Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“I’m sorry, I just think it’s selfish.”

336 replies

Oneanddonenotenough · 30/10/2021 17:34

I know this isn’t a new subject for here but I’d like to garner general opinion to see if I’ve lost grip on reality and I’m being a precious twat to be a bit upset.

Anyway, I was called selfish by a distant member inlaws’ family today for not particularly wanting a second child.

She asked me the age-old “and when can we expect a sibling for…?”. I initially avoided answering because this question really fucks me off for all the obvious reasons. She pushed for an answer and then started addressing the wider room full of my H’s family saying that she believed it selfish to only have one child. I said I didn’t feel like I wanted a second child, especially as I had suffered with crippling antenatal depression and felt suicidal during my first pregnancy, I’m very happy with my family as it is etc. I wish I hadn’t answered by she had form for holding court and was talking to the whole room saying it would be selfish to my child as they’ll be lonely and selfish to my H for not ‘giving’ him another chance at fatherhood, selfish to not try for one of the opposite gender. Ugh.

She’s a bit batshit but as lots of his family began agreeing that one on their own would be lonely, I’m wondering if I am in fact selfish for only wanting one?

OP posts:
SpaceshiptoMars · 30/10/2021 18:50

Bet that odious relative wouldn't have been up for any child minding later either. Just enjoying herself grandstanding at other people's expense.

Roselilly36 · 30/10/2021 18:48

So rude for anyone inc family to ask such a personal question IMHO. No one else’s business.

jamandmarmalade · 30/10/2021 18:47

Thanks @Nc123 i am also available for Weddings and Bar Mitzvahs.

I can clear a room with one steely eyed stare and maniacal grin.

Do feel free to introduce me to your relative, OP.......
I am a graduate of The Kathy Burke Finishing School, suggest you enrol..

Benjispruce5 · 30/10/2021 18:47

What surprises me more than the obviously none of her business point, is that this is a woman of age and experience. When I was younger I used to think only children suffered a bit. O was the youngest of 3 , DM one of 6, DGM one of 12 etc. But, I had 2 and realised I couldn’t be the mother I wanted to be with more and didn’t try to have the 3 I thought I always wanted. My two now 21 and 18 don’t always get on and it saddens me. DD1 often says she doesn’t want children and I’m totally fine with that and have told her so. She has friends that feel pressure to produce grandchildren and I think that is awful. I had my chance to have the family I wanted, my DD’s decisions are their’s and absolutely nothing to do with me. I will support their choices fiercely.
So surprised that ‘older’ women haven’t come to the same realisation that life has many options and all are equally viable and justified.
Good luck op.

BudgeSquare · 30/10/2021 18:45

I'm the eldest of three, and fuck me I wish my parents had stopped after me.

Fizzbangwallop · 30/10/2021 18:44

I’ve been thinking about having another child but what concerns me is that it may take after you!

Warblerinwinter · 30/10/2021 18:44

@RandomMess

Urgh I have 4 DC, believe me one and done is an equally valid and probably far more sensible choice!!!

Well done on not slapping her Angry

Having children is the ultimate selfish choice. You put your own desire to have a child above logic and being sensible.

I hope you have recovered fully it sounds like you had an incredibly tough time Thanks

This is an interesting statement “ having children is the ultimate selfish choice” At risk of derailing OPs post, which I completely agree is bang out of order, i would question this. Having children is a usually (pending infertility isssus) a natural consequence from sex where no choice to prevent that is used. Hence why big families were the norm going back in time until the mother could long no longer bare kids or even died. We now have to actively choose when not to have children e.g. none at all, some, specific times etc. I think we’ve sort of forgotten this and it leads to a lot of issues with men, and some women. I often think becuase of the struggles biologically and financially with having children it makes for very difficult choices where some couples don’t see eye to eye. Or even decisions over contraception where in a lot of cases men see it as a right to have sex without them even thinking actively about their role in preventing pregnancy,
So I don’t think that it is the correct argument . It is a hard decision and choice to decide when not to have children …but it is entirely down to that family or individual and no one else business for sure. Thoughts?
StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 30/10/2021 18:40

I can understand you not wanting to get into an argument with her considering the nature of the gathering (sick relative) but I would have had steam coming out of my ears. Who the fuck do people like that think they are asking such personal questions and then loudly passing judgement on the decisions you've made? Argh.

If I were you I'd be hard pushed not to pull her up when I found myself alone with her. People like that, people who take pride in speaking their mind and calling a spade a fucking spade, sometimes need to learn the hard way. I like a bit of vengeance though.

Beachmummy23 · 30/10/2021 18:38

I had this in a shop once. I had 9 miscarriages one precious child and got told I was selfish for not giving her a sibling by a random stranger in a shop. I'm more annoyed I was too upset to put him.in his place.

Mydogmylife · 30/10/2021 18:37

@tiggerwhocamefortea

She is of course very very rude and goady to express her opinion openly that way however I personally do think that being deliberately "one and done" as a lifestyle choice ie no medical or financial reasons why you can't etc is a bit selfish and I do think if you have a child you should be prepared to have a sibling but I appreciate that's a pretty unpopular and minority view on MN and why I wouldn't say it to someone's face unless they specifically asked my opinion on the subject.....
I'm sorry what a load of old guff! Thank goodness you don't actually say this to anyone
Eleganz · 30/10/2021 18:37

I'll tell you what is selfish - Thinking a room full of people want to hear your opinions on how many children other people should have because they are related to you.

Skippingabeat · 30/10/2021 18:36

Thank you @Oneanddonenotenough
My point is not having a sibling might be the least selfish and best thing you're doing for your child.

Benjispruce5 · 30/10/2021 18:36

There not theirs.

Benjispruce5 · 30/10/2021 18:35

Sorry you have those in-laws OP. It’s absolutely none of their business. Don’t doubt yourself.Enjoy your child. There are many benefits to you and to your child just as theirs are for more than one child.

1forAll74 · 30/10/2021 18:30

I would say, oh, thank you very much for your unwanted advice, and then stop listening to her diatribe full of rubbish talk.

godmum56 · 30/10/2021 18:29

MN standard response number 273
"Did you mean to be so rude?"

Thelittleweasel · 30/10/2021 18:29

@EllieSattler

Oh so well said Cake

Dacquoise · 30/10/2021 18:24

In my experience family is a lottery at the best of times so the only child being lonely is a bit of a poor argument. I don't see either of my siblings, or any other family, due to a completely messed up familyof origin. I have one DD and she relies on friends, not family, for company which is what I do. We get to choose who we are close to. Have another child because you want one, not because of some theoretical ideal that may not exist.

Nc123 · 30/10/2021 18:24

Just to say that with the world population as it is you could equally argue that it’s selfish to have more than one child.

But really jamandmarmalade is the lady with the answer, so you need to do what she says cause that’s brilliant.

1984Winston · 30/10/2021 18:24

Not selfish at all, I have two because I wanted more than one (shock horror they are the same sex so people assume I will have a third!) But they currently argue constantly!

SpaceshiptoMars · 30/10/2021 18:24

“and when can we expect a sibling for…?”.

"About 9 months after you send us the money for her private education"?Grin

TableFlowerss · 30/10/2021 18:23

Some people have zezo tact. None of her fucking business, how dare she make you feel uncomfortable.

CheesecakeAddict · 30/10/2021 18:22

I have 4 siblings and we never kept each other company or played with each other. The closest thing we got to that was when me and my brother drew penises all over my other brother's school leaver's yearbook. Even now, we are much closer to our childhood friends than each other. It wouldn't cross any of our minds to call each other up (we don't have each others numbers or addresses) and the only time we see each other is when we happen to be visiting our parents. I can't imagine we'll be each others rock when my parents die. We didn't have a big fight or whatever or purposefully go NC, we are just all very different people with our own lives.

My only child dd on the other hand gets 100% of my attention, she has lots of friends and loves spending time with her grandmas, I don't feel she can be lonely.

Oneanddonenotenough · 30/10/2021 18:21

@jamandmarmalade

Well we didn't feel it appropriate to go ahead and add to the family until we had your full stamp of approval. We knew we could count on you to choose an appropriate occasion and audience to air your concerns in full on this highly public matter. If any one has any further questions we can be found in the garden where DH's going to bone me with wild abandon in full view of the neighbours until said bun is safely in my oven
😂
OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 30/10/2021 18:20

@tiggerwhocamefortea

She is of course very very rude and goady to express her opinion openly that way however I personally do think that being deliberately "one and done" as a lifestyle choice ie no medical or financial reasons why you can't etc is a bit selfish and I do think if you have a child you should be prepared to have a sibling but I appreciate that's a pretty unpopular and minority view on MN and why I wouldn't say it to someone's face unless they specifically asked my opinion on the subject.....
And why do you think it's selfish exactly, when outcomes for single children are at least as good, if not better, than outcomes for children with siblings? Why would it be selfish to give your child such a good start in life?