Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable about gender representation in kids toys?

245 replies

stereeotype · 30/10/2021 09:19

I was looking for a birthday gift and have to say the shopping made me feel...slightly uncomfortable on how badly the toy options played into gender stereotypes. I haven't looked for a kids present for years as I don't have children, but I think I'd be frustrated if I did!

I would go as far as to say I found it disturbing. There was relatively little of use in the 'pink' section and nothing but practical/technical learning material amongst the boys.

Now I appreciate you don't have to buy girls toys for girls and boys for boys - but a girl is likely going to assume she subconsciously wants the girls toys as there are pictures of girls all over the boxes so likely to veer towards those.

Also, why can't the girl section appear girly but the actual toy still be of use, not just a dolls head for hairdressing or a kitchen for cooking?

Can't believe it's 2021 and we are still dealing with this.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Bunnycat101 · 31/10/2021 09:15

“The "boys" toys are challenging and interesting and the "girls" toys are unbelievably boring and sit pretty, very stereotypical, ie hoover, kitchen etc.”

I don’t think a toy kitchen is a ‘boring toy’ and that says more about you tbh. I’ve seen a toy kitchen in every toddler child I’ve ever been to girl or boy and it has been one of the most versatile toys in our house. It has been a cafe, vets, prison etc.

There seems to be an implicit thing on this thread that building toys = worthy and imaginary play toys less so. I think that is a mistake.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 31/10/2021 08:31

To be "uncomfortable" is just a bit of an over reaction isn't it?

I have a boy/girl twins so it's been interesting watching them develop. My boy likes to bang and bash things my girl is much gentler and prefers dolls etc. all the toys are in one toy box so I don't separate them pink and blue they choose what they want....they naturally gravitate towards different things 🤷🏻‍♀️

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 31/10/2021 08:28

It was a wooden vacuum but okay... Do you need a cup of tea?

Whitefire · 31/10/2021 08:22

@DockOTheBay

Yes products that are similar will be displayed together - so Barbie and Steffi dolls will be next to each other with the other fashion dolls like Rainbow High etc

In a pink section of the shop, with pink shelves and floor tiles, in pink boxes with pictures of girls on and a catalogue showing girls playing with them. So obviously aimed at girls. A boy wanting to buy a Barbie would be put off by the fact that they're so clearly aimed at girls.

I always find the attitudes on these threads really disingenuous with the faux "there are no boy aisles or girl aisles" Yes there is no sign above saying so but the way they are laid out clearly indicates what is going on. I was in Asda yesterday a double aisle of toys I presume the Lego, cars, construction, action figures on one side and the dolls, pretend play, Barbie, pink packaging on the other was purely just a coincidence?

The whole "I'm so enlightened I just see toys" is ridiculous.

Oh and to a pp who was saying their Tesco only has one single aisle of toys mine has two double aisles plus a back wall section, they are clearly laid out to gravitate children to one aisle or the other.

DockOTheBay · 31/10/2021 07:47

@MargaretThursday

I’m actually also annoyed at all the ‘gifts for her’ and ‘gifts for him’ sections in the Xmas catalogues. It’s not woke to just appreciate how much we are forced along societal expectation lines. Yes I'm going to be delighted with the gift pack of aftershave for Christmas. After all there can't possibly be any gifts that are more suitable for men than women or the other way round.
But aside from gifts which are specifically serving a purpose for men e.g. a facial razor, or women e.g. tampons, why is there any need to separate them?

Why can't a woman wear aftershave, how is it different to perfume? Why do we need "mens" and "womens" shower gel, toothbrushes, deodorant, books, tools, keyrings? Why are candles exclusively gifts "for women" and Swiss army knives "for men". It just doesn't make any logical sense apart from that those have been the traditional genders who would be given those items.

ConfusedBear · 31/10/2021 07:46

Yanbu! Can anyone else see an advert for spectacular science baking kits next to this thread? Black boxes with male scientists on the box, so even though no-one has told me in words - I know that it is a baking set for boys to use.

Colours and pictures carry meaning too. Think of colours used for Halloween and those used for Christmas. I could buy unlabeled seasonal items (like tablecloths which could be used at any time) and I would still know what celebration it was for. The images on packaging are carefully chosen to sell as much overall for the companies.

I've noticed that how obvious the marketing is can vary shop by shop. And personally I think gendered toys do matter because they can lead to practicing the same skill repeatedly and not having as much practice in other areas. Eg. Craft kits can help develop fine motor skills. This is important. Gross motor skills are also important and craft kits can be less good at developing these.

DockOTheBay · 31/10/2021 07:36

Look around you! Look at nature
Yes I love to see gender stereotypes in nature. Just the other day I was watching a hedgehog in the garden and I was so glad that it was wearing a little pink hat so that I knew it was a female hedgehog, otherwise how on earth would I know!?

DockOTheBay · 31/10/2021 07:26

Children don't think pink = girl, blue = boy or car = boy, doll = girl etc unless an adult puts this idea into their head. If an adult never said this concept children wouldn't even think about it.
But pictures and adverts of girls playing exclusively with dolls is an adult putting the concept in their heads. Not me, but some adult somewhere has decided to give them that idea.

DockOTheBay · 31/10/2021 07:23

Yes products that are similar will be displayed together - so Barbie and Steffi dolls will be next to each other with the other fashion dolls like Rainbow High etc

In a pink section of the shop, with pink shelves and floor tiles, in pink boxes with pictures of girls on and a catalogue showing girls playing with them. So obviously aimed at girls. A boy wanting to buy a Barbie would be put off by the fact that they're so clearly aimed at girls.

Yusanaim · 31/10/2021 06:40

I'm disappointed that lego aimed at girls isn't really building things whereas boys nearly always is. So they learn to handle and manipulate small objects from a very young age, read the instructions, have the satisfaction of building something.
Girls get to pretend play a scientist or a hairdresser - with pink trimmings.
I had a girl who used duplo and lego to build houses - that wasn't very scifi or techinical but still required the same skills as boy centred lego.
Son built tractors and planes at the same age.

AlmostAlwyn · 31/10/2021 05:53

@PandoraRocks

You misunderstand. The small stuff is worrying specifically about toys, not gender roles in general. Girls now have far more because of the achievements of the Feminist movement which focused on the real inequalities - equal pay, access to education and contraception etc.
But don't you think the "real inequalities" start with inequality in childhood? With differences in in toys and clothing? Right from the beginning, people have stereotyped expectations of girls and boys which affect the way they behave and cannot help but influence the children themselves. Inequality in childhood leads to inequality in education, which filters into the job market and positions of power.

Cognitive bias means that you're never going to be able to make people fully embrace equality. However much they're on board with the concept rationally, there's always that unconscious bias that says 'this man will be better suited to this job than this woman', 'this home task is a woman's job'. It must start with the "small stuff", with children themselves.

Newrunner29 · 31/10/2021 00:42

@PandoraRocks

You misunderstand. The small stuff is worrying specifically about toys, not gender roles in general. Girls now have far more because of the achievements of the Feminist movement which focused on the real inequalities - equal pay, access to education and contraception etc.
I dont feel its a misunderstanding, if the 'small stuff ' around toys is worrying why did u come on to this topic and say that people are disproportionately using time to discuss this when we should be conerned about global issues . 🤔 if u feel people need to discuss global issues create ur own thread about it, i would suggest.
PandoraRocks · 31/10/2021 00:23

You misunderstand. The small stuff is worrying specifically about toys, not gender roles in general. Girls now have far more because of the achievements of the Feminist movement which focused on the real inequalities - equal pay, access to education and contraception etc.

Newrunner29 · 31/10/2021 00:06

@PandoraRocks

I do realise that *@Newrunner29* but it seems people are absolutely obsessing, 'sweating the small stuff'. Topics like this consume a disproportionate amount of time and discussion generally. I just wish people would put as much focus and energy into the big stuff. Girls now have far more opportunities than I had and I don't think playing with dolls is going to spoil that.
But thats just such a whataboutism, gender roles is not small stuff. Its about challenging stereotypial things. Girls now have more because stereotyping was challenged. Girls have every right to play with dolls and ive never said they shouldn't , im just saying they could play with any toy and so could boys
PandoraRocks · 30/10/2021 23:59

I do realise that @Newrunner29 but it seems people are absolutely obsessing, 'sweating the small stuff'. Topics like this consume a disproportionate amount of time and discussion generally. I just wish people would put as much focus and energy into the big stuff. Girls now have far more opportunities than I had and I don't think playing with dolls is going to spoil that.

MargaretThursday · 30/10/2021 23:49

I’m actually also annoyed at all the ‘gifts for her’ and ‘gifts for him’ sections in the Xmas catalogues. It’s not woke to just appreciate how much we are forced along societal expectation lines.
Yes I'm going to be delighted with the gift pack of aftershave for Christmas.
After all there can't possibly be any gifts that are more suitable for men than women or the other way round.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 30/10/2021 23:49

Amazingly enough, the "woke generation" (though I'm nowhere near young enough to be in that) are capable of caring about more than one issue at any given point in time. It's not the environment or genderised toys, or human rights or genderised toys - we're perfectly able to care about multiple issues at once.

Newrunner29 · 30/10/2021 23:47

This is really shocking stuff but one can be concerned about all the things u mentioned Pandora and stereotyping of childrens toys at the same time 🤯 they dont cancel each other out!

PandoraRocks · 30/10/2021 23:43

This, Ladies and Gentlemen, is why the planet is fucked. It really annoys me that the 'Woke' generation spend so much time prioritising and obsessing over relatively trivial matters when the world is collapsing around us.

OP, you might find it 'disturbing' that there are aisles of gender stereotyped toys. I find it far more disturbing that we're pumping raw sewage into the rivers, filling the seas with plastic, allowing China to get away with multiple human and animal rights abuses..

I say to you OP, ignore the stereotyping and buy whatever YOU think is suitable for a child. For what it's worth, I was a child in the 60's. My mum never considered what she 'should' be buying me. I had Barbie dolls, Tiny Tears, a mini cooker but I also had Corgi model cars, a Lego petrol station, a Chopper bike, dinosaurs and a microscope set! I had the 'unisex' toys like jigsaws, roller skates and painting sets.

I played with dolls and girlie things but the brainwashing must have failed with me as I've never married or had kids Grin.

I don't think there is a correlation between lack of interest in science and traditional girls' toys. All my classmates had gender stereotyped toys but one grew up to be a pharmacist, several became doctors, another a biologist.....

I think that @chickychoccyegg makes some good points. I would agree though that there is way too much bloody pink around for girls. Far more than in my childhood Shock

Newrunner29 · 30/10/2021 23:35

This is that experiment

The whole documentary is on utube , it was on bbc called 'no more boys and girls'

Newrunner29 · 30/10/2021 23:32

I dont believe child are instinctively drawn at all there was a documentary i will find it and they had babies in opposite sterotype clothes so girls were wearing blue and boys pink they put them in room with various people and put both sterotype toys cars and dolls, the adult in room would everytime give them the sterotype toy to each baby or comment on the baby liking a sterotype toy. It was fascinating to watch they did few other experiments just showing how not instinctively they are drawn

Newrunner29 · 30/10/2021 23:28

[quote PearsandPartridge]@Newrunner29 but you said it yourself, it's his Dad's fault. Him not providing healthy family dynamics or respecting his wife. Nothing to do toys! I'm not trying to argue, just saying how it comes across to me.
My DH is an only child who grow up closely with 3 boy cousins. He does our food shopping, is an excellent cook, cleans the bathroom regularly and has had his fare share of nappy changes and caring for our son. According to him and his late DM, he never had dolls and pushchairs. But he was taught what's right and wrong and was being brought up to respect women. And I'm not saying it to make him sound extraordinary. To me it's normal. My DF was like this and so is my DB.

Again, apologies if I seem to be missing the point again but to me it's not that simple. This is a hugely complex subject. [/quote]
I also agree its complex, but if the dad is very clearly saying his boys cannot play with 'girl toys' and he is not looking after his children because he doesn't see that as his job , where do u think he found that idea from? He clearly sees woman and men having sterotype roles and hes putting that on his children. Hes continuing the cycle by defining their play roles.

PearsandPartridge · 30/10/2021 23:28

@CatJumperTwat

PearsandPartridge You think boys are "instinctively" drawn to cars and mechanics, and girls to pink, fluffy things?

Seriously?

As a said, to an extent yes, I do believe that choice of toys are instinctive. To an extent being emphasised. The bit about mechanics and fluffy things are just a couple of examples from my immediate family, and by no mean a generalisation.
Babdoc · 30/10/2021 23:22

I no longer have skin in the game, as my DDs are now in their 30s. But I’m glad they were young when all this gender stereotyping crap was much less pronounced.
DD1 loved Lego and Thomas the Tank engine. She has a maths degree and works in risk analysis. I think girls nowadays need to be very strong minded to fight the pressure to conform to fluffy pink stuff, or risk being labelled a trans boy.

PearsandPartridge · 30/10/2021 23:16

@latebreakfast

It makes me laugh that some people think that useless husbands are the product of boys not playing with doll houses and broom sets as children.

Of course this doesn't produce useless husbands. But it most certainly produces very lovely husbands who believe that both they and their wife have certain pre-determined roles in life. Fine if you fit those roles and are happy with those outcomes. Less so if you don't

DS will out his teddy to sleep and will make sure it is comfortable. He will walk around with his teddy sheep, offering it drinks and food. He will help his dad tidy up after dinner and will go to the park on a Saturday afternoon with Daddy to give mummy some alone time. He will try and preserve all the spiders and ants and is the gentlest soul. He doesn't have a pushchair, never has he asked for one and most of his clothes are blue / brown and green.
Swipe left for the next trending thread