Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Enthusiastic Consent - I am .. confused.

645 replies

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 11:29

So .. AIBU that the once previously highly held gold standard for consent between partners had to be enthusiastic and complete. Any hesitant or unsure thoughts = a grey area in which the other party should NOT ever step into??

I ask because (I am very new to all this so please be gentle if I've got this wrong) this sudden uprise in trans activists insisting that predominantly gay women (though men too apparently) should willingly sleep with transwomen and transmen regardless of what genitalia they have or where they are in their transition is confusing.

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

I must have this wrong.. surely.. we were banging the #metoo campaign drum not that long ago .. all up in arms about how both parties need to be fully able and willing to consent to engage in anything that could be considered sexual contact.. its how I've been raising my 4 boys .. its what I completely believe in .. that absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to without having to give a carefully drafted PC reason????

[Edited by MNHQ to remove poll]

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 30/10/2021 16:50

@Linning regarding your point about Allies, what is wrong with women standing up for lesbian women who have said they have these experiences.

The fact is that many women regardless of their sexuality have experienced the misogyny of men. Many of us have experienced men behaving inappropriately towards us. We are therefore natural allies to women who are saying that this is an issue over males who identify as women who are threatening women who speak out of this with rape and worse on social media.

I'm unclear why you appear to sneer at women standing up for other women? Why do you think we should not do this as fundamentally there is a commonality of experience if you take gender Identity out of the equation.

titchy · 30/10/2021 16:48

Oh and your subsequent post - no, not all genders are violent to women - the vast vast vast majority of perpetrators are male. Not female.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 16:47

*If you are going to quote my post at least include the part where I add that I know my experience isn’t representative of all lesbians and that of course there will be transwomen (like in any demographic of the population) sexual predators who will and have abused lesbians.

But sure, quoting a small part of the post and being aggravated by it is so much easier…*

So what point were you actually trying to make? You've had different experiences to those in the article but you acknowledge that your experiences are not shared by all? So what? No-one here is saying all or even most tranwomen are predatory.

titchy · 30/10/2021 16:47

If you are going to quote my post at least include the part where I add that I know my experience isn’t representative of all lesbians and that of course there will be transwomen (like in any demographic of the population) sexual predators who will and have abused lesbians.

So you do believe them then? In which case why didn't you post saying how abhorrent it was? And how awful for Stonewall to effectively victim blame?

Why did you post an essentially NATWALT post? Do you think an All live matter post on a thread about violent racism would be a valuable contribution or a way of deflecting, gaslighting, stonewalling (how ironic...)?

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 16:46

@Linning

I am a lesbian who has lived in many countries and therefore part of many many queer spaces and environment worldwide and is in almost continuous contact with trans women and I have never once felt threatened by them. I probably personally know over a 100 transwomen and none of them has ever expressed any entitlement to sleeping with women, or has had any objection to lesbians, in fact many of them fully expect to be rejected on the basis that they are trans and while they find it hurtful they tend to be extremely understanding of it, also many transwomen do NOT date women and would have absolutely zero interest in lesbians even if you offered one to them.

I am not saying that no transwoman has ever felt entitled to having sex/date a lesbian, or ever coherced a lesbian to have sex with them, but I have honestly not had one bad experience with a transwoman while I have gotten continuous sexual entitlement by cis-male AND even a fair amount of women (unfortunately including from a fair amount of lesbians).
You have entitled predators of all sexuality and gender. And as a lesbian who spends plenty of time a week with transwomen and people of all gender and sexuality, often in a setting where rape could easily happen. I feel 100 times safer around transwomen than I ever have around cis-straight men and definitely as safe as I do around other lesbians and bisexual women.

I also personally don’t know any lesbians who has ever felt threatened by a transwoman or coherced and and so I don’t actually know any lesbian IRL who fear transwoman the way people like to portray in articles or online forums and our bad experiences seem to be exclusively limited to cis-straight men and some fellow queer women which of course and again doesn’t mean that no transwoman has ever behaved badly. But that the threat that likes to be portrayed by media about the impact of transwomen on lesbian communities simply isn’t at all the reality i and most lesbians I know live in and has been extremely grossly exaggerated in a clear attempt to harm transwomen’s reputations and throw lesbians under the bus.

It’s funny how nobody cared about lesbians and our comforts or us having rights, until transwomen started getting more rights and suddenly all actions against trans individuals are made as a plea to protect lesbians.

As a lesbian I personally feel WAY MORE THREATENED and aggravated by “allies” who try to use my sexuality as a way to defend/justify their anti-trans actions and arguments than I ever have and ever will feel threatened by transwomen themselves and if I could get rid of one of them, I know which one I would vote to get rid of personally and it wouldn’t be transwomen!

Btw do you often keep around spare lesbians to offer to tw??
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 16:45

So, just to check I've understood:

The article which did not purport to show any trends, and acknowledged that it was a self-selecting group of respondents, should not be listened to as it "is trying to show a trend"

The article which very clearly said "some" and interviewed a transwoman, thereby clearly evidencing that it could not possibly be "all" is guilty of painting all transwomen in the same light.

There are some people on here who have not experienced this themselves to either don't believe others have or don't care.

You're only allowed to call yourself a lesbian now if your attraction is based on the concept of gender which still no-one has wanted to define. Despite this, there is no need to worry about the inequalities which people who fancy other people who had female bodies from birth, perhaps because if they let their prejudice make them not fancy people who want to have sex with them, then this is evidence that they are bigots and therefore should not expect any legal protections.

Calling someone a bigot, exposing them to on-line and RL hate which can sometimes culminate in people losing their livelihoods or sense of safety is maybe not 100% OK by some trans activists but still doesn't stop it from being 100% the woman's responsibility to not say yes to sex with someone they perceive to be a man.

If anyone calls any of this illogical or asks for someone to explain the logic of that position, they are transphobic.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 16:44

@Linning

I am a lesbian who has lived in many countries and therefore part of many many queer spaces and environment worldwide and is in almost continuous contact with trans women and I have never once felt threatened by them. I probably personally know over a 100 transwomen and none of them has ever expressed any entitlement to sleeping with women, or has had any objection to lesbians, in fact many of them fully expect to be rejected on the basis that they are trans and while they find it hurtful they tend to be extremely understanding of it, also many transwomen do NOT date women and would have absolutely zero interest in lesbians even if you offered one to them.

I am not saying that no transwoman has ever felt entitled to having sex/date a lesbian, or ever coherced a lesbian to have sex with them, but I have honestly not had one bad experience with a transwoman while I have gotten continuous sexual entitlement by cis-male AND even a fair amount of women (unfortunately including from a fair amount of lesbians).
You have entitled predators of all sexuality and gender. And as a lesbian who spends plenty of time a week with transwomen and people of all gender and sexuality, often in a setting where rape could easily happen. I feel 100 times safer around transwomen than I ever have around cis-straight men and definitely as safe as I do around other lesbians and bisexual women.

I also personally don’t know any lesbians who has ever felt threatened by a transwoman or coherced and and so I don’t actually know any lesbian IRL who fear transwoman the way people like to portray in articles or online forums and our bad experiences seem to be exclusively limited to cis-straight men and some fellow queer women which of course and again doesn’t mean that no transwoman has ever behaved badly. But that the threat that likes to be portrayed by media about the impact of transwomen on lesbian communities simply isn’t at all the reality i and most lesbians I know live in and has been extremely grossly exaggerated in a clear attempt to harm transwomen’s reputations and throw lesbians under the bus.

It’s funny how nobody cared about lesbians and our comforts or us having rights, until transwomen started getting more rights and suddenly all actions against trans individuals are made as a plea to protect lesbians.

As a lesbian I personally feel WAY MORE THREATENED and aggravated by “allies” who try to use my sexuality as a way to defend/justify their anti-trans actions and arguments than I ever have and ever will feel threatened by transwomen themselves and if I could get rid of one of them, I know which one I would vote to get rid of personally and it wouldn’t be transwomen!

That’s great for you.

I know thousands and thousands of men. But I’ve only been raped by a few. Definitely a lot less than 1 in 100 men I know have raped me.

Linning · 30/10/2021 16:42

@titchy

I probably personally know over a 100 transwomen and none of them has ever expressed any entitlement to sleeping with women, or has had any objection to lesbians,

Oh well in that case... you should have posted earlier. Clearly everyone is lying then if you have no experience of it. Hmm FFS

If you are going to quote my post at least include the part where I add that I know my experience isn’t representative of all lesbians and that of course there will be transwomen (like in any demographic of the population) sexual predators who will and have abused lesbians.

But sure, quoting a small part of the post and being aggravated by it is so much easier…

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 16:41

@bordersmidgebites

To those talking about black men , please read up about what happened in Rotherham
This ^

If we really had no recorded evidence on rape, no studies, no understanding why it happen by who, and a small number of women came forward to say they had been raped only by black men then an article that considered why some black men were raping women would be fine.

This article is just saying this happens, it’s clear it’s some tw and even includes tw who say this happens, who are obviously not saying they themselves do this, so the journalist has included tw who aren’t rapists also. So including evidence that not all tw do this in her article.

