Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL and Dog

213 replies

LadyGAgain · 30/10/2021 09:43

Firstly have to say that I have a very lovely MIL. We have a great relationship and I don't ever want to upset her.

Before covid she got a puppy. She's worked very hard to train him. He is a big dog (similar to a large labradoodle). He is very lovely natured. Loves the kids. Soppy.

We work hard and have worked hard to have a nice home. New sofas were delivered recently. The children have their toys of course to play with. We have a cat. This is (IMO) important.

Now my AIBU and to ask for advice. Christmas is approaching. On one of the celebratory days we will host the wider family here and I don't want her to bring the dog. My reasons for this are 3 fold. 1. We have a cat and she has never been around a dog.

  1. He jumps on sofas and will need to go out for the toilet and I don't want muddy dog on our floors/sofa.
  2. He still picks up things in his mouth and I don't want kids toys and our shoes in his mouth.

AIBU? How do I get over this and if I can't get over it, how can I gently explain this to MIL as I don't want to upset her. This dog is her life. Please help me. Thank you.

OP posts:
GirlWithAGuitar · 31/10/2021 09:07

It its totally acceptable and normal to leave a dog all day alone. That, is normal. You are very strange. Very strange indeed.

Of course it’s not acceptable to leave a dog alone all day. 🙄

MargosKaftan · 31/10/2021 09:01

Last message was supposed to be quoting @thecatgirl. Not sure why it didn't.

MargosKaftan · 31/10/2021 09:00

But very few people who work full time outside the home do have dogs without paying for dog day care or a dog walker to visit and take the dog out during the working day. Few breeders and no animal shelters will let you have a dog unless someone is in house for most of the day, and those who will sell to someone who works ft do question carefully about dog day care/dog walkers plans.

Leaving a dog all day is known to be cruel. They arent cats. This isn't a "fur baby" issue - in the 80s and 90s when I grew up, it was clear you only had a dog if someone was in the house for most of the day or so many grandparents came in to walk dogs of 2 working households.

If you know people who work full time out of the home and don't have someone come in to walk the dog /drop the dog with daycare, then they are very unusual and cruel. Its not ok.

diddl · 31/10/2021 09:00

Even if the dog has been in the house it would still be different if there are a few others about & everyone is busy & ignoring the dog.

Or it's closed in somewhere & someone lets it out!

DottyHarmer · 31/10/2021 08:52

Ten minutes?! No problem! A quick dash back to give the dog a loo trip (and oneself!) is fine.

I told some relatives I was unable to visit once because of my dog and they accommodated him in the utility room. As a pp said, a long walk and a comfy nook and a normal dog will settle down in peace. Big dogs are (after they are mad puppies) generally very well behaved (probably because they tire out more easily!).

Pawprintpaper · 31/10/2021 08:49

Does the dog sleep in a crate?
Could you insist the dog can only come if it stays in crate/garden/car and not the main house, otherwise your cat will freak out and start urinating everywhere (as stressed cats often do). Maybe those who want to could take it out for a big family walk after lunch?

CarrieBlue · 31/10/2021 08:47

Point 2 and 3,you are very unreasonable.

Point 2 and 3 are perfectly reasonable - it’s the OP’s house and she can have or not have whatever she wants to have in her home. A visitor’s dog (even if the visitor is MIL) doesn’t have a right to be in the OP’s house.

TheGirlCat · 31/10/2021 08:47

[quote Andwander]@LaetitiaASD.It is totally unacceptable to leave a dog all day alone.the selfishness of humans is staggering.I would report you to the RSPCA.Absolutely disgusting.if you dont have time to care adequately for a dog,dont ffs get a dog![/quote]
Wow, your attitude is scary! Taking your attitude, NO ONE who owns a dog would work full time. It its totally acceptable and normal to leave a dog all day alone. That, is normal. You are very strange. Very strange indeed.

Andwander · 31/10/2021 08:41

@LaetitiaASD.It is totally unacceptable to leave a dog all day alone.the selfishness of humans is staggering.I would report you to the RSPCA.Absolutely disgusting.if you dont have time to care adequately for a dog,dont ffs get a dog!

Andwander · 31/10/2021 08:36

Point 2 and 3,you are very unreasonable.point 1 however is a concern.Is there a way you could bring him with this suggestion.you all take the dog for a lovely walk and enjoy it.when you get back is there a way you could put him savely in a separate room with comfy dogbed,lickmat and other dog entertainment toys.He will be tired and settle and you can enjoy mudfree furniture etc.

MargosKaftan · 31/10/2021 08:31

OP have you asked MIL yet? Because as I wouldn't assume any invite for me included the dog unless specifically told by the host , and one only 10 min drive away id assume id leave her at home, mil might already be planning this. You might have to fit timings round her being out for a bit to walk the dog, or staying less overall, but otherwise, not likely she'd assume her dog was part of the invite.

CarrieBlue · 31/10/2021 08:27

It’s one day. Not worth the upset that it would cause.

Exactly. So the dog should stay at home and not cause upset to the op.

Dog owners seem to expect that their pets have to go everywhere. There were two greyhounds queuing with their owners to go into Durham Cathedral yesterday. Madness.

TheGirlCat · 31/10/2021 08:25

@Subbaxeo

We just put the cat in the bedroom when my dsd visits with her dog-we just say he’s not allowed on furniture. Yes, he is boisterous but he’s just kept on a firm lead until he settles down. Having good relationships with family does involve compromise and it’s easier for her to bring him rather than stressing about getting back in time. I don’t understand these people saying it’s your house so you get to say who comes-yes it is but surely you want those who you love to feel good rather than acting like a little Hitler. I could understand if say, your children are scared of dogs or allergic but that doesn’t sound the case-they might be delighted to see Granny’s dog on a special day.
So your DSD doesn't do the right thing and leave her dog at home so your cat has to pay the price. Strange how your DSD doesn't care about 'compromise' by visiting you without the dog. It's all one way. Your DSD is the one acting like the 'little Hitler' here, and you roll over and your cat has to suffer for it. Charming.
icedcoffees · 31/10/2021 08:23

Could you host at MIL's if it's only ten minutes away? You can still provide the food and do as much prep and cooking at yours beforehand, and the drive over there for the day?

I'd say that would make much more sense really - it means MIL isn't worrying about the dog and your cat has some peace and quiet and isn't trapped in a house full of noisy visitors.

MargosKaftan · 31/10/2021 08:13

Oh and we have a puppy. She's still only 5 months old so hasn't been left for more than a couple of hours yet, but we wouldn't assume an invite included the dog if it was so close to us that we didn't need to stay over. A 10 min drive, if we needed to be there for more than 2 hours now (or 4 hours when she's older), we'd just be clear with the host one of us would have to pop back to let the dog out / give her a cuddle, then come back.

MargosKaftan · 31/10/2021 08:09

If MIL lives only 10 minutes away, then this is a non-issue! You say you are very sorry, but the cat won't cope with having a dog in the house so puppy can't come over, but we thought maybe everyone could swing by MILs after lunch to collect bouncy puppy and take him for a walk to walk off the lunch. Puppy can be returned to own bed afterwards and MIL come back to yours for the rest of the afternoon.

Dog gets walk, kids get fresh air yo reduce the chance of afternoon squbbling - plan round this with some sort of outdoor toy like a scooter or walkie talkies for at least one of the dcs to take out and use on dog walk/ at the park.

RampantIvy · 31/10/2021 08:02

There speaks someone who has never had a "playful" young labrador.

Some dog owners, and it is only some simply don't get how inconvenient it is in many ways to have a dog visiting a dog free household.

Yesterday we had two sets of friends round with their dogs. One dog was put into our (heated) conservatory. Our other friends kept their dog in the car because both dogs fight are too boisterous with each other. Both sets of owners took their dogs for walk, fed them etc at appropriate times, and everyone, including the dogs were happy. They did this because they both had two hour drives, not 10 minutes.

I would have thought that if your MIL only lived a 10 minute drive away she could pop back to walk and feed her dog.

Subbaxeo · 31/10/2021 07:55

Btw-our cat is a well loved part of my family too, but she’s hardly traumatised by being put in a warm bedroom to sleep rather than being forced to interact with a large dog. We do the same if workmen come to the house. She sniffs around a bit when he’s gone and then goes back to normal.

Subbaxeo · 31/10/2021 07:52

We just put the cat in the bedroom when my dsd visits with her dog-we just say he’s not allowed on furniture. Yes, he is boisterous but he’s just kept on a firm lead until he settles down. Having good relationships with family does involve compromise and it’s easier for her to bring him rather than stressing about getting back in time. I don’t understand these people saying it’s your house so you get to say who comes-yes it is but surely you want those who you love to feel good rather than acting like a little Hitler. I could understand if say, your children are scared of dogs or allergic but that doesn’t sound the case-they might be delighted to see Granny’s dog on a special day.

CoolOven · 31/10/2021 07:37

If nothing the cat will be clever enough to find a spot away from the dog
And when the dog's gone it will go round pissing on everything to get rid of the dog smell and re mark its territory.

TeaDrinker247 · 31/10/2021 06:14

It’s one day. Not worth the upset that it would cause. It’s not going to be the only time she comes to visit. Look at solutions:

  • Get king/super king bed sheets to cover the sofas.
  • Ask her to bring towels to dry the dogs feet once it has been outside.
  • Borrow a stair gate. Put it on a door to create a dog-friendly room or get a play pen/room divider to block the dog off.
  • Introduce the dog and cat separately. You’ll be suprised how well these animals get on. If nothing the cat will be clever enough to find a spot away from the dog.
Whereismumhiding3 · 31/10/2021 04:49

@Goawayangryman
You have both dogs and cats so your cat will be used to a dog, hence why you can't understand. You'd house will already smell of dog. Cats that don't live with dogs are unlikely to be ok about it and show upset behaviour for up to a couple weeks afterwards.

If you RTFT you'll see how PPs explained it is a big deal to take dog into cats home even for a short while. It's unnecessary upset.

Goawayangryman · 30/10/2021 18:42

That's alright... Different strokes for different folks. It's not to accommodate the cat, but the MIL.

I've got both dogs and cats. I love them all. But neither dog nor cat will die from being confined to a relatively large area for a few hours...

zukiecat · 30/10/2021 18:24

@Goawayangryman

Anyone who suggested my cat could go outside or upstairs in my house, to accommodate a dog wouldn't be welcome.

My cat is part of my family and no way would I shut him anywhere for a dog.

HauntedVag · 30/10/2021 17:45

If she only lives 10 mins away she can't come for lunch, go home and walk him, come back for a couple of hours, then go home to him.

I wouldn't even entertain a conversation about the dog.

I know my mil would love to bring her dog and for us to just lock the cat out, or put him in the bedroom. Not happening. Our cat is a rescue and we probably wouldn't see him for a week if a dog had been indoors! It's his home, he had a tough enough life in and out of shelters, and he's our priority.