Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“I’m sorry, I just think it’s selfish.”

336 replies

Oneanddonenotenough · 30/10/2021 17:34

I know this isn’t a new subject for here but I’d like to garner general opinion to see if I’ve lost grip on reality and I’m being a precious twat to be a bit upset.

Anyway, I was called selfish by a distant member inlaws’ family today for not particularly wanting a second child.

She asked me the age-old “and when can we expect a sibling for…?”. I initially avoided answering because this question really fucks me off for all the obvious reasons. She pushed for an answer and then started addressing the wider room full of my H’s family saying that she believed it selfish to only have one child. I said I didn’t feel like I wanted a second child, especially as I had suffered with crippling antenatal depression and felt suicidal during my first pregnancy, I’m very happy with my family as it is etc. I wish I hadn’t answered by she had form for holding court and was talking to the whole room saying it would be selfish to my child as they’ll be lonely and selfish to my H for not ‘giving’ him another chance at fatherhood, selfish to not try for one of the opposite gender. Ugh.

She’s a bit batshit but as lots of his family began agreeing that one on their own would be lonely, I’m wondering if I am in fact selfish for only wanting one?

OP posts:
DonttouchthatLarry · 30/10/2021 19:17

I'm an only child - I was never lonely. Sometimes I think I would have liked siblings, but the sort that are in books and films, who all get on and are close. Sadly most people I know do not have these kinds of relationships with their siblings (including DH) so it's not all it's cracked up to be.

I have had to deal with both parents having dementia, moving into care homes, organising funerals and clearing and selling a house all on my own, but going by some of the threads on here about selfish/useless siblings it's probably a blessing that I was able to just get on with it and make my own decisions without having to consider anyone else's opinions or fight over inheritance etc.

parkle · 30/10/2021 19:15

Why stick old in front of it. The person concerned was in her forties.

parkle · 30/10/2021 19:14

@FuckPilledLatteplus, Calling women 'Old Trout" and 'Old Boot' because an assumption is made that a woman being offensive must be old is ageist. The OP later admitted the woman concerned was not old.
There are far too many ageist, misogynistic comments casually thrown around on a site focused on women's issues.

Fenelladepompom · 30/10/2021 19:14

I'm 59, btw.

jamandmarmalade · 30/10/2021 19:14

but she is an old trout Grin

disconnected1 · 30/10/2021 19:13

My brother and myself hated each other growing up, there is only a year and a few weeks between us.

We live within a few miles of each other and haven't seen each other or spoken in years.

I now have an only child and would never subject her to a sibling

Fenelladepompom · 30/10/2021 19:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

FuckPilledLatteplus · 30/10/2021 19:08

@parkle

I have reported this thread (sorry OP, not your fault) because of the number of posters making horribly ageist comments, "old trout, old boot" etc. No where does the OP mention the age of the person who offended her. Sooner or later, MN is going to get into trouble because of the number of posters who deliberately and persistently make ageist comments. Some posters on MN love to combine ageism with sexism, 'sageism' I think it's called. Old Trout , Old Boot , Just how many ways can some posters be misogynistic on a site mainly intended for women? Women do not magically stop being women at the menopause. Although some posters clearly think old women are always to blame for everything. We do ourselves no favours with this clearly discriminatory approach.
Nobody is talking about all old women. People are talking about this one nasty woman. Maybe the internet isn’t the place for you if you find everything offensive.
Peggytheredhen · 30/10/2021 19:07

I posted this on a thread earlier where a women felt judged for having three children, but it applies here too: Women are judged for everything, especially after becoming a parent. Tell her to fuck off.

I didn't say that last bit on the other thread but your relative's comment has really got my goat.

jamandmarmalade · 30/10/2021 19:07

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

'we're mainly doing anal these days'
GrinGrinGrin
kindlyensure · 30/10/2021 19:06

"A Swedish study, published in IOPscience in 2017, found that having one fewer child per family could save approximately 58.6 metric tons of carbon each year in developed countries."

Tell her you're doing your bit for the planet. What's she doing?

parkle · 30/10/2021 19:05

In fact I have taken a screenshot of the first page because of the misogynistic, ageist comments. Some MN posters need to think before they make horribly abusive comments directed at older women ( the OP even admitted the culprit was in her forties) but why waste the opportunity to hurl around 'old boot, old trout' insults on a site intended mainly for women. It's a disgrace.

Courtier · 30/10/2021 19:05

You're not a womb to be used to fulfil the needs of others. Your body, your choice. Nobody is owed children or siblings.

