Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So wonder how people hang on to family money?

31 replies

byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 07:06

Someone I know through work comes from a wealthy family who own property/land. Lives in a big house that belonged to the family and was given to him, but seems to struggle with the household expenses and says he can't afford to get jobs done on the house (plenty needs doing)

He is employed in the family business which he says is failing and everything has to be cash - he went to buy a large item the other week and asked me to help collect it in my van, the seller wanted a bank transfer but he said it had to be cash.

If the business is failing why not sell off some of the land/property to help? I'm confused that someone can live like this - they seem to buy a lot "through the business" yet be cash poor.

Coming from a fairly poor working class family where we just spent what we earned, I'm completely baffled by it all. Is he likely dodging tax or something? I also realise it's none of my business really, I'm just fascinated by it!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
caringcarer · 16/07/2022 22:08

Just for clarity I pay all taxes due on my property portfolio. I just want to avoid as much inheritance tax as possible. Hence I do the £3000 per year gifting inheritance tax free. That is £1k for each child each year.

caringcarer · 16/07/2022 22:04

I will be leaving a significant number of my btl properties to my dgc with my dd having a lifetime interest so she gets rental incomes for the rest of her life but she can't sell them as owned by my dgc. It protects the properties in case of a breakdown of her marriage. It means my sil would have no claim over properties whereas if I left them to my dd he would have. Neither of my ds's have children and both say ATM they don't want children so I can't do this with them. However I am considering putting the properties they will inherit into a trust to protect them. I don't think it is wrong to want to pass wealth on to your descendants. I think it is pretty normal tbh. I would not live in a house falling apart and not get it fixed though.

HairyToity · 16/07/2022 20:35

We have some family money. The family ethos:

  • You can live in a house bought with family money
  • You can live in a house owned by the family
  • You can live off income from your job
  • You can live off rents (after maintenance, repairs, money for a sinking fund - the big ones off expenses, tax all paid)
  • You can live off interest
  • You can work in family business and spend some of the net profit (although ideally roll most of the money back in)
  • You do not sell the assets. Once the assets start to be sold, the money gets frittered, and it is soon all gone.

I was basically told money I earnt could be spent, family money had heen built up by people who had worked hard / saved / been entrepreneurial before me, and should be passed down the generations. It is a safety net for everyone.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/07/2022 20:24

If you read up about estates like chatsworth they explain how these sorts of posh family estates are structured to basically avoid losing the estate through inheritance tax.

All the big valuable stuff (land, buildings, any big antiques etc) is endowed to a trust. In theory this will be "independently managed" in reality, the family will be represented as trustees and other trustees will be mates. For the biggest famous estates, the trust will also be a charity. The family pay "market" rent to the trust to live there (often only for a few rooms they "live in").

Tax perks:
a) Income from the estate is funnelled into the trust, which as a charity pays no tax. This means all repairs, extension, acquisitions of new stuff etc can be funded from untaxed income.

By contrast any normal person has to pay for home repairs etc from post tax pay.

b) the family get to continue to essentially have most of the benefit of the house, land, art etc and hand it down for the benefit of heirs, while paying no inheritance tax.

By contrast any other family pay tax when passing down wealth.

c) the family get to only pay "rent" for the rooms they officially use, while retaining enough control to prevent anyone else moving into live in the rest. Often the bit that gets put in the trust is all the big costly bit (the dilapidated expensive to maintain old house) while the family keep other easier assets.

By contrast, I have to pay for my whole house. If I only paid for say, the upstairs, the landlord would no doubt move someone else in downstairs.

Downside: they are stuck with it. Very difficult to move etc without losing the value.

It's a clever swindle though and it's how the very highest aristocracy can maintain their huge wealth. Often they keep proper ownership of the most income generative/low cost assets, and what gets put into the trust is the bit that's too expensive to maintain unless it's in a neat tax free charity

2319inprogress · 30/10/2021 09:51

My friend was brought up in the family castle (Castle X in Glen X), the castle was held in trust by/for the Clan & when a new leak sprung they would raid the library for an ancient volume to sell. So they would only have (a little) cash to pay for things. The farm kept them in lamb & beef but not much else.

Maybe your friend has cash in a similar manner?

When it's the family legacy you "just can't" be the generation that loses it even though you know you're passing the burden on to your children.

FreedomFaith · 30/10/2021 09:49

Could also be rich, but just doesn't want to spend it. That's how the wealthy tend to stay rich, they don't spend it, even when necessary.

SW1amp · 30/10/2021 09:40

@byzantinelaws

But there is no suggestion that’s what he is doing

Well he insists on paying for everything in cash, so I imagine he is getting paid in cash for at least some of the work he does.

That’s evading income tax by being paid cash in hand

That’s not funding your personal life through a business as such

But either way, it doesn’t sound particularly above board, especially given the situation with the business being so precarious

M0rT · 30/10/2021 09:39

I know someone who married in to one of these farms. A nice warm new bungalow was built for the older generation and she and her husband got the large uninsulated house with single glazed windows, slate flooring and 30 year old wiring. Supposed to be the better deal!
When the second child was born she insisted on moving in to a house with working central heating in the village. I was amazed she had held out that long!

Alarae · 30/10/2021 09:38

I see the other end of the spectrum of this, where the family wealth generates so much income but the beneficiaries don't want anymore so it gets built up. Literally a problem of having too much money (nice problem to have, eh).

