Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Enthusiastic Consent - I am .. confused.

645 replies

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 11:29

So .. AIBU that the once previously highly held gold standard for consent between partners had to be enthusiastic and complete. Any hesitant or unsure thoughts = a grey area in which the other party should NOT ever step into??

I ask because (I am very new to all this so please be gentle if I've got this wrong) this sudden uprise in trans activists insisting that predominantly gay women (though men too apparently) should willingly sleep with transwomen and transmen regardless of what genitalia they have or where they are in their transition is confusing.

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

I must have this wrong.. surely.. we were banging the #metoo campaign drum not that long ago .. all up in arms about how both parties need to be fully able and willing to consent to engage in anything that could be considered sexual contact.. its how I've been raising my 4 boys .. its what I completely believe in .. that absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to without having to give a carefully drafted PC reason????

[Edited by MNHQ to remove poll]

OP posts:
ArcheryAnnie · 31/10/2021 20:35

So what is the point of the thread? What's the point of the article? What's the takeaway that you think I should learn?

Ijustreallywantacat what I am hoping, from threads like this, and from the BBC article, is that young lesbians will see that they are not alone, that they are not broken, that their desire is not shameful, that their boundaries are not something that others should be permitted to overcome, that they don't need to learn to "cope" with penis-in-vagina sex in order to be seen as a good, progressive person.

If all this news coverage gives just one lesbian a bit of comfort and support to be able to say no, when she's pressured for sex by a male-bodied person, then that's a win.

If all this news coverage enables just one young lesbian not to feel shame at her own same-sex desires, then that's a win.

DrSbaitso · 31/10/2021 20:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ as it quotes a deleted post

BloodinGutters · 31/10/2021 19:50

@Snoozer11

I think all of those who talk about "enthusiastic consent" are virgins.
This is gross and misogynistic
TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 31/10/2021 19:47

I won't say here what he did in public to this 19 year old in front of lots of people in her workplace but it was fucking grim.

Oh Eresh. Flowers for her, wherever she is now.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 31/10/2021 19:45

[quote BloodinGutters]@TalkingtoLangClegintheDark

Betrayal trauma theory or betrayal trauma blindness is the term in children. It’s based on the need to put aside what we know to preserve the bond to our primary attachment figure for survival. Human brains are actually wired up to do this.

While an adult isn’t going to be as dependent as a child for survival, there’s lots of ways in which it must feel that way in some relationships/families/circumstances (prisons for example), and the human need for survival.

If women face how unsafe women are then that would mean facing they are that unsafe themselves. It’s the part of the reason those of us who are survivors of abuse blame ourselves, because it gives a false sense of security. If it’s our fault then there might be a way of figuring why, and correcting it- getting fat of wearing baggy clothes or stop provoking him, stop ending up alone with him and so on- which while it’s a fucking lousy way to live, it’s a lot less scary than facing the reality- that we have zero control over it and we are always at risk of it. It’s a function habit that serves to allow our brains to cope with living in such terror, to give us survival strategies (to our minds they are survival strategies). This is viewed as dysfunctional once we are adults and away from the abuse, but at the time this way of thinking serves a function. Then the neural paths ways link up and it becomes very difficult to change that.

I guess denial is like that.

But despite understanding that mechanism I still want to walk around screaming safeguarding at people, because what the fuck is wrong with adults who have the luxury to be blind to this when children (or women) have no say in being victims of this.

I understand yet I can’t understand at all.[/quote]
Agree with every word.

Snoozer11 · 31/10/2021 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2021 19:36

And yes, I’m sure the fact he was allowed to transgress so openly and his victims either disbelieved or ignored was part of the thrill for him. What a kick he must have got out of being able to exercise all that power over those far more vulnerable than him, being able to make everyone around him treat his sexual gratification as the number one priority.

I won't say here what he did in public to this 19 year old in front of lots of people in her workplace but it was fucking grim.

BloodinGutters · 31/10/2021 19:16

*the human need for survival overrides every other need

BloodinGutters · 31/10/2021 19:12

@TalkingtoLangClegintheDark

Betrayal trauma theory or betrayal trauma blindness is the term in children. It’s based on the need to put aside what we know to preserve the bond to our primary attachment figure for survival. Human brains are actually wired up to do this.

While an adult isn’t going to be as dependent as a child for survival, there’s lots of ways in which it must feel that way in some relationships/families/circumstances (prisons for example), and the human need for survival.

If women face how unsafe women are then that would mean facing they are that unsafe themselves. It’s the part of the reason those of us who are survivors of abuse blame ourselves, because it gives a false sense of security. If it’s our fault then there might be a way of figuring why, and correcting it- getting fat of wearing baggy clothes or stop provoking him, stop ending up alone with him and so on- which while it’s a fucking lousy way to live, it’s a lot less scary than facing the reality- that we have zero control over it and we are always at risk of it. It’s a function habit that serves to allow our brains to cope with living in such terror, to give us survival strategies (to our minds they are survival strategies). This is viewed as dysfunctional once we are adults and away from the abuse, but at the time this way of thinking serves a function. Then the neural paths ways link up and it becomes very difficult to change that.

I guess denial is like that.

But despite understanding that mechanism I still want to walk around screaming safeguarding at people, because what the fuck is wrong with adults who have the luxury to be blind to this when children (or women) have no say in being victims of this.

I understand yet I can’t understand at all.

REDHERO · 31/10/2021 19:08

"Stonewall employed a person they knew taught seminars entitled ‘how to break through the cotton ceiling’.

So no it’s not scaremongering, it’s endorsed by the leading lgbt+ organisation in this country.

Nancy Kelly ceo also said that lesbians should examine their ‘societal prejudices’ if they don’t want to have sex with tw, including the 90%+ who retain their penis.

Stonewall have rewritten the legally protect characteristic of same sex orientation as same gender attracted.

So yes this happens. Supported/promoted by stonewall.

And there’s the first person accounts in the article- are you claiming these lesbians are lying? The two tw in the article who say it has happened to lesbian friends of theirs are lying? Miranda Yardley (tw) also always stood by the fact this happens. And there’s links in fwr that have years worth of evidence to show this happens.

It’s not scaremonging. Stop trying to silence rape victims."

Even when people provide evidence of it happening some in the pro trans lobby say it isn't. Why should a lesbian woman be made to feel guilty or examine anything because she doesn't want sex with a man who now says he is a woman.

REDHERO · 31/10/2021 19:02

Anyone should sleep or have sex with whomever they want with no pressure for any particular group.

I have 2 lesbian friends and they just don't fancy trans women at all. Their choice. I also know lots of men and none of them would have sex with a trans woman. Some men obviously do but many men still see them as not women because you know sex at birth and still seeing them as men.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 31/10/2021 18:46

Anyone who’s interested in the psychological aspect of denial and how powerful it is should watch a documentary called Capturing the Friedmans.

It follows a family where the father and an adult son were both convicted of sexually abusing boys.

What struck me particularly was something the wife/mother said about her husband’s collection of magazines of images of child abuse (this was pre intenet): she said that even though he had the magazines in full view, and she knew they were there, she literally couldn’t see what they were. She could see them, but not see them.

Her psychological need to deny the fact her husband was a child abuser was so great that even the physical evidence of her own eyes failed to reach that part of her brain that would have reacted to it, that would have had to take this information on board and process it. She knew that threatened her whole life and family so she protected herself by blanking out the information even though it was right there in front of her.

All unconsciously, of course. This was by her own account, years later, divorced and looking back in some astonishment at the power of her own denial.

An non-abusive adult woman could actually see these magazines that were full of photographs of men sexually abusing boys, and rationalise them into something perfectly acceptable and normal.

When I see people hand waving away instances of abuse that don’t sit comfortably with their worldview, like they have done on here, I can’t help but think it’s the same kind of process at work.

It’s probably naive of me to be disappointed that posters such as Ijustwantacatreally don’t seem interested in engaging with the issue of how their own behaviour amounts to enabling abuse. I would have liked them to, but instead it’s radio silence or sidestepping. It’s a shame when those who are so vocal when pointing the finger at others have so little to say about their own behaviour and attitudes.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 31/10/2021 18:19

@Helleofabore

I think I asked the question up thread.

How many females being harmed will be deemed the limit before something is done?

Or will it always be n+1 in favour of the males.

Sadly I think it will always be n+1 for some people. Sad
TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 31/10/2021 18:18

I think it’s also worth pointing out that some of the biologically female people harmed by this culture also identify as trans themselves.

I have read several harrowing accounts by young same-sex attracted biologically female trans people who were coerced into sex/raped by older biologically male trans people. In all the accounts, the male person knew the female person wasn’t interested but despite an often repeated “no”, applied huge amounts of pressure until they achieved their aim. Some threatened to “out” their victims as “transphobes” to their community; some took advantage of their position as leaders of a support group for trans youth to groom their victims. Some resorted to physical violence.

To those of you who see yourselves as “trans allies” I ask, which trans person is more vulnerable in that scenario? Which of those people’s rights are you you advocating for? Does the biologically female trans person get a voice, or does that person’s right to a voice have to be sacrificed for the “greater good” of the (predominantly male) “trans community”?

Should these vulnerable young people be silenced and/or ignored along with those other same-sex attracted biologically female people we’ve been talking about here?

Or should we acknowledge there’s a pattern of male sexual entitlement and predatory sexual behaviour here, among SOME biologically male trans people (yes, a minority, but still a pattern) - and the fact of their being trans is what is stopping widespread awareness and condemnation of their acts, and as such, it needs to be addressed?

Helleofabore · 31/10/2021 17:50

I think I asked the question up thread.

How many females being harmed will be deemed the limit before something is done?

Or will it always be n+1 in favour of the males.

Helleofabore · 31/10/2021 17:47

And here is a collection of another group of women writing their stories.

grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/43?utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=cta

Should we be discounting their stories because it shows a group of males that continue to show male patterns of sex offenses despite their transition?

Or should we be saying, ok, there are now more and more stories coming out, perhaps NOW is a good time to listen to these women and understand there is an issue. One that is being swept under a colourful rug of silence.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 31/10/2021 17:45

@Ereshkigalangcleg

And in fact I’ve never even spoken to one person who was a victim of Savile

I have, she was a young woman I worked with in the early 2000s who was subjected to his sexually abusive and inappropriate behaviour in public at a work event and it was laughed off.

Laughed off, minimised, dismissed, the women affected threatened with reprisals as you say in your next post, if they didn’t keep quiet about it.

Always the same dynamics.

I always remember the woman on that documentary about him (after he was finally exposed as the prolific abuser he was) who he assaulted when she was a teenager in a children’s home. When she told the staff there what he’d done, she was punished for “lying” about “Uncle Jimmy”. Solitary confinement, I think - for a 14/15 year old girl.

And yes, I’m sure the fact he was allowed to transgress so openly and his victims either disbelieved or ignored was part of the thrill for him. What a kick he must have got out of being able to exercise all that power over those far more vulnerable than him, being able to make everyone around him treat his sexual gratification as the number one priority.

Anyone seeing any similarities yet?

I really do think some of the “handwavers” (indeed, Datun) on this thread would have responded the same way as the staff at that children’s home, if they’d been in that position, given their reactions to this abuse of lesbians that’s happening now.

FrippEnos · 31/10/2021 17:27

Ijustreallywantacat

What is the point of the thread?

That people with a penis shouldn't be able to call lesbians prejudiced, genital fetishes and transphobic, (and all the other threats on the internet) because a lesbian doesn't want to have sex with them.

bordersmidgebites · 31/10/2021 17:00

60% , the majority, of transwomen were attracted to women according to that link

BloodinGutters · 31/10/2021 16:52

[quote Ereshkigalangcleg]I had a quick look at research this morning and as I said, there has not been much scientific study (as opposed to comment) in the decades since your researcher

From Wikipedia

A 2015 survey of roughly 3,000 American trans womenn^ showed that at least 60% were attracted to women.

