Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Enthusiastic Consent - I am .. confused.

645 replies

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 11:29

So .. AIBU that the once previously highly held gold standard for consent between partners had to be enthusiastic and complete. Any hesitant or unsure thoughts = a grey area in which the other party should NOT ever step into??

I ask because (I am very new to all this so please be gentle if I've got this wrong) this sudden uprise in trans activists insisting that predominantly gay women (though men too apparently) should willingly sleep with transwomen and transmen regardless of what genitalia they have or where they are in their transition is confusing.

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

I must have this wrong.. surely.. we were banging the #metoo campaign drum not that long ago .. all up in arms about how both parties need to be fully able and willing to consent to engage in anything that could be considered sexual contact.. its how I've been raising my 4 boys .. its what I completely believe in .. that absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to without having to give a carefully drafted PC reason????

[Edited by MNHQ to remove poll]

OP posts:
BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 12:33

[quote Miliao]@Vanishun
Yes, I explicitly said I was assuming the poster’s sex, I don’t know why that confused you?

@Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet
Why would you think I don’t believe this happens, I did not say anything of the sort. Unfortunately I know humans are capable of some very horrible behaviour.

I do not agree with those who don’t agree with this having to speak out about it. It’s not their job. This was exactly the repost of many when some terrorists were found to be Muslim. I do not think all Muslims are terrorists and I don’t believe that Muslims that are not terrorists need to ‘speak out’ and show they aren’t. I don’t see how this is any different here.[/quote]
Muslims in this country would be a minority group.

Transwomen are biological males. Males are the most privileged group that has power over the group women.

Men using their privilege and power to doing something about male predatory behaviour is the bare minimum we should expect of this.

Male violence is the problem of all men. This is no different.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 30/10/2021 12:32

Yes, there are some trans people speaking out about this (Debbie, Rose, Miranda) but they definitely seem to be a minority.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 30/10/2021 12:32

Oh look, another women don't matter comment.

Yawn.

bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 12:31

Given that most transwomen still have a penis you can't even say lesbians don't like penis sex

They are being "encouraged " to accept sex with penis as lesbian sex

DrSbaitso · 30/10/2021 12:31

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

No, of course not.

But the loudest branch of trans rights activists right now says things like that because it isn't concerned with promoting the rights of trans people, it's concerned with erasing the rights of women.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 30/10/2021 12:31

@MamanSparkles

This thread is just a new version of NAMALT. #metoo - response from people who didn't want to deal with male violence was 'not all men are like that'. The response here is identical 'not all TW are like that'. We know that. That doesn't mean we don't need to talk about those who are like this, especially when those who are seem to have a lot of sway with a powerful lobby group. And that's exactly why some TW -Debbie Hayton, Miranda Yardley and Rose of Dawn featured in the article - are standing up against this themselves.
I've not heard of Debbie or rose but Miranda is someone I have a huge amount of respect for. They are balanced and very intelligent.
BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 12:30

@Gwenhwyfar

"I have to say if anyone had sex with out of a sense of obligation or because "meh" or they couldn't be bothered one way or another .. I'd be very uncomfortable.

If someone isn't as raring to go as the other it is .. uncomfortable and as the one more into it I can't see how you'd enjoy having sex with someone who's on the fence about it happening"

That's just your preference though. It doesn't mean a lack of enthusiasm is rape.

Lack of enthusiasm doesn’t relate to enthusiasm for sex, it relates to enthusiasm for consenting.

It means being complete sure you want to consent, even if your a bit meh about sex itself. It means being sure your consent is 100%, not that the consent maybe 60% sure and 1% definitely not sure and 39% social pressure.

VickyEadieofThigh · 30/10/2021 12:30

"Nancy Kelly ceo also said that lesbians should examine their ‘societal prejudices’ if they don’t want to have sex with tw, including the 90%+ who retain their penis.

So, what did Kelley mean if she wasn't calling lesbians bigots for refusing to consider males identifying as women as potential partners?

I'm struggling to infer anything other than this into her comments - and frankly, Stonewall clearly no longer represent the interests of lesbians.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 30/10/2021 12:30

@Regularsizedrudy

Oh look another trans bashing thread thinly veiled as concern for women. Yawn
Wtf?
Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 30/10/2021 12:29

So where are the trans people speaking out against Riley J Dennis, Rachel McKinnon, Drew Deveaux and any number of other TRAs on Twitter who are saying that 'genital preferences are transphobic'? Where are the trans people critically analysing what those people have said, and explaining rest its categorically wrong, with no 'buts'?

Why do the likes of Ash Sarkar say things like 'no one should be pressured to sleep with anyone they don't want to BUUUUUUUT if you don't want to sleep with a woman of colour then that's bigotry, soooooo.....' implying that not wanting to sleep with a transwomen is the same as being racist?

Why does Ruth Aylett, mum of Owen Jones, say on Twitter that lesbians using dildos is no different to having sex with a penis anyway?

For something that 'isn't happening' there seems to be a lot of people tying themselves in knots to try and defend it!

Miliao · 30/10/2021 12:29

@BloodinGutters
I absolutely agree with you, I’m saying the same thing. At no point did I say we can’t speak about this, we need to. But whilst I know some men rape, I don’t believe all men are rapists. That’s the issue I have. I definitely think this needs to be brought to attention, but I don’t think people should be making lazy stereotypes. I get bloody pissed off when people make assumptions about me due to my sex, hair colour, etc.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 30/10/2021 12:28

Enthusiastic consent isn't a difficult thing to understand
It simply means "clearly wants to".
It's not difficult to see the difference between really wanting to have sex with you and really not wanting to.