One reason how they manage to grow so much wealth is because they have the connections to invest vast sums of money in promising start ups. Once you have an 'in' you then get offered more opportunities. For example, they made approximately a £1m investment a few years ago and now its worth around £10m. Obviously there are investments that fail, but they are offered investments more likely to succeed than not.

The numbers involved are just ridiculous. When a 2 year old receives close to 100k in income a year, its just a bit nonsensical.

byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 09:38

But there is no suggestion that’s what he is doing

Well he insists on paying for everything in cash, so I imagine he is getting paid in cash for at least some of the work he does.

OP posts:
byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 09:36

It's not used for farming now, although he did tell me they rent one field out to a farmer for grazing. This is all very interesting. One thing seems clear, they're definitely on a tax fiddle!

OP posts:
SW1amp · 30/10/2021 09:35

@topcat2014

Paying for your personal life through a business is tax evasion though.
But there is no suggestion that’s what he is doing
topcat2014 · 30/10/2021 09:34

Paying for your personal life through a business is tax evasion though.

user1471538283 · 30/10/2021 09:31

It sounds utterly miserable to be in a house with all that lands as it decays. Alot of them think of money as crass though and wouldnt dream of using it as a business venture.

I've never inherited a house but I think a home is only any good if its suitable.

SW1amp · 30/10/2021 09:27

Farms are slightly different because they are already exempt from most inheritance tax - but it comes with conditions. Basically if the land is used for farming and the house is an appropriate size for the farm (ie not a stately home) then you don’t pay inheritance tax

But if eg you convert buildings from barns into holiday homes, those are obviously no longer agricultural buildings and tax is due. Or if the land is used for pet ponies rather than agricultural work

But farms will usually separate the farming ‘business’ from the property ownership so that might well be the reason they don’t use one to prop up the other
Or there might be a trust ownership structure
Or it might be pride
Impossible to know without a good snoop around Companies House and land registry data

But what you say about ancient carpets and rattling windows is pretty normal for farmhouses. They are rarely comfortably heated, regardless of how much money is in the business!

It also disproportionately devalues farms when you start selling off bits
Eg you might raise £500k selling off one of the houses and some land, but the remaining farm is worth £1m less because it’s now too small to be a commercially viable farm

VladmirsPoutine · 30/10/2021 09:17

@SW1amp I wondered this! Thanks for explaining so clearly!

byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 09:11

So who can be the trustees? The place I'm referring to isn't a stately home, it's a few acres of land with three houses on it, think it used to be a farm.

OP posts:
SW1amp · 30/10/2021 09:08

@HandlebarLadyTash

Can all homeowners put property in trust for the kids? & if so why is that not the norm?
Technically yes but then you have to give control to the trustees

Neither you nor future generations will own the house. The trust owns it, and gives beneficial use of it to the current generation

So you couldn’t downsize, move, upsize, extend etc
The trustees would be the only ones allowed to make those decisions. They are effectively your landlord, and make decisions based on what is best for the trust and future generations. Not what’s best for the current occupants

Great when it’s a historic stately pile and the alternative is giving it to the National Trust or having to sell it, or turn it into flats to pay a multi-million tax bill

Makes no sense when it’s a 4 bed house in the midlands and you are only looking to avoid a couple of grand of IHT in exchange for losing all control over your house

UndertonesOfCake · 30/10/2021 09:07

There's often a sense that they don't want to be the one who lost the house for future generations - there would be a huge sense of failure associated.

This sort of thing provides a few storylines in Downton Abbey.

NinjaTuna · 30/10/2021 09:03

A previous 'boss' lived in an asset rich, cash poor world. He limped from inheritance to inheritance . The new car was leased, credit cards were juggled and the baliffs turned up more than once for payment.

It all seemed very stressful but he marched through it with his head high, projecting a ' only little people worry about taxes' attitude. It was mesmerising and ugly at the same time. I'm not sure he or his wider family were ever truly happy but they certainly bonded together and looked down on anyone with double glazing or state education.

DaisyNGO · 30/10/2021 08:57

He might also be really attached to it emotionally, which I completely understand.

HandlebarLadyTash · 30/10/2021 08:54

Can all homeowners put property in trust for the kids? & if so why is that not the norm?

LakieLady · 30/10/2021 08:12

So does this mean even if the business goes bankrupt, they can hang on to the property? I don't know much about business or property!

Yes, it's entirely possible, especially if the property is vested in a trust. This is a practice widely adopted by wealthy, landed families as it avoids inheritance and other taxes. It also means that property is not owned by any individual or company and that it cannot be forcibly disposed of in the event of bankruptcy or to recover debt.

There are also significant tax advantages to income deriving from the land/property.

byzantinelaws · 30/10/2021 07:59

@SW1amp

It’s highly likely all or part of the land and property is held in trust

The advantage is that it gets around massive inheritance tax bills
The downside is that the estate can’t be easily sold

If this is the case, the business will be run separately but alongside the family wealth
Eg the business will pay peppercorn rent to the trust for the use of the land or premises but one can’t prop up the other

The trust has to pay for repairs etc
The business has to cover itself

So does this mean even if the business goes bankrupt, they can hang on to the property? I don't know much about business or property!
OP posts:
Whose · 30/10/2021 07:49

Yes there's a whole pride/honour thing around looking after the family property.
They say something to that effect in Downton Abbey... They don't own the place, they're just looking after it for the next generation.

But you're not wrong, they should sell up and pass on good values, sustainable finances etc rather than a huge, rotting liability