Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Enthusiastic Consent - I am .. confused.

645 replies

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 11:29

So .. AIBU that the once previously highly held gold standard for consent between partners had to be enthusiastic and complete. Any hesitant or unsure thoughts = a grey area in which the other party should NOT ever step into??

I ask because (I am very new to all this so please be gentle if I've got this wrong) this sudden uprise in trans activists insisting that predominantly gay women (though men too apparently) should willingly sleep with transwomen and transmen regardless of what genitalia they have or where they are in their transition is confusing.

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

I must have this wrong.. surely.. we were banging the #metoo campaign drum not that long ago .. all up in arms about how both parties need to be fully able and willing to consent to engage in anything that could be considered sexual contact.. its how I've been raising my 4 boys .. its what I completely believe in .. that absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to without having to give a carefully drafted PC reason????

[Edited by MNHQ to remove poll]

OP posts:
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 30/10/2021 17:28

@DameFanny

I don't believe the article did its due diligence by publishing a 'survey' run by an explicitly anti-trans organisation as if it were a proper data collection exercise, I don't believe you can establish a trend from the numbers given and the lack of examples, I don't believe you should ignore the sexual assaults Lily Cade is alleged to have made, I don't believe we should assume transwomen are in it to hurt ciswomen.

I do believe this is the new section 28 moral panic bullshit. I was there in the 80s, when the papers were telling me lesbians would try to turn me in public loos, and that gay men were all pedophiles. I didn't believe that either.

You realise it's not newspapers telling you about what lesbians or gay men might do, but women (lesbian women) themselves telling you what has happened and is happening to them?

I quote the statement from Angela C. Wild here.

A few days ago @BBCNews contacted @GetTheLOutUK for a quote about the complaints received for exposing the sexual pressure placed on lesbians
The article is here but the quote not
Balanced debate BBC?
Here's the quote BBC didn't include
#istandwithlesbians

"We understand our research is under attack for not being "representative". We never claimed statistical generalisation with this work as the methodology makes clear, but to show that a phenomenon does indeed exist and needs to be investigated further. This is what larger LGBT organisations are funded to do yet they neglect their duty towards lesbians and demonised survivors instead.

Many studies done by Stonewall themselves used a much smaller sample yet claim statistical generalisation and are used to change legislation. Yet they do not receive such negative reception as our piece did.

We spoke to victims of the cotton ceiling. Rape is not an anecdote when it happens to you. These women are brave beyond measure to speak up especially in the current climate of silencing we live in. Their stories are important and need to be heard in the wider #metoo context and the lesbophobic culture promoted by most, if not all LGBT organisations.
We believe women. We believe lesbians."

Angela C. Wild
Get the L Out

lazylinguist · 30/10/2021 17:27

I too have been raped by men and unfortunately also sexually coherced by women, and while it’s absolutely unacceptable and shouldn’t ever happen, none of us would say that women as a whole are a threat because I have had non-consensual experiences with them.

But nobody is saying that transwomen en masse are a threat because they force lesbians to have sex with them. (It should go without saying that it's wrong for anyone to coerce someone into sex). What people are saying is that it is not ok for TW or allies, or indeed anyone, to say that lesbians must consider having sex with transwomen. And it's not ok to say they're transphobic if they don't.

RandomLondoner · 30/10/2021 17:26

@Naunet

Are there trsnswomen out there who have pressured people in to sex? Of course there are! That's also true of almost every human group out there. There are transmen who have done so. There are natal women who have done so. There are people from every racial group who have done so. Just like all of these groups, predatory transwomen make up an extremely small percentage of the group and do not represent it in general

This is some gaslighting bullshit. MALES, commit 98% of all sex crimes, males of all races, religions, genders and statures. How dare you try to pretend women are just as likely to be predators, just as likely to be a sex offender? That’s an incredibly offensive, misogynistic thing to say. Shame on you.

Let's suppose the are 100 men in the world, and 100 women, and 1 of the men is a rapist. Do you really think it's a lot worse to label 100 innocent women as potential predators than to label 99 innocent men?
BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 17:24

@TatianaBis

I personally disagree with the definition that rape can only be caused by a penis and find it an incredibly damaging belief for victims of other forced penetrative acts (who don’t get the justice they deserve as a result of not being perceived by the law as a rape victim) but of course I do know this is often the legal definition of rape in many jurisdictions.

Eh? Penetration by anything other than a penis is called “assault by penetration”. You can get ‘justice’ for that.

Exactly.

But obfuscating terms is so much more fun to some.

lifeturnsonadime · 30/10/2021 17:22

Shame mumsnet have removed the voting option. At the time it was removed 94% of voters agreed with the OP.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 17:21

[quote Linning]@BloodinGutters

That’s exactly my point.

I too have been raped by men and unfortunately also sexually coherced by women, and while it’s absolutely unacceptable and shouldn’t ever happen, none of us would say that women as a whole are a threat because I have had non-consensual experiences with them. It doesn’t mean that my experiences don’t matter and aren’t valid and don’t bring forward genuine issues about rape/sexual assault amongst women or in the lesbian/queer community. But it would be a false association to say that women as a whole are a threat or lesbians/bisexual women (since they were my aggressors) are a threat to the rest of the female population.

I am not ever going to deny that some transwomen are predatory and some have and/or will harm women but is it a «transwomen are problematic and a threat» issue or is it «some specific individuals are a threat and highly problematic» issues and they just so happen to come in the shape of a transwoman.

My problem with this topic is that if a lesbian talked about sexual assaults within the community by other female (which happens more often than you might think), nobody would be out there branding that women are a threat or that lesbians/Bisexual women specifically as a whole are the issue and a threat to the rest of the community. It seems incredibly targeted to then jump from individual cases that statistically would only amount to a small percentage of the transwomen/lesbian population experiences (not that any amount isn’t already too many) to make a point that transwomen as a whole (and not specific individuals) are the issue.

It simply doesn’t sit right with me.

I think all lesbians who have experienced cohersion from a transwoman, or rape. Should absolutely absolutely testify and should be at the forefront of those talks. I am not sure branding (all/most) transwomen as a threat is something that is either accurate nor helpful, in keeping lesbians safe from cohersion.

Lesbians face many issues, and most issues lesbians tend to face often (and in my experience) rarely have to do with transwomen yet it seems the only issue people seem to want to fix. It would be nice if people had taken an interest in lesbian experiences and struggles before people started feeling threatened by transwomen, as it would feel much more genuine (to me).[/quote]
Nope the point I made was not the one you made.

Point must be exclusionary I guess.

Linning · 30/10/2021 17:19

@BeyondShrinks

Some might suggest it is a very privileged position to be "more threatened" by allies, than by rapists.
I am a queer woman of color who was raped as kid by family members and later on as a teenager. I have been cohersed into sex by both men and women. I doubt I am privileged (though no doubt some people have had it worst!) but I have NEVER and WILL NEVER say I am more threatened by allies than by rapists.

Transwomen AREN’T rapists, how disgusting of you to replace the word transwomen by rapists (as if they all are) and think you are making a smart comeback. Rapists are rapists they are a threat to society and sorry to tell you but they come in all shapes or form. Rapists are a threat to me but transwomen (as a whole) aren’t. And yes people like you who make assumptions about others background and are quick to call an entire group rapists are a much bigger threat to me than transwomen as a whole. There is not much difference between people who think «all gays are the same» to people who think «all trans are rapists». People are individuals. Hold them accountable as individuals and stop limping entire groups into the same basket.

YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · 30/10/2021 17:19

Hello everyone. We've removed the voting option on this thread as we didn't consider this conducive to civil discussion. We've also had to delete several posts for breaking our guidelines. Please note that;

We don’t allow posts which are derogatory or aggressive towards trans people. We believe there are ways to express both opinion and facts without crossing this line.

Sweeping negative generalisations about any group, including trans people and gender-critical feminists, won’t be tolerated.

Thanks.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 17:18

@BeyondShrinks

Some might suggest it is a very privileged position to be "more threatened" by allies, than by rapists.
Yes. And to be threatened by PEOPLE TYPING IN CAPS.
TatianaBis · 30/10/2021 17:18

I personally disagree with the definition that rape can only be caused by a penis and find it an incredibly damaging belief for victims of other forced penetrative acts (who don’t get the justice they deserve as a result of not being perceived by the law as a rape victim) but of course I do know this is often the legal definition of rape in many jurisdictions.

Eh? Penetration by anything other than a penis is called “assault by penetration”. You can get ‘justice’ for that.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 17:17

As a lesbian…..
My lesbian friends…..

The 10 years odd I’ve spoken to lesbians on Twitter about this issue, read the many threads on fwr about it where some women are no doubt lesbians and the conversations I’ve had in rl, never have I met a lesbian who uses the term lesbian so frequently to assert their lesbianism.