We need to not be afraid to be honest about speaking up against people with pc. The AIBU thread about the co worker with asd who is sexually harassing her is a good example. His asd has been used to down play his harassment of her by management, leaving her vulnerable. As someone with children who have autism it’s down right gross to excuse anyone behaving this way because of a disability, as if that is related to his predatory behaviour.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 30/10/2021 16:40

@VladmirsPoutine

This whole debacle has white men wanting to be confirmed as women and white women lashing out back. All other women who otherwise those parties couldn't find a single shit to give about are caught in the middle.
Why do you think it's only white women who care about this?
Linning · 30/10/2021 16:40

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

So *@Linning* are you saying that your experience is the experience and other lesbians are wrong, lying?

And you have no idea who here is also lesbian, so you might want to reign in the 'nasty ally' rhetoric.

Is that what I said? Or did you only read the part that triggered you and made up your own version of what I said? I specifically said that no doubt that there are transwomen out there who, (like people of all gender and sexuality can and have), cohersed women, included lesbian into having sex and dating them but that I definitely do not believe them to be the majority, and I, as a lesbian, who spends quite a lot of time surrounded by them, don’t feel a bit threatened by them.

I never said that other women are lying (did the word «lying» even appear anywhere on my post?) I am not dumb enough to think my experience is representative of all lesbians or that no transwoman is a rapist.

Also my ally comment is aimed at, ALLIES, so if you are also a lesbian, you are not an ally, and therefore my comment wasn’t aimed at you nor other lesbians/member of the community. I don’t need to know who is actually a lesbian or not in the comment section since my comment is not aimed at lesbians but aimed at the allies who fit the bill.

(Not) Sorry you disagree with my experience as a lesbian. It doesn’t give you the right to misuse my words and accuse me of things that I neither have said nor written.

Helleofabore · 30/10/2021 16:38

@Ereshkigalangcleg

The fact that Nancy Kelley, Stonewall CEO can't unequivocally state that homosexuality is acceptable any more without saying people have to consider that they may have "prejudices" they need to unpack is really quite telling.
It really, really is.

The fact that Stonewall cannot have addressed this without any mention of any particular group when it was first raised with them by simply stating that sexual boundaries are to be respected by ALL and no one is entitled to try to lower any sexual boundaries in any way, is very chilling indeed.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 16:36

As long as consent is not given through fear (real fear, not fear of a sulk), it is consent.

*Whether you want to be in a relationship where you feel the obligated to have sex is a good question and one that, as an adult, you need to answer for yourself.

As is often said on MN , a woman is an adult human female, not a child who needs protecting from themselves (even if you feel it is for ‘their’ own good).*

Women need protecting from dangerous narratives which leaves them the option of being true to themselves and risking significant violence (usually verbal), harassment and possibly losing their job or trying to internalise the narrative despite the fact that it does not fit for them and can have significant negative consequences. It is not reasonable to push the blame back to the victims, nor to suggest that the only people who need protecting are children.

titchy · 30/10/2021 16:33

I probably personally know over a 100 transwomen and none of them has ever expressed any entitlement to sleeping with women, or has had any objection to lesbians,

Oh well in that case... you should have posted earlier. Clearly everyone is lying then if you have no experience of it. Hmm FFS

Ereshkigalangcleg · 30/10/2021 16:33

This whole debacle has white men wanting to be confirmed as women and white women lashing out back.

This isn't about race, despite people trying to make out it is. There are plenty of black and Asian people on both sides.

Lucy Masoud isn't white, she's a black lesbian:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10132549/amp/Lesbian-claims-shes-seen-people-identify-trans-women-bully-young-girls-relationship.html

TatianaBis · 30/10/2021 16:31

Why is it that whenever women complain about anything - the number of them is never enough.

Turns out 80 isn't enough and they're biased anyway.

bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 16:30

I think you better be careful assuming it all white woken who are targeted and who are. Fighting back ( hint, it's not )

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 30/10/2021 16:29

So @Linning are you saying that your experience is the experience and other lesbians are wrong, lying?

And you have no idea who here is also lesbian, so you might want to reign in the 'nasty ally' rhetoric.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 16:29

Oh just to be clear - all the stats on rape make it beyond bloody obvious that being black doesn’t make a man more or less likely to be a rapist than being white.

VladmirsPoutine · 30/10/2021 16:28

This whole debacle has white men wanting to be confirmed as women and white women lashing out back. All other women who otherwise those parties couldn't find a single shit to give about are caught in the middle.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 16:27

@TedMullins

If 56% of 80 women answered a self-selecting survey by a white nationalist group saying they’d been raped by black men, would it then be ethically and factually sound to publish an article saying black men are raping women and that it’s a growing trend? Of course it wouldn’t. The trans women that are coercing lesbians are of course sex offenders and are completely in the wrong. But it is not the majority school of thought in the trans community that lesbians need to be ‘turned’. Trans Media Watch has put out a statement confirming as much. As PP have pointed out Lily Cade is herself a sex offender and one of the other interviewees said on Twitter that their and their friends experiences were all with the same person - one trans woman, not multiple. The BBC did not do it’s due diligence. On any other topic, a self-selecting survey with that small a sample size would not be permitted to be used as evidence to back up such a serious claim. I am familiar with their editorial guidelines so I’m not just focusing on the survey in an attempt to obfuscate.
There is already plenty stats on race and rape, and it’s well established that it’s being male that is the defining factor.

However if there was zero research, zero crime stats on race and rape (which would mean no crime stats on rape at all because because ethnicity is recorded about suspects so it’s easy to establish race of rapists and if there’s any relationship between race and being a rapist) but if there was zero evidence on that and the first people ever to come forward were all victims of black men and said so, then it would be fine for their to be an article that addresses this and uses the term ‘some’ in it. As this article did. How very racist to suggest otherwise.

It is obfuscation to compare lwithoutt as to a white nationalists though. Being a lesbian is a protected characteristic under the equality act. They are allowed their own groups. Suggesting this is like white nationalism is like screaming all lives matter in response to blm.

The poster on Twitter in no way suggested that the other interviewees were her friends, just that her friends experienced the same from this repeat offender.

Lilly Cade is not one of the lesbians interviewed about rape. She’s only in the article because the tw who expected to be able to fuck her used her refusal as the basis for the concept of the cotton ceiling. The journalist isn’t claiming anything about Lilly Cade, just explaining the origin of the term cotton ceiling. However Lilly Cade could be a cannibal child killer and as a lesbian she is still same sex attracted and entitled to tell a tw who wants to fuck her to piss off. Some lesbians being scum doesn’t stop them being lesbians does it? It doesn’t redefine the legal meaning of lesbian does it? The same way a tw wanting to be a woman doesn’t make that fact.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 30/10/2021 16:25

If 56% of 80 women answered a self-selecting survey by a white nationalist group saying they’d been raped by black men, would it then be ethically and factually sound to publish an article saying black men are raping women and that it’s a growing trend?

That isn't remotely an appropriate analogy. Female people are not the oppressors of males. MTF trans people as a group aren't more of a vulnerable population than lesbians, or women generally, IMO.

Not all situations are the same. What if there was a group of white men abusing their greater social power to coerce black women, and this was being covered up by white people because white people found it inconvenient? What would your view be then? Just curious.

bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 16:22

To those talking about black men , please read up about what happened in Rotherham

bordersmidgebites · 30/10/2021 16:22

It's not happened to me or my friends ... do you think those people are lying or fo you mean that it doesn't matter if it's only a few women?

Helleofabore · 30/10/2021 16:19

@TedMullins

If 56% of 80 women answered a self-selecting survey by a white nationalist group saying they’d been raped by black men, would it then be ethically and factually sound to publish an article saying black men are raping women and that it’s a growing trend? Of course it wouldn’t. The trans women that are coercing lesbians are of course sex offenders and are completely in the wrong. But it is not the majority school of thought in the trans community that lesbians need to be ‘turned’. Trans Media Watch has put out a statement confirming as much. As PP have pointed out Lily Cade is herself a sex offender and one of the other interviewees said on Twitter that their and their friends experiences were all with the same person - one trans woman, not multiple. The BBC did not do it’s due diligence. On any other topic, a self-selecting survey with that small a sample size would not be permitted to be used as evidence to back up such a serious claim. I am familiar with their editorial guidelines so I’m not just focusing on the survey in an attempt to obfuscate.
Can we consider the degree to which women, particularly lesbians, are being pressured to remain silent?

That 80 lesbians answered a self-selecting survey is not an issue.

This is an issue that has been brought to Stonewall's attention for some time. And they have doubled down. Not once have they released any communication to say 'Lesbians have the right to define their sexual boundaries and it is completely unacceptable for any person, of any gender, to pressure or coerce a lesbian to lower these boundaries.'

It SHOULD have been said when the social media abuse started, and yet it has remained completely unaddressed.

But it is not the majority school of thought in the trans community that lesbians need to be ‘turned’.

It doesn't have to be the majority school of thought. At all. It should have been addressed from the beginning.

And we have had posters on the FWR threads who have also been coerced into sex with a transitioned male. There are many lesbians anonymously saying this is happening to them. But no one speaks publicly about it. Look what happens to anyone who does.

So, tell us. If Stonewall will not address this, if they will not address the horrendous abuse that is happening on social media in front of their very eyes that lesbians receive for declaring their sexual boundaries, what should be done to address it? Or do you seriously not think this is a problem?