Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend has chosen not to attend close friends birthday weekend away

136 replies

freaklikemilkshake · 30/10/2021 19:24

Hi everyone I would like to start this post by saying that I am in Friend A's camp because I have never lost a partner before so I could never imagine what it must feel like to lose someone you was in love with.

So in summary Friend A lost her partner who she knew for less than a year 18 years ago, Friend B has a significant birthday coming up which she has arranged for a weekend away with for her closest friends, the weekend away does not fall on her actual birthday. The death of friend A's partner unfortunately falls on one of the days. Friend A does not want to attend because of this. Friend B rang me earlier and was a bit frustrated that Friend A would not attend and said this "She knew him no more than a year, she has known us for more than 30 years". Friend A over the years has claimed she is a widow when technically she's not, I however feel that it doesn't matter what she describes herself as the pain of losing a loved one does not matter whether you're married or not.

What do you think, would you understand Friend A's decision not to attend? For context Friend B would never say anything to Friend A that she is disappointed etc, she has been nothing but polite and sympathetic to her but has let her true feelings known to me in private.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 31/10/2021 00:39

OP you and B have known A for over 30 years.

A partner died 18 years ago.

You knew him then, and the circs of his death.

So you must have your own opinion of whether A or B are being unreasonable.

As you knew them as a couple and how he died. How old he was etc.

That's pretty fundamental to your question.

So why ask people who don't know any of you to judge whether one of your friends is reasonable in remembering this man on the day he died, or not...?

SelkieQualia · 31/10/2021 00:34

Friend A can decline for any reason she likes, although she sounds a bit unhealthily stuck. Friend B is entitled to some private frustration, so long as she's just venting to you and not gossiping with everyone.

TheAntiGardener · 31/10/2021 00:34

I’m not really seeing the drama here tbh. One friend isn’t going because, worst case scenario, she just doesn’t want to and has come up with a weak excuse. But just as likely, is genuinely marking a sad day in the calendar. Unusual, but not something to judge.

Other friend is miffed, which I think is understandable, and had a moan to you. Hasn’t been unpleasant to A, hasn’t made a meal of it. Just a moan to another friend.

Hardly makes her a selfish twat as one charming post had it.

A rare AIBU where nobody is actually being unreasonable, just human.

alexdgr8 · 31/10/2021 00:25

nobody has to go anywhere.
friend b sounds like a schoolgirl. immature. she needs to grow up.

Cosyblankets · 31/10/2021 00:21

I was widowed.
I remarried
I don't refer to myself as a widow.
The first anniversary, I was going away a few days later and felt I couldn't look forward to the holiday as I needed to get through "that day"
The next one I actually was away and we raised a glass to him

It's not for anyone else to say how she deals with that day but I do wonder how her husband feels

sessell · 31/10/2021 00:20

It's the judgment that's the problem here and in many of the posts. Friend A didn't need to give her reasons, but the date matters to her and she marks it. I do the same with the anniversary of DHs death. I always keep it free, I don't say why, just that I'm busy. Maybe friend A was pushed for a reason. Maybe she has PTSD, maybe she just doesn't want to give up a whole weekend. Whatever, it's her business and should be respected. Those giving judgement and advice should just....

Offmyfence · 31/10/2021 00:04

[quote CavernousScream]@Offmyfence I don’t care that they weren’t married. If she feels like a widow after the death of her partner, she’s a widow. It’s not 1895.[/quote]
I'm also not sure of the use of the word "partner" less than a year in 2003 I think it was probably boyfriend.

Offmyfence · 31/10/2021 00:02

*2003

Offmyfence · 31/10/2021 00:02

[quote CavernousScream]@Offmyfence I don’t care that they weren’t married. If she feels like a widow after the death of her partner, she’s a widow. It’s not 1895.[/quote]
2021, 2093, 1895

She's not and hasn't been widowed.

saraclara · 31/10/2021 00:01

[quote CavernousScream]@Offmyfence I don’t care that they weren’t married. If she feels like a widow after the death of her partner, she’s a widow. It’s not 1895.[/quote]
widow
/ˈwɪdəʊ/

noun
1.
a woman who has lost her spouse by death and has not married again.

People can't just dictate what they are.
They weren't married, she knew the guy for less than a year. It was 18 years ago and she is married to someone else.

To claim that her behaviour within the bounds of normal grief is pretty odd in itself.

CavernousScream · 30/10/2021 23:57

@Offmyfence I don’t care that they weren’t married. If she feels like a widow after the death of her partner, she’s a widow. It’s not 1895.

tedsletterofthelaw · 30/10/2021 23:55

Two people close to me have lost partners young in tragic circumstances.

Both are in new relationships but they will never fully recover from the grief of their losses.

Although I can't even begin to imagine what they went through, I saw and still see what the grief has done to them so I can see why Friend A is still affected by this.

Offmyfence · 30/10/2021 23:55

@CavernousScream

I’m a widow and am part of widow support groups. There are some people for whom having been widowed becomes a very profound part of their identity and I think it sounds like Friend A is one of those people. It’s not just about the grief (and no one has a right to judge how or how long people grieve for), it’s about this event that has shaped them as a person that it’s important for them to continue recognising, to the point where it’s difficult for them to move on from key dates. It’s not unusual for widows to have complex PTSD too, which could be part of this.
She's not a widow, she is however now marred.
saraclara · 30/10/2021 23:53

and no one has a right to judge how or how long people grieve for

Maybe not judge exactly. But a good friend should be actively concerned if someone's grief is stalled and not moving forward. It's not helpful to indulge that, when actually the person needs some help.

And yes, a friend is allowed to feel frustrated at times, when it impacts their lives too.

Mantlemoose · 30/10/2021 23:51

I'm with friend B. Friend A has remarried but is also claiming to be a widow of someone she wasn't married to? I pity friend A's spouse and also the family of the deceased where some random is claiming to have been married to them!

saraclara · 30/10/2021 23:50

I can't imagine being her husband, and having a wife grieving twenty years on.

Exactly. Remembering the guy fondly, yes. But marking the day with such grief that she refuses to have a weekend with close friends on the day?

My DF was widowed tragically before he met my DM and they had me and DB. I have no idea when his first wife died. Doubtless he would remember her with sadness, but he never inflicted it on us or used the date to limit our lives.

B is a drama llama, and calling herself a widow is a great big indicator of that, without the weekend stuff.

ISpyCobraKai · 30/10/2021 23:47

Is she genuinely still really grieving?
If so she needs help, but I've known people like this and its not so much grief, but drama...

CavernousScream · 30/10/2021 23:45

I’m a widow and am part of widow support groups. There are some people for whom having been widowed becomes a very profound part of their identity and I think it sounds like Friend A is one of those people. It’s not just about the grief (and no one has a right to judge how or how long people grieve for), it’s about this event that has shaped them as a person that it’s important for them to continue recognising, to the point where it’s difficult for them to move on from key dates. It’s not unusual for widows to have complex PTSD too, which could be part of this.

phoenixrosehere · 30/10/2021 23:42

It’s hardly wallowing to remember someone on the day they died. Its not every day, it’s one day.

Agree. I can’t imagine telling someone that they need to get over a person they loved’s death because they didn’t know them long enough. Who am I to give a time frame on how long you should know someone before you can grief their passing.

InTropicalTrumpsLand · 30/10/2021 23:40

A was probably still in the honeymoon period when her partner died, daydreaming of a marriage and children and a picket fence... Then these dreams were all taken away. I'd wager she's not actually grieving for the partner, but for what could have been.

Initially I sympathised with her, but yep. I can't imagine being her husband, and having a wife grieving twenty years on.

JustLyra · 30/10/2021 23:34

@CrazyTimesAreOccurring

Why are you supporting Friend A? You are enabling this ridiculous wallowing of nearly 2 DECADES?!!
It’s hardly wallowing to remember someone on the day they died. Its not every day, it’s one day.
JustLyra · 30/10/2021 23:33

[quote saraclara]@Skysblue It's not a bit obnoxious to book a weekend away with close friends for a significant birthday. And no, she shouldn't have to change the date because one friend is still marking an 18 year old bereavement anniversary of someone she knew for less than a year.

Friend B rang me earlier and was a bit frustrated that Friend A would not attend

Being a bit frustrated is hardly bitching. I'd feel the same if not more so if it was my birthday weekend. And I lost my DH after a 35 year marriage.

It would be ridiculous of me to expect a friend not to celebrate her birthday when she wants to, and I'd absolutely go if it was on the anniversary of my DH's death.
I have a lot of empathy for those who've lost a partner, but this is just silly. She has a DH for goodness' sake.[/quote]
Friend A isn’t expecting her not to celebrate her birthday though, she’s simply declined to join.

The only one with ab issue is friend B - who clearly has never heard the MN mantra that’s so oft trotted out about invitations not being a summons.

Patapouf · 30/10/2021 23:30

Friend a needs counselling. Friend b needs to just suck it up if friend A's widow fantasy takes precedence over their friendship.

Courtier · 30/10/2021 23:26

Nobody has to go to anyone's birthday weekend away for any reason tbh. It's only a birthday.

saraclara · 30/10/2021 23:23

Seriously? Maybe she didn't know that friend A refuses to do anything on that day. Maybe it's never cropped up before because there's never been a clash

And jeeze, I can barely remember people's birthdays. Never mind the exact date that one of my friends might not be available because she weirdly marks the death of a boyfriend 18 years ago. Half the time I don't even notice my own husband's death anniversary go by. I would be astonished if any of my friends remembered when it is. Why would they?

Swipe left for the next trending thread