[[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgender_sexuality]][/quote]
Gosh we had no SOMEidea did we?

BloodinGutters · 31/10/2021 16:51

I think SOMEbody forgot to put SOME in front of Savile.

SOMEbody else will be along to give you SOMEtelling off soon.

VickyEadieofThigh · 31/10/2021 14:54

I've never understood the 'I've never had this happen/known anyone it's happened to' responses - so fucking what?

I haven't been raped, been in a car crash, been pregnant (and therefore, never had an abortion)...it means bugger all in terms of the scheme of things.

Datun · 31/10/2021 14:37

@TalkingtoLangClegintheDark

Let me tell you about my takeaway from this thread, *@Ijustreallywantacat. What I’m seeing is that there is a cohort of posters - including but not limited to: you, @fallenwood, @toconclude, @DellaPorter, @VladmirsPoutine, @Viviennemary, @Miliao, @ABCeasyasdohrayme and @Lokdok* - who are choosing to deny/dismiss/minimise this particular form of sexual abuse of some of one group of female people by some of one group of male people - and it seems to me that you thereby implicitly condone and enable it.

Just as many people denied/dismissed/minimised the sexual abuses carried out by Savile, by some Roman Catholic priests, by some Muslim men who were part of grooming gangs in various English towns; and thereby implicitly condoned, and enabled those abuses to be much more widespread and continue for far longer, and affect more victims than would otherwise have been the case.

The victims of Savile, of RC priests, of the grooming gangs were all disbelieved, blamed, and vilified for “smearing” their abusers by those around them, including staff at children’s homes, members of the RC church, the police. Some grooming gang victims were themselves charged with “prostitution” offences and I believe one girl was even prosecuted for “harassment” of one of her abusers, seen as “racially aggravated”, before her situation was recognised as abuse.

What you are doing when you disbelieve, deny and dismiss is nothing new. Victim blaming has always been a thing. It is an easier course of action to take than recognising there is a genuine problem in a community you feel part of, or feel loyalty to, or feel protective of. It happens all the time in families where abuse of any kind happens too.

This is one of the ways abusers manage to keep on abusing, how they get away with it. The people around them don’t want to know, have a vested interest in not knowing. It’s not a problem if we don’t recognise it as a problem. It’s not a problem for us.

But it is a very real problem for a lot of lesbians currently. I have personally spoken to a young woman it happened to: a lesbian student who formerly went along with genderist “TWAW” ideology 100%, till she and several of her friends were all sexually assaulted by the same biologically male trans person in their LGBT group. The other testimonies I’ve come across have all been online or from friends of friends, because the lesbians I know are older and/or in long term relationships and so not likely to be targets of this themselves. But they know it’s happening too.

(And in fact I’ve never even spoken to one person who was a victim of Savile or one of the grooming gangs - but I don’t need to, to know those abuses happened. The evidence is there for those who are not deliberately looking away from it.)

It’s not even being denied by those who are fostering this culture. Twitter is awash with “trans rights activists” literally proclaiming it is transphobic for lesbians to be exclusively same-sex attracted. Nancy Kelley herself has equated same-sex sexual orientation with a “societal prejudice”!

The coercion is blatant and highly, highly visible and I’m struggling to find a parallel - all the other agencies that have told homosexual people they need to “rethink” their “prejudice” over the years have been coming from a deeply conservative/religious perspective. The truly shocking thing about this is that it’s coming from those who are supposedly “progressive” and on the side of gay people and gay rights. Supposedly.

If anyone else was telling lesbians their sexual orientation wasn’t completely valid and shouldn’t be respected just as it is, would you accept it? Would you accept it from a church, from a right wing government? If not, why do you accept it from Stonewall and other trans rights bodies/activists? Why is it “conversion therapy” if it comes from a fundamentalist church, but “trans inclusion” if it comes from Stonewall?

