Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm Irish American"

682 replies

MacMahon · 31/10/2021 07:44

I've noticed that to many Americans their Irish, Scots, Italian etc. roots are a big part of their current identity. As a nation of immigrants in a New World I can see why this link to earlier generations is interesting and important.

But it's also something I find confusing.

I live in Yorkshire. I'm English. I have Irish ancestors on both side (great grandparents and great x2 grandparents). If I was in America this would quite possibly be a big deal. I'd be an Irish American and identify with the struggles and persecution that my people suffered at the hands of the English. But I wasn't born in America, I was born in Leeds, and my Irish ancestry play zero role in my identity.

I'm on an ancestry group and Americans are getting that DNA test done and finding out that, contrary to family lore that they are Cherokee or Mexican or Italian Americans, they're actually pretty much 'just' 100% British.

It makes me wonder how authentic this celebrating or identifying with their Irish/First Nations/Italian roots is, and how much is just (mistaken) tribalism and division.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IsleofRum · 03/11/2021 16:49

Some people are obsessive about their roots, others are interested as others are interested in genealogy. It is a conversation opener and perhaps a form of guilt or pride. Guilt as in survivor-guilt or pride that they achieved what they achieved.
I was born in Britain, my parents in Jamaica. I'm interested in their life in Jamaica. DD is not. Prior to that someone got a one way trip across the Atlantic from Africa. I don't know where in Africa, but not as interested in that as Jamaica. My choice.

Should we all gaze wistfully at the Euphrates or Ethiopia?

JassyRadlett · 03/11/2021 15:41

Maybe by talking about a ‘foreign monarch’ @PrincessNutella means Canadians have the Australian monarch on the stamps?

Giving the benefit of the doubt, because it couldn’t possibly be that she feels Canada’s history only started after sovereignty and its previous history became Someone Else’s?

SickAndTiredAgain · 03/11/2021 15:36

Canada is also still way too tied to the UK for it to be truly independent in its identity. As I said before, it has a foreign queen on its stamps. Why should it have the British monarch on its stamps

Canada doesn’t have just the British monarch on its stamps. It has the Canadian monarch. She is their head of state. If you were asking “why is she still their head of state” that’s a valid question (although I still don’t think it means Canadians don’t have an independent identity), but if you’re asking about stamps, she’s on them because she is their queen.

PrincessNutella · 03/11/2021 14:53

I think it is harder to have a distinct sense of what being Canadian is than it is to be an American is, though, for several reasons. Canada is divided by two cultures. French Canadians and Anglo Canadians do not have the same ideas about what Canada is or should be. Canada is also still way too tied to the UK for it to be truly independent in its identity. As I said before, it has a foreign queen on its stamps. Why should it have the British monarch on its stamps--especially when it has such a large French population which has been oppressed under British rule? They are also very influenced by the US. Most Canadians live right next to our border. They are influenced by our media, they shop in our stores, they rely on our military, etc. How could this not be true, they have a tiny population and we have a huge one. Right now, Canada is famous for being nice and liberal, but they haven't figured out how to deal with their deep historic divisions. They're just kicking these troubles down the road. Canada will not have a truly independent identity until they can figure out who they really are.

PrincessNutella · 03/11/2021 14:40

Both Canadians and Americans are, except for Native Americans, diasporic people. We are people who came here from somewhere else. Usually because trauma uprooted our ancestors. It's hard not to be somewhere and think, "how did I get here?" when it is not the continent where your ancestors came from. There is a sense of geographic dislocation that does not go away. And yet, this is the way it has always been for humans. They move to new places. This is why we have brains. To figure this out. And that is why we think about our ancestors. What was it like for this Huguenot who escaped in a barrel in the 1600s? For that Jew who got a visa in Hamburg in 1938? For that Irish girl who held her dead little sister in steerage in 1846 on that boat to Boston? For that Ukrainian farmer who dreamed of having his own wheat fields in Manitoba? For that black child in chains being stared at like property on a hot Savannah day? How did they all survive long enough to make us? It is really a miracle that all of these people made these vast geographic leaps across continents. Maybe people who come from America and Canada feel intrigued by their roots because these were people who really took a grand leap, or because they endured, and both of those things are acts of love and courage.

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2021 14:32

I think it's often rooted in racism and not wanting to be associated with some countries, especially the Eastern Block. They certainly don't want to be associated with Communism or as they confuse the two, socialism. There's a pride that borders on white supremacy.

PrincessNutella · 03/11/2021 14:23

Yes, that was unfair of me. Canada is a lovely country with a very interesting history. I actually love Canada, and I have traveled its entire length on a number of visits. Not only that, I have Canadian heritage! My great-grandmother was a grand lady of Ottawa and I have many Canadian relatives. If you have not been there, it is hard to imagine the grandness of the Canadian landscape. But what I have learned from the Canadian people I have spoken to and from what I have learned is that being Canadian is different from being British and it's different from being American, even though it shares features of both.

RavingAnnie · 03/11/2021 14:13

[quote NotAnotherPylon]@RavingAnnie The OP specifically referenced the fact that, for many Americans, 'roots are a big part of their current identity'. She then went on to say that she had Irish great grandparents and didn't feel connected to her Irish heritage in the same way, perhaps because she is English.

What post are you reading?[/quote]
Same post as you, not sure what your point is?

RavingAnnie · 03/11/2021 14:12

@Verfremdungseffekt Yes I agree those things are also very strange and I don't understand them either. People seem to form very odd emotional attachments to things that are actually nothing to do with them. Presumably gives people a sense of belonging but it seems the basis of this is a falsehood in many of these examples.

NotAnotherPylon · 03/11/2021 13:15

@RavingAnnie The OP specifically referenced the fact that, for many Americans, 'roots are a big part of their current identity'. She then went on to say that she had Irish great grandparents and didn't feel connected to her Irish heritage in the same way, perhaps because she is English.

What post are you reading?

Verfremdungseffekt · 03/11/2021 13:05

[quote RavingAnnie]@justmaybenot Lots of things are different from me but make sense, this doesn't. It makes no sense to suddenly decide you are Irish for example and that becoming a strong part of your identity when you've just found out that one of your GGGPs is Irish and you've never been there! I don't think that opinion is that controversial but obviously it's the internet so people are behaving irrationally as appears to be compulsory these days when someone has a different opinion to you.[/quote]
Lots of things about people's sense of their own identity don't make a lot of rational sense, though. I mean, people's strong emotional connection to 'their' football club (which may be in another country they have never actually been to I discovered when I lived in the ME that all Omani sardine fishermen appear to be ardent Arsenal fans...?) makes zero sense to me at an immediate level, but it doesn''t need to. Likewise people who anthropomorphise their pets, or people with a strong, unquestioning religious faith, or who camp out overnight on the routes of royal weddings or funerals waving flags, or any number of things. I find the strong investment by many English people in a royal family some appear to genuinely feel are their 'betters' absolutely baffling I first arrived to live in England just before Princess Diana's funeral, and found the level of hysteria deeply odd.

There's a current thread on Mn from a woman worried that her 17 year old DD has suddenly said she wants to start going to church. It may of course be that she has her eye on some guy or girl who goes there, but to suddenly start believing in an invisible, but omnipotent supernatural being who never appears to intervene in his creation, but requires regular worship nonetheless is at least as strange as identifying with a newly-discovered Irish heritage and a country you've never been to, surely?

RavingAnnie · 03/11/2021 12:41

@justmaybenot Lots of things are different from me but make sense, this doesn't. It makes no sense to suddenly decide you are Irish for example and that becoming a strong part of your identity when you've just found out that one of your GGGPs is Irish and you've never been there! I don't think that opinion is that controversial but obviously it's the internet so people are behaving irrationally as appears to be compulsory these days when someone has a different opinion to you.

RavingAnnie · 03/11/2021 12:22

[quote NotAnotherPylon]@RavingAnnie you did some delving into your ancestry and made a few interesting discoveries. That's vastly different from a person who has grown up with a sense of identity which has been handed down for generations. People generally don't declare themselves Irish American after a quick internet search. Also, it's not everything about who they are, but rather a part, albeit an important part. I think your comments are rather dismissive and it's a shame you 'just don't understand people who do that'. Maybe read the thread and discover that your position is not the default.[/quote]
But this thread (and my posts) isn't about people who live in strong communities who have a direct connection to a specific country or culture. That's completely different.

derxa · 03/11/2021 12:06

@JaneJeffer

What I don't understand is how you can have pride in something that you haven't done or experienced or influenced? Why pride? I also don't understand "national pride". I'm not proud of just happening to be born somewhere. Likewise how can you be proud of something your past ancestors did or experienced?

It's the month of remembrance ceremonies in the U.K. for people who lost their lives in the wars. You hear people saying how proud they are of their ancestors all the time even though they may never have known them.

