Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XR are going after the wrong people

37 replies

AsAMatterOfMyArse · 31/10/2021 00:53

And the entire Green movement is too preachy and finger pointy. Plus a bit nihilistic.

Looking at my own life, I don't earn a lot of money and I can't do much to change the world. When folks sit down on the road I'm on to get to my just-over minimum wage job it only makes my life harder when it's hard already. I kind of agree with what they're saying but I can't do anything about it and it makes me stressed when they stop me from getting to work. And yeah I'd like to not have to drive there but I did that for years, getting on buses, and it took a lot of time and a lot of money and I missed out on doing lots of things because I couldn't get to them, and I don't want to go back to that when the enviros aren't giving me a viable option.

I just kind of think they're doing that thing of raising fights against people who are not at the top, like the Tories always want us to do.

Plus they need to wash.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
donquixotedelamancha · 31/10/2021 09:25

Climate change making summers hotter and hotter. UK homes even if old built more to keep heat in than stay cool.

In the UK it's more likely that it will eventually make us much colder as the gulf stream shuts down. Even if not, a two degree difference over a century will not make insulated houses too hot.

On the OP: I agree that IB and XR are imbeciles who are damaging the cause they claim to support.

MadameMinimes · 31/10/2021 09:13

Yep. There needs to be massive, fundamental shifts in government policy.

The “what about China?” argument doesn’t really stack up either. Yes, China has an enormous carbon footprint but a huge chunk of that carbon footprint is generated producing the stuff that we consume and buy in the West. If you allocated the carbon generated in producing goods to the countries where they end up being bought and used then it paints a different picture.

Individual consumer choices aren’t enough. Most people can’t afford to choose more expensive, small-scale produced British goods over mass produced goods from China. Ultimately, the government has to take action to remove the worst choices and worst options. They need to increase regulation on big businesses and force greater environmental responsibility. Prices will go up significantly, businesses will be angry and withdraw political funding or even go bust and the measures won’t be popular, which is why it hasn’t been done already.

IB are a walking PR disaster for the environmental movement but something very fundamental needs to change. It’s not enough to just shrug our shoulders.

If climate change continues, Britain is going to get significantly colder, not warmer. Uninsulated homes will be a huge problem if the Gulf Stream stops. London is further north than Calgary in Canada and Edinburgh is further North than Moscow. If climate change ends the Gulf Stream we really won’t be worrying about our homes getting too warm.

whenwillthemadnessend · 31/10/2021 08:53

I bought a 1870 house in 2019 so single brick

So far we have spent £2000 insulating bedrooms
12k on new Sash windows and new doors front and back
3k new efficient boiler.

8k on damp roofing side wall and floor

We knew we had to do the work and factored in the cost on our offer.
We have most likely increased value but it has made a huge difference so our comfort and efficiency of the heating.
The first winter I was here it was freaking freezing. Now it's been too hot at times and we are comfortable at heating at 19 degrees It's a massive house so that's a huge achievement. Think the windows and doors made the biggest impact

But in order for most to do this three things need to happen

1.Grants or cheap loans provided by govt

  1. Prices to be reasonable and regulated. The difference between some of our quotes was a piss take.
  2. Grade 2 listed homes need to have some of their restrictions lifted windows and doors etc
FuckingFabulous · 31/10/2021 08:49

I personally know someone who is often featured in the press for XR. He's a heavy drug user who steals from his own parents and a horrible little creep who likes to touch up drunk or sleeping women in the various houses he crashes at. He's in his 40s and he's been the same since he was a teen. And yeah, I'd definitely say the term unwashed is fair when applied to him. I can't speak for all of them. But that one, for sure. He also protests against the vaccine and various other things. He protested against anything he could 20
years ago, was always attaching himself to a cause, got done for criminal damage loads of times.

whenwillthemadnessend · 31/10/2021 08:45

#workwoes

Yes totally agree. I pray this summit actually brings a level of acceptance and appreciation and more importantly ACTION from all governments

workwoes123 · 31/10/2021 08:39

They aren’t «going after» anyone, much as in the same way climate change / global heating aren’t «going after» anyone in particular. But your pov encapsulates the biggest challenge to making the changes that are needed.

Global heating doesn’t care that you’re on minimum wage. It doesn’t care why you drive now rather than getting the bus. It doesn’t care whether you think the protestors are grubby looking - or indeed whether they are or not. It doesn’t care if you / we use cloth bags or beeswax wraps 🙄. It doesn’t care about your little life. Or mine. Or our childrens lives.

But we do care about these things, hugely. We care about ‘petty’ little things like finally earning enough to not be forced to get a on crappy bus every day. We care about being able to take our kids on a cheap sunshine holiday once in a while. The changes that are needed will require people to make choices that are directly contradictory to our short term interests - and humans are really bad at that.

Plus, the scale of change required utterly dwarves the impact of individual choice. This realisation is finally starting to dawn on the environmental movement: that the “individual carbon footprint” was invented by BP and marketed by Ogilvy & Mather as a way of shifting focus from their commercial actions not individual lifestyle choices. Hence all this pointless focus on “easy ways to go green” which make absolutely fuck all difference.

So we need governments and multinational corporations to do it for us. Because we cannot do this at an individual level, no matter how many bamboo toothbrushes we buy 🙄.

whenwillthemadnessend · 31/10/2021 08:35

God a ton of spell errors in there. Hope it makes sense Grin

whenwillthemadnessend · 31/10/2021 08:34

I'm def up with the problem being ours. The little man

Yes we can do some small steps but for change to really happen

Big bio needs to carry the load

Change packaging in supermarkets
Govt need to invest in wind and kelp farms
Take away cups need to be banned. It's not hard to carry a reusable cup some even fold up and fit in pockets
Investment in cheap and reliable public transport that actually goes to places people want and need. Not just cities
Food rationing. I'm not suggesting a war time style but we can be rationed in meat sales for example. Only 4'meat dishes a week per person ? Seems reasonable.

I'm Sure there are plenty Fast fashion needs to stop. Maybe swop shops can can set up in city's and towns for good quality clothes

Phineyj · 31/10/2021 08:26

I think the poster who pointed out that well insulated homes could be unbearably hot in summer is onto something. I am lucky that I could afford to insulate and put double glazing in my 70s house. Due to large windows, the solar gain in hot weather is huge. Solar control blinds and curtains mitigate a bit but not enough. IB should probably add shutters, white roofs and public cooling facilities to their list.

Lasttraintolondon · 31/10/2021 08:21

I'm not sure how I feel about Insulate Britain.

I know how I feel about OP though. 'unwashed' - nice stereotyping. Walk through London when extinction rebellion are protesting and go and have a chat with them - turns out they are normal human beings, rather some simplistic daily mail caricature - which is clearly designed to ensure there's no rational debate about climate change action.

Probably the same kind of person that thinks Labour are all communists and the Tories are all Toffs.

sst1234 · 31/10/2021 08:11

@IsleofRum

They do not target China they do not target Russia the do not target India. They do not protest outside these countries embassies, consulates. They are racist / xenophobic.
Because virtues are there to be signalled not lived. Clearly
sst1234 · 31/10/2021 08:09

They are middle class and bored. Needed and hobby and a way to show off their progressive credentials. So they found a ‘cause’. The problem is that they are not too bright. Because UK produces less than 1% of global carbon emissions. Somehow they are not brave enough to protest directly to comrade Xi and grandpa Biden. Wonder why? Because protesting in central London is a nice day out and they feel like martyrs at the same time.
On a separate note, it really is comedic that climate warriors drive diesel cars. Less comedic that they emphatically claim they would block an ambulance that carrying a dying person.

IsleofRum · 31/10/2021 07:34

They do not target China they do not target Russia the do not target India. They do not protest outside these countries embassies, consulates. They are racist / xenophobic.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/10/2021 06:55

[quote Henrysmycat]@OnlyFoolsnMothers I had to not take a job offer as my options for travel were trains tickets that were coming up to £24 per day (and 4 hours door2door commute) or ULEZ and car costs because right now I can’t afford an eco car and small car is not ideal for my job.
And I expect it’d be carnage in London. My friend living just on the ulez borders in Ealing was asked by a random person if she was willing to rent her empty driveway during the working week. I expect the traffic and mess will be spread just outside the ulez ring.[/quote]
This is why I wish groups would campaign for more affordable travel not just keep penalising car users-

SickAndTiredAgain · 31/10/2021 06:53

Just looked up what IB actually want.

All homes in UK upgraded to be decently insulated.

Well ok so that's to reduce use of energy in colder months heating homes.

Got a few thoughts on that

Climate change making summers hotter and hotter. UK homes even if old built more to keep heat in than stay cool. Heatwaves getting longer etc. People getting ill dying etc. Those can afford getting air con things. Make homes even hotter? Hmm.

@NiceGerbil yes…a well insulated home would take longer to cool in summer, if it got warm. But a well insulated home would also keep heat out, so the house doesn’t warm up as quickly/as much. Insulation reduces the transfer of heat, that works if outside is hot or cold - oversimplification but like a thermos flask keeps hot drinks hot in cold weather and cold drinks cold in warm weather. You’d need to consider ways to keep the sun coming in through the windows of course.

Somuddled · 31/10/2021 06:48

You are mixing g up IB with XR. XR specifically want government and big business to change and are very clear that while it's great for individuals to do small every day actions (because it creates markets, demonstrates concerns etc), it is not what will actually prevent the damage. Perhaps do the tiniest bit of research?

UnsuitableHat · 31/10/2021 06:42

Not sure you did your argument any favours with the ‘unwashed’ stereotype OP!

I think the environmental message is a difficult one because a lot of what is being pushed for feels expensive and unrealistic to the average person - plus there’s a sense that you could never quite do enough. This might be why the movement feels ‘preachy’ to you OP- the message needs to be forceful or it’ll be ignored. Perhaps the thing to do is to learn about it, and what you can personally do, gradually.

You say XR are going after the wrong people- what should they do instead? (I don’t have an answer to this, but your OP title suggests that you do, so am interested).

Henrysmycat · 31/10/2021 06:37

@OnlyFoolsnMothers I had to not take a job offer as my options for travel were trains tickets that were coming up to £24 per day (and 4 hours door2door commute) or ULEZ and car costs because right now I can’t afford an eco car and small car is not ideal for my job.
And I expect it’d be carnage in London. My friend living just on the ulez borders in Ealing was asked by a random person if she was willing to rent her empty driveway during the working week. I expect the traffic and mess will be spread just outside the ulez ring.

MoreAloneTime · 31/10/2021 06:31

Also wouldn't you need a car to drive home a foods shop worth of filled containers as opposed to not having a car and having shopping delivered?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/10/2021 06:16

@JamMakingWannaBe

You can take your own Tupperware to be filled at the deli counter in most supermarkets now. It's not about changing where you shop but more about shopping habits. Years ago, we all got free supermarket carrier bags - now we all have to pay for a bag or take our own reusable one. A small, in this example, financial penalty changed habits. Unfortunately these penalties are no longer going to be small and for a lot of people are going to be unaffordable. Who can afford to upgrade their car to an electric or duel fuel for low emission areas?
But you see I don’t buy from Delhi counters or fish counters etc because it’s still more expensive than the packaged stuff or Aldi. Sad because I would like to stop the packaging but supermarkets or the government have to make it affordable- penalising people for doing the right thing builds resentment. Ulez completely screwed my family over financially as we live next to the south circular- I’m bitter!
Henrysmycat · 31/10/2021 06:16

@JamMakingWannaBe people to take their containers to the deli counter? You assume that people on minimum wages have enough money to be able to afford Parma ham, Machengo cheese and sundried tomatoes, right?

That’s the thing with Insulate Britain: it’d full of wealthy individuals that instead of going to the Houses (lords/commons), Prime Ministers residence and lovenests or every other massive corporation’s HQ), they make life difficult for Joe and Jo Bloggs on minimum wage driving a clapped out non-eco car because the latest Electric car costs 2 years rent.
It’s so nice speaking from a place of privilege.
I personally find IB odious individuals that do more harm than good to the eco causes.

JamMakingWannaBe · 31/10/2021 05:36

You can take your own Tupperware to be filled at the deli counter in most supermarkets now. It's not about changing where you shop but more about shopping habits. Years ago, we all got free supermarket carrier bags - now we all have to pay for a bag or take our own reusable one. A small, in this example, financial penalty changed habits. Unfortunately these penalties are no longer going to be small and for a lot of people are going to be unaffordable. Who can afford to upgrade their car to an electric or duel fuel for low emission areas?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/10/2021 04:57

@JamMakingWannaBe

It's much more effective that a lot of people take a little effort to tackle the climate emergency than a small amount of people do a lot.

Everyone can take simple steps: buy food with less packaging, recycle, switch off lights if you are not in the room, take 2 minutes less to have a shower, stop over consumption of plastic toys (from China), reduce use of single use products etc

If EVERYONE did this, it would make a MASSIVE difference and none of it is difficult. The potential future is that we will be forced to live differently and it will be difficult.

I went into a shop without packaging once- everything was pretty much double to triple the price of a supermarket with packaging, Ultimately I cannot afford to shop like that.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 31/10/2021 04:56

I don’t even get their aims- if it’s your house surely the insulation is your cost and if it’s a council home, for many insulation is pretty low down on the to do list. Do they think tax payers really want to pay to insulate council homes- it’s not a vote earner

JamMakingWannaBe · 31/10/2021 04:50

It's much more effective that a lot of people take a little effort to tackle the climate emergency than a small amount of people do a lot.

Everyone can take simple steps: buy food with less packaging, recycle, switch off lights if you are not in the room, take 2 minutes less to have a shower, stop over consumption of plastic toys (from China), reduce use of single use products etc

If EVERYONE did this, it would make a MASSIVE difference and none of it is difficult. The potential future is that we will be forced to live differently and it will be difficult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread