Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So wonder how people hang on to family money?

31 replies

byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 07:06

Someone I know through work comes from a wealthy family who own property/land. Lives in a big house that belonged to the family and was given to him, but seems to struggle with the household expenses and says he can't afford to get jobs done on the house (plenty needs doing)

He is employed in the family business which he says is failing and everything has to be cash - he went to buy a large item the other week and asked me to help collect it in my van, the seller wanted a bank transfer but he said it had to be cash.

If the business is failing why not sell off some of the land/property to help? I'm confused that someone can live like this - they seem to buy a lot "through the business" yet be cash poor.

Coming from a fairly poor working class family where we just spent what we earned, I'm completely baffled by it all. Is he likely dodging tax or something? I also realise it's none of my business really, I'm just fascinated by it!

OP posts:
PerseverancePays · 30/10/2021 07:49

Many of these old estates are tied up very tightly so they are passed down intact . People that marry in can’t inherit, bits can’t be sold off, not easily anyway, heirs and spares must be produced to keep the whole thing going.
One of the problems is that they, the inheritors, may not have any business sense whatsoever but will always have a scrimping and saving ethos drummed into them. So they will be wearing a fifty year old coat but not know how to set up some air b&b for some actual money. They are the relics of colonialism and imperial rule.

SW1amp · 30/10/2021 07:41

It’s highly likely all or part of the land and property is held in trust

The advantage is that it gets around massive inheritance tax bills
The downside is that the estate can’t be easily sold

If this is the case, the business will be run separately but alongside the family wealth
Eg the business will pay peppercorn rent to the trust for the use of the land or premises but one can’t prop up the other

The trust has to pay for repairs etc
The business has to cover itself

byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 07:36

@Hollyhead

I think often in families like this there is an instilled duty to keep it all going so selling part of it feels like failure.
He did mention to me a couple of years ago about passing the house down to his son, so you might have a point there.
OP posts:
byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 07:34

I wonder why people live like that though. The house is still full of ancient carpets with holes, the windows are knackered (he was moaning about those and the energy bills, can't afford to replace the windows) why not just sell the house to someone who can afford to look after it and not have the money worries? The one house alone is worth over a million (in an area that isn't very expensive)

OP posts:
Hollyhead · 30/10/2021 07:33

I think often in families like this there is an instilled duty to keep it all going so selling part of it feels like failure.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 30/10/2021 07:30

He may be asking clients to pay in cash to avoid paying tax, yes. Obviously not sure what the business is, but I mean income/corporation tax. Thus only having cash to spend.