Even if it were only a “tiny minority” of biologically male trans people doing this, it would still need to be recognised and addressed. No number of victims of rape and abuse is an acceptable amount of collateral damage. But the fact is, we don’t have any reassurance at all that it’s only a tiny, tiny minority of biologically male trans people doing this, especially when Stonewall itself is supporting the mindset that justifies it.

Just as it’s a fallacy to say that it’s only a tiny minority of biologically male people in general who do or would sexually offend, given the chance. When men speak honestly, without fear of consequences, it turns out quite a few of them are happy to be predators after all. This thread www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/a4387825-Research-reveals-rapes-and-assaults-admitted-to-by-male-UK-students?msgid=112051215#112051215 makes sobering reading: the article linked to has a survey of male students in the UK, 11.4% of whom admitted to sexual offending. 11.4% is a significant minority, and obviously those numbers of offending males can catastrophically impact a much, much higher percentage of female victims, given they will usually offend as often as they can get away with.

There is no reason to think there would be any lower incidence of predators within the biologically male trans population than within the biologically male population in general. The MoJ found that of the 125 biologically male trans prisoners known to be in prison in England and Wales, 60 had been convicted of sex offences. Sixty. Close to half. Which is actually a much higher percentage than within the general male prison population (around 18-20%, I believe). fairplayforwomen.com/transgender-prisoners/

So the statistics that we have (and that women have had to fight very hard to have access to) show that being trans does not in any way lessen the likelihood of a biologically male person being a sex offender. And we know that male people in general are far more disposed to violent and sexual crime than female people. So it is not “transphobic” to extrapolate that there will be a significant minority of biologically male trans people who are sexual predators. Just as in the wider male population.

I am sure, Ijustreallywantacat that you think of yourself as a nice, decent, liberal-minded person who has a keen interest in social justice and protecting the most vulnerable in society. Just like me. The difference between us, I suppose, is who we perceive to be most vulnerable and at risk.

I doubt very much your trans friends are representative of the wider trans population that exists nowadays. I’m guessing they’re “old school”, dysphoric, trying to pass, sexually attracted to males, and possibly yes, quite vulnerable. But the “trans umbrella” has widened considerably in recent years, and includes many males who don’t have dysphoria at all, who were once called cross dressers or fetishists, who are very proud of their “female penis” and very much enjoy using it for sex with women. And some of whom use the protection that being a member of a “marginalised, vulnerable” subset of (male) people affords them to behave coercively and abusively towards some of those women (and girls) they want to have sex with. Or, more properly, the women and girls they want to abuse.

In that scenario, it’s the latter who are vulnerable and at risk, not the former. It’s the latter I care about. And I find it appalling that you don’t.

This is a particular form of abuse being carried out by some members of one cohort against some members of another cohort, and all of you saying it’s transphobic to bring it up, recognise or discuss it are enabling that abuse. That’s how it works. Abuse that isn’t named and can’t even be mentioned flourishes. Abusers thrive on denial.

This (enabling) presumably isn’t what you’re consciously intending to do, but it is nonetheless the result of what you’re doing. Abusive cultures need to be named in order to be tackled. You don’t want people to even name this. It’s shameful.

(If anyone feels I have misrepresented what you’re saying, please do come back and say that you unequivocally condemn all forms of abuse and you welcome any light being shone on abuses that have hitherto been covered up and not spoken of publicly, that you agree that patterns of abuse must be named and recognised in order to be effectively tackled and prevented in the future, no matter who the abusers. I would welcome that most heartily, and so would the women affected by this, I’m sure.)

Excellent post. Comprehensive and undeniable.

I'm still not sure how so many people can hand wave away this issue, when every time a woman even challenges transgender ideology, she gets threatened with rape and sexual violence.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2021 14:28

Because as we now know, he got a kick out of doing it in plain sight, when he knew no one else would do anything and the victim would not be able to object for fear of reprisals. That's how predatory males operate (and some predatory females, yes, but the numbers are much lower statistically).

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/10/2021 14:25

And in fact I’ve never even spoken to one person who was a victim of Savile

I have, she was a young woman I worked with in the early 2000s who was subjected to his sexually abusive and inappropriate behaviour in public at a work event and it was laughed off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread