Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Enthusiastic Consent - I am .. confused.

645 replies

loopyapp · 30/10/2021 11:29

So .. AIBU that the once previously highly held gold standard for consent between partners had to be enthusiastic and complete. Any hesitant or unsure thoughts = a grey area in which the other party should NOT ever step into??

I ask because (I am very new to all this so please be gentle if I've got this wrong) this sudden uprise in trans activists insisting that predominantly gay women (though men too apparently) should willingly sleep with transwomen and transmen regardless of what genitalia they have or where they are in their transition is confusing.

Are trans people really insisting that people have sex with them despite their lack of enthusiastic consent because its their right??

I must have this wrong.. surely.. we were banging the #metoo campaign drum not that long ago .. all up in arms about how both parties need to be fully able and willing to consent to engage in anything that could be considered sexual contact.. its how I've been raising my 4 boys .. its what I completely believe in .. that absolutely everyone is allowed to turn sex down at any point, even during, simply because they wish to without having to give a carefully drafted PC reason????

[Edited by MNHQ to remove poll]

OP posts:
JayniSummers · 30/10/2021 20:40

This 100% this

Helleofabore · 30/10/2021 20:40

You know. This thread is a live demonstration of how this article has played out.

So many people arguing that the article is damaging to a group of people, instead of saying, 'well, actually yes, it has happened, it cannot be denied that it is happening, let's all work together to make sure it stops. That NO body thinks that they are entitled to sex, and that all people understand that saying no is ALWAYS acceptable, accepted unconditionally and should never have to be justified.'

What part of this do people who would have voted in that 6% not understand?

What part of saying 'it has never happened to anyone I know and therefore is not a big enough issue to be addressed by the mainstream media' is NOT coercing other lesbians from disclosing their experiences?

What part of saying 'this discussion is harming trans people' when it is discussing SOME transitioned males behaviours towards women' is not part of a coercive action to silence lesbians trying to raise the alarm?

Does it matter that it is a small number of lesbians that it has actually happened to, or a larger group or a large number? The fact that it is happening, that it needs addressing is being ignored by people caught up in censoring lesbians trying to speak up.

And those censoring those lesbians wonder why they are not hearing about the extent that this is happening.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 30/10/2021 20:38

This is the first time in my life I've found myself frustrated by people who didn't read a headline. Normally I'm frustrated because people didn't read beyond the headline.

merrymouse · 30/10/2021 20:37

THIS. More 'trans people are secretly rapists' bigotry, as indicated by too many posts on this thread.

Your post would carry more weight if you gave the impression that you had read either the article or the thread.

toconclude · 30/10/2021 20:35

@DellaPorter

It's just a load of rubbish scaremongering not grounded in reality, another attempt to turn people against trans women.
THIS. More 'trans people are secretly rapists' bigotry, as indicated by too many posts on this thread.
BeyondShrinks · 30/10/2021 20:19

@BeyondShrinks

Some might suggest it is a very privileged position to be "more threatened" by allies, than by rapists.
I'll quote myself for ease of reading :)
BeyondShrinks · 30/10/2021 20:18

I didn't call anyone privileged (is that a bad word now too?)

I said that to many people, someone who is saying they are more scared of lesbian's allies than of literal rapists, would appear to be saying so from a privileged position.

It appears that way, but it's also entirely possible they're either dense, or suffering from some serious internalised misogyny. 🤷🏼‍♀️ Doesn't matter to me either way, it's just sad that any woman would side with their oppressor. Hardly rare though, is it.

And I used "rapists" as (again...) no one was talking about all transwomen - they were talking about the situation in the OP.

RepentMotherfucker · 30/10/2021 20:07

@Artichokeleaves

I am not sure branding (all/most) transwomen as a threat is something that is either accurate nor helpful

Perhaps raise that concern with the perpetrators and supporters of this behaviour (which includes those public figures telling lesbians to re think their prejudice) as opposed to telling the victims of the behaviour to hush up and not make other people feel bad.

Or just read the word 'some' in the headline?
Artichokeleaves · 30/10/2021 20:06

I am not sure branding (all/most) transwomen as a threat is something that is either accurate nor helpful

Perhaps raise that concern with the perpetrators and supporters of this behaviour (which includes those public figures telling lesbians to re think their prejudice) as opposed to telling the victims of the behaviour to hush up and not make other people feel bad.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 20:02

@TalkingtoLangClegintheDark

Sorry that was in reply to BloodinGutters’s last post.
You’re completely correct. I found it very necessary to type SOME before SOME people demonstrated faux offence.

Not what you meant?

Yep articles normally don’t need to state that SOME men or SOME white people.

It would be a pita to censor ourselves like that day in day out.

SOME politicians are slimy scum suckers.
SOME teenagers have stinking attitudes.
SOME dogs sniff crotches.

Such vague wishy washy essays all teachers must be getting these days. No one will be able to argue any point without preempting is with SOME. There will soon be instructions that to avoid offending people start using the prefix SOME before any word that someone somewhere might find offensive.

SOME8 SOMEbillion SOMEpeople SOMEin SOMEthe SOMEworld

It’s already too exhausting to type but you get the point.

Helleofabore · 30/10/2021 19:58

Yes. Really has talking.

It was a shocking thing to read from a supposed leading feminist.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 30/10/2021 19:53

Finn McKay has hit a new low here, hasn’t she, Helleofabore.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 19:50

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Hmm, just stay with me here, but could the kind of predatory male who manages to not get caught also be even sneakier than the kind that gets caught and sent to prison?
Whose ‘thinking’ are we demonstrating here @PurgatoryOfPotholes? Because that might influence the answer.

And do those not caught identify as sneaky or identify as nothing but purely innocent?

Helleofabore · 30/10/2021 19:50

So…. Has anyone come along with the Stonewall statement that said along the lines, ‘any lesbian has the absolute right to define their sexual boundaries and no person ever has the right to try to lower those boundaries, ever’?

Anyone?

Are those decrying the women speaking out then agreeing with Finn MacKay that women experiencing this abuse, these rapes, should not speak out because it will be ‘weaponised’ to cause division. Basically saying any lesbian speaking out will weaken the LGBT community. Many lesbians depend on these groups. So any lesbian speaking out will cause the destruction of the groups they need.

Coercive at all??? Mmm??

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 30/10/2021 19:48

Sorry that was in reply to BloodinGutters’s last post.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 30/10/2021 19:46

The some in that title was very noticeable too, wasn’t it - it kind of clanged a bit, and that’s because you wouldn’t normally need to put it in, it would be taken as read that you weren’t talking about an entire demographic.

But such is the need to walk on eggshells on this topic, such is the enormity of saying anything that one single person somewhere might possibly just be able to construe as “transphobic”, such is the enormity of the crime were that to be the case, such is the horror which would ensue if a member of the sacred caste or one of their acolytes should have their feelings hurt - so much more sensitive and important than ordinary bog standard people’s feelings - that the “some” had to be conspicuously wedged in there to ward off any possible accusations of generalising, any possible misinterpretation that it was meant to be about all biologically male trans people.

And even after all that it still didn’t work!! Still the accusations flow.

Still the calls for the ducking chair.

Ho hum.

Nothing less than 100% capitulation and obedience will do. As ever.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 30/10/2021 19:46

Hmm, just stay with me here, but could the kind of predatory male who manages to not get caught also be even sneakier than the kind that gets caught and sent to prison?

titchy · 30/10/2021 19:45

Blanchard's research isn't banned here. The word he uses for certain TW is, but his research is perfectly legitimate Confused

MN is many things, but it is not an arbiter of what is and what isn't decent research. How peculiar to think otherwise.

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 19:38

SOME does not equal ALL

before someone spits the dummy out

BloodinGutters · 30/10/2021 19:37

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

Hmm, I wonder if perhaps violent males without criminal convictions (i.e. not caught yet) might want to identify their way into women's spaces on the outside. Nah...

Only men with a criminal record would ever be so sneaky...

Don’t be silly. That would never happen.

Men who aren’t already locked up in prison for being predatory couldn’t actually be predatory could they?

Everyone knows predatory criminals just magically appear in prisons in a poof of smoke with a black mask over eyes and striped prison garb.

Same way we can tell actual bad guys in real life by the same outfit choices and transwomen only wear feminine clothes so none of them could ever be bad guys could they?

*thought process of some of the twaREALw crew.

TalkingtoLangClegintheDark · 30/10/2021 19:31

@PurgatoryOfPotholes

This is completely absurd.

This is like a thread of people trying to raise awareness that there were abusive priests in the Catholic Church, with two or three posters in the middle shouting "Stop saying all priests are abusers, priestphobe!"

No-one thought all transwomen were rapists.

But we need to deal with the number that are, and their enablers

Indeed. Would a discussion about the incidence of child abuse in the RC church (or in other churches, for that matter) be subject to the same denials and defensiveness from devout Catholics, I wonder?

I suppose it was, for a long time. There were indeed many devout Catholics who enabled the very worst sins against children to be perpetrated by abusers within the “sacred caste” of priests, for decades and decades, because it was too threatening to their belief system to acknowledge the reality.

As a result, many many more people had their lives ruined by CSA that could have been prevented if people had been willing to listen and believe the victims.

I think that’s a very accurate analogy for the denial and defensiveness on here. People don’t want to believe it so they have to accuse those saying it of scaremongering, of exaggerating, of having it in for those they are accusing.

Meanwhile, the abuse goes on, and if any decision about action on it were left to these people, it would continue to go on and on and on, unchecked.

Because naming abuse that’s happening is a far worse crime than actually committing the abuse, in the eyes of these people.

As others have said, there’s a parallel too with the way Muslim grooming gangs were allowed to operate with impunity for years and years after they were first identified, and many, many more vulnerable girls raped and abused, because it wasn’t ok to recognise the phenomenon seeing as the abusers were from a minority themselves. Same old, same old. No lessons learned. No outrage, no protectiveness, no concern for these vulnerable victims at all.

Just a resounding “so what”.

I don’t have words for the extent of my contempt for those who enable this.

YouSetTheTone · 30/10/2021 19:30

Strange how no one calls heterosexual men bigoted for only being attracted to women.

But women who are only attracted to women… who won’t sleep with men, however they identify, because they have penises….? It’s fair game to call them all sorts of disgusting slurs and pressure them into sex.

It’s deeply, deeply sad how homophobic and misogynist our society is at the moment.

FrippEnos · 30/10/2021 19:29

I really can't get my head around anyone thinking that a lesbian should have sex with someone with a penis.

I mean lesbianism is a simple premise.

And anyone that thinks anyone should be able to peer pressure, pressure or coerce someone into sex is just fucked in the head.

DdraigGoch · 30/10/2021 19:27

@Ijustreallywantacat

It's 'scaremongering' when women talk about their experiences of being coerced into sex?

It is scaremongering when a national news organisation runs a whole article focusing on the behaviour of a few people from a minority group, and then people are led to believe that it is representative of that group, and that that group are people we should be afraid of.

That article very explicitly used the word "some" in the headline. It could not have been more clear. The only people who take that to mean "all" are morons. People trying to claim that it implies something else are clearly trying to shut discussion of sexual violence against a vulnerable minority down. I don't want to consider what their motives might be for doing this.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 30/10/2021 19:23

My post was me sharing my experience as a lesbian and why I don’t consider myself threatened by them.

But again, so what? What do your personal experiences matter? Bully for you if your experiences have been positive ones. This is a discussion about the negative experiences of some. Your point only has any validity of the article was generalising to everyone's experiences. Which it clearly wasn't.