Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

what do i do

114 replies

agnesireland · 30/10/2021 23:08

so i need to move asap for a fresh start for me and ds3 (13) and dd2 (10). theres a few reasons why and i dont want to drip feed but i'm trying to keep this short and to the point. we’re living in NI right now but i want to leave the country for good. we will be potentially homeless soon. i cant decide between nevada (my mum and stepdad live there) or scotland where my brother lives with his family. i’m basically looking for a complete fresh start bc I cant live this life anymore… i need to leave with my youngest two. i want ds2 (he’s 15) to come too but his dad wont let me .
please help what would u do in my situation? i want whats best for my kids but i also need out of this environment

OP posts:
Hertsgirl10 · 31/10/2021 18:46

I haven’t read the whole threat but I get the feeling that speaking to woman’s aid would be a good thing for you? Are you able to get the contact details or can I get them for you?
I think I understand what it is you need to run from ❤️

NeedAHoliday2021 · 31/10/2021 18:32

I would say the best place is where you want to call home. What’s your plan re work when you do move and where gives you the best opportunities for work? What are you going to change to get out of the current situation? Your past sounds chaotic but you want to make a change and you really can do it. Scotland is probably a better option thinking of your dc further education options.

agnesireland · 31/10/2021 18:14

@Kanaloa will reply properly to everyone later but it's ok dw about it, im sorry if i seemed too antagonistic, i take things too personally and lash out .. so im really sorry if i came across as rude cause that wasn't my intention either

also yea i think america was more of a pipe dream.. it has too many logistical issues ur right. i was just thinking that the two places i could 'get out ' to were there and scotland and id already tried to make a fresh start for my self in america in my twenties

OP posts:
agnesireland · 31/10/2021 18:12

@bigbeautwoman

OP I feel like there is something you are failing to tell us? Why are the children all over the place? What are you running from?
im trying to reply to everyone but i have to go out for a job in a bit so i just wanted to clear this up first.. im really bad at telling things coherently and leaving out information ect but basically

-my mum is american and she moved back there when i was 8, i stayed with my dad and stepmum, i left school without qualifications bc i got pregnant at 16 and didnt see a point .. stupid i know. im stupid. i had dd1 when i was 17, i lost custody of her when she was 3 cos i was homeless and addicted and my dad and stepmum became her legal guardians

-id barely spoke to my mum since she abandoned us but she reached out after i lost dd1 and offered to pay for me to move in with her on the promise that i went to rehab ( i did and got clean ) then i met ds1's dad, again a very bad relationship and when we broke up we were juggling custody.. in the end his aunt got custody of ds1 and shes basically raised him as her own son in california

-i moved back to ireland and met ds2's dad, he lived on a halting site and we were married with ds2 within a year. if youve never been on or known anyone whose lived on a halting site.. some are probs really nice but all the ones ive lived on have been fraught with domestic abuse, addicts, kids leave schools very young , it drove me back into a dark place and was a very unhealthy relationship. i met my younger two kids dad and left with him bc he promised me a better life, said he wouldnt hurt me, i tried to come back for ds2 but his dad wouldnt let me near him and i ended up letting him have full custody.

im not trying to excuse myself bc the point is ive been a shit mum and my eldest three are better off without me, ive made HORRIBLE choices and hurt them but ive also not had it easy.. abuse started at 11.. im 45 now and it's my last chance to be a ' normal ' mum. i just want to give my kids a safe HOUSE ( or flat ) to come home to , not a trailer, i don't want them around anyone using drugs, i want to get a job and have a career like normal women can.. i dont want another man, im not dating anyone ever again and i know i need therapy to help me stop going back to abusive men.

i just want a fresh start and it feels like this is my last chance for me and my dc.. i know this time im the parent theyre better off with.. as much of a fuck up as i as

OP posts:
5128gap · 31/10/2021 18:05

Scotland, no question. Much less upheaval for your DC. Nevada isn't going anywhere and will be there as a future option if you would prefer, when you only have yourself to think of.

Kanaloa · 31/10/2021 18:00

And I think to be even considering a move to the states with this type of mindset is almost dangerous in its lack of forethought. I mean you didn’t seem to have any consideration for healthcare, the different schooling systems, whether or not you could legally take the children there. I think that’s what gave me the impression this was more of a mad dash away from problems than a considered and thoughtful move that you think is best for the children.

Kanaloa · 31/10/2021 17:57

I’m not trying to attack you at all. I’m sorry you felt that I was, sometimes in writing it’s hard to convey tone I think. And I was trying to give you advice - my advice was to consider some professional help.

