Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about getting a dog

89 replies

Framings · 30/10/2021 15:38

After my last IVF fail, I'm coming to terms with the turmoil of that. I don't have any family apart from DH and I'm a homebod person without many friends so I feel very lonely.

Someone has suggested I get a dog; I absolutely love animals and would love to.

I'd like a dog from a shelter and have seen a sweet 1 year old rescue that's at the local animal shelter that could be a great fit.

Trouble is, the rescue shelter are very firm on how long you're allowed to leave a dog at home alone for; 3-4 hours max.

Both myself and my DH work part time shifts, and there are 3 days a week where our shifts cross with more than 4 hours gap.

For example, I'll work 5am-11am and he's on a 7am-5pm. He leaves at 6.15am though, and I'm not back until 11.15am.

So the dog would be home alone for 5 hours. Should I be honest with the rescue shelter, or (like my DH suggests) fib and say it'll only be 4 hours? Or just not continue with my application to have her?

I want to do the right thing by the dog and not be selfish about this.

OP posts:
TheVolturi · 31/10/2021 10:07

[quote Andwander]@Meredithwho.you should be reported to the RSPCA.Disgusting to leave a dog for that long.WTF do you have a dog.Selfish![/quote]
Are you for real?

gogohm · 31/10/2021 08:23

Personally I think that's ok typically, but it's breed dependant, some suffer from separation more, and with a rescue it could be they struggle. Plenty of dogs are left all day and are fine, mine is left 6 hours he's older though and quite frankly ignored us for 4 hours + at a time when we worked from home (he goes off into his den (under the desk) and there he stays)

UseOfWeapons · 31/10/2021 06:36

OP, I feel for you. I had unsuccessful IVF many years ago, and now live alone.
However, I’ve adjusted to that, and am content. I would love to have a dog, but the reality is that for 4 days a week, I would need doggy day care, as my hours at work are long and unpredictable. My counsellor tried to encourage me to get 2 dogs as they would, be company for one another. I haven’t and I won’t. I want getting an animal companion to be a joyous experience for both of us, so I’m going to wait until I retire, and have the flexibility to offer a proper home and my time to a new friend.

I realise that this isn’t the same situation as yours, but I’d be straight with the shelter, and have the best interests of the the dog at the heart of what you’re doing. If you and the shelter can find a way to make it work positively for the dog, then fine. But it might be a better idea to cultivate other friendships until you are in a position to welcome an animal who may already have had a difficult time.

Good luck, OP.

MrsGeralt · 31/10/2021 06:21

Why does it have to be this dog? There are thousands of dogs out there in need of a home - I've just rescued a young dog that was given up by his owners because of a relationship breakdown and he's slotted straight in. Unusual i know but they are out there. So far he's been great. So do you maybe have the rose tinted glasses on about how right this particular dog is? If she's been abused she's highly likely to have issues and be less likely to be able to be left alone. Don't lie to the rescue that's a terrible idea. They know the dog and know what she needs. Might be worth revisiting what you know about her and looking honestly at the reasons why you've decided you're the perfect home for her.

Whatever dog you get you'll need to take time off to settle it in. So maybe right now isn't the right time either.

Andwander · 31/10/2021 05:59

The selfishness of people on this thread is staggering.Humans are truely shit.the shelter is totally correct not to leave a dog longer than 3 hours.DONT have have a dog,if you cant provide proper care for it!!

Andwander · 31/10/2021 05:52

@Meredithwho.you should be reported to the RSPCA.Disgusting to leave a dog for that long.WTF do you have a dog.Selfish!

QueenofLouisiana · 30/10/2021 23:21

We introduced our dog walker about 3 weeks in, we were lucky to be able to adopt him during our summer holiday and so could spend a lot of time with him. The rescue (breed specific) were happy with the plan for a Walker on the days I couldn’t be around so much. They were much stricter on garden fence height and based the selection of dogs we could meet on the 5’10” (not 6’ fence) we have.
For reference, we pay £10 for a half hour walk on his own, with putting on his lead, coat in bad weather, muzzle and then drying off, treat time at the end the whole thing is probably 45 minutes. I get photos and messages about the walk. The Walker we use has canine first aid, training qualifications, insurance and a system in place with a local vet for emergencies. I am happy paying someone that committed to the dogs she cares for- definitely preferable to someone earning £5 with none of those things in place.

whereisthekey · 30/10/2021 23:16

an older rescue dog will likely be ok with 5 hrs Max if they are early morning when you're out rather than middle of the day. (my dogs have all not really bothered doing much other than snoozing until 11am anyway when they get ready for their first walk)
But do plan to adopt while you have at least 10 days holiday to be able to take.

the "4 hour alone" time is all day though so have that in mind too.. its not seeing them at 11 and then I going out again for multiple hours in the afternoon too. They are very tying!

shiningstar2 · 30/10/2021 23:13

Our dog 🐶 s a rescu and we always aim for no more than 4 hours separation. See o maybe 10.oo until two a quick ship and lunch ora full afternoon or an evening. Never both in the same day. She is fine with this. She watches to see what shoes)coat we r putting on and either gets excited as it's obviously walk time or goes to her bed. Either way she wags her tail as she goes. We sometimes end up being out a bit later . Maybe5 hours but never more. However we r retired so this is not a problem but so long as you can commit to no more than 4/5 hours away you should be ok op. Ask about which breeds will be most suitable to your lifestyle and I'm sure you wil ge able to give a homeless dog a great new start. Remember u will need patience and expect a few blips along the way but if u r patient and kind u will have a pet who will give back so much in love and loyalty.

LadyCleathStuart · 30/10/2021 23:06

What training and qualifications would I need to walk a dog exactly?

Well you don't need any but the walkers I have used have at least had certificates in dog first aid, one was even a qualified trainer. She often would take on people who wanted to be dog walkers to allow them to get some experience and often they couldn't hack it. I don't think it's as easy a job as people think.

Lavender24 · 30/10/2021 22:49

@FudgeFlake

How much pupternity leave will you be able to organise? You certainly can't go straight in with a dogwalker or daycare until ddog has had time to decompress and settle - this can be several weeks.

Oh and anyone who is doing dog-walking for £5 an hour is almost certainly untrained unqualified and uninsured.

Jesus Christ. Just when you think you've heard it all on this site
Rubyupbeat · 30/10/2021 22:45

Oops....dog walker

Rubyupbeat · 30/10/2021 22:45

If you do decide on a fog walker, make sure they are fully insured.

holidaynearlyover · 30/10/2021 22:41

Ours go to doggy day care and love it there when my husband and I are both at work

TheVolturi · 30/10/2021 22:40

I think the dog will be fine for that amount of time, once he's settled in.
I wouldn't be that keen on having a dog walker (stranger) having a key to my house to be honest, it would have to be someone I trusted.

Darbs76 · 30/10/2021 22:35

I think you do need some time to settle the dog in before leaving for a long period. Some dogs are destructive when alone if they are stressed.

villainousbroodmare · 30/10/2021 22:33

OP, given the choice, I would recommend anyone looking to acquire a dog choose a relaxed and reasonably confident animal. A scared dog can obviously become less so but if I had a choice, nerviness would be my least desired trait in a dog. Just be aware.
Common "rescue" myth: anxiety is mostly due to previous ill-treatment. It is not, it's highly heritable and usually baked into every cell in their bodies from birth.

Scottishskifun · 30/10/2021 22:29

Find a good dog walker.
A good one will set up a session to get to know your dog and pay the bit extra for either a small group or one on one in the beginning.
It's best to introduce this early go with recommendations but meet them too. It's best that this is done early. She will be used to a variety of people from kennels it's about building up that trust.

The most important thing about a rescue is having patience, keeping calm and start training but it has to be gentle reward based training.

Clementineapples · 30/10/2021 22:23

Oh and anyone who is doing dog-walking for £5 an hour is almost certainly untrained unqualified and uninsured

What training and qualifications would I need to walk a dog exactly?

Saoirse82 · 30/10/2021 21:56

Ffs you don’t need to be qualified or trained to walk a dog 😂

Well you might be happy to hand your dog over to anyone but I certainly wouldn't. I'd want someone professional and my dog has no issues either.

hookiewookie29 · 30/10/2021 21:35

*adhoc

hookiewookie29 · 30/10/2021 21:34

I read somewhere that dogs have no sense of time so they don'tknow the difference between 5 minutes and 5 hours..how true this is, I don't know. If they're OK with being left then every so often is fine. If not, look at an advocate dog walker.
Would just like to say though.....we got a dog for our 18 year old daughter. She suffers with her mental health and I'm pretty sure she has ADHD. The change in her since we got him us amazing, he's changed her- and our- life. He's been so good for her x

MujeresLibres · 30/10/2021 21:20

Get a dog walker for those days. I wouldn't leave my dog for that long without company.

tabulahrasa · 30/10/2021 21:07

“it seems unrealistic to think every dog owner is home 24/7”

Well it’s unrealistic in that people do leave their dogs longer than 4 hours... but it doesn’t mean they should.

Studies done on dogs and owners show there’s a huge amount of owners who either don’t care or don’t notice that their dogs are dressed and unhappy to be left alone... owners report at about 30% of dogs, observations on dogs and hormone tests show it to be more like 80%.

That’s a lot of owners insisting their dogs are fine that obviously aren’t.

Dogs are social animals, they need company, if someone can’t provide that and isn’t able or willing to outsource it instead - then tbh they shouldn’t have dogs.

And the choice is not between an imperfect home and stating in rescue forever - other more suitable homes exist.

Framings · 30/10/2021 20:53

@RunningFromInsanity

You know dogs can’t tell the time. They have no idea the difference between 4 and 5 hours.

Just tell the rescue it’s 4 hours/that you’ll get a dog walker.

This is what my DH says too, and it seems unrealistic to think every dog owner is home 24/7. But I do want the dog to have the right home!

Again, and sorry for repeating, but unfortunately I can't take any leave from work, and I work weekends - my job requires all staff to take all holiday by a certain date; no staff are allowed holiday now until January.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread