Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL and Dog

213 replies

LadyGAgain · 30/10/2021 09:43

Firstly have to say that I have a very lovely MIL. We have a great relationship and I don't ever want to upset her.

Before covid she got a puppy. She's worked very hard to train him. He is a big dog (similar to a large labradoodle). He is very lovely natured. Loves the kids. Soppy.

We work hard and have worked hard to have a nice home. New sofas were delivered recently. The children have their toys of course to play with. We have a cat. This is (IMO) important.

Now my AIBU and to ask for advice. Christmas is approaching. On one of the celebratory days we will host the wider family here and I don't want her to bring the dog. My reasons for this are 3 fold. 1. We have a cat and she has never been around a dog.

  1. He jumps on sofas and will need to go out for the toilet and I don't want muddy dog on our floors/sofa.
  2. He still picks up things in his mouth and I don't want kids toys and our shoes in his mouth.

AIBU? How do I get over this and if I can't get over it, how can I gently explain this to MIL as I don't want to upset her. This dog is her life. Please help me. Thank you.

OP posts:
008NoTimeToDiet · 01/11/2021 22:39

People who have dogs have to understand they can't take them everywhere. They either accept the restrictions on their lives, or they don't get a dog.
No way would I have such a dirty animal in my home.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 01/11/2021 22:19

That's how I feel too and why I always have accommodated MIL's dogs within limits even though I would rather not. I do like her and want to see her and more importantly want her to see DH and her grandkids regularly

If I refused to have her dogs in the house at all it would be hard for her to come as often because she lives a couple of hours away so realistically she has to stay over and she can't afford to board out 3 dogs regularly plus the old ones are getting health issues now.

We don't have any pets and honestly I don't like her dogs terribly much. I like my house clean and not smelling of dog and my life would definitely be easier if she didn't have them but she does. I would not cause her to see her son and grandkids less over issues like that as family is more important.

Goawayangryman · 01/11/2021 20:21

But to me, important humans always do come before pets. Or a pristine house. Not ridiculous to me. Those are my choices.
My dog would prefer never to have to go away to his boarder when we go away (dunno about the pup yet ...). We want the occasional holiday therefore dog has to go to boarder Confused.

Cat would far prefer fish and milk or an egg every day and to never have to share home with any kids, other small furries or irritating things like Hoovers, invocations to get off/ not scratch the furniture etc. Again, nope.

There is a balance with pets, children, etc. To me personally, a clean house is much less important than gritting my teeth and accommodating loved family members at Christmas. Sometime we have to put ourselves out a bit for others. Others may make different choices and that is ok but I wouldn't feel good about saying someone couldn't come because of their dog.

RockinHorseShit · 01/11/2021 20:01

Important humans always come top and before pets.

Don't be ridiculous. Those important humans have just put their dog above the home owners best interest or wishes. Why is that okay, but saying "no" I don't want a dog in my house isn't. Those "important humans" need to learn to give & take & understand that not everyone is going to live their dog too

Goawayangryman · 01/11/2021 19:50

Other not-compatible with visiting animal pets... Sorry. Cut a chunk out of my post by accident.

Goawayangryman · 01/11/2021 19:49

Yep. I think it's a bit bonkers to make your whole house off limits owing to cleanliness, other pet, or "precious things" reasons.

And I say that as someone who grew up pretty not-well-off and who has various incompatible-with-visitors/ other animals pets ... Important humans always come top and before pets.

ShadowsInTheDarkness · 01/11/2021 19:06

[quote Whereismumhiding3]@Goawayangryman
You have both dogs and cats so your cat will be used to a dog, hence why you can't understand. You'd house will already smell of dog. Cats that don't live with dogs are unlikely to be ok about it and show upset behaviour for up to a couple weeks afterwards.

If you RTFT you'll see how PPs explained it is a big deal to take dog into cats home even for a short while. It's unnecessary upset. [/quote]
When we just had the 4 cats we often hosted PIL with their large cat chasing dog. We would section an area off for the cats and they spent that time in there. They were never overly affected afterwards, always had a good sniff round to make sure the dog was really gone, and would be back curled up on the sofa a few hours after the dog had vacated it!

We now have both dogs and cats. Our dogs don't like cats despite our best efforts and would chase them. The dogs have the run of the kitchen diner and back garden, and occasionally the front room, and the cats have the run of upstairs, the front room and study most of the time and the front garden, orchard and woodland. They occasionally come face to face through a stair gate and get woofed at which they don't enjoy (usually when a visitor forgets to shut a door) and this doesn't affect their behaviour for weeks either.
Ime cats can quickly get used to occasionally sharing their territory with another animal and in the OPs situation I would (and have) just restrict the dog to a room and make sure the cats have access to other rooms. Perfectly manageable for one day. Besides which for us Christmas isn't Christmas without the dogs. They are part of the family, like extra children and I suspect MIL has quite a strong bond to the dog, especially if she's on her own. I think it would be a nice thing to do to make an effort to accommodate the dog.

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 01/11/2021 18:35

I do agree OP doesn't have to have the dog at all if she doesn't want to but she says she has a good relationship with MIL and I thought she might be looking for a compromise hence utility room behind a stair gate suggestion.

I found that in real life it was harder just to tell MIL to piss off with her dogs cos 'my house my rules' as mum sent always suggests because I did actually want to maintain a relationship with her and not fall out.

VillageOf8 · 01/11/2021 17:53

Why do some dog owners think everyone else wants to entertain their dog? I have a dog and wouldn't dream of bringing her to someone's home unless the person specifically told me to bring her.

OP, you don't need to use anything as an excuse. It's your home. If you don't want the dog there, say no. Your husband can back you up as it's his home that will be messed up too or he can go be with his mom and her dog on Christmas.

I guess I'm just too old and cranky to sugarcoat anything or care if I offend. My house my rules. I would not want anyone's dog over my home, especially if it was misbehaved and ESPECIALLY if they just brought the dog and assumed I would be ok with it. Nope, nopity nope.

ColinTheKoala · 01/11/2021 17:52

@BlairSinclair

I don't have a cat and I still won't let dogs in my house. Just not wanting it there is a valid reason OP.

We have a small shelter they are welcome to keep the dogs in outside, or their cars. I appreciate that means people may not choose to come but that is their decision. A dog is not a baby/child and does not require the same adjustments - and smells a lot worse!

A dog is not a baby/child and does not require the same adjustments

Indeed. Sadly most dog owners disagree.

VampireVicki · 01/11/2021 17:50

To be fair, MIL hasn't said anything about bringing the dog. OP is just getting prepared in case it is raised as a suggestion.

Given how close she lives, I really cannot see it becoming a problem OP and you are probably worrying quite unnecessarily Flowers

Satsuma2019 · 01/11/2021 15:48

I had the same issue. DP told MIL dogs were not invited. She has now said she will only come for a couple hours which is fine by me tbh 😂

BlairSinclair · 01/11/2021 15:47

I don't have a cat and I still won't let dogs in my house. Just not wanting it there is a valid reason OP.

We have a small shelter they are welcome to keep the dogs in outside, or their cars. I appreciate that means people may not choose to come but that is their decision. A dog is not a baby/child and does not require the same adjustments - and smells a lot worse!

AhNowTed · 01/11/2021 15:05

No way would someone's dog trump my cat.

It's a totally valid reason OP.

My cat would be traumatised. He doesn't like new people in the house, never mind a bloody dog.

Laiste · 01/11/2021 15:00

I mean who brings their dog with them when they live 10 minutes up the road?!

Laiste · 01/11/2021 15:00

It's 10 minutes away. MILs house.

Ten.Minutes

She can feed/walk the dog before she leaves and pop back every 2 hours if she wants to to let it out or walk it again.

Confused She wont expect to bring the dog surely?
AmyDudley · 01/11/2021 14:59

If she's only ten minutes away it is no problem, the dog will be fine and she can pop back every couple of hours to let him out for a wee, and take him for a walk before she leaves. He will be fine. I have a dog and would never take him when I go to my DS and DDIL's house because they have cats (actually the cats are more likely to attack him - he's a complete wimp).
Also I wouldn't take my dog anywhere where he might eat a little toy like a Barbie shoe or something, it could end up with a very expensive vet visit - I'd use that as a reason for you MIL, that you don;t want the dog to eat plastic and get sick. Also after Christmas etc the dog will probably be finding lots of new people and new places a bit overwhelming so it would be kinder to leave him at home in peace.

LaetitiaASD · 01/11/2021 14:51

@CoolOven

Or maybe they just don't want a dog in the house? It isn't unreasonable to not want a dog in the house IMO It's so hard to explain this concept to some. I invited a new acquaintance and her husband for dinner and she thanked me and said "just to let you know, we'll have to bring the dog". I told her I don't have dogs in my house because they make me sneeze. Plus I don't really like them very much and I'd be in edge. "But we won't be able to come otherwise" she said.

I said ok fair enough. She seemed quite shocked and I ended up feeling like the unreasonable one. Our friendship has not taken off.

You really really really shouldn't have felt like the unreasonable one.
LaetitiaASD · 01/11/2021 14:49

@CovoidOfAllHumanity

I think you need to agree with MIL a safe place where the dog is going to stay eg utility room behind a stair gate and make it the norm that this is where it stays when at your house. Put it a bed in there and give it treats when it goes and lies down there. Maybe a Kong or chew toys to keep it entertained. Invite her over and practice this before Christmas so the dog knows what the routine is.

It will actually be better for the dog too if you make a nice safe spot for it. It likely will prefer a safe quiet space away from children and the cat too. Make sure children don't pet it on its bed as that is its safe spot.

As I said I wish I had established this rule with my MIL's dogs and my BIL did do this quite successfully at his house. As long as the dog has had a walk and has a comfortable spot it's not cruel for it to be away from the rest of the house and in fact it may be better. MIL might also find it less stressful not having to worry how the dog is around the children and the cat and nor do you so it's actually a win win for all.

Your problem comes if she doesn't agree with this plan and says it'll be fine etc etc. In that case it's a hard line of dog in the utility room or no dog in the house at all. I regret that I allowed boundaries to be transgressed and I resented cleaning up fur for ages after every visit and that one of the dogs actually nipped my 2yr old when MIL was supposed to be supervising them.
The toddler was bothering the dog but this should never have been allowed and they should have been separated as I'd originally asked.

The only acceptable place at OPs house is MILs car IMHO.
tickledtiger · 01/11/2021 12:16

I get it op. I would definitely use the cat as an excuse although all of your reasons are fair enough. And your DH should have the conversation.

I think this is just one of the realities of having a dog as your MIL will have realised.

RockinHorseShit · 01/11/2021 11:47

You have a cat, it's a simple no. It unfortunately par for the course when you get a dog, stick to your guns.

We have cats & after trying once with a friends well trained & good natured dog, no dog enters our house. Our poor big soppy tomcat actually had full blown panic attack & couldn't breathe Sad

CoolOven · 01/11/2021 10:56

Or maybe they just don't want a dog in the house? It isn't unreasonable to not want a dog in the house IMO
It's so hard to explain this concept to some. I invited a new acquaintance and her husband for dinner and she thanked me and said "just to let you know, we'll have to bring the dog". I told her I don't have dogs in my house because they make me sneeze. Plus I don't really like them very much and I'd be in edge. "But we won't be able to come otherwise" she said.

I said ok fair enough. She seemed quite shocked and I ended up feeling like the unreasonable one. Our friendship has not taken off.

diddl · 01/11/2021 10:45

"I think you need to agree with MIL a safe place where the dog is going to stay"

Why does she?

There are plenty of other solutions that MIL can be looking into for her dog!

CovoidOfAllHumanity · 01/11/2021 08:55

I think you need to agree with MIL a safe place where the dog is going to stay eg utility room behind a stair gate and make it the norm that this is where it stays when at your house. Put it a bed in there and give it treats when it goes and lies down there. Maybe a Kong or chew toys to keep it entertained. Invite her over and practice this before Christmas so the dog knows what the routine is.

It will actually be better for the dog too if you make a nice safe spot for it. It likely will prefer a safe quiet space away from children and the cat too. Make sure children don't pet it on its bed as that is its safe spot.

As I said I wish I had established this rule with my MIL's dogs and my BIL did do this quite successfully at his house. As long as the dog has had a walk and has a comfortable spot it's not cruel for it to be away from the rest of the house and in fact it may be better. MIL might also find it less stressful not having to worry how the dog is around the children and the cat and nor do you so it's actually a win win for all.

Your problem comes if she doesn't agree with this plan and says it'll be fine etc etc. In that case it's a hard line of dog in the utility room or no dog in the house at all. I regret that I allowed boundaries to be transgressed and I resented cleaning up fur for ages after every visit and that one of the dogs actually nipped my 2yr old when MIL was supposed to be supervising them.
The toddler was bothering the dog but this should never have been allowed and they should have been separated as I'd originally asked.

oneglassandpuzzled · 01/11/2021 07:16

@GirlWithAGuitar

It its totally acceptable and normal to leave a dog all day alone. That, is normal. You are very strange. Very strange indeed.

Of course it’s not acceptable to leave a dog alone all day. 🙄

The girlcat seems to be extolling some very cruel dog ownership practices. Of course it’s not all right to leave a dog all day to got to work. I feel sorry for the dogs in this country of hers if they’re left out in the garden all day during winter.