Actually forgot this issue, never have I met a lesbian who says As a lesbian yadda yadda do dum, As a lesbian dum diddy do da, so frequently.

It’s an awesome word to type by the way @Linning. I’m so blessed to have met someone who likes typing it as much as me.

I also love saying vagina. Do you also love saying that word @Linning? I especially like saying it loudly and repeatedly and in public. Nothing beats the looks on people faces when I spill my coffee and yell VAGINA instead of oh fuck it.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 30/10/2021 17:16

Linning but that is exactly what this thread is about. All people are saying is lesbians have the right to same sex attraction and stonewall have turned round and said they need to think about their societal prejudices.

No one is saying all trans women are evil, no one says all men are evil either however that doesn't mean that situations don't arise where some transwomen behave badly, the same as some men behave badly, yes some women also behave badly but it's statistically at a lot lower a rate. Stonewall stating that lesbians need to reconsider their prejudices is wrong, no one needs to reconsider where their sexual boundaries lie.

Helleofabore · 30/10/2021 17:15

Also many transwomen don’t have a penis anymore,

I believe that it is estimated that over 90% of transitioned males in the UK still retain their penis.

Linning · 30/10/2021 17:10

[quote BloodinGutters]@Linning

Being coerced into sex is called rape. Rape in the uk is a crime of forced penile penitration. Only males have a penis, so only men commit rape. Their gender identity matters not a fuck.

The only exception are if a woman is charged because she assisted a man to rape someone or in Scotland transmen (biological females) can now be prosecuted if they have a neo penis and use it to rape someone. Although to the best of my knowledge that has never been prosecuted, but I might be wrong.[/quote]
Not sure what point you are trying to make?

Are you saying that women can’t sexually assault/coherce other women because UK laws disagree with that?

Not everybody here is from the UK or under British laws.

I personally disagree with the definition that rape can only be caused by a penis and find it an incredibly damaging belief for victims of other forced penetrative acts (who don’t get the justice they deserve as a result of not being perceived by the law as a rape victim) but of course I do know this is often the legal definition of rape in many jurisdictions.

Doesn’t change the fact that there are other form of sexual assaults and that women can also physically assault other women even if laws disagree with that.

Also many transwomen don’t have a penis anymore, does that mean they aren’t a threat to lesbians? And can’t sexually assault them/coherse them? And can’t rape people anymore? And so the only «threat» are pre -op transwomen?

Like what point are you trying to make? Laws are flawed. That’s why lesbians can’t get married in most countries and are persecuted in many more.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 30/10/2021 17:09

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee,

‘Women need protecting from dangerous narratives which leaves them the option of being true to themselves and risking significant violence (usually verbal), harassment and possibly losing their job or trying to internalise the narrative despite the fact that it does not fit for them and can have significant negative consequences. It is not reasonable to push the blame back to the victims, nor to suggest that the only people who need protecting are children.’

Speak for yourself there , not all women!

This victim narrative is infantilising intelligent adult women and is rolling feminism back-ooh-about 70 years.

Women need to be protected from criminals (as does everyone), not ideas, thanks.

DrSbaitso · 30/10/2021 17:08

I am not ever going to deny that some transwomen are predatory and some have and/or will harm women but is it a «transwomen are problematic and a threat» issue or is it «some specific individuals are a threat and highly problematic» issues and they just so happen to come in the shape of a transwoman.

It's a

Linning · 30/10/2021 17:02

@BaronessEllarawrosaurus

As a lesbian I personally feel WAY MORE THREATENED and aggravated by “allies” who try to use my sexuality as a way to defend/justify their anti-trans actions and arguments than I ever have and ever will feel threatened by transwomen themselves and if I could get rid of one of them, I know which one I would vote to get rid of personally and it wouldn’t be transwomen!

Please can you explain how the sentence lesbians are same sex attracted is in any way anti-trans?

Did I say that? I at no point said that nor even at all referenced to that sentence.

If you are going to challenge me at least challenge me on things I have said not things you think my post implies but doesn’t.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 17:01

@Linning

Being coerced into sex is called rape. Rape in the uk is a crime of forced penile penitration. Only males have a penis, so only men commit rape. Their gender identity matters not a fuck.

The only exception are if a woman is charged because she assisted a man to rape someone or in Scotland transmen (biological females) can now be prosecuted if they have a neo penis and use it to rape someone. Although to the best of my knowledge that has never been prosecuted, but I might be wrong.

Linning · 30/10/2021 17:00

@BloodinGutters

That’s exactly my point.

I too have been raped by men and unfortunately also sexually coherced by women, and while it’s absolutely unacceptable and shouldn’t ever happen, none of us would say that women as a whole are a threat because I have had non-consensual experiences with them. It doesn’t mean that my experiences don’t matter and aren’t valid and don’t bring forward genuine issues about rape/sexual assault amongst women or in the lesbian/queer community. But it would be a false association to say that women as a whole are a threat or lesbians/bisexual women (since they were my aggressors) are a threat to the rest of the female population.

I am not ever going to deny that some transwomen are predatory and some have and/or will harm women but is it a «transwomen are problematic and a threat» issue or is it «some specific individuals are a threat and highly problematic» issues and they just so happen to come in the shape of a transwoman.

My problem with this topic is that if a lesbian talked about sexual assaults within the community by other female (which happens more often than you might think), nobody would be out there branding that women are a threat or that lesbians/Bisexual women specifically as a whole are the issue and a threat to the rest of the community. It seems incredibly targeted to then jump from individual cases that statistically would only amount to a small percentage of the transwomen/lesbian population experiences (not that any amount isn’t already too many) to make a point that transwomen as a whole (and not specific individuals) are the issue.

It simply doesn’t sit right with me.

I think all lesbians who have experienced cohersion from a transwoman, or rape. Should absolutely absolutely testify and should be at the forefront of those talks. I am not sure branding (all/most) transwomen as a threat is something that is either accurate nor helpful, in keeping lesbians safe from cohersion.

Lesbians face many issues, and most issues lesbians tend to face often (and in my experience) rarely have to do with transwomen yet it seems the only issue people seem to want to fix. It would be nice if people had taken an interest in lesbian experiences and struggles before people started feeling threatened by transwomen, as it would feel much more genuine (to me).

BeyondShrinks · 30/10/2021 16:57

Some might suggest it is a very privileged position to be "more threatened" by allies, than by rapists.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 16:55

@bordersmidgebites

I think you better be careful assuming it all white woken who are targeted and who are. Fighting back ( hint, it's not )
This ^^
BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 30/10/2021 16:53

As a lesbian I personally feel WAY MORE THREATENED and aggravated by “allies” who try to use my sexuality as a way to defend/justify their anti-trans actions and arguments than I ever have and ever will feel threatened by transwomen themselves and if I could get rid of one of them, I know which one I would vote to get rid of personally and it wouldn’t be transwomen!

Please can you explain how the sentence lesbians are same sex attracted is in any way anti-trans?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 30/10/2021 16:52

include the part where I add that I know my experience isn’t representative of all lesbians

Like the survey in the article then, which made this clear.

lazylinguist · 30/10/2021 16:51

Oh god. More trans bashing. Let's all dump them into the same category, just because there are a few arseholes out there.

I hope and expect it is only an arsehole minority among TW and TRAs who actively think it's fine for lesbians to literally be forced to have sex with a TW.

But is it really true that only a few arseholes among TW and TRAs think it is transphobic for lesbians to entirely exclude TW from their 'dating pool'? I'm not so sure.

But it is unacceptable. People have the right to exclude anyone from their 'dating pool' for literally any reason they damn well like. And yes, that includes things over which the potential partner has no control - height, eye colour, even nationality or ethnicity. Because nobody is obliged to even consider dating or having sex with anyone from any group or category, or to justify why not.

Artichokeleaves · 30/10/2021 16:50

As a lesbian I personally feel WAY MORE THREATENED and aggravated by “allies” who try to use my sexuality as a way to defend/justify their anti-trans actions and arguments

As a lesbian, I've got it from both sides right here on MN from multiple threads.

I get the homophobia and scolding from women and TW who believe that I have no right to a sexuality that recognises biological sex and excludes male people from my body. I'm bad for being homosexual and not adapting that to better fit male people and their wishes. And I've encountered that harassment as a lesbian right here on MN many times.

I get the scolding from those insisting that this doesn't happen. On threads where it's happening usually. And that I'm bad all over again for being a homosexual who says this happens, talks about it and am apparently only saying it for evil political purposes.

Frankly these days I'd strongly suggest that lesbians are much safer pretending it's the 60s again and getting back in the closet. Fgs don't tell anyone you're homosexual. Sadly that particularly includes many women who would call themselves LGBT+ and queer. And fgs don't go to Pride unless you're good at lying and acting pan/hetero.