MurielSpriggs · 30/10/2021 19:04

Yes, you are being selfish. In much the same way as she's being selfish for not popping round to do your gardening, clean the house and sort out all the ironing every week for the rest of her life.

It would be really really nice for you if she'd do it. The only reason she doesn't, is that you've no right to expect it, and it doesn't fit her plans. Selfish cow.

thepeopleversuswork · 30/10/2021 19:02

@tiggerwhocamefortea

She is of course very very rude and goady to express her opinion openly that way however I personally do think that being deliberately "one and done" as a lifestyle choice ie no medical or financial reasons why you can't etc is a bit selfish and I do think if you have a child you should be prepared to have a sibling but I appreciate that's a pretty unpopular and minority view on MN and why I wouldn't say it to someone's face unless they specifically asked my opinion on the subject.....
It's unpopular because its based on nothing except prejudice and narrow minded, outdated views of how things "should" be done. There is absolutely no data whatsoever back this view up, its just reheating of old wives tales.

I'm glad you don't say it to people's faces because you will lose friends if you do.

WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 30/10/2021 19:01

@tiggerwhocamefortea

She is of course very very rude and goady to express her opinion openly that way however I personally do think that being deliberately "one and done" as a lifestyle choice ie no medical or financial reasons why you can't etc is a bit selfish and I do think if you have a child you should be prepared to have a sibling but I appreciate that's a pretty unpopular and minority view on MN and why I wouldn't say it to someone's face unless they specifically asked my opinion on the subject.....
You're not even going to give reasons for your bullshit views? Why does a child NEED a sibling?
ColinTheKoala · 30/10/2021 19:01

Yes it's very selfish not wanting to put your body through another NINE MONTH pregnancy, risk daage to your body from it - and indeed risk your second child having a disability. Totally selfish.

Everyone should get pregnant with another child as soon as they've dropped the current one.

Stupid mare. I'd have told her to mind her own f-ing business. My body, my choice. It makes me so angry.

Fenelladepompom · 30/10/2021 19:01

She's a cunt. Next time, pick a response from here, or watch the cricket. Flowers

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 30/10/2021 19:00

'we're mainly doing anal these days'

ThinWomansBrain · 30/10/2021 18:58

next time - if you see this dreadful relative again - just say "we're not having sex at the moment, how frequenly do you have sex?"

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 30/10/2021 18:56

poor you, that's just so horrible of her. what a twat.

you are not selfish for wanting one, in a self-centered meaning.

are you selfish in a self-preserving way? abso-fucking-lutely and good for you!

If it ever comes up again just say "I'm done discussing this, it's none of your business".
read about JADE

parkle · 30/10/2021 18:53

I have reported this thread (sorry OP, not your fault) because of the number of posters making horribly ageist comments, "old trout, old boot" etc. No where does the OP mention the age of the person who offended her. Sooner or later, MN is going to get into trouble because of the number of posters who deliberately and persistently make ageist comments.
Some posters on MN love to combine ageism with sexism, 'sageism' I think it's called. Old Trout , Old Boot , Just how many ways can some posters be misogynistic on a site mainly intended for women? Women do not magically stop being women at the menopause. Although some posters clearly think old women are always to blame for everything. We do ourselves no favours with this clearly discriminatory approach.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 30/10/2021 18:52

@tiggerwhocamefortea

She is of course very very rude and goady to express her opinion openly that way however I personally do think that being deliberately "one and done" as a lifestyle choice ie no medical or financial reasons why you can't etc is a bit selfish and I do think if you have a child you should be prepared to have a sibling but I appreciate that's a pretty unpopular and minority view on MN and why I wouldn't say it to someone's face unless they specifically asked my opinion on the subject.....
Why do you think it's selfish? When DD was growing up my house became something akin to the local youth club she had that many friends around so it couldn't be the lack of a "playmate", which IMO is one of the worst reasons to have a 2nd child. She shared all her toys and understood what "no" meant, so she wasn't spoilt. I was able to afford for me and her to go on a UK holiday every year, so she wasn't deprived of my time and attention, so I ask again, in what way was my decision "selfish"?
Rosscameasdoody · 30/10/2021 18:52

TBH I think you are to be congratulated for not punching her lights out !!

Rosscameasdoody · 30/10/2021 18:50

I know this isn’t a new subject for here but I’d like to garner general opinion to see if I’ve lost grip on reality and I’m being a precious twat to be a bit upset.

I think your in law is the the precious twat who’s lost her grip on reality and you’re more than entitled to be upset. You have your own reasons for not wanting to have another child, and to have someone wade in publicly like this is incredibly ignorant. I’m sorry but I would have told her exactly that.