Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Enthusiastic Consent - I am .. confused.

645 replies

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 11:29

So .. AIBU that the once previously highly held gold standard for consent between partners had to be enthusiastic and complete. Any hesitant or unsure thoughts = a grey area in which the other party should NOT ever step into??

I ask because (I am very new to all this so please be gentle if I've got this wrong) this sudden uprise in trans activists insisting that predominantly gay women (though men too apparently) should willingly sleep with transwomen and transmen regardless of what genitalia they have or where they are in their transition is confusing.

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

I must have this wrong.. surely.. we were banging the #metoo campaign drum not that long ago .. all up in arms about how both parties need to be fully able and willing to consent to engage in anything that could be considered sexual contact.. its how I've been raising my 4 boys .. its what I completely believe in .. that absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to without having to give a carefully drafted PC reason????

[Edited by MNHQ to remove poll]

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 30/10/2021 14:37

Strange how Transmen don’t seem to be as demanding and aggressive .

titchy · 30/10/2021 14:36

Same old same old innit?

SOME men are violent - let's talk about VAWG
That's not fair, NAMALT, so stop talking about it.

SOME people are violent racists - Black Lives Matter
That's not fair, all lives matter.

SOME priests are child abusers - let's talk about it.
That's not fair, priests are all good a trustworthy.

SOME TW are rapists - let's talk about it.
That's not fair - you're making it up, you're transphobic.

Fortunately in the first three examples people are talking about it, and those is authority or who represent the perpetrators who act in their name, have (finally) spoke out and condemned those few.

Sadly, the in the last example, the very group that should be condemning make rapists - the charity that purports to represent lesbians, have instead effectively victim blamed - if they weren't so exclusive they wouldn't be raped. Nice.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 14:36

[quote ohdelay]@BloodinGutters
It might read that way but it's not new for people to pressure women into having sex. "but you hurt my feelings" or "transphobe" should just be words and you still get to make the decision about who you sleep with. The stonewall tw thing might be going over my head as I'm pretty old, but you don't need to be taught how to be a good lesbian. If you're a lesbian, I'm guessing you're just are a lesbian and you fancy women that you fancy and you don't fancy women/men/dogs/chickens that you don't fancy. Maybe this is the issue and people are more stupid/fearful of fallout/mindless than they used to be. Maybe these political organisations telling teenagers who to sleep with should be looked at closely as in my teen years we really didn't need this level of instruction.[/quote]
Just because it’s not new doesn’t mean it doesn’t have devastating consequences. And in this incidence the consequences are for a very small minority group-lesbians- who have the protected characteristic is being homosexual, being women and presumably the belief that sex us real- as that’s clear from Maya’s case is covered under the belief pc. It needs talked about not shut down by saying they should just tell tw to fuck off and be done with it.

Yes we need to be looking at the organisations that go into our schools who teach this ga lighty bs. Why don’t you join fwr threads on getting stonewall etc out of schools. Because despite the new d of e guidance on pshe teaching and despite ofsted themselves dropping out of the stonewall diversity champions scheme, there are numerous schools with ofsted ratings of good and outstanding that breech the d if e, that pay stonewall thousands each year, who break laws on building regulations on schools toilets and who fail miserably on safeguarding.

Read safe schools alliance info and start helping us parents these organisations out of schools. Because I can tell you as a parent it is not easy. I know all the arguments inside and out, I can quote policies and d of e and education & equality acts to school, I can point out precisely where they fail on this and still I’m stuck facing putting in a formal complaint as the informal one has been repeatedly ignored by academy seniors.

It’s very very difficult to make schools follow the guidelines. It shouldn’t be but it is.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 14:32

I see what you're saying, but where do you think that stonewall and other trans activists (as in people who are sincerely standing up for trans people) are going to put their energy - in to the small subset of trans people who do say controversial things, or articles like the BBC, which are tarnishing the reputation of transwomen as a whole? That's what transpeople deal with. That's what the marches and the campaigns are for. To fight against the rhetoric that transwomen are sexual predators. That's more important than policing what people call themselves or getting enraged about hypothetical scenarios.

It's really not OK to defend the right of trans people to prevent tarnishing of their reputation whilst attacking the right of women to defend their safety. Both should be OK. The trans activism and name calling (every debate around the opposing rights issues is NOT transphobic) is unwarranted and aggressive. Some transwomen are sexual predators. You can't possibly think that's not the case.

The situations are not hypothetical and it's disgusting to suggest that actual experiences of rape and assault are hypothetical.

Nancy Kelley and others like her are trying their best to say to you that they agree that coercing people in to sex is wrong. That's what she said. She has a different idea than you about what gender and sexuality is. Fair enough.

No, this is a very unhelpful attempt at gaslighting. If it was OK to have different ideas about what gender is, the fear which women are now experiencing would not have arisen. By attempting to force women to give up female-only spaces because a minority think that gender is different than sex is clearly NOT saying 'fair enough, we have different ideas'. It is an attempt to force your view on others. Saying that transphobia may be the reason a women who fancies women does not want to sleep with a biological male is not a 'live and let live' attitude. It is clearly paying lip service to the idea that coercing people into sex is wrong. It's very much of the 'I'm not racist but....[insert racist comment]' and no-one is being fooled.

Your views only make sense if we accept that TWAW and TMAM. You are attempting to force that belief on others. You are failing to recognise that sexual attraction hinges on how A percevies B. How B perceives themselves is absolutely irrelevant.

LauraJaneJones · 30/10/2021 14:30

@Jaxhog

Wouldn't it be nice if Transwomen came out against the very idea that this could be deemed reasonable by anyone? Rather than denying it as a vicious Terf rumour.
Why is it just like typical male behaviour?
fallenwood · 30/10/2021 14:30

I have a friend who was born male and is now a transwoman, who has been in a relationship with a male, not a trans male, for many years. They are both in their fifties. Neither expected anything, they just hit it off. Neither would think the people interviewed in the article are lying. Neither would expect anyone in particular to sleep with them. These are examples of normal trans people/people in trans relationships, not transactivitists or abusive people who happen to be trans.

LauraJaneJones · 30/10/2021 14:30

@DellaPorter

It's just a load of rubbish scaremongering not grounded in reality, another attempt to turn people against trans women.
Yes just hysterical women crying r4pe, lesbians who only want sex with female people are disgusting bigots. Welcome to 2021.
Jaxhog · 30/10/2021 14:27

Wouldn't it be nice if Transwomen came out against the very idea that this could be deemed reasonable by anyone? Rather than denying it as a vicious Terf rumour.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 30/10/2021 14:27

@ArabellaScott,

You can consent because of your partner’s expectations, should you choose to.

Ultimately, anything that takes freedom from women and tries to redefine a decision other women disagree with as coercion, I am against.

People are allowed to make mad decisions or bad decisions; it is the privilege of being an adult.

As long as consent is not given through fear (real fear, not fear of a sulk), it is consent.

Whether you want to be in a relationship where you feel the obligated to have sex is a good question and one that, as an adult, you need to answer for yourself.

As is often said on MN , a woman is an adult human female, not a child who needs protecting from themselves (even if you feel it is for ‘their’ own good).

Artichokeleaves · 30/10/2021 14:26

Be angry about how a small group of trans people are behaving in an abhorrent and abusive way but make it clear at the same time that that group does not represent the majority of trans people.

Because the most important thing when a group of women speak out about experiencing sexual abuse, and manage to do this against a lot of anger, pressure and attempts to silence them, including from vast, public funded and very wealthy groups...

is to make sure first that they are protecting the feelings and public image of male people. And really, it would be nicer and politer if they just wouldn't mind not talking about it at all. It's not very nice, but really can't they just.... I don't know, put up with it quietly and not make a fuss?

NATWALT. All lives matter.

Feedingthebirds1 · 30/10/2021 14:25

Why does the TWAW agenda focus so much on lesbians who won't have sex with them? Why don't we hear even more about men (who let's face it are more numerous than lesbians) who won't have sex with a TW being called transphobes? is it by any chance because those TW still have the mentality of male privilege and think it's only women who have to subjugate to their ideas? Not a man - basically one of their own?

ChristmasPlanning · 30/10/2021 14:25

@SultansOfMing

Nobody has any right to have sex with anybody.

Everybody has the right to choose who they do and don't have sex with.

Everybody has the right to withdraw consent to sexual activity at any point for any reason.

Unsure why anyone would try and argue different?

@SultansOfMing

This

ohdelay · 30/10/2021 14:24

@BloodinGutters
It might read that way but it's not new for people to pressure women into having sex. "but you hurt my feelings" or "transphobe" should just be words and you still get to make the decision about who you sleep with. The stonewall tw thing might be going over my head as I'm pretty old, but you don't need to be taught how to be a good lesbian. If you're a lesbian, I'm guessing you're just are a lesbian and you fancy women that you fancy and you don't fancy women/men/dogs/chickens that you don't fancy. Maybe this is the issue and people are more stupid/fearful of fallout/mindless than they used to be. Maybe these political organisations telling teenagers who to sleep with should be looked at closely as in my teen years we really didn't need this level of instruction.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 14:21

@Gwenhwyfar

"However, people should also be able to consent for whatever reason they choose.

It is not for others to say that you have to be ‘enthusiastic’. As long as the consent is freely given , it can be for any reason whatsoever."

Exactly. The 'obligation' to be enthusiastic is another kind of tyranny.

I’m sure you’re aware that the enthusiastic comes from the fries acronym.

People get pedantic when they don’t have a valid point.

Consent starts from a place of no. Enthusiastic consent is used to mean that people are 100% saying yes, not 98% yes but 2% no. It doesn’t mean they actively have to feel enthusiasm at that point. I’m not convinced I feel enthusiasm about anything really, I’m not sure it’s an emotion I’m capable of (csa, v extreme) But I am completely sure I know when I 100% want to have sex. That’s what enthusiastic consent means.

It’s not difficult to grasp. It’s the best word that fitted the acronym to explain what consent is, and yes plenty women are capable of drawing clear boundaries and don’t need an acronym, but plenty of us do find it’s helpful to have that reinforced. Because every single bit of female socialisation we experience tears down the idea women have a right to boundaries.

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 30/10/2021 14:20

@Naunet

Are there trsnswomen out there who have pressured people in to sex? Of course there are! That's also true of almost every human group out there. There are transmen who have done so. There are natal women who have done so. There are people from every racial group who have done so. Just like all of these groups, predatory transwomen make up an extremely small percentage of the group and do not represent it in general

This is some gaslighting bullshit. MALES, commit 98% of all sex crimes, males of all races, religions, genders and statures. How dare you try to pretend women are just as likely to be predators, just as likely to be a sex offender? That’s an incredibly offensive, misogynistic thing to say. Shame on you.

This. 100 times over.

Reprehensible misogynistic untruths.

Fact matters.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 14:17

It is scaremongering when a national news organisation runs a whole article focusing on the behaviour of a few people from a minority group, and then people are led to believe that it is representative of that group,

Why on earth would people be led to believe the behaviour is representative of that group? Do they have trouble reading?

TatianaBis · 30/10/2021 14:17

@WallaceinAnderland

www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-42652947

Transwoman India Willoughby tried to pressure a man into kissing her.

From the link above:

Willoughby asked her housemates about their dating preferences, and the resulting conversation kicked off a social media storm.

"Would you go out with a transsexual woman?" she queried.

"I believe it's your choice... I would choose not to," replied the R'n'B singer Ginuwine. "That doesn't make me scared."

"You would go out with a woman?" Willoughby asked.

"Yes."

"But you wouldn't go out with a transsexual woman?"

"No."

The conversation rumbled on. When Willoughby suggested "Let's have a kiss," Ginuwine replied "no" and leaned away from her.

This quote from Willoughby (from the article) cuts to the chase:

”all this superficial stuff that you are a woman and all that sounds great and is the right thing to say. But it makes no difference if people don't believe it - that's the problem."

WalkingOnTheCracks · 30/10/2021 14:16

This does lead to the situation where two translesbians with penises are pretty much obliged to have sex with each other or be guilty of transphobia.

Dervel · 30/10/2021 14:16

I’m not against trans people per se, and obviously would like everyone to find someone they both desire and are desired by, but surely I’d be doing trans people a disservice if I didn’t apply the same standards to them that I would to literally anyone else that we don’t want to get into a place where anyone is coerced into sex they don’t want?? How would that be so controversial?

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 14:14

@ohdelay

I recognise that but it's the same energy that heterosexual girls face from men. Rape, abuse and ostracism sometimes happen when men get rejected, but that doesn't mean you question yourself. I'm 45 and have had my share of close encounters and physical when younger, my mates stuck by me. Being called a transphobe out of the situation wouldn't touch the sides. Young lesbians more than anyone, really ought to be getting the basics right and lesbianing. The people who need their heads wobbling are the women (and it will be women) so up their own arses on ideology and "kindness" and "right on feels good wooo" that they sacrifice their own. The men are doing what men often do, the women supporting them are equally complicit.
This reads like victim blaming.

Look at lgbt+ organisation, lesbian dating sites, lesbian groups at uni etc and all have long been infiltrated by stonewall telling them it’s transphobic to say no to transwomen.

Fuck never mind that, stonewall is in our bloody schools and has been for a long time now.

The send in very male looking tw to teach young lesbians how to be lesbians and our schools have been letting them, actually paying them to gas light our kids. Go look at the resources on safe schools alliance that stonewall put into schools.

Young lesbians don’t stand a fucking chance against that level of influence. Their minds are already conditioned to accept this bs.

I’d use stronger examples but MN don’t let us tell the truth about what this is.

AndSoFinally · 30/10/2021 14:11
  • Nancy Kelley, CEO of Stonewall, gave thus quote to the BBC:

"Nobody should ever be pressured into dating, or pressured into dating people they aren't attracted to. But if you find that when dating, you are writing off entire groups of people, like people of colour, fat people, disabled people or trans people, then it's worth considering how societal prejudices may have shaped your attractions.*

But "men" are an entire group aren't they? So lesbians are only lesbians because because their sexual attractions have been shaped by societal prejudices?! Skating very close to the basis of conversion therapy there, Nancy!

fallenwood · 30/10/2021 14:09

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

No, trans people are not. There are a small percentage of people who are absolutel twats who think they can demand anything, some of those happen to be trans, but don't put them all in the same boat.

Your voting is ridiculous too, absolutely swayed one way because trans people on the whole do not demand sex from anyone.

This is pretty much spot on. Some people who behave without respect for others happen to be trans. It isn't all trans people.

Be angry about how a small group of trans people are behaving in an abhorrent and abusive way but make it clear at the same time that that group does not represent the majority of trans people.

OP It only takes 10 minutes on twitter to prove your statement wrong
'Choke on my girl dick"
"I'll fuck the prejudice out of all the tef lesbians" OP, you are missing the point here - the people doing this are vile, they do NOT* represent the majority of trans people.

I don't get why transactivists aren't up in arms over these abusive members of their community, shouting loudly "not in our name, this is not okay, and we'll publicly shame and excommunicate anyone who tries this shit" the transactivists are the abusive members of the community - as you were clearly not aware of this, yet should be, it is now the time to listen more to normal trans voices who are NOT accusing anyone of lying!

No, I am not trans in case you are wondering, I was born 100 percent biological woman, I am just fed up of the cognitively challenged people confusing issues and causing more harm than good.

Itsnotdeep · 30/10/2021 14:09

@Chocolatewheatos

I am very pro-trans rights and I totally see why they feel the way they do. They want accepting as the gender they are and its shit to be rejected for something you didn't have control of and have changed. But no one is ever entitled to sex under any circumstances.
But they have a penis. And the vast majority of lesbians don't want to have sex with people with penises.

I don't want to have sex or a sexual relationship with someone who thinks they're a woman (even if they've got a penis).

And neither me nor the lesbians are bigoted. My choice.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 14:07

@Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet

Are people thinking that 'enthusiastic consent' means that you have to be swinging from the chandeliers every time?
People are being deliberately obtuse.

I’ve had sex when I’ve been a bit meh about it, a bit tired at the start. But I’m still 100% sure I’m up for consenting. But at that point I’m only consenting to cuddling and kissing. Even by the point I’m 100% sure I want to consent to sex it doesn’t necessarily mean I’m ready to turn cartwheels about it. Sometimes while my body is turned on I’m definitely ticking other things over in my brain, I’ve never been great at being 100% present for anything, Adhd brain and all. But I am 100% sure about consenting, because I want the intimacy or because I really want to orgasm and have zero interest in doing so on my own. Because I know I want how I’ll feel after it.

I’m willing to bet that’s true of other women at times, or that they are 100% sure about consenting but they are doing so because they want to get pregnant, not because they are super pumped about sex at that exact point. Or similar.

It’s completely possible to not be over the moon excited about sex but 100% enthusiastic about consenting to sex.

Enthusiastic consent just means anyone is 100% sure they are consenting and consenting for their own reasons, not because of social pressure or expectations of a partner. It means if someone is 95% sure but 5% uncertain they should recognise that’s the point they should be saying no.

Consent starts at the place of no. Anything less than a 100% yes is a no, and that’s not consent.

That’s what the phrase is meant to mean. I think people like to be deliberately obtuse on this point.

Dervel · 30/10/2021 14:06

@BloodinGutters well I for one don’t mind going up to bat or support you however you need me to.