Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It is not people!! It's men!!

161 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 31/10/2021 00:29

Arguing with a male friend who feels men are just as vulnerable as women when it comes to date rape and the new injection of drugs.

I am so annoyed I have walked away. Hes a twat but I need a decent argument as most men are stupid. Not all men but most.

Yabu he's right men are as vulnerable as women.

YANBU kick him in the nuts.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 02:19

It seems strange to me that people esp men who are keen to explain to women that it's not right to focus on MVAWG, never seem to know much about male victims.

I often recommend a couple of charities for male victims and suggest they look into supporting them. It's always ignored though.

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 02:17

On MN which is a female dominated website the focus when talking about sexual violence is on women and girls being attacked which is IMO perfectly reasonable.

Very often there are a few posters who are concerned about male victims and feel that focusing on female victims is not the right thing to do.

I have wondered for a while about the equivalent threads on male dominated websites.

I imagine those on the thread concerned about male victims would have a good idea about those conversations and I think personally for perspective it would be useful to read. As those who are passionate about helping male victims do on MN.

Full disclosure-

I have asked this question/ similar questions on other threads and irl when men started conversations about rape. I've never got any answers really.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 31/10/2021 02:05

Everyone is vulnerable.

But it’s pretty much just one sex doing all the attacking / assaulting / raping / worse.

Why not focus on that?

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 02:01

Thinking about it I think getting better informed about what's going on re this issue would be useful, for me at least.

I know of a couple of good charities that support men around sexual assault and rape.

For those posters who have raised male victims of sexual violence is there any chance you can share-

A chat site/ sites (like MN) with mainly men posting where this issue is discussed? Not victims talking obv but a general community iyswim. To get a feel of the type of things being discussed to help/ reduce etc. It's a different situation to VAWG and so what ordinary men think the best approaches are will help.

I think the situation re police attitude is massive plus under reporting and impact on victims. What sort of things can/ should be done.

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 01:55

Yes indeed. I mentioned the second upthread and the police response with the port case was appalling.

RobertaFirmino · 31/10/2021 01:53

I think taking sexual violence towards me and boys more seriously is a key part in society effectively tackling sexual violence

Yes. Males do get raped. There's the case of Stephen Port, for example. Then there's the man who is said to be Britain's most prolific rapist - Reynhard Sinaga. He is believed to have raped at least 206 men.

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 01:28

Anyway.

Men and women can be vulnerable. Old/ young/ drunk/ bad luck to be in path of sexual predator.

The messages about common sense are the same for all. Stick with your mates, don't wander about the streets, don't get totally fucked etc etc.

It would be good to see this stuff pushed to all esp young people. I don't understand why it seems that the majority of it is assumed at young women, and with a very heavy focus on being sexually attacked by men you don't know on nights out.

What about all the (more common) incidents? Why aren't blokes targeted for warnings about nights out etc when they are at risk of violence?

NadiaVulvokov · 31/10/2021 01:22

Yes, I do think more women are raped than men. Yes, I think women are more physically vulnerable than women/

However, I think many, many more boys and men are sexually abused and raped than we realise.

For women’s here is still a lot of stigma to reporting sexual violence and very little likelihood of justice. For men I think the stigma etc around reporting is in something like the 1970s.

So I think this leads to massive under reporting, even informally, for men. They also are very, very unlikely to be able to talk about it to friends and get an empathetic response.

I still think more women than men are subject to sexual violence/

But I have to say that I think taking sexual violence towards me and boys more seriously is a key part in society effectively tackling sexual violence.

Firstly, it’s the right thing to do. Victims of sexual violence deserve empathy, support and justice. Full stop.

Secondly, the men’s and boys who have suffered sexual violence can be not just allies but partners in the work of making sure sexual violence is taken seriously.

Thirdly, if men and boys are better able to report sexual violence it will break down one of the key misconceptions that often makes men fearful about addressing sexual violence in society. And that is the misconception that men are more likely to be falsely accused of rape than be raped or sexually assaulted. Once men start realising they have more to fear from sexual predators than from being mistaken for a sexual predator there will be a big shift.

I also do often wonder to if some of the people who say “namalt” or “men are just as vulnerable to rape” are people who’s re trying to work their way round to disclosing. And for all victims I think the place to start is “I believe you”. I hey might be wording it clumsily, but let’s face it, men get very little education on how to talk about these things and disclosing is difficult for anyone.

I also think men and boys who suffer sexual violence and abuse are most likely to be abused by men. But this isn’t exclusively so. Of three men I have known who have suffered sexual abuse one was raped by another man. One was abused as a child by his aunt and her son. Another was groomed as a teenager by a much older woman.

Basically I think the sooner we get to a position where sexual violence is framed as “everyone vs the rapists” rather as a “women vs men” issue, the more chance of making real progress in eradicating sexual violence.

For what it’s worth, I do also think that sexually predatory men are the ones who create a culture of “you have to fear a false accusation of sexual misconduct” amongst other men. Seeding fear is a very effective technique to create a false sense of division and a false sense of unity/loyalty. We just need to give that trap no power.

So yes, women are more vulnerable than men to sexual violence. But it doesn’t mean they are immune.

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 01:14

@moanymyrtle

spiking drinks is now done randomly so lots of drinks will get spiked in one club and they then watch and see who doesn’t have a group to look after them and choose the victim. So it’s inevitable with this tactic men and women will get spiked even if the girls are the target. In my 20’s we were told it would be someone targeting us specifically eg chatting us up, asking to buy us a drink so the tactics and scale has changed
This stuff is just scaremongering.

If a man (group of men?) want to carry out a sexual assault then there's way easier ways to do it then this!

Buy all the drugs
Smuggle them in
Drug loads of people randomly without being noticed
Hope that one of them that they've randomly drugged is separated from friends
Then... Get them out/ into a cab/ the toilets? etc without being noticed challenged etc

I mean come on.

If a man or group of men want to attack someone they can just grab a drunk person off the street. Or a sober one come to that...

Justilou1 · 31/10/2021 01:10

Sure they are… Never let statistics get in the way of a good story, Bro.

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 01:08

Got any links?

I mean if it's a thing it's impractical, tricky, and unnecessarily risky and complicated.

Like I say could well be wrong.

Whatever is going on it pales into comparison next to booze. In terms of a myriad of issues. Injury, violence, robbery, sex offences, anti social behaviour etc etc

moanymyrtle · 31/10/2021 01:07

spiking drinks is now done randomly so lots of drinks will get spiked in one club and they then watch and see who doesn’t have a group to look after them and choose the victim. So it’s inevitable with this tactic men and women will get spiked even if the girls are the target. In my 20’s we were told it would be someone targeting us specifically eg chatting us up, asking to buy us a drink so the tactics and scale has changed

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 31/10/2021 01:58

3. I have reservations about this whole needles thing for a variety of reasons. My gut feel is not happening/ one man (med student?) in one area. Could be wrong obv but at mo just seems incredibly unlikely to me.

Sadly it is happening and arrests are now happening across certain areas however I don’t believe they are happening to the scale they are being reported at by the media.

NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 01:48
  1. Most common substance for spiking is booze. Doubles/ trebles instead of singles. Bottle was only a quid more than a glass. Yay I've got a tray of shots! Go on just one more etc.
Using alcohol to reduce inhibitions is kind of accepted though. And if enough to not know what's going on then victim blaming kicks in.
  1. Men who are interested in attacking men surely target gay clubs/ bars, or areas with gay venues. Or men walking home etc. Clubs frequented by straight men (usually in groups) would be way more difficult so why do that?
  1. I have reservations about this whole needles thing for a variety of reasons. My gut feel is not happening/ one man (med student?) in one area. Could be wrong obv but at mo just seems incredibly unlikely to me.
HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 31/10/2021 01:39

OhWhyNot I’m sorry you’ve experience this however that is not my experience and your experience does not generalise men, as mine also does not.

Perspective is very much needed when discussing highly emotive topics

OhWhyNot · 31/10/2021 01:37

Actually my work I support men

But carry on with your nonsense

Heyiam · 31/10/2021 01:33

You’re*

Heyiam · 31/10/2021 01:32

@OhWhyNot coolio, your one of those those that believes In womens rights, as opposed to EQUAL rights.
Genuinely pleased that you can help and support 50% of society (women). Shame about the other 50% (which I believe is actually higher as iirc current more males born than females).

OhWhyNot · 31/10/2021 01:30

I haven’t seen men take to the street to demand changes to laws to protect women, I don’t see men standing up and saying maybe it’s us who should be curfewed, men didn’t fight for women to have safe spaces

I have only once had a man defend men when I have been harassed by another in public and that has happened on a number of occasions

The vast majority of men just turn a blind eye or are quick to tell you not all men are like this Hmm

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 31/10/2021 01:29

Oh shush

As Smart As Bait!!!

OhWhyNot · 31/10/2021 01:26

I don’t feel I need to protest no or to raise awareness. I have worked in dv women had to and continue to have to fight for female victims to have safe spaces (and there is a fight now for keeping these just for females)

I can listen and empathise

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 31/10/2021 01:24

Any decent man would be listening to women’s fears, thinking how they can make a difference and speaking out against women being harassed or worse when they see this happening

The vast majority of men do, it’s a minority of men raping and assaulting women, not the majority,

I believe some perspective is required on here at times when discussion sexual violence.

HailAdrian · 31/10/2021 01:24

Stop minimising violence of men, one doesn’t override the other just because ones statistically higher than the other!!!!!

Oh shush.

Hertsgirl10 · 31/10/2021 01:23

There has been a lot of talk about this injection thing, not a lot of proof though. There’s been so much about people being injected with the date rape & HIV. I don’t know it seems like things keep getting added on to the stories. I don’t believe the injections but I don’t know that drugging has become so causal in most clubs that if someone’s been spiked it seems the younger generation are just like mehh it’s what happens. No one apart from my daughter reported what happened to them to the police.

I think it’s happening within friendship groups and with people they trust. I’m not talking about rape, maybe it’s on a the minds of some but the way it’s so casual I’m finding it difficult to believe the intensions are always to rape. When I say casual, ask any 18-28 year old if they know anyone that’s been spiked, they will say yes, or what this week.

Heyiam · 31/10/2021 01:21

Do you advocate this? Should have been the last sentence sorry. English isn’t my first language

Swipe left for the next trending thread