I think this ‘run away to America’ thing just sounds like the daydream that everything will be better somewhere else but unfortunately that’s rarely the case. Move to Scotland if you think it will suit but in my experience unless you do some serious work in a year or so you’ll be wondering where to move for a new fresh start. I would at least consider the freedom programme and some counselling for yourself and the kids.

agnesireland · 31/10/2021 17:56

@Smilerjone

I am not clear that you could afford to rent in Scotland or the USA (if you are allowed to move there). How would you afford healthcare in the USA? Could the father of the younger children stop you taking them? How could you afford to fight that?

Not trying to be pessimistic, you sound like you know you need a change and to do better but perhaps start small, a permanent job for example, so you can build up experience that you could take with you and get a reference.

so my plan would be to stay with family ( if i go to america, my mum + stepdad and if i go to scotland then my brother ) until i've saved for a deposit on an apartment for the three of us. healthcare would be an issue yeh .. when i lived in the US before i was on my mums healthcare insurance and then there was a period where i just didnt have insurance at all. obviously in scotland health care wouldnt be a problem.

their dad wont care that i take them.. like he literally doesnt give a shit unless hes trying to use it as leverage to control / belittle me.

OP posts:
bigbeautwoman · 31/10/2021 17:53

OP I feel like there is something you are failing to tell us? Why are the children all over the place? What are you running from?

agnesireland · 31/10/2021 17:51

@Wingedharpy

Where would you live in Scotland? Is the plan to move in with your brother and his family? If so, has this been discussed with him (and his wife/partner, if relevant), or are you assuming he would support the move?
yes thats the plan until we get on our feet ( so for a few months until ive got a deposit for our own place ). hes not spoken about it with his wife yet bc hes waiting on my decision between american and scotland but tbh im almost 100% set on scotland now
OP posts:
agnesireland · 31/10/2021 17:48

@flirtygirl thank you so much for your response. people not rtft have made me feel really shit tbh .. i keep saying im not happy living in this place , i feel like people dont know how bad halting sites can be , im surrounded by addicts including the father of my children.. why on earth is it more logical to stay living there..

i cant move in NI, our social housing lists in my county are so long that my kids would literally be in there 20s by the time we got a place .. and i cant afford to rent locally, even if i could i dont have anyone i could use as a guarantor and the family i have here i cant live with cos either a ) no space or b ) theyre also addicts and in similar shitty situations.

in scotland my brother has said he'll help me out.. him and his wife and kids are the only family i have over there but they're all clean hardworking decent people . we would be safer there. im committed to building a better life for my kids , as soon as we arrive in scotland (if thats where we go) im going to start applying for jobs and saving up a deposit ect.

also thank you for ur REALISTIC input of what social services would be like ... i mean those of us on halting sites they treat badly enough and dont give a sh*t unless theres actual really bad abuse going on in the home and even then sometimes they won't do a thing.. everyone has this idea of social services being this magical thing that solves everything but ive been involved with ss my whole life ( since i was 14 ) , i know the realitys .

thank you so much for your kind response and for taking the time to understand my dilemma Daffodil

OP posts:
FancyNan · 31/10/2021 17:47

@agnesireland you are very welcome. I hope you and your family manage to settle down in a safe environment. You've won half the battle by wanting to change things for the better. Now do some research and contact organisations who can help you to escape.

Details for apprenticeships, there's no age limit so don't be put off by it being associated for teenagers. You can start an apprenticeship at any age.

www.gov.uk/become-apprentice

Wingedharpy · 31/10/2021 14:12

Where would you live in Scotland?
Is the plan to move in with your brother and his family?
If so, has this been discussed with him (and his wife/partner, if relevant), or are you assuming he would support the move?

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 31/10/2021 13:45

@Kneller92

I would say Scotland would probably be less of a culture shock for you and your children plus still close to family members and ability to go back to NI more easily to see your son should the opportunity arise
I agree with this.

Scotland is a much more practial choice.

allupsidedown · 31/10/2021 13:40

Come to Scotland. It isn't far if you or you children living in NI need/want contact. It would be less of a culture shock for the kids too. It would be fairly cheap to get here and some areas are more affordable than others.
Some parts of highlands can be pretty remote. It sounds like you need to get close enough to your siblings here but you need a community that you can become part of...it takes a village and all that.
Also look for a place that would have good access to services in you start struggling with addiction again.
Good luck

agnesireland · 31/10/2021 13:30

@50ShadesOfCatholic thank you so much.. wow thats an inspiring story and has given me some hope ( although i doubt id ever end up that successful haha ) , ive always thought id be good at social work or something like that bc ive been through it all and understand the system ( unfortunately)!

sorry i missed where a pp mentioned the freedom programme , is that to do with getting away from my kids dad / abusive relationships i presume?

@Pottedpalm wow thank you i really thought i sounded dumb af haha , i left school at 16 without any worthwhile exams, someone else mentioned adult apprenticeships which might be a good idea.. i like ur idea about someone on the site teaching me to drive. my brother in scotland is a driving instructor and said if ended up moving over there he would teach me so theres that option too i guess

@ThinWomansBrain yes i think a lot of people havent rtft and have missed a few details.. thank you for understanding.. ive been clean for seven years and i feel like everyone is still picturing me rigging up with my kids dad every night Grin

OP posts:
flirtygirl · 31/10/2021 13:23

Op will you fall foul of local connection rules when getting housed?

Even moving locally within NI could be difficult. I don't know about Scottish rules but one way is to contact women's aid and similar.
As they can help those leaving violence navigate the rules.

The rules of local connection keep many women living in violence.

flirtygirl · 31/10/2021 13:19

Scotland has the benefits system and whilst crappy in the UK, its a hundred million times better than the US.

Scotland actually giving more than England.

Stompythedinosaur · 31/10/2021 13:18

I think if be trying to find somewhere in NI to base yourself, at least until your elder dc are adults.

flirtygirl · 31/10/2021 13:17

Hi op those who listened and read your replies properly have said Scotland sounds best.

Those saying to stay Ioving on a halting site and with a violent addict, just have not been reading at all. Especially when you t alk about being surrounded by other addicts.

Can you move in NI? if not then Scotland sounds like your best bet. It sounds like your brother would be a help but either way you need to search out counselling and support.

Social services are unlikely to be any help especially as your kids are not facing violence. Others will say they will help but the reality of social services is they get involved in the worst cases (or the ones where no help was really needed and they were heavy handed.) There seems to be no middle ground for true support from social services like what you need.

An addiction and recovery charity could be helpful if you can find one that covers the area you live in or move to.

The USA is f ar worse for addiction and recovery services if you have no money.

Moving is very hard but it does sound like what you need. But you need to work on yourself and your continued recovery.

Good luck op.
I wish you all the best.

agnesireland · 31/10/2021 13:15

@EveningOverRooftops thank you for such a throughout and considerate answer. i feel like not many people on this thread dont fully understand addiction which is obviously not there fault and its better that people don't understand it cos it means theyve never been through it.. ive been sober for seven years so i dont think id be that tempted to relapse especially as id be in an enviroment (whether nevada or scotland) where no one is using around me. but ur completely right and i need some professional support , i will seek that out for definite . thank you so much x

OP posts:
Smilerjone · 31/10/2021 13:14

I am not clear that you could afford to rent in Scotland or the USA (if you are allowed to move there). How would you afford healthcare in the USA? Could the father of the younger children stop you taking them? How could you afford to fight that?

Not trying to be pessimistic, you sound like you know you need a change and to do better but perhaps start small, a permanent job for example, so you can build up experience that you could take with you and get a reference.

agnesireland · 31/10/2021 13:06

@Orla1970

Hi OP. few things from me. Where about in the Highlands does your brother live? Obviously some parts are very rural so not being a driver may be a challenge. Do your kids want to move away? What’s their thoughts on this? In relation to work there are an abundance of care worker vacancies right across Scotland. if this is maybe something you would be interested in, initially might help you get on your feet until you figure out longer term career plans. For your own support I’d check out what the recovery support is available too as well done for being in recovery but a big move etc will be stressful so good to have a support network in place for you so you don’t relapse. Good luck x
thank you so much for the helpful practical advice.. he lives on the west coast near a town ( kind of half in the suburbs half rural, but once you travel into the town it's urbanized). so its not too rural and the public transport is surprisingly good. in terms of the kids, my son ( 13) isnt so sure but i know its best for him long term, my daughter (10) is happy to move. i would love to do care work, do u mean like nursing homes ?
OP posts:
agnesireland · 31/10/2021 13:00

@Offmyfence

I think you need to try and change your life in NI. Good luck to you.
living in a halting site is half our struggle , and i have next to no support from my family who live over here , i need to get away from my kids dad.. i can see to people not in my shoes how it would be easier to stay but im at my wits end seriously staying here
OP posts:
agnesireland · 31/10/2021 12:57

@FancyNan thank you sm. i didnt know adult apprenticeships were a thing so ill look into that. and yeh the closest city from my brother is like a 2 /3 hours away.. me and my siblings all have weird age gaps so weve not really all lived together since we were young kids so idk if it would help to be around him . but i think it might be nice for the kids to have a father figure nearby..

also thank you for the advice about CAB and thank you so much for the domestic abuse sources. and thank you for being so nice generally , these are all helpful things ill take into account x

OP posts: