@PurgatoryOfPotholes
This is completely
absurd.
This is like a thread of people trying to raise awareness that there were abusive priests in the Catholic Church, with two or three posters in the middle shouting "Stop saying all priests are abusers, priestphobe!"
No-one thought all transwomen were rapists.
But we need to deal with the number that are, and their enablers
Indeed. Would a discussion about the incidence of child abuse in the RC church (or in other churches, for that matter) be subject to the same denials and defensiveness from devout Catholics, I wonder?
I suppose it was, for a long time. There were indeed many devout Catholics who enabled the very worst sins against children to be perpetrated by abusers within the “sacred caste” of priests, for decades and decades, because it was too threatening to their belief system to acknowledge the reality.
As a result, many many more people had their lives ruined by CSA that could have been prevented if people had been willing to listen and believe the victims.
I think that’s a very accurate analogy for the denial and defensiveness on here. People don’t want to believe it so they have to accuse those saying it of scaremongering, of exaggerating, of having it in for those they are accusing.
Meanwhile, the abuse goes on, and if any decision about action on it were left to these people, it would continue to go on and on and on, unchecked.
Because naming abuse that’s happening is a far worse crime than actually committing the abuse, in the eyes of these people.
As others have said, there’s a parallel too with the way Muslim grooming gangs were allowed to operate with impunity for years and years after they were first identified, and many, many more vulnerable girls raped and abused, because it wasn’t ok to recognise the phenomenon seeing as the abusers were from a minority themselves. Same old, same old. No lessons learned. No outrage, no protectiveness, no concern for these vulnerable victims at all.
Just a resounding “so what”.
I don’t have words for the extent of my contempt for those who enable this.