Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed with the way my sister is raising her kids

194 replies

snup · 30/10/2021 10:38

Backstory, we had a difficult upbringing with loving but inadequate parents (mental health issues, alcoholism).

Now she has 4 kids with fairly big age gaps and I have one.

The dynamic in her family is just dreadful. Everyone fights and argues all the time, the older kids take parental approaches to the younger kids which I think is inappropriate. She and DBIL are super strict with many many rules that are enforced with iron will. There's no abuse, plenty of money and all the kids are loved and well cared for, materially.

But no meal happens without at least one child being sent outside / away. No day out without a huge bust up between at least two members of the family and sometimes more. There is always someone shouting and someone crying.

I feel so sad for her kids and for her really.

But I also get that 4 kids is about crowd control and I also think she's mirroring a lot of what was bad about our own childhood.

She seems stressed and joyless.

Should I say something? If so, what?

OP posts:
Lokdok · 30/10/2021 11:44

If you want to help her, stop being so judgemental and offer some childcare!

Comedycook · 30/10/2021 11:44

I remember reading a post on a different forum once where a mum of one girl was contemplating reporting her neighbour who had four boys because she often heard the mother shouting and she wouldn't dream of shouting at her only girl...Hmm

Lorw · 30/10/2021 11:43

Paha. Our 3 boys have age gaps and due a little girl in December, our house is chaotic, always fighting, always having to pull one off the other, send one for time out. Meal times are the worst ‘he’s looking at me funny’, ‘he’s touching me’ ‘he got ketchup on my chip’ - all while screaming at each other, you have to tell them 50 times, we’ve had to separate the eldest from the youngest two at meal times 🙄

I don’t think you can judge when you’ve got one tbf OP 😂

TheQueef · 30/10/2021 11:42

I think you are getting a hard time here Snup it is your business and you should take interest.
It does sound like a perception (4 vs 1) but keeping an eye and offering help is no bad thing.

jeannie46 · 30/10/2021 11:41

My mother was one of 8.

Lots of noise, lots of 'minding each others' business', arguing etc. But, in adulthood, ( obviously the only part I saw ), they would stand with each other against the world, fantastic in a crisis - still minding each others' business.

Their parents must have had a 'full life' and were very hardworking,
involved and organised but gave their children the best gift of all - they thought they were all great.

Maybe what you see as stressful, they see as showing concern, letting it all out, getting instant feedback, resulting in fantastic mental health - once out it doesn't bother them anymore. They're raring to go again the next time. Some people thrive in this kind stimulating environment.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 30/10/2021 11:38

it is on the passionate/clashing personalities side of normal, but there's nothing ultimately wrong there.
we have 7 kids, not a day goes by without some arguments. it's part and parcel of having a lot of individuals living together.

in fact I know of families where it's just 2 or 3 people and they still argue a lot so having bust ups is not a big family privilege.

You should never ever comment on someone else's parenting to their face, unsolicited and unwarranted "help/advice" is never appreciated. yikes, don't do it.
stay out of it.
I'm sure she's doing the best she can, if you want to help ask her if she needs support in any way.

FigureofEight · 30/10/2021 11:38

Oh hang on

I'm thinking it's a wind up

FigureofEight · 30/10/2021 11:38

I think OP got the message but you really don't have a clue how it is with a) more than one child, 2) children who aren't well behaved 3) teens 4) mix of ages where you can't meet everyone's need so there will always be someone displeased.

Even meals. One child you have full attention onto 1 from possibly two adults. Can pick foods they generally love and conversation is calm.

I can get my head around the fact that you can't see how noncomparable this is.

SuperSleepyBaby · 30/10/2021 11:36

It sounds normal to me. It probably looks worse for you looking in from the outside. I have 4 children and they argue and fight every day but also get on well most of the time. They sometimes hit each other, shout but then put it behind them 5 minutes later and are back to being friends- its water of a duck’s back to them.

Oh4Tunas · 30/10/2021 11:33

I don't think the age gap sounds that large, tbh. Not small, but from the OP, I was expecting something like a 15 or 20 year gap.

I don't think it's your place to intervene, unless you think the children are being neglected or mistreated. Different situation, different parenting style... If you say something, you risk alienating her, and then you won't be able to help her or the children if they do need your assistance.

Bluntness100 · 30/10/2021 11:32

Maybe stop being so judgey op? You don’t even take all four together to baby sit, give it a shot for a few days then judge her.

Gwenhwyfar · 30/10/2021 11:32

@gcgirlsrock

Yes take all four for the weekend, and if you successfully achieve silence and calm for 48 hours as they sit in a line knitting etc then you are clearly the superior parent and can share your top tips (with us) most likely you will get a clear insight into juggling multiple children and how excruciatingly exhausting it can be and cut your sister some slack?
For the 'experiment' to work she'd have to have them from infance though.
gcgirlsrock · 30/10/2021 11:30

Yes take all four for the weekend, and if you successfully achieve silence and calm for 48 hours as they sit in a line knitting etc then you are clearly the superior parent and can share your top tips (with us) most likely you will get a clear insight into juggling multiple children and how excruciatingly exhausting it can be and cut your sister some slack?

AudTheDeepMinded · 30/10/2021 11:29

I have three children and recognise a lot of the 'issues' you have highlighted with your sister's family. I can totally understand the inflexibility of rules, if everyone got to what they liked when they liked my house would be even more chaotic than it is now. Rules ensure things run smoothly and everyone is treated fairly. There is usually someone crying or fighting too, we don't encourage this of course, but it happens. However, just as frequently, there are collaborative games and mutually caring behaviours and looking out for each other (and ganging up on me!). Comparing a large family with an only child is like comparing an apple and a grape, they are both fruit, but that's about it!

nitsandwormsdodger · 30/10/2021 11:25

Never criticise another’s parenting it will only end badly

Take her 4 for the weekend support her

canichange · 30/10/2021 11:24

My house was calm when I had one child. I now have two children and it's carnage. I can only begin to imagine the chaos of there were twice as many children here again.

As long as the children are provided for and know they are loved, stay out of it.

gcgirlsrock · 30/10/2021 11:24

Kids make noise - lots of noise. More the merrier! There is a judgy element to your observations which makes you sound unkind towards your sister.
If you are that worried about their welfare then get stuck in and help! Judging from the sidelines in a pious way will be a guaranteed way to wreck your relationship with her.
I expect you don’t see the fantastic massive family Christmases, or the fact they are able to be self sufficient socially if they want to be or the fun they have together. It seems you only look at the negative. Which is sad for you and your child mostly as I can’t think they will rush to invite you over.

TimeForTeaAndG · 30/10/2021 11:24

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

Thing is, she won't change her parenting style if you say anything. All that will happen is that she will be furious, and is likely to limit contact with you, so you will have less opportunity to support your nephews & nieces.

I don't agree with PPs that shouting and sending out is normal at every meal, though - and I'm one of 4, with a very shouty mother, and had 3 (DFC) myself. Yes, you will have a lot of chaos and bickering, but even my family managed the occasional moment of harmony. And you are right that it's horribly stressful. I loathed family meals as a child and the term, 'family time' makes me shudder to this day.

Or maybe if OP asks if everything is ok, the sister might say no it's a fucking riot and I've no idea how to change it.
Gwenhwyfar · 30/10/2021 11:24

" the older kids take parental approaches to the younger kids which I think is inappropriate."

May I ask why? I do think it's wrong if the older children are given tasks and responsibilities that should not be theirs, but having a parental 'approach' is pretty normal isn't it?

I'm one of four and there was a lot of arguing and shouting as well. Not something that did me much good, but probably is normal with four children, especially on days out or confined to a small space.

Ozgirl75 · 30/10/2021 11:23

I have a lovely friend, with one child. She is so great, but she just has such a totally different experience to people who have more than one. I’m an only child as well and my parents didn’t shout, I had no one to bicker with, home life was very calm and chilled.
I have two boys and although they generally get on well, the noise! And there is just bickering sometimes, random arguing over nonsense, sitting on heads, running into a bedroom and farting at each other etc. And that’s just with two! I know my parents sometimes look at our house and go “wow” as it’s just such a different experience than having one (especially one girl I have to say).
So the arguments etc might not be great but honestly a house with one 4 year old girl is just not comparable to a house with four children of a variety of ages.

Ponoka7 · 30/10/2021 11:23

"The older kids tell off the younger kids."

My six year old GC tells off her 4 year old sister, it starts with pointing out danger and carries on.

"Think i read a meme or something somewhere to say any more than 3 and you are basically a bouncer"

I could work for any security service because my de-escalation is world class and I practice it daily.

Shouting can be a personality thing. My DD shouts, I don't and never did.

Comedycook · 30/10/2021 11:22

I think this can often be family life especially when you have multiple kids and they are older...tweens and teens can often be stroppy as full of attitude. Loudness and shouting doesn't necessarily mean a miserable existence...some families just have a slightly different dynamic. You say they're loved and there's no abuse...just love and support them like you would any family member.

Cheeseplantboots · 30/10/2021 11:22

Sounds like most families with four kids. Them being strict and sticking to their guns isn’t a negative thing at all.

You cannot judge or have any idea what it’s like to parent 4 children. They sound like good, consistent parents.

HouseSitter2B · 30/10/2021 11:22

I was one of 4 kids, with some big age gaps. Family life was nothing like you describe. There was never any shouting or arguments, beyond some mild occasional sibling bickering. It sounds grim OP, but I don’t think there’s a lot you can do.

ViceLikeBlip · 30/10/2021 11:19

Maybe they're "even stricter" when you're around as they can tell you don't approve of their unruly kids? I'm guilty of this sometimes and my (unruly) kids just tend to look at me in total confusion 😏

There are lots of downsides to growing up in a large family, and the constant bickering and the crowd control element are definitely wearing. But there are also lots of upsides as well- never bored, lots of stimulation, lots of conversation, and plenty of experience in conflict resolution 😉 If the parents are overwhelmed/struggling, then help them out. If they're happy with how they're managing, then keep schtum.

Swipe left for the next trending thread