Well put
SenecaFallsRedux · 03/11/2021 11:40

I grew up in a state named for "a foreign country's king." Interestingly, no one thought to change its name after the revolution or the names of the other seven states named for foreign royalty.

eggandonion · 03/11/2021 11:04

We have similar commemorative events in Ireland, North and South. I lived in England during the 400th anniversary of the Spanish Armada, which was interesting. Very different to the way the wrecks are viewed around the Irish coast.

JaneJeffer · 03/11/2021 09:57

What I don't understand is how you can have pride in something that you haven't done or experienced or influenced? Why pride? I also don't understand "national pride". I'm not proud of just happening to be born somewhere. Likewise how can you be proud of something your past ancestors did or experienced?

It's the month of remembrance ceremonies in the U.K. for people who lost their lives in the wars. You hear people saying how proud they are of their ancestors all the time even though they may never have known them.

Changechangychange · 03/11/2021 09:38

@PrincessNutella

As far as identity goes,obviously the US is a much more exceptional nation. Its people fought for independence from a colonial rule. it became the richest and most powerful nation in the world. For all of its problems, it still is. Meanwhile, weak little Canada still sells stamps with a foreign country's queen on them.
I think we can all agree that the US is “exceptional”.
JassyRadlett · 03/11/2021 08:34

Meanwhile, weak little Canada still sells stamps with a foreign country's queen on them.

Aaand we’re back to my earlier point about the idea some people have that shared history severed and erased when people emigrate, and belongs solely to the country they left, and not to the new country - even if they helped to build it.

I’m not a monarchist, but fuck me. ‘A foreign country’s queen’?

SickAndTiredAgain · 03/11/2021 07:20

@PrincessNutella

As far as identity goes,obviously the US is a much more exceptional nation. Its people fought for independence from a colonial rule. it became the richest and most powerful nation in the world. For all of its problems, it still is. Meanwhile, weak little Canada still sells stamps with a foreign country's queen on them.
Earlier in this thread you said “I think this thread is incredibly condescending and shows the narrowmindedness and lack of imagination of some British people” You may have been right but to then say “weak little Canada” and your comment yesterday about how Australia and Canada never developed their own distinct identities shows a remarkable level of condescension and narrowmindedness of your own.
EmeraldShamrock · 03/11/2021 06:43

What I don't understand is how you can have pride in something that you haven't done or experienced or influenced? Why pride? I also don't understand "national pride". I'm not proud of just happening to be born somewhere. Likewise how can you be proud of something your past ancestors did or experienced?
Because you can IMO.
I'm proud of my DGM mother running the streets passing letters risking her life for the future generation, her younger brother was shot during the revolution.
It was a very big part of my life growing up and gives me a sense of pride.
I wasn't born had nothing to do with it, fine if you can't understand it.

PrincessNutella · 03/11/2021 04:29

As far as identity goes,obviously the US is a much more exceptional nation. Its people fought for independence from a colonial rule. it became the richest and most powerful nation in the world. For all of its problems, it still is. Meanwhile, weak little Canada still sells stamps with a foreign country's queen on them.

PrincessNutella · 03/11/2021 04:14

Raving Annie is right--different communities bring different customs and values that persist across generations, and one reason we are aware of peoples' heritages is that it helps us to communicate in respectful ways. For example, a young Jewish woman I know was working with a group of South American immigrants. She thought she was being respectful by only saying hello to people who weren't busy working with clients when she entered her workplace. She didn't want to disturb or sidetrack people who were working with clients. But her boss took her aside. He said she needed to go around and greet everyone. That was what they did in his country and that's what he adn all the workers there expected.

SenecaFallsRedux · 02/11/2021 18:27

For me, it’s not a sense of personal achievement, it’s a sense of being linked by my heritage and birth to people who did some things that were objectively incredibly difficult and overcome huge hurdles and hardship, and thinking ‘fuck me, that’s what I came from, what an example I’ve been set, that’s something to live up to and aspire to’.

This is it, in a nutshell. A few years ago, I stood close to the spot where my Scottish many times great grandfather sailed in the late 1700s to North Carolina. He took most of his children with him, but left a married daughter in Scotland, knowing he would likely never see her again. Standing in that place and looking out at the vast ocean, I had a sense of the kind of courage and optimism it must have taken to embark on a journey like that, leaving everything that you know behind. And it is a story that has been repeated over and over again in the history of immigration to the US.

JassyRadlett · 02/11/2021 16:57

This odd idea that Canada doesn't have such a powerful individual identity as the USA is one I have come across before. It is American exceptionalism at its finest.

The look on the Canadians' faces as it was explained to them by American the was quite something. I imagine that an Australian might also have the same look.

This one certainly does.