Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It is not people!! It's men!!

161 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 31/10/2021 00:29

Arguing with a male friend who feels men are just as vulnerable as women when it comes to date rape and the new injection of drugs.

I am so annoyed I have walked away. Hes a twat but I need a decent argument as most men are stupid. Not all men but most.

Yabu he's right men are as vulnerable as women.

YANBU kick him in the nuts.

OP posts:
Bumblenums1234 · 31/10/2021 09:06

No-one is arguing otherwise, as far as I can see?

I was reffering to the original OP, as in her and the guy were having the wrong argument. It's not about who is more vulnerable, it should be about who is responsible.

Brefugee · 31/10/2021 09:04

I think taking sexual violence towards me and boys more seriously is a key part in society effectively tackling sexual violence

the perception among a lot of women is one of utter eye rolling fury at this. Blimey, it's starting to impinge on men's enjoyment of their night out so now we must all pay attention.

My experience is that on IWD i tweet a lot of resources and statistics about VAWG and equality in various things (work, countries, political representation etc) and inevitably spend a lot of the day fending off "but what about da menz". I point out that on International Men's day i do the same thing but about men. And there are some observations:

  1. women never do "what about the womenz"
  2. women are as likely to be doing this as men
  3. men who were vocal about da menz and "why isn't there a men's day" - sometimes i approach them in the run-up to Nov 19 and point out what the year's theme is and ask if they'll join us in raising awareness of resources for men's mental health etc. And except in one case, i have never ever had a positive reply

Women set up, after a lot of campaigning, women's refuges. Women have been protesting VAWG and inaction and victim blaming by the public, the press and the police, for YEARS. And what do we get? Wayne Fucking Couzens colleagues speaking up for him in court etc etc

So yes, violence against men is awful, concerning and not rare. But what are most men doing about it?Are they altering their ways? are they having a Boys Night In? are they asking women with experience in campaigning on such issues for tips and strategies?

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:01

@Bumblenums1234

Men probably are just an vulnerable to these sort of attacks but the perpetrators are basically 100% likely to be men. I think you are having the wrong argument tbh.
No-one is arguing otherwise, as far as I can see?
thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:01

@DickMabutt73962

I think the way to deal with these comments (the first 2 on this thread are good ones) by turning it on it's head, so focussing on the perpetrators as opposed to the victims. A lot of men people take the above tack when they're trying to show that men aren't the problem, as they are victims too.

Men are the problem.

Men are murdered more? Men can also be raped? True, but who's doing en murdering and raping in the overwhelming majority of cases?

MEN.

Yes, men are the problem.

So if I am drugged and anally gang raped, I've bought it upon myself?

It's not in dispute that violence is overwhelmingly committed by men. But this 'all men are violent bastards' narrative is going to fix nothing at all.

Bumblenums1234 · 31/10/2021 08:59

Men probably are just an vulnerable to these sort of attacks but the perpetrators are basically 100% likely to be men. I think you are having the wrong argument tbh.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 08:58

I think men are also very fearful of other men's violence and aggression. the difference is they think they have a chance of defending themselves, whereas women have the fear which is compounded by the fact that most of us are aware the average man is more muscular, has greater body has, is stronger and faster than us.

I'm a feller and I can honestly say it doesn't work like that. Violent arseholes (overwhelmingly men, of course) don't, on the whole, engage in fair fights.

Where men and boys I know have been attacked, it's universally the case that their attackers have been much older, or much younger, or they have been outnumbered, or the other person has had a weapon.

The fact that I am bigger and stronger than most men (and I'm a big guy, though a fair bit of it is lipid) may or may not mean that I'm less likely to be attacked, but it is really no guarantee that I can defend myself, and I can think of a few occasions (one just a few weeks ago) where I have been seriously scared for my safety.

Brefugee · 31/10/2021 08:53

Some poor bloke was interviewed the other day and he'd woken up after a night out, in hospital having been anally gang raped after being drugged in a nightclub.

instantly believed? police right onto it? did anyone ask what he was wearing?

I get it. Men are vulnerable too - so now they are getting date raped with drugs we all have to pay special attention to them as though we haven't been shouting about this since at least the 80s?

Yes. I have sympathy but I'll continue not to engage in discussing it as a competition and i will continue to focus most of my efforts on keeping women safe.

DickMabutt73962 · 31/10/2021 08:48

@Courtier

Both are raped, both are murdered, but it's rare that women do either
👆🏽bingo
DickMabutt73962 · 31/10/2021 08:47

I think the way to deal with these comments (the first 2 on this thread are good ones) by turning it on it's head, so focussing on the perpetrators as opposed to the victims. A lot of men people take the above tack when they're trying to show that men aren't the problem, as they are victims too.

Men are the problem.

Men are murdered more? Men can also be raped? True, but who's doing en murdering and raping in the overwhelming majority of cases?

MEN.

Yes, men are the problem.

Pinkorangutan · 31/10/2021 08:31

The thing is though, the response to someone's fears or description of a traumatic experience is never, or should never be, oh it happens to me/us too. And even worse, well it's harder for me/us.

OP's friend should be empathising with her fears about potential male violence and being drugged. Instead he's being dismissive by making it about the male experience.

If a man was talking about fears of being beaten up or of sexual violence, I wouldn't be saying, oh well, so am I, I'd be talking to them about their feelings and experiences.

I think he's winding you up, OP, and it's not nice.

Jamdown123 · 31/10/2021 08:22

body mass, sorry

Jamdown123 · 31/10/2021 08:21

@Bonsaibreaker

Arguing with a male friend who feels men are just as vulnerable as women when it comes to date rape and the new injection of drugs.

I am so annoyed I have walked away. Hes a twat but I need a decent argument as most men are stupid. Not all men but most.

Yabu he's right men are as vulnerable as women.

YANBU kick him in the nuts.

I don't know the statistics, but I think the incidence of rape is likely to be very high among gay men. It is probably significant even among straight men, as in straight men are being raped by men (whether those men are gay or straight).

Men are truly the problem here.

I think men are also very fearful of other men's violence and aggression. the difference is they think they have a chance of defending themselves, whereas women have the fear which is compounded by the fact that most of us are aware the average man is more muscular, has greater body has, is stronger and faster than us.

So the key is 'vulnerability' here. What does that mean to your 'friend'? I would say whatever the numbers are for men being victim to men's violence it is far lower than it would be if the perpetrating men thought the victim would have little chance of fighting back. This is the situation when men attack women. So we are more 'vulnerable' in that sense - in that the predator deems us weaker by default.

I have a son and he's a baby now. But when he gets older I will tell him that I will love him no matter what, UNLESS that matter includes violence against women and children. If he does that he's lost me forever.

Charlize43 · 31/10/2021 08:19

Not really a question if you've already decided that 'most men are stupid'. Sounds like confirmation bias to me.

ALittleBitWorrriedNow · 31/10/2021 08:07

CourtierBoth are raped, both are murdered, but it's rare that women do either

Totally agree. One of my DSISs male primary school friends was very sadly murdered. I think gay men are also very vulnerable.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 08:04

@Namenic

In terms of drink spiking I would think that logistically it’s harder to date rape a man because 1. Higher dose needed 2. It would be harder to carry an incapacitated man to a private place. Statistically I think for rape, men are more likely to be perpetrators. Most men are heterosexual, so women are more likely to be at risk.

However, as people above say - I think men are more likely to be victims of random stranger assault as there is a taboo against beating women and I think in the case of gang violence perhaps women are not seen so much as a threat?

But in the end - what is the point in the discussion? Tougher sentences on people for violent AND sexual crime would be helpful to deter these acts.

You're missing the point. What we're trying to do here is create a strong narrative between the sexes, to build up barriers and push people apart.

Most decent people recognise the shared enemy here, which is the class of people who are violent arseholes - who are of course, mostly men.

Very few women are in this class, and a significant minority of men. They make the world fucking miserable for everyone else. Please can we show a little analytical rigour instead of posting crap that seeks to divide people who are basically on the same side. Posting 'all men are stupid' is wankerish and just escalates things.

Namenic · 31/10/2021 07:58

In terms of drink spiking I would think that logistically it’s harder to date rape a man because 1. Higher dose needed 2. It would be harder to carry an incapacitated man to a private place. Statistically I think for rape, men are more likely to be perpetrators. Most men are heterosexual, so women are more likely to be at risk.

However, as people above say - I think men are more likely to be victims of random stranger assault as there is a taboo against beating women and I think in the case of gang violence perhaps women are not seen so much as a threat?

But in the end - what is the point in the discussion? Tougher sentences on people for violent AND sexual crime would be helpful to deter these acts.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 07:57

I haven't read the whole thread but did see pp's point about sexual attacks as a way of humiliating other men.

Humiliation, vindictiveness and shadenfreude - pleasure taken in the suffering of others, including delight taken in causing or imagining that suffering - seem to me, from observation and experience, to be very male motivations.

I'm not saying no women has ever taken pleasure in another women having failed where she has succeeded, or in observing another's social humiliation. But vindictiveness and its active pursuit and fantasising about same, seems to be an automatic 'go to' for many, many men, in a way that it is not for most women.

anon12345678901 · 31/10/2021 07:55

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Everyone is vulnerable.

But it’s pretty much just one sex doing all the attacking / assaulting / raping / worse.

Why not focus on that?

This. Of course men can be vulnerable, it doesn't matter that it happens less, the fact that it happens to men, means they too can be vulnerable.
Cam77 · 31/10/2021 07:48

@Onlinedilema
Again I'm not victim blaming but it absolutely is a fact that if men altered their behaviour like women feel obliged to do then they would not get attacked as much

I dispute that. As a teenager growing up in a random town, there were about a dozen occasions when either myself or my two/three friends were attacked walking down paths in broad daylight. Usually these were groups of young hooligans aged say 14-20, but the threat is already very real at that age as many teenagers have the strength of adults, with even less sense of criminal responsibility. Women are sometimes less likely to be targeted for these random acts of violence (not sexual assaults) as there is still something of a stigma about violence against girls/women. As a parent of both, I’d definitely be more worried about one being a victim of other violence and another victim of sexual assault. The stats back this up, while your take is pure speculation, and indeed doesn’t chime with the personal experiencesof many, many males who have been attacked in broad daylight.

GCAcademic · 31/10/2021 07:43

@Hont1986

Between 2012 and 2018, 436 individuals prosecuted for rape in England and Wales were recorded as women.
Given that the police allow rapists to self-define their gender and that we know that there are obviously male rapists defining their gender as female, that number tells us very little.
lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 07:40

Men do almost all the murdering and raping. Most men are heterosexual, so most rape and sexual crimes are against women.

Let's also remember that most male sexual harassment and everything between that and rape are motivated by power, anger and a desire to exert control, not by sex (as in attraction). (Rather, normal male sexuality is not all about attraction but that's a diversion). They use anything from sexual language to their penis as a weapon. [Rape as a weapon of war is a large-scale, institutional example. Soldiers can be ordered to rape numerous women as a military attack and they do it].

Men attack and murder each other and that can include attacking strangers. But most murder of men is of violent men, who are already fighting, or violent criminals themselves, not of ordinary men.

knittingaddict · 31/10/2021 07:38

Most men aren't stupid.

Men have been drugged, raped and murdered.

The vast majority of victims are women.

Almost 100% of perpetrators are men., so much so that it's reasonable to say 100%.

Hont1986 · 31/10/2021 07:32

Between 2012 and 2018, 436 individuals prosecuted for rape in England and Wales were recorded as women.

Cam77 · 31/10/2021 07:28

Important to know what the actual stats say and argue from there (see above), rather than just making shit up.

rwalker · 31/10/2021 07:28

@Bonsaibreaker
as most men are stupid. Not all men but most.

A passive aggressive way of implying all .

Swipe left for the next trending thread