Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It is not people!! It's men!!

161 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 31/10/2021 00:29

Arguing with a male friend who feels men are just as vulnerable as women when it comes to date rape and the new injection of drugs.

I am so annoyed I have walked away. Hes a twat but I need a decent argument as most men are stupid. Not all men but most.

Yabu he's right men are as vulnerable as women.

YANBU kick him in the nuts.

OP posts:
thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 11:08

@Onlinedilema

Thedancingbear can I ask, do you always drive or get a taxi if you are alone at night or in a strange or slightly rough area? Did you make sure you only ever walk along well lit, main roads, even if it means adding time into your journey. Do you avoid places where groups of females are? Or makes are? Are there pubs for example where you would never, ever go in just from 'a bit feeling'? Do you make sure you son never, ever walks anywhere alone? Do you walk with your car keys between your fingers ready to use as a weapon? I could go on but this is stuff all women consider doing. That is down to make violence nothing else. If you don't have to do all of this then you are putting yourself out there in a way that women just don't. Once again, if women walked around like men do they would be attacked far, far more. It must be frustrating for decent men, I know dh gets annoyed when I slate men but seriously he has never had the shit that I have had to tolerate.
I can absolutely relate to some of this.

I grew up in a rough area and there were absolutely streets that you wouldn't walk down after dark. There are loads of pubs I wouldn't go in. I have been randomly attacked several times in my life.

My DS was relieved of his phone by some scumbags last summer. We managed to retrieve it but now I worry every time he leaves the house on his own, in part with the same scumbags in mind. We're in a 'naice' middle class town now fwiw.

Male violence has been a blight on many men's lives too. I recognise that women as a group have it worse. But there are people of both sexes on the same side.

Onlinedilema · 31/10/2021 10:40

Thedancingbear can I ask, do you always drive or get a taxi if you are alone at night or in a strange or slightly rough area?
Did you make sure you only ever walk along well lit, main roads, even if it means adding time into your journey. Do you avoid places where groups of females are? Or makes are? Are there pubs for example where you would never, ever go in just from 'a bit feeling'? Do you make sure you son never, ever walks anywhere alone? Do you walk with your car keys between your fingers ready to use as a weapon?
I could go on but this is stuff all women consider doing. That is down to make violence nothing else. If you don't have to do all of this then you are putting yourself out there in a way that women just don't. Once again, if women walked around like men do they would be attacked far, far more.
It must be frustrating for decent men, I know dh gets annoyed when I slate men but seriously he has never had the shit that I have had to tolerate.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 10:35

@thedancingbear

I'd agree with you there *@Jamdown123*. On a class analysis, it's not a fair fight. I was as much trying to make the point that violent men are - ironically - by and large - cowards. And that being a feller isn't, of itself, a bulwark against violence because the situations in which we're able to defend ourselves are, almost by definition, those in which we are not likely to be attacked.
And, in fact, it makes me wonder whether the oft-quoted stat that men are as likely/more likely to be victims of violence of is bollocks, as it just doesn't stand up to reason.
thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 10:33

I'd agree with you there @Jamdown123. On a class analysis, it's not a fair fight. I was as much trying to make the point that violent men are - ironically - by and large - cowards. And that being a feller isn't, of itself, a bulwark against violence because the situations in which we're able to defend ourselves are, almost by definition, those in which we are not likely to be attacked.

Jamdown123 · 31/10/2021 10:28

@thedancingbear

I think men are also very fearful of other men's violence and aggression. the difference is they think they have a chance of defending themselves, whereas women have the fear which is compounded by the fact that most of us are aware the average man is more muscular, has greater body has, is stronger and faster than us.

I'm a feller and I can honestly say it doesn't work like that. Violent arseholes (overwhelmingly men, of course) don't, on the whole, engage in fair fights.

Where men and boys I know have been attacked, it's universally the case that their attackers have been much older, or much younger, or they have been outnumbered, or the other person has had a weapon.

The fact that I am bigger and stronger than most men (and I'm a big guy, though a fair bit of it is lipid) may or may not mean that I'm less likely to be attacked, but it is really no guarantee that I can defend myself, and I can think of a few occasions (one just a few weeks ago) where I have been seriously scared for my safety.

Perhaps I should have been more clear. here goes:

I think men are also very fearful of other men's violence and aggression. the difference is the me who are doing the attacking think the men they are targeting have a chance of defending themselves.

The, I go on to say that if men were much smaller, less physically strong, etc etc they would be more likely to be attacked.

I COULD say then, in response to your comment:

The, I go on to say that if men were much smaller, less physically strong, etc etc they would be more likely to be attacked without extra force of a weapon or others in on the fight.

Fact is sir, women are more vulnerable because we are smaller, less strong, slower. So on this we are certainly agreed, it's nota fair fight.

This is the case. Ask any woman who has been held down by a man. A man with no weapon, no mates around, who hasn't even used a drug to sedate us. Held down, and almost nothing can be done.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 10:15

Most violent offenders are male is a statement of fact and not the same as all men are violent offenders.

I recognise that. But there are a number of posts above which talk about where responsibility lies for male violence. It seems to me that there are two possible answers. It is the responsibility of violent men, or it is the responsibility of all men.

It's obviously true to say that violent men are responsible for their own actions. So any other conversation about 'responsibility' is looking to shift blame onto people who are not violent, and are often victims.

Just out of interest are you contributing to discussions about male violence on any predominantly male forums? Or have you just dropped into to tell women how to discuss it without offending men.

This is the only forum I post on. I have called out misogyny and contributed to discussions about male violence on social media, in my own name. I have contributed thousands of pounds worth of pro bono work to organisations that help prevent VAWG (in a very specific context that would be outing). I have put myself in harm's way to protect women on a number of occasions, including intervening in a DV situation a few weeks ago, which resulted in me getting punched for my efforts.

When women start conversations about male violence we are talking about violent males which by definition excludes non violent males. The demand that every conversation must be prefaced with NAMALT is really fucking tiresome and only ever comes across as an attempt to shut discussion down, if that's your position you are part of the problem.

I completely understand that. I've been round here for years and get the NAMALT thing. it has been done to death and the succession of men who post NAMALT on here boils my piss (and I've helped to call them out). I was trying to make a specific point about how we ascribe responsibility for VAWG (following a not-terribly-well-thought-out OP, which itself casually talks about inflicting violence) and clearly haven't made that out as clearly as I'd've liked - in part because it's not 100% clear in my own head, and I apologise for that.

PurpleDaisies · 31/10/2021 09:55

But this 'all men are violent bastards' narrative is going to fix nothing at all.

Who is saying that? Dh is not a violent bastard. Neither are any of my make friends.

That doesn’t change the fact the the overwhelmingly majority of violent bastards out there are men.

FOJN · 31/10/2021 09:52

But this 'all men are violent bastards' narrative is going to fix nothing at all.

I can't see anywhere where anyone has said that.

Most violent offenders are male is a statement of fact and not the same as all men are violent offenders.

Just out of interest are you contributing to discussions about male violence on any predominantly male forums? Or have you just dropped into to tell women how to discuss it without offending men.

When women start conversations about male violence we are talking about violent males which by definition excludes non violent males. The demand that every conversation must be prefaced with NAMALT is really fucking tiresome and only ever comes across as an attempt to shut discussion down, if that's your position you are part of the problem.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 09:43

Bollocks. Got my own acronym wrong there didn't I.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 09:42

We get it, NAMALT right?

Men as a sex class =/= any particular man as individual.

It really is that simple. Please take up any objections with the rulers of English grammar.

I might feel motivated to start 'NAMMMALTs' Not All Middle Class Mums Are Like That.

(I derided unknown numbers of anonymous posters on another thread the other day, as 'middle class mums meet Hell's Angels' for their jaw-droppingly selfish, rule-breaking, libertarian, exceptionalist ideas and actions. I am a middle class mum. I managed not to include or offend myself).

Chocolatewheatos · 31/10/2021 09:41

Men are not as, but are also, vulnerable to rape. And one could argue that its much more taboo a man being raped and those that are are less able to seek support from their friends and family and the police and that men are less aware of the risks and dangers because they're not taught about it like we are. I remember a serial rapist that was inviting men who's phones had died to go to his apartment to use his phone and offering them a drink. The idea of going to a strange man's apartment and accepting a drink, especially without my phone, is beyond me. But the felt safe, because they're men.

But as has been said, its mostly men doing the raping of both men and women. But we as a society shouldn't be allowing anyone to rape or abuse anyone . And we should be supporting everyone who has been raped.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:33

@Justilou1

Wow! Why is the mans getting so cross when the wimmins are throwing around the same logic used against us all the damn time? Does lil mans think that wimmins arses don’t get raped too? (Mine needed reconstructive surgery when I was drugged and raped at 14. No point reporting it, as the disproportionately extreme response to picking me up from hospital told me already how much support I’d be getting if I did.) Maybe his arse is sacred because of the sunshine, etc - therefore has more value than wimmins arseholes.
Ah fair enough. As I've said, I understand your anger, and though you won't believe me, I'm genuinely sorry and angry that these things happened to you.

I'll keep doing my bit to try to keep people safe from male violence. You do you.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 09:32

Anyway, back to the point of the thread.

None of the men who ever come out with this (again IME) care about men/ boys being victims of sex offences at all. They just enjoy winding women up about men raping us...

This has been my lifelong experience. A LOT of men actively enjoy winding women up about the threat of sexual violence 'out there', as a way of trying to confine us to the domestic sphere / keep us living in fear as way to distract us from thoughts of power / or to boost their own credibility as our 'protector'. Of course the type of man who likes to do that is usually more inclined to be a controller than a protector.

Decent men IME, recognise the real threats to women and feel no need either to inflate or diminish them. (Whether they'd accept any slight curtailment to their own freedom to achieve that, is another question).

Justilou1 · 31/10/2021 09:30

Wow! Why is the mans getting so cross when the wimmins are throwing around the same logic used against us all the damn time? Does lil mans think that wimmins arses don’t get raped too? (Mine needed reconstructive surgery when I was drugged and raped at 14. No point reporting it, as the disproportionately extreme response to picking me up from hospital told me already how much support I’d be getting if I did.) Maybe his arse is sacred because of the sunshine, etc - therefore has more value than wimmins arseholes.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:29

@lottiegarbanzo

You are all men, the universal man, omnipotent and responsible for the actions of all men *@thedancingbear* ?

Think you've confused yourself with God there.

No. Not at all. The opposite. The point is that I can't control these fucking arseholes. They're a threat to me, a threat to my partner, they're a threat to my kids. They're a threat to the poor woman who I saw being dragged down the street by her hair just a few weeks ago.

I am very keen to work against these scum, to make us all safer, to end this shit. I've done loads to try to do this, including compromising my own safety on a couple of occasions. I have done hours of pro bono work to help campaigns that protect vulnerable people against (predominantly) male violence.

But I won't be tarred by the same fucking brush as these people. I can completely understand why women distrust men, why they may want to lash out at any man who comes into view. But it fixes nothing because it doesn't reflect the true character of male violence.

Bumblenums1234 · 31/10/2021 09:26

...is the reply of someone who has lost the argument

Have a good day

You too sweetheart

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:23

@Bumblenums1234

So by your logic, as a man, I'm partially responsible for my own arse rape. Cheers for that

I guess it would depend what colour pants you were wearing.

...is the reply of someone who has lost the argument.

Have a good day.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 09:23

You are all men, the universal man, omnipotent and responsible for the actions of all men @thedancingbear ?

Think you've confused yourself with God there.

Bumblenums1234 · 31/10/2021 09:22

So by your logic, as a man, I'm partially responsible for my own arse rape. Cheers for that

I guess it would depend what colour pants you were wearing.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:18

@Bumblenums1234

So again, if I am drugged and anally gang raped, I am responsible for that?

Ermmm almost certainly a man. I don't really understand what you mean? I said I think both sees are as vulnerable to male violence, sexual or otherwise. The OP states that she was arguing because she thinks women are more vulnerable to date rape/injections as men. I don't think they are and the vulnerability of the person does not change that it is men who are responsible.

So by your logic, as a man, I'm partially responsible for my own arse rape. Cheers for that.
Bumblenums1234 · 31/10/2021 09:16

So again, if I am drugged and anally gang raped, I am responsible for that?

Ermmm almost certainly a man. I don't really understand what you mean? I said I think both sees are as vulnerable to male violence, sexual or otherwise. The OP states that she was arguing because she thinks women are more vulnerable to date rape/injections as men. I don't think they are and the vulnerability of the person does not change that it is men who are responsible.

lottiegarbanzo · 31/10/2021 09:14

OMG @thedancingbear the perpetrator (almost always male) is responsible, the victim is the victim.

Mouseonmychair · 31/10/2021 09:11

So this thread supports an act of violence against men. i would argue women can be pretty stupid and violent too (the statistics for women killing their own children are pretty horrific but slip out of Mumsnet discussions) but when they do it they are excused see the thread about not sending women to prison. So no it would be unreasonable to say most men are stupid (that is statistically the other way round if anything) and it is unreasonable to advocate violence against a protected class.

thedancingbear · 31/10/2021 09:09

@Bumblenums1234

No-one is arguing otherwise, as far as I can see?

I was reffering to the original OP, as in her and the guy were having the wrong argument. It's not about who is more vulnerable, it should be about who is responsible.

So again, if I am drugged and anally gang raped, I am responsible for that?
maddy68 · 31/10/2021 09:06

I have to say the only people I know that have been date raped (drugged) have both been men. I think it's very prevelant and not really talked about especially on the gay scene

Swipe left for the next trending thread