged from? The Blues in America as much as British folk and indeed eastern music (see the Beatles) You do know that the most popular pop group in the world at the moment is Korean?

As to universities I doubt you will find any Oxbridge Don who does not ascribe some of their academic success to absorbing ideas from elsewhere, particularly the Middle East and Asia. It is just there has been a 200 year project to erase that influence and agency.

Fordian · 31/10/2021 18:04

lljkk 'I live now in a small town in rural East Anglia. I know a lot about local pressure to conform.'

I hadn't read this before I posted about how 'cutting the tall poppy down' is not an 'English trait'.

A small town in rural East Anglia is hardly representative of England as a whole, where, as a whole, we're surrounded by diversity and difference. Which we, as a whole, either embrace or are learning to embrace.

I'm sorry if your local area is mired in the same small-town thinking that must benight much of rural America (cf Trump); but the comparison ends there.

MarshaBradyo · 31/10/2021 18:01

Being from o/s people seem more down on English culture on here

Not all, but many

We had a fair bit of it on other side of world