ArabellaScott · 30/10/2021 12:27
  • YANBU, OP.

absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to

Exactly correct.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 12:27

Can we just be clear: lesbians don’t refuse to have sex with transwomen because lesbians don’t do dick.

They don’t have sex with transwomen because they are only attracted to women.

Women are not just merely men minus a penis.

There are 6000+ physical differences between male and female bodies. There is no way even the best passing transwoman would ever be close to being physically female. Not including the effect of growing up with male socialisation. Lesbians are not merely not attracted to tw because they will always retain male features but because they can never fully fake the 6000+ difference that women’s bodies have from male ones. And lesbians are only attracted to female bodies.

There maybe some women who have only dated women who find themselves attracted to tw, the term for this is bisexual. Homosexuality is a legally protected characteristic and people can force its definition being rewritten.

ArabellaScott · 30/10/2021 12:26

I think most of the pressure and insistence that lesbians should 'examine their prejudice' and 'learn to cope' with penises often isn't coming from trans people themselves, fwiw.

This is about a cultural movement that is seeking to elevate gender above sex. It's linked to 'queer' theory, that seeks explicitly to remove boundaries and erode societal rules.

If one looks at it objectively, it is clearly at odds with any form of sexual orientation that 'excludes' any group.

Regularsizedrudy · 30/10/2021 12:26

Oh look another trans bashing thread thinly veiled as concern for women. Yawn

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 30/10/2021 12:26

Nobody has the right to demand sex.
Who you choose to have sex with is one of very few areas you should have complete control over.
Belief that you have the right to use a woman's body is practically the definition of male entitlement!

bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 12:26

It's rape when you are bullied into to sleeping with sone one you don't want to

Don't belittle the experience of those poor women

MamanSparkles · 30/10/2021 12:25

This thread is just a new version of NAMALT.
#metoo - response from people who didn't want to deal with male violence was 'not all men are like that'.
The response here is identical 'not all TW are like that'.
We know that. That doesn't mean we don't need to talk about those who are like this, especially when those who are seem to have a lot of sway with a powerful lobby group. And that's exactly why some TW -Debbie Hayton, Miranda Yardley and Rose of Dawn featured in the article - are standing up against this themselves.

Gwenhwyfar · 30/10/2021 12:25

"I think in this case it's important to distinguish between "meh, let's give it a go, I'm sure I'll get going once we start" and "meh, you're not gonna stop fucking whinging about it otherwise so it's quicker and easier to just agree to shut you up""

That's not what enthusiastic means though. Both of those scenarios would be unenthusiastic. The second one is the only one that does not reach the threshold of 'freely given consent'.
The enthusiastic thing is a load of bs.

Miliao · 30/10/2021 12:25

@Vanishun
Yes, I explicitly said I was assuming the poster’s sex, I don’t know why that confused you?

@Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet
Why would you think I don’t believe this happens, I did not say anything of the sort. Unfortunately I know humans are capable of some very horrible behaviour.

I do not agree with those who don’t agree with this having to speak out about it. It’s not their job. This was exactly the repost of many when some terrorists were found to be Muslim. I do not think all Muslims are terrorists and I don’t believe that Muslims that are not terrorists need to ‘speak out’ and show they aren’t. I don’t see how this is any different here.

bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 12:24

The only people making this an anti trans thing are the TRA community

The article was very clear .., some ... it also interviewed transwomen who are totally supportive of the victims , who would never accuse someone of transphobia for being homosexual

Gwenhwyfar · 30/10/2021 12:23

"I have to say if anyone had sex with out of a sense of obligation or because "meh" or they couldn't be bothered one way or another .. I'd be very uncomfortable.

If someone isn't as raring to go as the other it is .. uncomfortable and as the one more into it I can't see how you'd enjoy having sex with someone who's on the fence about it happening"

That's just your preference though. It doesn't mean a lack of enthusiasm is rape.

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 12:22

@Ijustreallywantacat

If lesbians refuse even to consider transwomen as partners they'reBIGOTS.

Nancy Kelley did not say this at all.

I have not responded to the ridiculous leading question on the poll. But yes, I do believe that the BBC article and attitudes like this are fear-mongering, hurtful rhetoric. I sat there with my mouth agape.

It's an article that is trying, and succeeding, in making transwomen as a group people to be afraid of.

Are there trsnswomen out there who have pressured people in to sex? Of course there are! That's also true of almost every human group out there. There are transmen who have done so. There are natal women who have done so. There are people from every racial group who have done so. Just like all of these groups, predatory transwomen make up an extremely small percentage of the group and do not represent it in general.

I have spent much of my adult life surrounded by trans, non binary, and gender diverse people as a bisexual woman who for a time identified as a lesbian. Not once have I been pressured or coerced in to sex by them.

I refuse to give in to fear and hatred. Transwomen are welcome in my space.

I think your post is by far the most measured counter response and I absolutely respect what you've said and thank you for your contribution.

Recently the rise of the Incel movement has seen a complete stand against that mindset from straight men. Condemning the incel movement and their social media presence.

Where are the transpeoples response to the as you say, small sect of their community's hate speech about leabians on social media.

I accept wholly that of course not all transpeople think this way however a very vocal, active and vicuous subgroup of their overall community obviously do and the lack of condemnation of it is .. almost as loud.

OP posts:
bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 12:22

Anyone who refuses to speak out about rape because the perpetrators are untouchables is no better than those whi ignored Jimmy Saville, those who ignored the Rotherham gangs , those who ask women not to complain to protect the abusers family

It happens time and time again, and it's wrong

Swipe left for the next trending thread