Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

CM is apparently crippling him financially, and I don’t know what to do

298 replies

CMOrNoCM · 30/10/2021 13:38

ExH sees 7yo DD 1 night a fortnight, that’s it. This is court ordered. He occasionally has her for tea if it’s a special occasion that makes him look better i.e. his birthday, her birthday (which is in the order so can’t stop him) his parents birthdays etc.

He lives in a little house about a mile from me, but has contact at his parents’ 10 miles away as he has a housemate who’s in the other bedroom – DD and he both have their own rooms at his parents.

According to the CMS he earns £180 a week so about £850 a month. He has to give me £102 a month according to CMS.

Recently he’s asked me if we can look at what he pays as he can’t afford to live. He has sent me a breakdown of his outgoings to show he “can’t afford it” and according to that he pays rent on his house and to his parents for the 2 bedrooms there (I can well believe his parents charge him rent for those rooms as when he moved out when we moved in together they had lodgers in them paying around £50pw each – they have two bathrooms so they probably had exclusive use of one of them between them).

In one breathe I feel sorry for him but in another I don’t. I work 25 hours a week and can’t work more as DD has a muscle condition and some learning needs so she struggles with childcare for long periods. Apart from that £102 I get nothing else from him. I get some UC top up but DD doesn’t qualify for DLA or anything and she needs specific things for her condition – don’t tell me to apply for DLA I’ve applied 5 times and been told every time she doesn’t qualify or require more care than any other 7yo, I’ve even been to tribunal over it and had the decision maker upheld. I also think if he lost his job and couldn’t work for awhile I’d have to suck it up and work more myself and pay for more childcare (he wouldn’t have her more). I also work more hours than him usually anyway (I earn between £250 and £300 a week on my 25 hours).

Without the CM I could manage to live, but with CM DD and I have quite a comfortable life, I don’t have to worry about her needing new shoes (£85) or having to give up her extracurricular activities.

Another part of me thinks that I have to parent 95% alone and why shouldn’t he be made to pay at least the legal minimum? I have to pay for everything for her, clothes, shoes, extra activities, as well as bills and food when she’s with me. He refuses to have her 50% of the holidays so I have higher childcare costs then too (can be as much as £100 for 3 days holiday childcare).

So WWYD? Speak with him about a reduction or just ignore?

OP posts:
Kiduknot · 30/10/2021 21:42

No. He needs to contribute to his dd.

He might not like giving up his bed for his dd once a fortnight but tough, we all have to do things we’d rather not.
How much childcare is there to do for one overnight per fortnight anyway, that he needs his mother’s help. He needs to grow the fuck up!

SchadenfreudePersonified · 30/10/2021 20:36

@AcrossthePond55

So, he 'likes' his domestic arrangements the way they are and sees no need to change them in order to have more money. Instead, he expects you to 'retrench' your budget to benefit him.

Not only no, but Oh FUCK No!!!

I'm just curious...why do you 'feel bad' for him? I wouldn't. He's chosen to make his multiple beds, now he can lie in them.

All of the above . . .
AcrossthePond55 · 30/10/2021 20:35

So, he 'likes' his domestic arrangements the way they are and sees no need to change them in order to have more money. Instead, he expects you to 'retrench' your budget to benefit him.

Not only no, but Oh FUCK No!!!

I'm just curious...why do you 'feel bad' for him? I wouldn't. He's chosen to make his multiple beds, now he can lie in them.

Lotusmonster · 30/10/2021 20:02

Ring his parents, ask them if they really charge rent?!!!

Oftenithinkaboutit · 30/10/2021 20:01

You earn between £250-300
You get UC
But that only totals £1200

I’m confused
You will get £324.84 single person allowance plus £237.08 for your one child a month. Plus CB of £140. So £710

Plus you will take home about £1100 a months

So that’s circa £1809 a month without without his contribution

I absolutely think you should insist he carries on paying

But your monthly income without his contribution is much more than £1200 a month

Lotusmonster · 30/10/2021 20:00

Follow your instincts on this OP. There are a lot of vacancies out there, is he actively looking for a job that gives more hours. To me, this sounds like an early effort to slowly withdraw from his responsibilities.

Abraxan · 30/10/2021 19:54

@baileys6904

85 quid for shoes???? For a 7 year old? That's more than comfortable and to be honest, I'd try and give him a break even if just temporarily. Show a bit of kindness now and it may come back in the future
The OP says her Dd has a muscle condition. I would imagine, as they have been priced in the post, they are special ones for her condition.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 19:51

He can make different choices if he wants to. There is no reason DD can't stay at his. Or he can move permanently into his parents house. Or perhaps there are more things he could do to get some extra hours. Either way, it's not your problem. He already gives a pitiful amount to his child and it's time for him to grow up.

2020isnotbehaving · 30/10/2021 19:43

How much is he paying his parents (if at all?) for two nights a month he could get hotel room for £70 night which could well be cheaper. If he’s claiming £50 per week per room as previous lodgers.

whynotwhatknot · 30/10/2021 19:40

He likes the way he lives-tough he has a child to look after so he either

gets another job
drops one of the rents
gets more shifts

also why isnt he having her 50% of the holidays how does he think you organise it all

RandomMess · 30/10/2021 19:38

Stop feeling sorry for him!!!

I hope you are going via CMS especially if he is likely lying about his earnings, you can ask for an annual review.

He doesn't need to have DD at his parents and therefore pay them - he's admitted it's his choice!

Please open your eyes and see him for the person he is rather than the victim he pretends to be.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 30/10/2021 19:21

There's obviously a reason you're not still with him OP, and good job too by the sound of it.

If you pander to this, you are putting his selfish laziness before your daughter's wellbeing. I'm sorry, but it's that simple. He's already quite a shit parent, don't let him lower his standards and hurt your daughter even more.

I wonder about the grandparents and the 'rent'. Charging rent for a room only occasionally used is not really a thing, is it? Not if it's a family member, not if it's a grandchild? I'm not sure I believe it. I think he might have made this bit up.

I bet you're right that his Mum is the one doing the actual caring when they go there though.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 30/10/2021 19:16

@Cottonheadedninymuggins

Why wouldn't he ask his parents for no rent? Or if he can move in with them full time rather than just paying rent for every so often and paying rent for his own place? Or work more hours/change his job?

The very least he can do is provide for his daughter, why should she miss out just because he 'doesn't want to....' do the other stuff that would make more money?

Absolutely!

This is their GRAND-DUAGHTER they are chargng rent for - unless they are (literally - quite literally)on the breadline, they are CUNTS!

(And heaven forgive me - i NEVER use that word!)

Blush
StopGo · 30/10/2021 19:08

26 nights a year are crippling him? I can't imagine the other 339 nights are a walk in the park for you. Best he gets a job or provides childcare whilst you increase your hours. Selfish man.

ThinWomansBrain · 30/10/2021 19:04

For two nights a month, can't he have a zed bed/blow up bed or similar - either for daughter or himself - or a sofa bed and she sleeps in his room?

Wauden · 30/10/2021 19:01

His finances are his responsibility and not yours.

Chloemol · 30/10/2021 18:58

Not your problem. He talks to his parents and asks them not to charge to see their granddaughter.

Why can’t he see her at his house, she sleeps in his room and him on the sofa.?

Why can’t he get more work

youvegottenminuteslynn · 30/10/2021 18:52

He would rather his daughter went without rather than find more work to maintain his (already paltry) £3.35 a day contribution to her wellbeing... god people like him are so fucking selfish.

PooWillyNameChange · 30/10/2021 18:49

No I wouldn't. If he is that hard up he can have DD at his house and not pay his parents rent. Or get another job. I struggle to believe with retail experience he can't find anything anywhere.

He's no longer your responsibility, his daughter however is his!

CaMePlaitPas · 30/10/2021 18:46

I hear the sound of a tiny violin in the distance.

mineofuselessinformation · 30/10/2021 18:45

OP, reading your last post is the clincher for me (I'd already RTFT.)
If he's making the choice of not earning (or declaring) more and of not having DD at his house because it isn't convenient for him, I have no sympathy for him and nor should you IMO.

PennyPinkPineapple · 30/10/2021 18:43

He gives his daughter £3.35 a day and wants to reduce it? 🤨

CovidCorvid · 30/10/2021 18:35

£4 a day doesn’t even cover food never mind other expenses such as heating, clothes, childcare. I’d laugh in his face. He should be approaching his parents before you and asking for a rent reduction. He could get more hours in a supermarket, they’re recruiting like mad round here, he could get bar work, etc.

TravelLost · 30/10/2021 18:32

Honestly? She is his child and she is his responsibility too.

Yiu are working to ensure she has a roof over her head, food on the table and equipment as needed for her. The least he can do is to ensure he can pay CM.
If he thinks it’s too much and he is struggling, then he has to make it work somehow. He can’t just stop paying for his child. I mean what would he do if your weren’t here? Stop feeding her?

CMOrNoCM · 30/10/2021 18:29

Sorry I was catching up on emails from work and forgot to check back.

To answer questions.

Yes DDs condition is diagnosed by an NHS professional but unfortunately she's not bad enough to be considered for shoes on the NHS - we've been for the assessment and this is what we've been told so I have to buy the shoes myself, they are literally the only shoes DD can wear that she can walk in, and walk in without injuring herself - we're not talking falling over and grazing her knee we're talking falling over and fracturing her hip, she fractured her eye socket falling over before we got these shoes and needed surgery to pin it back together so I am not going back there.

I have no idea why he doesn't work more, I suspect he is actually working more and hiding it.

He can't kick his housemate out, they're joint tennants. I have told him DD could sleep in his bed and him on the sofa but he said he likes things the way they are, plus I suspect his mum does most of the actual care. If I go back to court they'd either stick to the current arrangement or remove the overnights which doesn't help me mu ch in terms of working - i currently use breaks and flexi time to sort DD out for school etc. so this is my "catch up" time which I'm paid for, I also like my job and could never quit. I could go up to fulltime but in terms of childcare I wouldn't be any better off financially so I stick with 25 hours for now.

For those asking I earn betwene £250 and £300 a week depends on if I get a bonus or not I do maybe once or twice a month from my job plus I get UC, CB and the CM. So my income total is about £1.2k per month but I spend most if not all of that on DD, I do get my haircut or buy new clothes when I need them. If I didn't get his money I might have to go longer without those, but I would not compromise my DDs upbringing for the sake of a haircut.

The court order actually states 1 night per fortnight overnight, 1 night per week for tea, and 50% of the 2 week and 6 week holidays. He only has her EOW for the 1 night and occasionally for tea for special occasions.

I do feel bad for him of course I do, but it's whether I use that and help him or not, but most of MN seem to think I shouldn't so I will go back and read all the replies.

OP posts: